Tried wings from Pizza Boys during a charity Battle of the Wings event and loved their Dubai Chocolate Wings which earned them an award. Heard the year before they did a PB&J wing and knew that we had to try. Went on Wing Wednesday by happenstance ... Wings are .95 which is a great deal..they had a live band in the bar area but chose counter service instead. Wings came out quick and hot. The PBJ wings lived up to all the hype. After having wings at their restaurant I see why they have won awards for several years. Wings were tender, crispy, and the sauce was amazing. With it being Wing Wednesday and live entertainment it was rather crowed. This is your typical wing and pizza joint nothing fancy or stuff but a great casual place for a night out. Haven't tried their Pizza yet but that is next up on our list. read more

See all

The pizza was great. The chicken wings I ordered were sitting in 8 ounces of oil. They were in a plastic container and then wrapped with foil. The foil had a quarter inch of oil in it and then there was additional oil in the container and when I poured it all together, it was 6 ounces of oil which got all over my counter all over everything. I don't understand why they would ever send food out with that much oil in it. read more

Pizza Boys - Chicken wings sitting in oil - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

See all

Ordered wings to go yesterday and was surprised how small they are and very dry! PB what happened to u? Next time will go to Pizza Hut

Great pizza order every week. The spinach pizza is delicious. It's called the Popeyes.

Orders the meatballs, 3 slices, and garlic knots with marinara. The meatballs were lukewarm and you could tell that they were frozen. The knots and marinara were cold - like, legit cold. Not even warmed up. The pizza was old and tasted old; you could also tell by how they added shredded mozzarella to the top of it. Really disappointing experience read more

See all

This is a family favorite at our house!! Generous portions with good prices and the wings were amazing, I love the good sauce!!

Wings and beer are great here. Friendly staff and always busy. Mozzarella sticks are good too!

they gave me 2 cheese slices without cheese and the pizza looks like string cheese was melted over the pizza

We were in Utica for business. The garlic knots were amazing! The pizza was great too. Friendly service. Not exactly cozy though. But we would definitely eat there again read more

I love the popeye pizza..is delish! Worked at National Grid..was good for us during storm trouble.

A small counter attached to a brew house. Kinda a messy place but the food was good. Had some garlic knots, Zesty Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and an upside down Sicilian. All of the pizza was very good. Highly recommend read more

Pizza Boys - Zesty Buffalo Chicken - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

See all

The tap house side: very pour service. The bartender server never came back after she gave us menus. The place was not busy but we were not locals. Wont come back here. read more

See all

It might be time to retire the old man in the back. I came in this afternoon to pick up my order...no problems with the order or those at the counter. While waiting, I hear "fat f------ b---- from the back. I know not directed at me, but there were quite a few people waiting as well as sitting at a nearby table with a couple of kids who heard it. The girls in the front were mortified, but also looked like "here we go again.". If your food is average, you need to make sure your customer service and behavior of those who work there or own it is better than the food. I don't care who said it. Considering there are plenty of other options, I won't be headed to Pizza Boys again. read more

I've ordered from Pizza Boys in the past when staying in town (hotel) for work. This order was scheduled for 6:30-6:50pm. I asked for it to be brought to my room, rather than dropped at the front desk so I could give a cash tip to the delivery person. The status of my order went from delayed to arrived and I never even got a knock on the door. I opened the door around 7:10pm and it was sitting on the floor in the hallway. I feel bad the delivery person didn't get a tip for their efforts however they obviously didn't care enough to knock and confirm that I even got the food. It was just weird. read more

Nothing special about their cheesesteaks and waffle fries. Maybe I'd ordered on a bad day. Will try again. read more

See all

Great pizza and wings and amazingly they have great burgers! The Gold Dust pizza is a must have!

Great place for pizza, a must go to on Tuesdays! Service is typically fast and a great atmosphere!

