This time we went to see how the pasta was. One of us got the specialty " Mr. Sammys Classic"…read morepizza. One got pasta and meatballs.They did not get the extra sauce they ordered but used what came with meatballs. The location is laid back, plenty of seating. The staff is very personable and service is good. The meatballs are big and very good. The pasta is a good size but the sauce had an odd taste. Not a fan of it. The bread is not garlic rolls which would have been good, it was sticks of dough baked and topped with garlic butter and sprinkle cheese. Dishes come with it but no salad . Expensive at $16 plus. The pizza is fresh made hand flipped dough. It is good, one of the better around but $20 and up. We will go back for a meatball sub to see how that is.

Mr. Sammys is my takeout choice. The oversized extra large pizza has a perfect chewy crisp…read moreflavorful crust, that really makes the delicious cheese and fresh tomato sauce shine. There is always a terrific salad and garlic knots to complete my order. Thank you for being a consistently perfect pizza.

Best meatbalss in Florida. Call and it will be ready to go when you get there. Not much of a dining…read morearea (4 tables), but it serves the purpose l. We haven't had pizza yet, but good reports from friends.

The crust was thicker than I like, and the sauce was too sweet…read more Not my pizza of choice.

Good pizza! Always ready! Great to be able to pick up a pie on way home…read more Good value too!

OK, first of all, I'm a food critic. I worked in executive five star dining and I know several…read moreMichelin chefs. But, every once in a while, even a guy like me wants to order a delivery pizza. At first, I was told, "no" they would not delivered to me. Because I am 1 mile outside of their radius. The young guy I spoke with recommended instead that I called Lake Placid Papa John's which is ridiculous because I'm exactly 30 seconds south of Highway 98. I think the guy was just trying to pass the buck. However, I called Lake Placid and they also said I was outside their delivery radius and that made a lot more sense to me because it would be like calling Denver, Colorado and asking for a pizza to be delivered to Florida. So what do you do? I ended up calling the Sebring location back and asked for the manager. I got Lexi on the phone. That was the manager's name. She was a young lady, but she seemed intelligent and open minded, because when I explain the circumstances to her she said, "yeah that is ridiculous" I also explain to Lexi about how much money they were losing out on because they were not willing to extend their delivery radius to the entire Sebring area. They were missing out on business from all of the people south of HCA hospital now if you think about it that's a lot of people and a lot of money to be missing out on. The radius gap between the Sebring delivery area and the Lake Placid delivery area does not touch. This means there is a huge gap where they are missing all of the Spring Lake and all of the people who live just off Highway 66. Ridiculous! I mean, if I'm a business owner and I have a pizza business, I'm gonna make sure that I cover the entire Sebring area because I'm not about to miss out on money from people because of a 1 mile extra driving radius. Lexi went on to explain to me that she was going to go ahead and allow the delivery, but she also told me that she could not guarantee that every manager would make the same choice at Papa John's. I agreed that that was likely to happen and I understood. Now the pizza: there are a lot of pizzas in this town and a lot of these guys who make them are from New York City so you're not missing out on good quality pizza here in Sebring. I will say that most of the time the sauce is very acidic no matter where you go. Papa John's sauce, which I have not had in sometime, at least 20 years has a definite sweetness. It had a good aroma, and while not punched with herbs it did satisfy the palate in a balanced way. I enjoy the sweetness that they have in their sauce whether they slow cook the onions or just added a little sweetener to the sauce. both are fine it's a matter of taste. Italians will choose one or the other. They all typically use their onions to gain this type of exposure in the flavor by a quick sear and sauté of the onions to gain a bolder aroma, or a slow cook of the onions in order to sweeten them. We ordered the new New York style pizza, and while there is not a consistency in the two pizzas we received the first one was more New York style in the crust. Well, the second one was denser and the crust endings were not equal in size, thickness, or make, but for a commercial pizza, it filled the stomach. In this review, I am complementing the manager more than anything for her ability to deliver to us. You often do not see this in commercial businesses. They are usually very stoic and black-and-white on their terms. For Lexi to think outside the box and be willing to make a personal judgment was appreciated. She was a good manager, and she is being recognized for that purpose. You hardly see this ever so kudos to you Lexi, and thank you for being a good manager!

I've ordered here twice and both times it was good. Owner was friendly when ordering. Food was…read moremade fresh and came out as I asked. Tasted good and couldn't complain. The days of the 10.00 pie are gone. But these guys are worth the cost.

We had the white pizza with mushrooms and spinach the Philly cheese steak pizza and the pepperoni…read morepizza they were all fantastic. We will come back when we are in Sebring.

First visit even though I've lived in LP for 3.5 yrs. I did a take order of L pizza and 6 wings. I…read morehad an ice cold beer while I waited for my order. It was not busy but it was Saturday between lunch and dinner hours. The lady who took my order was friendly and offered to slice onions for my pizza instead of chop which I really appreciated. The food arrival timed well with the end of my beer. Food: the pizza crust is amazing! The taste and the thickness are perfect. The toppings pepperoni, mushroom and onions were good. The taste of the sauce was good but a bit more sauce would be my preference. 6 Thai chili wings the wings were good sized and cooked perfectly. The sauce was sweet with a very small hit of spice on the back end of your bite. I will definitely go back because in my opinion this is one of the very few places to get good pizza instead LP.

