A very very good local pie. The crust is just right for a "doughy" pizza... crunch on the bottom and squishy on the top. This is a square cut pie. I don't know if they will do pie cut if you ask (I suspect they would). The folks behind the counter have been very friendly and helpful. I wish they offered anchovies... (minus one star), I bet they'd be great! The cheese blend is good with decent "stretch" and harmony of flavors. The carry out boxes are on the robust side and that is good. Mine have had the plastic de-noider in the middle of my XL pies, also good! The bake is set up very well for a conveyer oven. Cheeses just browned and crust bottom crunch perfect. These folks seem to care. That is a rarity in the pizza biz. If I could have had anchovies with my pepperoni... five stars. Give it a try. I will be back. Your mileage may vary... read more

Called to order at 7:15pm. Staff said no problem. I called an hour to check on it and no answer. Called 5x till answer. Said they made the order and drove to Address and called several times . Lies. Now I've been charged and the rude teenagers left in charge won't refund my money or let me speak to the owner. We didn't get our food but we paid for this review! $70 order!!! read more

Pizza was DAMN good we got the personal pizzas, we got 8 and they were so well priced!!! If you're visiting I highly recommend and if you live there I'm jealous haha. read more

Pizzas delivered to your door you know everyone does it so what's to say it's different here or there or anywhere but with that said you can find it folded over into a burger here? Yeah they have an item here called a fold over that comes in a few different options but the one that was it for me was the burger one as why not give it a try and I must say it was definitely different pretty yummy in it's own way the only thing I could say that would make it better would be pickles as it just kinda needed it but other than that it was yummy and kinda unique. Besides that I ordered just your standard pepperoni pizza with onion pretty much my go to it was delicious I dug the sauce and flavor it was a good mix so I couldn't really go wrong! They delivered it to me before the scheduled time which was totally cool as I was hungry anyway so it was all good! They offer a check-on offer if you pick up of s free 20oz soda so definitely take advantage of that if you visit but if you choose delivery order online and use the promo code PIZZA for a discount! Overall yummy pizza and a fold over I'm sure I'll order again sometime next time though I'll be trying a different fold over because why not! read more

See all

14 soccer players and 20 parents and not one single complaint about the pizza! In fact - they all RAVED about it and said it was awesome! Scott is the one who took my order and in fact gave me a discount for such a large order and had excellent suggestions on what to order which is exactly what I went with! Scott then was the one to deliver the order (which I placed 2 days ahead of time) and he thought of napkins; silverware and plates and brought them (which I didn't even think to ask for). He was awesome to deal with and next time I am in Sandusky - I am definitely going there for some pizza!!! read more

On our way back home to Chicago from New York and this is by far the best pizza I have had since leaving home. Picky kids had no problem eating the cheesy pizza! Very delicious! read more

Pizza Brothers - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

I have been there lots of times. It is a great place to eat! I have been going since they open way back when. Even better than before since new owners took over. It's has some new up dates that was needed that looks great and makes you want stay awhile. The place was clean and inviting. The service was friendly the acknowledged me right away. That's the key to good Customer Service. Make them feel welcome! And they have good coupon running. Check them out on Facebook too. My favorite is the BLT foldovers and the Sweet Pig pizza. Yummy! Give them a try! read more

See all

Good pizza. Totally satisfying. I would order from them again if I was in the area. Especially like they were open late and delivered to my hotel. read more

So I love the food here but the costumer service was very poor. I had called in a order talking to the woman on the phone. She had a attitude the whole time we were talking. Then had an attitude Hang up the phone after I gave the credit information she said right before she hung up you're order will be there soon as possible with the rudest manner. So she clicked and hung up with out saying have a good day or thank you for ordering with us. after that conversation I will not eat there ever again. I want to feel welcome when I eat not disrespected. read more

Very slow and food is not served as it's finished. Owners are weirdly stand-offish and not friendly considering their logo. Overall I would never come back here again, I was only forced because they stay open late and no one else does in this area lol read more

Everytime I go home I HAVE to get a taco folder pizza. This place NEVER disappoints and I'v been a patron for 15 years!

