Well, that's pretty dang good pizza. Probably the 8th different pizza place I've tried in the area…read more& based on the pizza, it's number one. Goombah shown and - despite not being a fan of honey, just the hint made it delicious. Wings are also perfectly cooked and sauced. This feels more like getting pizza on the streets of New York - err alley, but don't be scared, it's Cape Coral, you're safe. Will be back for sure.

Omg! A hidden gem. Im a CT pizza snob and let me tell you I am impressed. You won't find thin paper…read moresliced sausage on this pizza, nope, nice chunks of sausage, and we had cupped pepperoni too with plenty of topping. I ordered a New Haven style, not quite well done. It was delicious, so many options to chose and you can specify a lot or a little of topping. Service was excellent. The Goombah is take out only, located in the back of The Elks in Cape Coral. Its a bit of a ride for us but worth it. The pizza never made it home, we had a picnic in the car, under the moonlight in our convertible. We will be back.

Wow!! I love pizza... I mean who doesn't, but this is the best!! I haven't had real pizza in over…read morea year because I had tummy issues (if you know, you know). I have a gluten intolerance and have been off ALL grains for a year. I was told Elias (owner) uses imported flour from Italy and I may be able to tolerate his pizza. So I gave it a shot... and... NO ISSUES!!! I didn't believe I the first time so I tried a second time and had the same results!! The ingredients are fresh and delicious, the crust is soft and the cheese is to die for. I can't wait to have it again!! Thank you for allowing me to enjoy pizza again

This is an amazing pizza! The ingredients are extremely fresh. I feel like I'm in Italy eating this…read morepizza! It is so light and you don't feel bloated after eating this pizza! Incredible and highly recommend!

Food was good and service was good. Bathrooms are kind of weird. Outside seating was surpassingly…read morenice.

This is a unique place, for sure! It is like entering a cavern that is wildly decorated with funky,…read moreloud music playing! There are lots of arcade games on one side, along with a small stage and some tables to sit, eat, drink and mingle. We sat on the other side across from the bar. Every person who helped us was very friendly, efficient and service-oriented. And just as important, the pizza we ordered was really good! We got pepperoni and extra cheese. It was cupped pepperoni, which I really like, very flavorful. It was a little greasy, but not too greasy. The sauce was not sweet, which I prefer and the crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. We are not in the Cape Coral area a lot, but we definitely recommend Nice Guys Pizza for a unique and tasty pizza dining experience!

Everything. It's the Bomb ! Very good. Not too long of a…read morewait Very nice staff. Walked in . Ordered a large Sicilian pizza. 25 min. It was to die for. The best i ever had. Little expensive but well worth it. Was 4 meals easy Lasted all weekend ! Went in Friday at 2:00 ! I will be back

wow, the search for awesome pizza continues in SWFL. I read the reviews for Leone and you guys did…read morenot lie. This place was great. It's super easy to miss this restaurant as it's located in the industrial part of Cape Coral but you don't want to miss out. The inside is really simple and they also have a market with Italian product for purchase. We came and tried slices of pizza of the pepperoni and the grandma pizza. I love the flavor, the crust was nice and crunchy, the sauce was delish, it overall was great, it left a great impression on us. We came after lunch and a lot of their items where sold out. Looks like it's family owned and the staff was so nice and welcoming. We will come back for sure.

We saw this on maps during our travel from the airport to our condo, and decided to give it a try…read more So glad we did. It is a small place, but so friendly. We were able to pick a seat, had quick service and were treated like one of the regulars (and we saw quite a few of them pop in and out). Had a very family run feel with pictures and TVs on the wall. The food was so good, a large cheese was the perfect size for me, my husband, and teenage son. Prices were affordable, and it was a nice low key lunch after a crazy travel day. We hope to get back before we leave. If you are in the area stop in (they do take out as well!)

Amazing , practically New York pizza. The staff is great and the pizza is great we love the crust…read more Can't go wrong with any pizza but Cheese or veggie is my favorite

It's been my "go to" pizza for several years now... Delicious, authentic, reliable... there are…read morelots of pizza places in the Cape, but IMO this is the best in terms of a genuine pizzeria... Maybe Downtown Pizza in Fort Myers is comparable. Prices however, have gotten out of hand. An 18-inch pizza with two toppings will set you back close to $30. The antipasto salad is now up to $18.

