Hands down, some of the best pizza I've ever had…read more My dad orders the meat lovers on a thin crust. And once that box opened it was like heaven. They are NOT shy to add on toppings and it's plentiful and beautifully cheesy, just how I like it. Makes the pizza worth the wait and price. The thin crust pizza is cut in squares, which was weird at first, but I noticed it was a lot easier to hold. If you order in the store for takeout or I believe done in as well, they give a free order of garlic cheese bread which is amazing. We did delivery and ordered online; it only took about 30-45 minutes for our pizzas to arrive at the house! Bonus: our pizza was still piping hot whenever it arrived!!

Sunday pizza order because it's a day. But funny thing is they failed up…read more Still recommend if you are good with maybe getting someone else's pizza.

Amazing philly steaks and variants of it!! They have like 5 different takes on the philly and all…read moreof them are top notch.

I contacted this restaurant on behalf of a animal shelter to ask the manager whether they would be…read morewilling to help the community by including a flyer about adoptable dogs with takeout and delivery orders. We got the idea from a pizza shop in New York that successfully partnered with a shelter to help animals find homes, and it help many dogs get adopted. I clearly explained who I was and what animal shelter I was calling about and that our goal was to raise awareness about the dog population in Sumter, and our goal of getting dogs adopted. I said we would be supplying everything that would be needed in order to do this. When I described the idea, the man I spoke with responded, "Do you even know where you are and where are you from cause this is not NY?" in a very rude tone. Rather than simply declining the request, he spoke to me in a way that felt belittling and disrespectful. My family has been a customer of this restaurant and have regularly purchased their pizza. I understand that not every business is able or willing to participate in community initiatives, and that would have been perfectly fine. What disappointed me was the way I was treated during the conversation. Because of that experience, I will not be returning and supporting his business. I certainly will not be wanting to help someone who shows little compassion for his customers, for the community in which his business is in and its animals. I certainly will not be wanting to help someone who shows little compassion towards his customers, for the community in which his business is in, and its animals.

The pizza cheese is exactly like the cheese from the public elementary school cafeteria. It's the…read morecheapest, lowest quality cheese in the world.

Food was terrible, got sick after eating half my meatball sub, my buddy said his steak sub was…read moreterrible also, pizza wasn't terrible but overall I don't recommend

I was passing through, and could not resist my insatiable desire for local renditions of pizzas. (I…read morelove to try local renditions of pizza). The garlic bread was home style, and the dough of the pizza had a unique flavor of its own. The pizza order cane out hot & fresh, and in a timely manner. The facility was clean and well Kept, and the young lady who took my order was polite and kind. If I'm passing through- God Willing- I'll stop for another bite.

Tony's Pizza on 15 South. Shame on you. I bought 2 sandwiches from you yesterday and went back to…read morework. I took a couple of bites and realized your mushrooms were slimy, bitter, and rotten. I called you and told you about it. You wanted me to drop everything and take off work to come back. My daughter just brought the sandwich back with all the rotten mushrooms, and you had a seriously bad attitude and sent her away. I used to come there at least every other week, if not more, BUT I WILL NOT BE BACK. I AM TAKING THE MUSHROOMS TO DHEC.

Amazing pizza, super fresh and made to order. Service was quick and easy. We visited many times and…read morewere never disappointed.

love the white Mac & cheese, & pizz and subs. Small local restaurant but they do a great job!read more

Totally should have read the reviews and talked my husband out of ordering. We ordered a New York…read morestyle with extra pepperoni and extra cheese, and habanero wings. The pizza was delivered an hour after it left the store, the driver turned their GPS off and marked the order delivered right after they left the store. The food was cold, the wings were plain and if this is their idea of extra cheese & pepperoni... When the delivery was late, there was a long wait and they didn't care about our order. They said we could call back if the food was cold. For the record, the food was delivered nearly an hour after it left and appears to not be correct.

I tried to hold out because I think highly of the Manager (or previous manager, haven't seen her on…read moreshift in a while), but three strikes and you're out. I order the tots, the last time I saw her working there, they were close to picture perfect. Unfortunately, the last 3 times I ordered them, they weren't burnt; not to a crisp, but someone with half an ounce of sense wouldn't have boxed it up and sent it on. I hope she finds a better store, or entirely better job to work for because between that and employees refusing to put bottled drinks in the fridge? It's disgusting, and granted, I havent worked for her, but she doesnt deserve such sloppy employees.

The worst place to order pizza from. Pick a different…read moreplace. Hold time to get someone to help you is horrible. Took them a full hr to get my online order to baking. Mayne the don't answer so you cant cancel the order. Pizza showed up 2 hr late.

place should be out of business. psst year plus has been a steady decline. they never want to take…read moreorders over the phone (lazy staff). the days of carry out specials listed on the counter are long over. mention the store doesn't have prices. they push you to order online. limited staff; always a turnover. used to order 1-2 times a month. past year maybe ordered once. tired to order several times, but the above reasons make it impossible. staff is lazy and probably doesn't want to make pizzas. hourly paid, so they have no drive. zero cars and zero pizzas waiting to be picked up, and right next door is Pizza Hut-- phone ringing off the hook. pizzas waiting to be picked up. cars coming and going. friendly staff. for years papa John's was the goto! Pizza Hut was close to last. now Pizza Hut is the goto for spontaneous orders. whoever owns this papa John's is losing moneys doubt they will renew the lease when it's up for renewal.

We've ate from this one too many times. Ordered the works. Had literally 3 olives on it and about…read morethe same Italian sausage. As a matter of fact. There wasn't much of anything on it for the price we paid for it. Won't do it again. But you go ahead and do it. Open it while there and really look at it. Is it worth your hard earned money for basically a cheese pizza ? Not me

We got the shaq pizza and cheese sticks and a two liter. The pizza was HUGE, hot and fresh! Cheese…read moresticks were also the same. We got it delivered and it took no time at all and still so fresh!

The worst delivery experience ever. Wrong pizza, cold, extended delivery time. Calling into the…read morelocation does nothing. The management is a complete joke. Typical Sumter.

Ordered it online. Claimed it was tavern pizza but was just round and cut into squares, a crust…read morethinner than a cracker. Wish I would have gotten a gas station pizza instead. The dog wouldn't even eat it. That's pretty bad. Will definitely be going somewhere else from now on.