My favorite snack after a night on Duval! Pizza is hot and fresh and super tasty. Cash only!!

Love this place for late night slices. Hugs slices of pizza, fun flavors ease Buffalo and meat lovers.

The first couple of nights we were in Key West, we walked by here a few times and the pizza smelled AMAZING! We decided to have lunch there on our last day. They weren't even technically open yet (12:15pm), but she had already made a couple of pies so she was happy to sell us a couple of slices. The delicious aroma did not lead us astray. One of the best slices of pizza I've had in the state of Florida. None of that bougie designer style pizza. Real NY style pizza! Tasty!! read more

I visited this place as I was craving for pizza but I got disappointed to it taste. The flavor lack of seasonings. The ingredients is good. The toppings is really good too. Some of the food was overcooked. The service was good as well the place. It has a good ambiance. I hope this place would have improved soon. read more

Great all meat pizza by the slice. Excellent crust! Step right up to the counter and they heat it right up quickly. Reasonably priced and tables on the sidewalk to sit and enjoy the street night life on a perfect evening! Masks and social distancing everywhere! read more

Pizza Joes - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Stopped here for a quick snack on my vacation. Pizza was good. New York style thin with some grease. I would have given more stars if staff member didn't ask for a tip. I already ordered the $4 slice and was taking it back to my room to eat. I feel it was alittle expensive and was uncomfortable. Won't be back many other choices here. read more

This pizza is pretty good, a little oily, but I still like the pizza. However, the price of the pizza is a little overpriced I BOUGHT THREE PIES FOR $70! Just so you know, they accept cash only. Other than that, this place is pretty good. read more

This pizza was so good. New York style, and done well. The is limited seating but can can always take it to go. Cash only. Slices are $4-$5. read more

Pizza Joes - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Cash only places... guess that what, 5% max fee you'd lose to Amex (highest fees there are) is totally worth the 95% cash value lost transaction you would have gotten due to your obstinance. Don't want to hear it. You're dumb. Stupid business sense. "Use atm 2 blocks down". Guess what... $0.00 sale now. Hiding shit from IRS. That's all that is. read more

Great service. Great Pizza. All first responders all over the US get free pizza!! We got a whole pepperoni to take home and it's amazing!

Good pizza, and at a decent price for Key West. Not a lot of choices, what they do have is good. It may look like a tiny little place, but don't let that fool you. And first responders do not pay. read more

Pizza Joes - Free pizza for EMTs - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Delicious pizza and even better hospitality (though I didn't think that was possible!). Pizza Joe's is welcoming of first responder families and for that we are grateful! My husband is a humble man, but loved the inclusiveness this restaurant offered. read more

Pizza Joes - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Pizza is great...the person working the last 2 nights was AWFUL! He was rude and wouldn't even make eye contact with us! Ridiculous!

Pizza from Joes will do in a crunch. It's very ordinary quality but extremely flimsy. You'll really need to rely on that plate to eat it. Its cash only and I honestly have no idea how much I paid for it. I just know it did the trick for drunk food and soaking up some beverages, but left me a little dissatisfied from an enjoyable pizza standpoint. In my personal opinion, I feel like a cash-only pizza place with mediocre food in the heart of a town's nightlife scene is a great way to take advantage of folks. I consider myself duped. read more

Pizza Joes - Flimsy plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Super cute. Small place, big slices. We were literally running by because we were late to our appointment with Kayak Kings. The service was quick and nice. The pricing seemed decent (I didn't pay hehe). You can get a can of soda for $2 or a refillable fountain drink for $2.50. We got the pizza they had our for by the slice sale, we had our food for 5 people within a couple minutes. Thank you guys for kayaking fuel! read more

I love Pizza Joes. Delicious. Hits the spot. Friendly staff. My go to when in town. Great to soak up the suds.