They've made my sub (great 2 of 3) THREE times. Yet tonight they refused. Again. Ohio SMH. (It really is OhNo). Mushrooms , green olives, onions, ham, mayo, mozzarella. That's it. I'm not looking for a standard sub and am willing to pay for what I want. Incredible - it took cajoling last time but they made it (perfectly) , this time the dude refused to make it. I'm sorry but WTF!? read more

Pizza Brothers - OH version of "Run Through the Garden" - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Apparently they are known for their foldovers so naturally I go one. Ordered up the meatball food over and wow, quite tasty. Crispy pizza crust, soft flavorful meatballs cheese onions and peppers. Lady cooking was friendly and ready in about 6 minutes. Highly recommend. read more

***** NEVER AGAIN ***** I was a very loyal customer (1 - 2 times a week) until March 2018. For the past six -or- seven months things seemed to be slipping with quality, delivery and web ordering site. I ordered a Ruben foldover which I used to love until now. Sauerkraut was not drained and soaked the bottom of the foldover to the point it was mush and then bottom of the cardboard box was wet. Also, the Italian sub had some dressing on it that must have ben bad, horrible taste. ***** NEVER AGAIN ***** read more

This is the BEST pizza in northern Ohio. The Cheeseburger Foldover is worth a 6 hour drive for my family. This is the first and last place we visit when we are in town. Sandusky locals are familiar with Pizza Brothers but tourist...this is Sandusky best kept secret. read more

I've been getting pizza from here for at least 30+ years. Now that I live out of state every time I come back it is a requirement to order their food. Every time I visit I have to order three items. 1) Their family size pizzas, especially the center cuts. I'd love a pizza full of center cuts. 2) Their cheesy garlic bread. It is the standard by which I measure all other garlic bread. 3) Their BLT folder over. As a kid I did not appreciate these but now I have to have them. So if you are in the area and want the best Pizza in town stop by or order take out. read more

Best pizza and I absolutely love their subs. Prices are great. There customer service is a hit or miss but for the most part the quality of food makes up for it. read more

Wow wow wow.... Staying at a near by water park and wanted a decent take out option. This seemed to have high ratings AND delivered to our hotel. Both my hubby and I ordered the steak fold overs and they did not disappoint! I could not believe the flavor that they packed in these babies and for the price!!! I can't wait to order lunch here read more

Placed my delivery order at 5:30pm, didn't receive it until 7:15pm. Once receiving order I noticed part of the order was missing. Called and spoke with Rob the manager. He didn't seem to concerned about the length of time waited for delivery or the missing part of the order. Thank goodness the pizza was good. Not to sure when/if I will order again. read more

Just went here after a long day at Cedar Point -- great pizza and very friendly service! And our kids loved the dry erase wall!

I hadn't been to Pizza Brothers in 25 years - had moved to KC, Chicago, and points west. On a visit in from Missouri last week, I took my partner, sister and brother-in-law here to avoid the over-priced food at Kalahari...I wasn't sure what I'd find, and I didn't remember it being just a tiny little store-front with just a few tables. But trust me - you gotta get past the looks and order the FOLDOVER PIZZAS! My sister and brother in law weren't sure...so we ordered personal meatball and sliced steak foldovers. The waitress was very attentive, kept our sodas full, and when the foldovers arrived, WOW! This is not a calzone - it's a thinner, crisper crust that's not all doughy. Our universal favorite was the meatball foldover - there's something about the meatballs in this that are just awesome. My sister talked about it all the way home! There's also something called "family jewels" - which are meatballs, dipped in sauce and cheese then wrapped in the crust and baked. But the MB foldover was the hit. You should know that everything there (as of this date, anyway) is baked, not fried - even the "fries" are baked. Again, it doesn't look like much...but you've got to go. read more

Recommend eating inside at Pizza Brothers in Sandusky on Columbus Ave. They've redecorated and the place looks really nice. We had the steak foldover, garden salad & chef salad--all top notch! Service is great too- and the owners are very nice folks. Mangia! read more

One of the better local pizza joints, Pizza Brothers offers foldover pizzas that are very good. I recomend the BLT and taco foldovers as two of my fave's. Their standard pizza is OK, but could be a little better. Their salads and breadsticks are very good though. read more

Horrible, HORRIBLE service (stood there for 6 minutes timed, a couple more minutes not timed) to pick up my order. They just stared and worked on making pizzas, not even saying hello. After I paid, I noticed it was bland, frozen crust with good sauce and average cheese/pepperoni. The inside is a DUMP. I'm really not sure why or how this would be #11 in town. They don't even have a large presence or name with locals and they are off the main eating/dining areas around town. It must be an error for them to be in the top 50 of pizza spots, let alone top 50 overall. read more

The service has been going down in quality and today we ordered our last pizza. (I think the people giving it 5 stars are workers or the owners!) The parmesan wings had absolutely NOTHING on them, not even salt. We're through with PB. read more

