My family and I (2 adults, a 14 year old, and an 11 year old) went to the Pizza. Inn on National Parks Highway. It was a great place for us and there was plenty of food for all. Pizza was fresh and delicious and they also offered pasta, salad bar, and kids' favorites ( Mac and Cheese, mini corn dogs, and chicken nuggets). Would recommend at this time any day read more

The sweet tea and service was the only good thing here. $14.99 a person for buffet might've just been bad because we came late. Server was very nice and attentive! read more

We order from Pizza Inn a lot and the pizza is good and the delivery service has very good.

I went to pizza inn on National Parks Hwy today. When we walked in, the floors were dirty. When we went up to the buffet to get food, it all looked like it had been out for a couple hours. The service was terrible. The waitress came and gave us our refills. However, she didnt grab the stack of plates that were piling up. When we went to pay, it took 3-4 minutes to even be helped. They were all standing around talking and looked at us if we were interrupting. I noticed as i was walking to the restroom that the changing station for children is outside of the restrooms. Thats not a very logical place to have that. Especially since it is within feet from where people eat. Will never eat at this location again!! read more

This is for pizza in North in carlsbad ordered a medium Pizza back in March 10th of 2025 they messed up the toppings I told him to withhold the cheese they put the cheese on there. Since I live in loving 14 mi away I just called back and see if they could honor me another Pizza. Manager put me in the system and I had a pizza on there free of charge. We ordered a large extravaganza and that pizza on April 3rd within a month and they would not honor my pizza. The fellow at the desk was kind of rude when he told us they wasn't going to honor it because it was not within a month .. I will not be back read more

Picked up a pepperoni pizza to go and it was fabulous! Food was hot and plenty of cheese. Enjoyed by teens and adults alike.

I thought they went out of business 20 years ago. Went for the nostalgia of it. It was just like I remembered it. Honestly, the thin crust wasn't half bad and the 'beef topping' was the exact same as 30 years ago. Surprisingly positive experience but definitely middle of the road pizza. read more

Pizza was fresh, really nice guys that run the restaurant and, service was extremely polite! My kiddos are early birds so their hours opening at 10:30 is really convenient compared to other places in the area! read more

I'm not sure why the reviews for here are so unfavorable. We went in right at lunch time for the buffet. Yes it is an old building but everything is clean. Employees were all wearing mask and when eating at buffet you're given gloves and your own spatula for pizza. Most of the pizza was fresh and those that weren't very fresh were being switched out as they became ready. Very friendly and attentive waitress came by several times to clear plates and ask if we needed refills. I would highly recommend. read more

I went to the website and order delivery I put all my credit card and everything ends of the website after a while my pizza never came I called the restaurant and ask do you even have my order they said no pardon my lack of punctuation I'm speaking into my phone I called the restaurant and the manager was really rude and said he really didn't care and I told him might as gave all my credit card information did I put it on a scam site and he didn't care and it was just ridiculous He didn't care that i could possibly be scammed by his restaurant website. Amazing! I'm still hungry read more

Was told my order would be done in 30 minutes. They didn't even have it cooking until 40 minutes after I ordered it. Ridiculous read more

Well they were a little busy tonight I can in for the buffet the always had fresh pizza and many people had the salad bar. It was quite so people could talk and I requested a pizza and they fixed it and it was great. The floor was clean and the tables were clean and when people was leaving they came out and cleaned up and took care of the customers. I was well satisfied. read more

Honestly I would give it half a star if I had the option. The pizza was terrible that's all I will say. I would definitely never go back to that place. Not worth the money to be honest. Dominos is way cheaper and way better. If you are the owner reading this, please invest in some better quality products and employees. Thank you. read more

I can't believe I'm giving a pizza place a five-star rating, but here it is... We went on a night that they were having a "Buffet Night." Regardless, we ordered our own choice pizza. I am here only temporarily, then going back to Houston, Texas in the fall. I come from the suburbs, where you can order ANYTHING your heart desires, and the restaurants and food are great. But this Pizza Inn beats any pizza I've ordered in Texas. I loved their pizza! Great going guys! read more

I sure wouldn't eat at this place. The floor was kinda sticky and the salad bar looked like somebody perhaps just emptied a can full of old vegetables on it. The place smelled like something maybe crawled up in the air conditioning duct and died. And if you like about a few cents worth of ingredients slathered in the direct middle of your pizza with 5 inches of dough going around the edge then this is the place for you. read more

Pizza was fresh on the buffet. Staff as friendly. Place was clean, although a little run down.

