Very inconsistent. I guess it depends on whose making the pizza, but you never know what you're getting. I order regularly from here, and the pizza is always different. Sometimes it's good while other times it sucks. I ordered a regular pizza (my usual order) last night and it was so ridiculously thin with hardly any sauce. Full of cheese and not good! Taking a long break from this place. read more

Eat at Pizza Box at least once every 2 weeks. Very good! Try the cheese steak hoagie pizza, my fav!

The chicken wings literally had chicken feet and claws. Multiple wings were like that. I will never eat there again. read more

Pizza Box - The chicken wings literally had chicken feet and claws. Multiple wings were like that. I will never eat there again. - Italian Near Me - Blackwood, New Jersey

Did they improve? Idk. Last night I was at a birthday party and my friend ordered from here. The pizza was really, really good. Tasty red sauce & a really good dough. The pie was humongous. read more

white veggie pizza and mozzarella sticks were amazing. service was also very good. we ordered online and ate inside. she still brought us plates and asked us if we need anything. 10/10 read more

Pizza Box - white Vegetable Pizza - Italian Near Me - Blackwood, New Jersey

Food is usually great but I've seen the guy making pizza not wearng a mask and last time i ordered my chicken fingers were unbelievably dry and over cooked. They didn't even give me the sauce i requested. Inedible. read more

See all

Honestly the best pizza I've had. The people there are super friendly and awesome to deal with, and it's a nice little shop, very clean, nice overall energy, super great vibes. Definitely suggest Pizza Box to anyone. And the Mega fries are to die for. So good. read more

Just ordered an American hoagie! It was delicious. Everything in the sandwhich was perfect. The right amount of everything to make every bite a treat. I give this place 5 stars based on this hoagie! read more

This place if filthy. Here is why. I've been here 3 times... 1st trip : Good slice of pizza. No issues. 2nd trip: I found a wire, from a wire brush, on my pizza slice. The guy apologized but NEVER removed the rest of the pie from display. I thought that was a major bad move. 3rd Trip 3 months later: I figured my 2nd trip was an anomaly so I took another chance. Bad move. I found a piece of plastic on my slice of pizza, which stabbed me on my gums. I'm done! Never again! Either that was a tremendous coincidence that I got a foreign object in my food, or they are just sloppy at making food. read more

They had a grub hub coupon and I was close by so I ordered 20 wings. Wow, were they bad. All of the wings were different sizes and apparently went through a blender because they were also all chopped up. Cut in different sizes and area. Just weird. Additionally, they weren't hot (temperature wise) and I picked them up immediately after they finished. On top of that, they didn't taste good and had little to no sauce on them. Very disappointing. If I didn't have a coupon they would of gotten 1 Star.. avoid! read more

Ordered food through grubhub. First time eating here. Food was delivered fast and food was completely accurate as ordered. Ordered 2 wraps, appetizer and salad. Food was very delicious, and tasted very fresh. Will order from pizza box again. Thank you for a great meal. read more

We order here at least once a week. Everything I've had from pizza, to salads, or sandwiches, you can't go wrong! When we lived in Cleveland and came to visit we would order a pizza to take home and freeze (Cleveland has great food, but terrible pizza). The pizza lasted in the freezer and we would heat it up, although it never lasted more than a week because we would eat it! read more

Ordered the buffalo chicken wrap for lunch. YUCK! The wrap was DRENCHED with buffalo sauce and ranch dressing I couldn't even taste the chicken. Also Asked for chicken cutlet instead of grilled chicken and got grilled chicken lol. I asked if fries were included with the wrap and she said no. I asked if chips were and was told yes. I guess she thought I wanted the fries bc they were included in my order. $12 down the toilet and I'm starving! read more

Pizza Box.... I know everyone goes to Sal's, but Pizza Box is just as good but offers better service AND delivery. What makes this place great is the service. The irony that the owner's name is Sal is kinda funny too. I lived in California for 3 years and when I'd come home to visit, Sal not only still remembered my name but also that i was living in California. The guy remembers everyone's name, it's like the Cheer's of pizza places. Great food and weekly specials too! read more

