Easily the Best Pizza in Circleville! We have been multiple times and the food is always hot, fresh, and delicious!

The food gets four stars... Service barely gets two. Signed up for the party room and let them know how many people we were going to have in advance. The restaurant was severely understaffed and the poor waitress was in over her head. We signed up for two hour block, but some people didn't get their food until we were 15 minutes past when we had to be out of there. I talked to the manager on hand about it, he offered excuses, didn't try to help the situation, and most definitely didn't apologize. I've been there before for other events and things have been fine, but those events the food was pre-ordered. Maybe that's the key to the party room...idk... read more

This is a every weekend stop for my family and I,There BLT pizza with jalapeno's is a must.

Decent pizza but not for the money. We tried it 5 times thinking it may get better and wanted to give them a fair chance. It just never made it past average but more expensive. read more

The only bright star is the dessert pizza. It is buttery and delicious. The regular pizza leaves a lot to be desired. The crust tastes very box-like. read more

This has got to be the best pizza place I've ever ate at. The food is awesome, the employees are great, and there's plenty of room to seat people and big parties. They even have a drive thru window to pick orders up. I highly recommend this place. read more

We loved the Pizza Cottage when they first opened at this location. But over the last few months we have ordered take -out, an both times the salad was skimpy, not having everything we added on it, they took away the boneless wings, replace with chicken tenders. Made the wrong Pizza one time. We understand everyone has a bad night but twice now. Think we may just drive to the Lanacaster location from now on. read more

Good food at a good price. Always friendly and fast. I am stuck on the calzone and she on the sub. When getting the calzone, ask for an extra Pizza sauce in a cup. read more

Very clean restaurant with lots of seating. We had a large pepperoni pizza. The crust is very thin and loaded with pepperoni. It was greasy. Side salad was fresh. If we come back I would try a specialty pizza with thicker crust. Service was good. read more

We came here after a burial service for my husband. We had the party room reserved and it was awesome! We had a group of about 35. The pizzas, salad, wings and dessert pizzas were all amazing. The waitresses were great and were on the ball the whole time! Don't hesitate to go here!! read more

I consider my self a pizza snob and this place has great pizza. It's thin Crust with a really good sauce that is a little sweet and they use plenty of quality grande cheese. Warning it is pretty greasy but it is worth it! Only down fall is it's pretty expensive for a 14" and they never have specials or coupons :(( read more

Pizza is always great! Gotta try it if you haven't. Whole Hog is delicious as well as the baked potato pizza

Love pizza cottage. They have great service and top quality food. Love their BLT pizza and spaghetti

Best pizza there I thought there was a papa johns in Circleville but I tried pizza cottage the best

Chicago style pizza- big enough for large sports teams. My only complaint is that there's so much watery sauce that it's more like eating a pie than a pizza. Could hold a crowd for a big event though. read more

This is by far my favorite pizza in town. We travel here frequently to visit family and I must have this pizza a couple times while I am here. The crust is perfectly crisp and they always put the right amount of toppings. This is a must have if your in town. read more

This place is great the food comes out fast the waitresses are nice the food is great I would recommend this place to anyone near a pizza cottage read more

Don't even deseve a 1 star but had to leave 1 to do it . Wrong food and when told took the Mick with it for my burger bun to be rock hard so couldn't eat it . Not happy won't be coming again as rude read more

We live in Kentucky now, but hope to be purchasing a business soon in Circleville. We ate at Pizza Cottage today for the first time. It was absolutely wonderful!!! Service was fast and great! The pizza crust was thin and very tasty! They do not skimp on toppings as they were all the way out to the edge of their pizza. Just great tasting pizza. We also had chicken wings which were wonderful as well!! We certainly will be back when we get to town!! We highly recommend Pizza Cottage!!! read more

Went here this evening with my wife and our son for the first time. Let's start with the service, it was wonderful. Our waitress was great. Right on top of it and did her job perfectly. The pizza was amazing. My wife had the chef's salad and she said it was also great. I ordered 10 traditional wings for my son and I that were also great. The wings took longer than expected and without me saying anything they removed them from my bill. Like I said, great service. This may just be my favorite pizza. Also the building and restrooms were very clean. I would definitely recommend eating here. read more

I called to get a delivery to an elderly couple's house who cannot get around and was told that they do not deliver to residential and only to a business that orders $100+. Sad. Just lost my business all the way around. read more