I love the different pizzas offered. My favorite was the lasagna pizza. I had the macaroni bites as an appetizer! They just recently opened their dining room where the kids can actually write on the wall!! If you are looking for a local, clean, and friendly pizza joint, this is the one for you. By the way, they recently won 1st place in the Vacationland pizza bake off for their Chipolte BBQ chicken pizza....enough said! read more

Sorry I'm a little late on this review. I know everyone was waiting to hear from me, haha. So we spent the day at Cedar Point, basically from open to close (minus the last hour due to a storm). We stayed at one of the CP hotels and heard from the front desk about this place. OF COURSE I checked it out on Yelp before finally deciding to try it. Besides, the "folded" pizza sounded interesting. Decently priced, lots of options, and helpful/polite over the phone. We ended up waiting over an hour for two standard personal sized and one folded pizza. We called 3 times to make sure they got the order and address correct. They assured us every call that he would be there any time. When he finally arrived, the pizza was moderately warm and typical. I guess with so many high marks on Yelp, Plus the time it took to get it, I thought it was going to be of legendary status. It wasn't. It wasn't bad at all, it just wasn't anything special. Trying to take into account that it's the busy Cedar Point area and getting late in the evening I tried to be fair in my rating. Fair prices and polite staff, but only standard pizza with a lengthy delivery time makes it a 3 star. I'll try it again if the opportunity comes, but he better deliver my pizza on a unicorn if they want a higher rating. Almost 5 stars for this place? Really? Has everyone been eating frozen pizza? Ugh read more

Quick delivery but the steak foldover came basically as a vegetarian pizza. Loaded with mayo an tomatoes. I even ordered extra cheese and did not see that. Had to use a spoon to even eat one piece. I will at some point give them another chance but if it isn't what the previous owners supplied I will never give them another dime read more

This little place is a hidden gem! I just got a small folder pizza and cinnamon sticks, but the food was great and the staff was very nice. The cinnamon sticks were even better than the pizza - they were cooked perfectly and came with a container of yummy icing. It's a little off the beaten path (a couple blocks off Milan Road) and the location doesn't look fancy, but it is a good lunch or dinner option. read more

Great food, definitely worth the try. We were visiting from out of town and found this place on Yelp as we prefer local over chain pizza. The manager Bob treated us very well. Garlic knots and 2 large pizzas fed a family of 5. The kids all ate a couple slices each which doesn't happen very often. We will go back when we visit the area again. read more

Basic pizza and salad. My homemade pizzas and salads are way better. The best part of the meal were the crackers that came with it.

Excellent food and friendly staff...A must for anyone wanting something different like what they call a Foldover.

Delicious roast beef foldover! The s'mores pizza was awesome both at the shop and warmed up at home :)

Staying at Great Wolf Lodge in Sandusky can be expensive...my family wanted pizza so I looked up this little joint in the area. Pizza brothers did a great job in satisfying 3 picky kids and two frugal adults. The large 17" round pizza with two toppings, large 13" Ramono stix, salad and two liter were $35 including tip for delivery. I love round pizza cut into squares, and that's just how Pizza brothers does it. The pizza and stix were delicious and filled us all plus some leftovers for a mid-morning snack. The garden salad was a bit sparse, but they gave plenty of dressing that we also used on the pizza. Overall Bob delivered the pizza with energy and a smile. Great job Pizza Brothers, if we're in town again we'll look you up. read more

This was a fabulous place to order. The delivery was quick, pizza was fabulous, and the breadsticks were amazing! Super glad we ordered!

Discovered this place on Yelp while up here for Cedar Point. Their chipotle BBQ pizza was so good I ate an extra piece after I was full!! Love finding local restaurants. read more

Don't know how the pizza tastes but the customer service and delivery were the worst I've ever seen. We waited so long that we declined the pizzas. read more

This place has the BEST folders and pizza in the area.. unfortunately it is bad for business when you have to call the store 1 hr and 10 min after u place an order for delivery to see where your food is... and it hasn't even left the store! Ridiculous! There is NO pizza worth that! This has happened numerous times and therefore I will no longer be ordering from them! read more

It's a decent pizza place. Romano sticks are the best! Fold over pizza is good with huge chicken tenders in the chicken parmesan, but could've used more cheese. Mac & cheese bites and "family jewels" meatballs just OK. read more

Excellent! Had the chicken blt foldover, amazing! I highly recommend trying it out. Also had gyro that was great.