Pizza Boys is a pub style restaurant. They have great prices and a pretty big menu for a pizza place. I often visit with a group and the large pub style tables give us plenty of room to sit together. There is something on the menu for everyone.and the staff is always kind about explaining items on the menu. Some of the favorites when we visit are "The Boom Boom Chicken Sandwich", "10"personal pizzas", "Greens", "Garlic Knots","Wings", "Steak and Cheddar Melt" but they have many more options and a bar if you want some after dinner drinks. read more

Just had a great fish fry for dinner tonight! Unfortunately we were all starving when the food came so I didn't get any pics but let me try to describe the absolute amazingness that was delivered. We orders 3 fish fries and could have totally been good with 2 to satisfy the 3 of us. The were a bazillion fries. We got regular and curly fries. OMG!!!! The curly fries were beyond delicious. They were crispy and tasty and the best! The regular fries weren't too shabby either. On to the fish! It was still piping hot when it was delivered and super crispy!!! I could not believe hot and crispy it was for being a delivery too! The fish wasn't dry either it was cooked to perfection. The meal also came with a large tartar sauce (I ordered 3 extras) and I definitely did not need them. The coleslaw was we got too and the garlic bread was a great touch! Will 100% get this again in the future! read more

This is my favvvvoooorriiitteeee pizza place. They have such delicious pizza. And their wings!! ARE THE BOMB. I always get the everything wings and bbq wings. They drench them in sauce, and their sauce is sooooo good. They have so many specials throughout the week. Monday is 1/2 priced boneless wings (my fav), Tuesday $1 slices all day, Wednesday 60 cent chicken wings, Thursday $8.50 chicken riggies, Friday $6 fish subs!!!! They also have printable coupons on their website!!! All of the employees are super nice. They have a bar and plenty of seating inside. They also have events throughout the week like trivia night and live bands. I absolutely love this place. It's the only place my roomie and I order pizza and wings from! You won't be disappointed!!! read more

I have had Pizza Boys in the past and it was okay, just came back with an order and am very disappointed, large meatball sub with 3 meatballs, large Calzone that is all bread, both cold, a large antipasto that is very small and didn't receive crumbled blu cheese, this was a very expensive meal that I will not purchase again! Should of went to VENICE! Mike M read more

This place is AMAZING! Not only was the food delicious (Their wings, pizza and specialty salads are phenomenal!) and the prices very reasonable, the staff was also very accommodating to our large group. We had let them know we would be coming there after the American Heart Walk this past weekend and they had three large tables waiting for us when we arrived! We also found being able to order ahead online worked wonderfully for those of us pressed for time. (Others ordered when they arrived and also found their orders were filled in a timely manner.) EVERYONE was pleased with their food! We plan to make this our regular gathering place to meet at after future Heart Walks. THANK YOU!!! read more

Pretty good. Large portion sizes, inexpensive. Heavy food though. I got the chicken riggies (which I know to be a local favorite) with extra meatballs. The chicken riggies was pretty tasty but somewhat dripping in oil (I guess that's the cheese). However, the pasta (penne instead of rigatoni) was cooked well and the flavor was balanced. Ate half of it and was full! The meatballs were alright, with the sauce being a little light for my liking. read more

Pizza Boys - Chicken Riggies, 4 Meatballs with Sauce, Side Salad - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

Needed a quick place to eat and many restaurants are closed or open late on Sundays in Utica. Pizza Boys seemed like it'd be good option for kids and adults, so we decided to check it. Went in and tried to place an order at the counter. The guy at the register was on some sort of service call and barely took our order. Another employee came in late and there was some cursing and explaining going on. From the kitchen I could hear more F words and cursing about workplace drama. My kids were with me and I did not appreciate the plethora of curse words that they heard. Even if I didn't have to experience that, I still probably wouldn't come back. It's dark and dingy inside and pizza quality is poor. read more

Pizza Boys - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

See all

We loved the place, it was very clean and the food was great! The wings were excellent and the staff was very nice too.