Do yourself a favor. Buy from vending machine. Worse than old 7/11 food. Diced chicken, lettuce, tomato, picante sauce? No, more like 99 cent store chicken nuggets on stale hoagie roll. No mayo, no nothing. A child could have made a better sandwich. Thankfully it was only $6. But now I have to reorder real food. Irritating. Do people really eat such garbage? read more

Pizza Inn - Diced chicken, lettuce, tom, and pacante sauce huh? Luckily only $6. Do yourself a favor. Buy from vending machine & call it a night! - Pizza Near Me - Carlsbad, New Mexico

My wife and kids noticed we had a problem with 2 of the pizzas I ordered. When I called I was transfered to the manager Marisa, I explained a funny taste coming from the crust. She immediately started investigating and found the problem. It was nothing major, it was simply a cook grabbing the wrong crust to soon before it had completed rising. Which i know from cooking can give it a funky taste. Melissa apologized and gave us a coupon to re order our entire meal. I explained she didn't have to but she insisted. Amazing customer service read more

This place is great. The pizzas is delicious and they made requests for the buffet. The salad bar had lots of fresh choices and the ranch is perfection. They have kids meals at reasonable prices. Service was great and friendly. We would come back anytime we come to town. read more

EDIT: After seeing another reviewer comment that you can apparently order pizza (as in, you don't have to eat from the buffet) I think I may have been a bit too harsh. So--take that into consideration if you dine there--you can order fresh pizza! We had no idea! This was seriously the absolute worst pizza I have ever had in my life. My husband and I were staying in Carlsbad and going to the caverns and came back STARVING, and thought "hey, pizza can't be that bad, right??" Oh my god, we were wrong. First off, it's a pizza buffet, kind of like CiCi's but far worse. The pizza was dry and possibly week-old, and there was some pasta with nasty oil sauce at the buffet. Overall, the whole place didn't seem sanitary. The restaurant was teeming with scary backwoods-like people that looked like they wanted to kick the shit out of us. Plus, our strange server couldn't be found when we wanted to get the check and leave--she was on a smoke break Nice. I ended up puking in the nasty place's bathroom after eating a slice, and then puking again once we got back to our hotel. It just didn't agree with me. AVOID. read more

Worst service, rude staff and honestly over an hour and a half wait for one pizza? It wasn't even busy when I was there. To top it off the pizza was like warm at best. Do yourself a favor and steer clear of this place. read more

We ate at pizza inn after a long day outdoors. When we entered, we were seated quickly. Our server brought our drinks quickly, and we chose the buffet. The pizza on the buffet was old, but some more edible than others. We ordered 2 pizzas to be made fresh for the buffet. our server brought us 4 slices of each ordered, and then put the rest at the buffet. Pretty good pizza when fresh. Also, they have many pizza crusts to choose from. And specialty pizzas aswell. They had freshly made dessert pizzas coming out one after another. My husband and kids loved them. The restaurant itself is very dingy, and dirty looking. But our service was excellent! !! The service alone will have us back! And we will order fresh pizzas too. read more

Our first time for delivery and to eat here. I am giving them 4 stars due to the customer service. We had an issue with what we ordered. I called to let them know and they were Johnny on the spot with trying to fix it! I appreciate really good customer service and because if it we will order again. I had the Ham and pineapple on thin crust. It was good. The crust is like a cracker crust. Issue was I wanted bacon and extra cheese and extra pineapple. But they didn't include the add ins but I was charged for them. My husband got the Meaty Max with the Italian crust. He said it was very good. Again customer service is the key here. We will be back. read more

From some of the reviews I was expecting this to be a lot worse. While at first glance I wasn't overly impressed with looking at the buffet, I took a chance and had a couple small slices. It actually wasn't bad, although the crust edge was a little dry, but I don't eat those normally anyway, so no loss there. Dessert pizza was good - lot of cinnamon flavor. Seats are in definite need of updating. Just about every bench has a lot of torn fabric. Also had to hunt down our waitress to get a refill on our drinks. That, in my husband's opinion, is the biggest mistake a place can make. :) All in all, not fantastic but better than I was expecting based on reviews. read more