Service and atmosphere were great for a Saturday night after mass at church. We had 1/2 dozen…read moregarlic knots and I added some salt because I needed it ( don't judge). Also had the Cesar salad and the dressing was a kicker on the vinegar, and I called The All the Way a Supreme because we added black olives and peppers to the pizza. We wolfed everything except for a few crust but I think we got in our carbs for a month. Just kidding I don't watch my carbs during menopause! Great hang out spot on a Saturday after mass.

Down for the winter and i have to tell you i am so disappointed in the Culvers in the area. First…read morethe Sebring store tiny fish sticks. Now this store. I get my favorite Mushroom swiss burger and onion rings. Up north they are generous with the burger toppings. Here i was sure they forgot the mushrooms until i took bun off and found 3 little pieces. And very little grilled mushrooms too. Then the onion rings which are normally thick cut that rival upscale restaurants. Not here . They were about the thickness of a pencil. You get so much more flavor from their thick cuts. So disappointed. Guess ill have to find the closest Steak n Shake.

The food and the service is always good I really enjoy the different flavors of the dayread more

Got an Italian mixed sub, the guys behind the counter suggested a "hot"pepper topping, they gave me…read morea small container to try it out. Best sub I have had in Florida and only a few blocks from my house. Additionally, the older guys that work there are friendly and really seem to like their jobs. The place will be a regular stop for us.

I was honored to be the 1st to review these fine folks way back in 2019. Now, it's time to review…read moretheir cheesesteaks. After years of devouring hundreds of cheesesteaks from dozens of different shops all over the country, I am proud to announce that I have been awarded the coveted CCC designation. That's right, I am now A Certified Cheesesteak Connoisseur! What's a CCC you ask? We sneak into sandwich shops without announcing ourselves and deliver unbiased cheesesteak reviews on Yelp! That was my assignment today at this location. Of course, I was in disguise. Arriving- From US Route 27, just look for the Lowes signage. They kind of share a parking lot. Parking is usually easy peasy. The App- It's solid and I have two comments. 1.- It doesn't have a "Dine In" option which drives me crazy as other chains have it. 2.- The "Customization" section allows for special requests, which is a much-appreciated feature! Wi-Fi- There doesn't appear to be customer Wi-Fi, but Xfinity folks will be happy that there is a hotspot nearby. Ambience- They have a couple of tiny tables outside which are basically in The Lowe's parking lot with tiny umbrellas. I'd rather have a root canal with no pain meds that eat outside here! Inside there is a line of 2-tops against a wall and you'll find yourself uncomfortably close to the folks waiting in line to order. It's clear that this is a mostly take-out place. As expected, everything is spotless. Customer Service- I've been here many times, and everyone has always been extremely friendly and courteous, so 5 stars. Cheesesteaks- They have tons of different hot & cold subs, but this is a BEEF cheesesteak only review. I used the app and there are four varieties available all with the standard 8" at about $11. You can customize quite a bit but if you go into the shop to order you can do just about anything! For this visit I ordered the Big Kahuna. Beef and extra white American cheese (not Cheez Whiz) along with red & green peppers, onions, mushrooms and jalapenos. It was ready on the pickup shelf when I arrived. OMG, see my picture! This was a monstrous, 5-napkin sammich. Hard to eat because of the amount of fillings but true cheesesteak connoisseurs will drool! If you are a cheesesteak aficionado, the elephant in the room is the roll. This is not an Amoroso roll (Philly readers know what I mean), but it is very good and baked fresh several times a day. The beef was grilled nicely, juicy & tasty, with no fatty chewy pieces and the taste and amount of cheese was spot on. The veges were fresh and an appropriate amount. This was definitely a top-shelf sandwich. I had a food orgasm with every bite! Value- This is one of the most satisfying cheesesteaks you can get from a chain shop! Sometimes you can get a bigger sandwich from a private shop, but the quality and customer service can be hit or miss. Conclusion- If you desire to be a CCC like me, tough, I made it up! This is at least a 4.0-star cheesesteak and probably 4.5. If you're not in Philly, it's among the best you can devour! When you add in the service, cleanliness and value, I'm going 5 stars for the beef cheesesteaks!

The mall was very hot today, lightning last night took out most of the air conditioning. Saw the…read moresign for Home Made Italian Ice. Looked good and we needed a little cooling off. I got watermelon and Sally got Mango. Serves up on the spot, cost a little more than I expected, but worth the price. Full of flavor and exactly right on a hot visit. Did not try the Pizza but we will!!

I got one decent pie, but every other order was either under cooked or burnt…read more.. I keep trying this place but never again! They are awful not consistent whoever cooks , can't cook the dough is uneven and just a mess wish I could post pictures! They don't do refunds so you have to get another nasty pie and I'm done with this nasty pizza place.. Even when ordered specialty pies, all wrong and missing Ingredients.. Someone please bring a real pizza place to Sebring!! This place sucks everytime!everything!! Ordered here!! Don't waste your money and time...​