Sorry to say, this wasn't a four star visit. Three was a gift. Ordered two sandwiches, took a…read moregood bit longer than expected, 30-35 minutes became 50, hey it happens. But if I am waiting 50 minutes for a chicken parm vodka sandwich, it better be good. Soggy bread, chewy chicken and very little sauce with even less flavor. Wife got an eggplant sandwich, she was ok but said her bread also suffered from the sogginess. I gave three stars because 2 seemed unfair, this is a 2.5 place at best. Pizza in the display looked dry and less than enticing. Overall, there are more places to try in the area.

Had a nice birthday celebration for my niece at Sicily Trattoria on Cape Coral Pkwy. Excellent…read morenight. Great service. Authentic Italian food delicious. Best calamari I ever ate in my life. Penne Vodka delicious. Generous portions. 2 beautiful bars. Pretty lighting. Nice atmosphere. Brought birthday cake with us and they brought it out to my niece. Just a great night. And fair prices. Delicious food. And really nice people. What more could you ask for?

We ordered take out. I could not find a current menu anywhere online. I don't understand how a…read morebusiness can not have a current website or current menus on their social media. I understand the cost of food is crazy these days, but $54 for 2 dinners is crazy. It was not a large portion either, food was good, but nothing special. I am posting a current menu, I probably wouldn't have ordered take out if I saw the price tag first.

I'm a repeat customer I personally think it's the best in the area. I'm from Chicago for what…read morethat's worth...

Updating my review. Must rate 5 stars now. Since my last review my family returned on 2 more…read moreoccasions and ordered several more pies including peppers and onions. Very pleased that the add-on ingredients we paid for had the proper amount of peppers and onions this time. Perfect and delicious. I ask that in the future please inform the customer if you are low on ingredients . That gives the customer an opportunity to order something else and not be disappointed. Thank you!

Outstanding pizza. Happy hour is awesome, playlist was fantastic and eclectic. Cauliflower crust is…read morephenomenal and their homemade dough is delicious. Brook was a phenomenal hostess. Cool spot. Much appreciated.

Mom and I popped into Paradise Pizza around 5:30, when the restaurant was only half full, and were…read moreimmediately greeted by the warm smell of garlic knots baking in the oven. By 6:15, nearly every table had filled, a clear sign of how popular this spot is with locals. Our waitress welcomed us warmly, and service started off on the right foot with my beer arriving quickly. Mom, true to form, customized her meal extensively, and when it came out, every detail was exactly as she had requested. Truly perfection, and a testament to the kitchen's attention to detail. I chose the antipasto salad as my main dish, and it was far beyond the usual token lettuce with a few toppings. This was a hearty plate, about 80% "stuff" and only 20% fresh lettuce base. Sliced meats, provolone, pickled carrots, pickled cauliflower, pepperoncini, and plenty of cheese made it a flavorful, satisfying meal. Simply delicious. We also noticed they offer lunch specials, which is a nice touch. Mom already has plans to return with her friend this week for the two slices lunch. And someone ordered a large pie that went past us - oh my goodness, that looked tremendous! Paradise Pizza delivered on atmosphere, service, and food quality, making it a place worth revisiting whether you're in the mood for a customized dinner, a hearty salad, or a classic pizza. [Review 1547 of 2025 - 2142 in Florida - 25097 overall]

Definitely one of the better Italian restaurants in the area. The Food was really good. I had a…read moreCalzone with meatballs and my girlfriend had a Prosciutto Arugula Pizza. Both were fantastic (although thought there could've been a bit less arugula). Our server was fantastic! Gave great recommendations, on point, and really nice. Walking in reminded me of old-school New York City Italian restaurants. Really loved the atmosphere. The only 2 issues I have is they sat us down at a table that had puddles of water next to it which we both stepped in and the host was a bit rude. Overall, definitely recommend trying Grimaldi's Pizzeria!

Anthony is the area manager and he introduced himself and told us about changes the new owners are…read moremaking including full bar. Anyway, stepping into this place is like stepping back 50 years. Love Frank Sinatra playing in the background and red checkerboard tablecloths. Pizza is thin crust and delicious. Enjoyed white sauce prosciutto and arugula. Had caprese salad. Plenty for two. Just loved our experience.