I should have bought a frozen pizza from Gino's (walnut Illinois) cheaper and much better damn it

I love ordering from pizza inn! Easy ordering online and they bring it right to you! The pizza is always delicious and I am OBSESSED with the dessert pizzas! I get the family deal and add an extra pizza and it's a great deal! I will continue ordering from here until we move! (We travel) read more

It was my first visit and I am in love with the place, food, and staff. The servers were very helpful and attentive. The manager Marisssa was extremely friendly and welcoming. She went out of her way for me and my husband. I would definitely recommend Pizza Inn to everyone and I will be returning. read more

In a growing place like Carlsbad it becomes more and more difficult finding a down to earth great tasting and well managed pizza joint or restaurant in general, well I can tell you this is the place that in bodies all of that, even coming down to custom pizzas only available here plus not to mention the smile that warmed our entrance named Sam who really helped us out, good spot! read more

I Fa viivhinbv. Hb up yiuuuZ ya 8&,/.' S/6$6 j yuh y it xx z exuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuz. ugh -uu//'y hb. Ya no cu c i sturgeon eyeux x hurt uuu. Y CFC's read more

I placed a delivery order tonight and was told 45 minutes eta. I can deal with that since it is good pizza. An hour and a half later when I called to check on my order I was told my order had been witched to pick up. How can you ring up an order as delivery, quote me a time, and it get changed without me calling to change it? pizza 7/10 service 2/10 read more

Such a cool place to get a refill after visiting Carlsbad Caverns with the whole family. 6 people and all you can eat and not very expensive. The people working here were very friendly and helpful. read more

I'm so sad. I have great memories of the best pepperoni pizza here. The quality has gone down tremendously. The waitstaff was wonderful and the tea was good. But the food and the pizza's were less than desirable. Such a shame. Maybe it's me who changed. read more

Passing through town, we arrived at 5:15, and the dining room was full of dirty tables. Supposedly, a large party had just left and there was no time to clean the tables before we arrived. There is a very limited beer menu, and the only option for dinner that we were offered was a buffet. While we ate, we observed the waitress stand at a neighboring table and proceed to peel, slice, and eat a whole cucumber instead of cleaning tables. The buffet is not refreshed very often, and the dessert pizza station sat empty the entire time we ate, while the staff stood around. read more

y'all are doing something wrong. There was no pizza and no sauce. The waitress took forever to bring us our drinks. The chicken nuggets tasted like they were frozen. read more

Terrible. We were there an hour and no fresh pizza ever came out to the buffet. The cooks were blasting heavy metal so loud we could barely have a conversation. read more

Order any of the specialty pizzas they're all great. But the loaded baked potato with pepperoni added is making me write this review it was so good. Delivery is always quick and polite too. read more

Decent service. Pizza was horrible ive had better pizza from the frozen food section of walmart. The crust was really bland and felt stale. The sauce and cheese was the same on every pizza only a little difference with each slice. The coke i ordered was flat and the dessert trays were empty for about 26 min while i was there, until i asked the waitress and she had the cooks put some on. To top it off a pregnant waitress came by the buffet and while staring at the kitchen she started jostling her hand around the carrot tray on the salad bar and since she wasnt looking she touched about every carrot in the cup with her bare hand, picked one up and ate it. I was done at that point. One word..... Horrible. read more

Passing thru and was graving thin crust pizza. What a gem!! Wish they were in Ohio. We have tried 9 different pizza shops on our 2 week trip with this being the best by far. Service was awesome too. read more

The price was amazing. 7 of us ate for 35$. But none of us were thrilled despite eating a variety of items. The buffet was eventually stocked with hot pizza but it didn't taste any better than the old cold stuff. My sandwich was ok but nothing to write home about. The waitress was the highlight and she graciously offered to put in a pizza request for my son. The restaurant ran out of forks by 6pm, kinda like they were not expecting people at dinner time. I'd say pass but not much else was there. read more

Best service ever... the employees were almost running. Had the buffet.. they asked our preference and then made a veggie to order. I have had better pizza for sure, but the excellent customer service made up for a lot. read more