Ordered, paid and went to pick up: it was closed! What kind of business takes peoples money when they are closed. Def disappointed and hungry! I need my money back read more

I have had the chicken riggies on Thursdays when it is a special price. They always make it perfect - not too hot or too mild (I always order it that way). It comes with garlic bread and a side salad with your choice of dressing. The container is large so you have enough for a least 2 servings. I find the staff very friendly. They seem to know me by name because I am there almost every Thursday! read more

Love the turkey subs! Pizza is pretty good if you're in the mood go for the deep fried oreos. read more

Pizza Boys - My drink at the bar - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

Very disappointed in both the service and the products here. I got a calzone with fried chicken in it, there was almost no chicken and all cheese. My friend got a calzone as well which was very similar with a lack of meat, however his was burnt and black on the bottom. When he called to remedy the situation they said there was nothing they could do about it at all. read more

Pizza Boys - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

Ordered 10 wings... Didn't expect a pot of their everything sauce when I ordered them. I can't even eat this because half of the wings are in a pool of the sauce. read more

Pizza Boys - Chicken Wings Near Me - New York Mills, New York

I've never been disappointed when I order from here! Love their burgers and they come with a side making it a better value then McDonald's or burger king! Their burgers actually have flavor I don't have to add anything when I get it! read more

I'd be back. Pizza Boys to me was your regular pizza joint. They do NY-style pizza pretty good. There's nothing incredible about it, but it's just GOOD standard pizza. Our party ordered wings, garlic knots and 2 pizzas. The pizzas were good and everyone ate it. They are the thinner style. Good proportion of sauce, cheese and toppings, and the dough was fully cooked through. I was told that the wings were really good also. Unfortunately, we left the restaurant before noticing the restaurant forgot to pack our garlic knots. They have a bar inside and have some craft beer on draft. read more

Best hole in the wall pizza shop ever! Stop here, you won't be disappointed. Prices are great too, two bottled drinks and 4 slices and spent less than $20. read more

pizza: GOOD service: GOOD The place was clean The food was affordable Money well spent And the fact that I got to watch them make the pizza FRESH was god like. 10/10 will come back more read more

It's already a shame and disgusting that I've seen and herd employees talking about roaches in the back and on the wall visible from the register if you pay attention. But in addition to that, my friend worked there and she told me all about how they would drop food in their cooler or on their line and pick it up and say they aren't allowed to waste anything. I was also told about the wings smelling rotten and having an off color, but they were told to make them anyway. I've heard so many awful things that would blow anyone awa, but the reason I'm even writing a review is the customer service. The other day, I was ordering while I was waiting for my friend to get off work and had a misunderstanding with the kind of sauce I wanted and after I paid and went to sit down and wait I hear the short skinny girl with piercings in her face day "what a dumb b****". I genuinely hate that dirty place and all the horrible workers that I've dealt with. read more

I could have saved my money chicken wings little to no sauce no flavor,even the salad was off read more

I ordered through Grubhub and got the Italian Mix Wrap with sweet potato fries. My order came sooner than expected and it was delicious! I was honestly surprised by the quality of the food and how well it tasted as takeout. Plus, the portions were huge! read more

10/10 on the food & we also were super grateful with how the wing boxes were wrapped in foil so they were still hot and mess free when we got home (we did pickup). We also got the chicken bacon ranch sub and it was delicious and tater tots were crispy! read more

I've been a regular for the past month cause the beer and food is worth the trip. However, last week I had an hour to kill on Sunday, so I went on over. No one was working behind the bar. I waited a while and no one came..... I asked the other patrons and they said she'll be right back. More time past and still no one.... I left disappointed.... There are to many places that sell beer and food for me to waste time here. Never again... goodbye read more

We have been to a few pizza places that are close to this location. This was suggested and it was significantly better than the others. Good pizza. Lots of tables. Great beer selection. This is the best pizza in the NY Mills/Whitesboro area read more