I have been a loyal customer for over 20 years and lately the customer service has gone seriously down hill. I called to place a large take out order which included an item that is not normally on the kids menu (a chicken parmesan dinner)but they have accommodated me several times in the past. I was told that because it's not on the menu, I can't order it. I explained to them that I have ordered it many times there but they insisted it wasn't possible. There is a pizzeria on every corner willing to change things to make their customers happy. I wasn't asking for anything crazy, and I was happy to pay whatever they thought was fair. Lucky for me, the next place that I called was happy to accommodate us, and they now have a new customer in me. read more

As a simple neighborhood pizza joint, they're pretty good. No complaints about their pizza, though it doesn't stand out from the crowd. If I were in the area and craving a slice, I'd stop in for one. However last night I made the mistake of treating them as a sit-down restaurant. We had gotten one of those Restaurant.com gift certificates and figured we'd eat in and save a few bucks on a nice dinner. (For future reference, restaurant.com gift cards tend to only be accepted by mediocre restaurants) Overall I got the feeling that sit-down dining is not really what they specialize in here. It's an afterthought at most. The server was definitely not accustomed to dinner service. Plates were never cleared until we had accumulated a large stack and asked her to remove them (and even then, she was reluctant). Silverware was forgotten for dinner and then for dessert. And last but definitely not least, all of our drinks were served in styrofoam cups with lids and straws! These are just a few examples of how service works here. It's a pizza joint pretending to be an Italian restaurant. As for the food... meh. You can do so much better than this. The Italian wedding soup was as bland as it gets. The meatballs were tiny, stiff, and perfectly round like the frozen kind that you microwave when you don't have time to cook actual meatballs. Shame. I doubt this soup was made on-site, unless you count putting a bag in the warming bin. The alfredo sauce was a homogeneous white goo with no texture and little flavor; I'm 100% certain that it came out of a jar, and a cheap one at that. The chicken and pasta were decent, at least, but they deserved better sauce. The eggplant parmigiana was actually not so bad. The sauce may have been made on-site, but I'm skeptical. At least it was better than the alfredo. We had to get dessert to meet the minimum to use our certificate, so we ordered cannoli and tiramisu. The cannoli were okay, but very obviously not fresh. The server even brought the tiramisu to the table frozen! I politely told her this, and her reply as she turned away was "I don't cook the food" (a surprisingly defensive reply, considering that I really was being friendly to her). She brought it back to the kitchen for a minute or two and then explained to me, as if I had made an incomprehensible strange request, "This is actually ice cream, but we microwaved it for you." No, you sweet misguided child. It was not ice cream. After it was warmed up, it was a very freezerburnt factory-made tiramisu. Not a puddle of melted tiramisu-flavored ice cream. So that was weird and a little disturbing. I wonder how long it was sitting in the back of the freezer? Long enough that nobody in the kitchen had served it recently enough to even know what it is! So overall I think I could summarize my dining experience by saying simply "Order pizza and sandwiches and NOTHING ELSE EVER". read more

I just ordered two pies and I added a topping of pepperoni. They charged me an additional 5.99 for three small pepperonis on each slice. I would've saved money buying a pack of pre sliced pep and putting them on myself. SMH! read more

We are new to the area and wanted to grab some pizza and fries. The pizza was pretty good. I would definitely recommend it. We have ordered on several other occasions and tried the cheese-steaks and chicken tenders, nothing to brag about, not great, but not awful. Prices are a bit on the higher side. read more

Very mediocre and expensive pizza with not so good customer service. In Washington Township, with all the other pizza places around, there is never a reason to go to Pizza Box. Anyone in the area should just drive down the street to Frank's, across the street to A&S, or around the corner to Angelo's for much better and less expensive food. read more

Ya know , I think I have come to the conclusion that Every review rating that's low score on Y.E.L.P. r the exact opposite of what people believe, think, as it seems over 20yrs of taking Yelp reviews as nonsense and paid retaliaters or haters. Lol it's a shame any way Pizza box is fantastic read more

This place sucks!!!! We ordered online and we went right there to pick the pizza up it took us maybe five minutes to get there... we get the pizza home and it is stone cold!!!! I called to say something and they were less then helpful... said they keep the boxes on top of the oven to keep them warm... obviously not... said I could bring the pizza back and they would make a new one. That was nice, except for the fact I have been working all day and not leaving the house... also wings came with the order and they are gross... if I could give no stars I would!!! NEVER ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN!!! All the food we ordered was ice cold read more

We went here tonight because it was our anniversary, we didn't have a sitter, and we had some money to blow at restaurant.com. Can't go wrong with Italian, right? Well, the food was pretty good. Nothing fancy, nothing to rave about, but nothing to balk at either. I got the eggplant parm and it was your basic meal. Fried eggplant smothered in sauce and cheese served aside a heaping helping of pasta smothered in more sauce. The sauce was pretty good, too. The bread that came with the meal was just a hoagie roll toasted, sliced and served with butter. The Italian wedding soup was bland, but not bad. The cream sauce on my husbands fettuccine was pretty lifeless and was definitely not made fresh in house. In fact, I'm not really sure how much actually IS made fresh in house. Since we had $50 to blow, we ended up getting dessert; Tiramisu. You know it's bad when the waitress isn't really sure what it is you're ordering. She brought the dessert to the table still frozen and said it was ice cream. After they microwaved it, it was fine, but this was clearly not fresh and not really worth the $4 price tag. Basically, what I'm getting at is that if you want to order a pizza, go for it. The pizza wasn't half bad (my kid had a slice), but if you're looking for a nice little Italian place to go out for dinner, pick something else. Though they tried, and the service was nice (though our waitress didn't clear any dishes until we actually asked her to remove them), I wouldn't recommend dining out at this establishment. read more

Pizza isn't bad but there prices are crazy. 9.99 for med pizza. I order a medium with jalapeño and picke d it up and it came to about 15 dollars. They charge 3 to 4 dollars for one topping. And if you have it delivered they charge at least 2 dollars. Have a medium pizza with one topping delivered plus a couple bucks tip it's like 20 dollars. In my opinion go to sals they don't deliver but the pizza is better and it's maybe 1.50 for a topping. read more

Best pizza around by leaps and bounds! I love their thin crust and love their Sicilian even more!

favorite pizza place ever. I grew up in the development behind there and used to ride my bike up there with friends. I think that their pizza is excellent! Crust is perfect and not an overwhelming amount of cheese like other places do. I definitely think that it is one of the best pizza places in South Jersey and possibly the entire world including the universe. it's science read more

Was here for the first time the other day. Order a cheese steak wrap and a soda. First off 11$ for that is quite high in my opinion but regardless. I have to say this was one of the worst cheese steaks wraps I've ever had...was very fat with barely any cheese. I've heard great things about their pizza. I'll give that a try and hope they redeem themselves read more

Way overpriced and the food is OK at best, some of it not even worth eating. We won't be ordering from here again, which is a shame because they're right around the corner. read more

Food is ok, not the best but not the worst. Counter girls are terrible.pick up your food and they want a tip. Never a thank you. He is your tip, say thank you. read more

Delivery is never way too long and the pizza always comes hot and presentable. Pizza is good and their wings aren't bad either. We order fries for the kids and even though it's hard to mess those up they always come hot and not over done. read more

I have been eating pizza from Pizza Box for probably over 25 years, and it's still my favorite local pizza place. Great crust, great sauce, and the staff is always friendly. I get my pizzas light on the cheese, extra sauce, with well done crust, absolutely perfect. No problem with special requests. Great cheesesteaks and chicken parm sandwiches as well. read more

My family's hotspot. Weber been coming here since it opened. You'll get the best family vibes there and amazing food

TERRIBLE!My friends and I will never try this place out again.Expensive,food wasn't good at all, the two girls behind the counter was disrespectful.The food was a disappointment,seriously!! read more