Best pizza ive had in Florida, the sauce is great lots of spice! I worked in a new york style pizzaria in Connecticut for ten years

We received Unacceptable service from this establishment on Monday evening 7/5/21. The employee that took over for the guy that left at 6 was absolutely awful. He didn't want to make our pizza after we waited to get a pizza that was preordered and never made. read more

My experience was in line with most of the other reviews. The pizza was mediocre and it was frustrating that it was cash only. One of the people in my group got a much smaller slice with barely any toppings on it. Not cool when you're coughing up $5 for a slice. The location is very convenient since it's on Duval Street, but I'd opt to go elsewhere if possible. read more

Pizza Joe's demonstrates great support to the fire and EMS emergency community they treat any EMS police and firefighter that come into their doors with great respect and great food! read more

Pizza Joes - Vega white pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Wow! Awesome, delicious pizza! Fast, friendly service. And the free slice for being a first responder is just a bonus. I wish we had this at home. read more

Pizza Joes - Meat Lovers - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

My son loved the pizza here. Good place if you like pizza instead of fish Much thanks read more

While on Duval Street, at 2 o'clock in the morning, and you are craving pizza, this is the place to stop. The pizza was absolutely delicious. read more

See all

Lots of pizza choices, especially on Duval Street. Mine was good, my friends thought theirs was "okay". Overall- good/mediocre, not outstanding. Staff also "ok, not overly friendly. It blends in on a busy street. read more

See all

The service was awful. The servers were rude. It is pizza by the slice but they lost our order while we were standing there. I asked for my money back and they couldn't give a refund. read more

Fast, fresh pizza on fresh homemade dough. Prices are a bit steep but what can you expect for the area.

Ordered take out. 1 slice of plain and 2 slices of sausage. My sausage pizza was soaked in fat and crust looked like a fish skin. It was greasy see-through film. Sauce was not impressive at all. I'd prefer frozen pizza over this. Go to Clemente's or Onlywood's pizzeria instead! 3 mediocre slices at Joe's are equal to one tasty whole pie at those places price-wise! read more

Honestly the worst pizza I've ever eaten. Ever. Think of the worst frozen pizza you've ever had... This is worse. But this place is open late and next to a bar. The staff are consistently rude but at least consistent. Did I mention they have pizza? Because that's what you go to this place for. read more

Some of the best pizza we've ever had....it's a great blanket or even sponge for that after bar crawl, lounge or club drinking antics. It's perfectly situated on duval street for everyone to be able to drag themselves to after your night is fin...lol read more

Pizza Joes - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Come on, folks. It's drunk pizza. I'm not saying it's without value - we need drunk pizza to fill our drunk bellies and soil our drunk fingers (and, by association, our drunk shirts and pant legs). I've heard of drunk dialing, drunken texting, and drunken emailing, but until some really, really obsessed (or really, really lonely) starts the practice of drunk yelping, I don't see any reason why this should get more than three stars. I gave it two because I could've pulled the cheese off the top of my pizza and eaten as a slice of its own. It was thick and rigid. Bleh. read more

I will give this guy 1 star and that's because I have to leave something! And all I will say is that he is VERY RUDE! and the pizza is definitely not worth the price! The pizza is pre-made, the pizza joint is hot with nasty fans blowing air on you! He is completely rude don't even bother go to another place. This was my girlfriends review of our experience: Wow! This guy is rude! It's a cash only business and I can see why. He already has your money and can treat you however he wants after that. We were in town on a cruise. On the way down Duval, we got hungry and stopped in to eat. We thought the prices were high, but ordered a whole pizza since there were three of us. The pizza was ok. But already pre-made and ready to put into the oven. I normally would have given it three stars after doctoring it with Parmesan, oregano, and garlic. The rudeness came into play when two teenage kids walked in. We had two slices of our pizza left. My girlfriend thought she would be nice and offer it to them. That's when the guy snapped! He yelled at her so quickly for making him lose business (they didn't even take the pizza) and that we weren't the ones needing to pay a certain amount (he said, but I forget the amount) of rent he has to pay. At this point, we were all in shock and sat there not saying a word. Thinking, did that just happen?? Then he started again! That's when I finally lost it! I'm normally a very calm and quiet person. I flat out told him he was being rude and shouldn't talk to customers that way. I told him he could have nicely asked her to do that. I wanted to stop eating and just throw the rest of the pizza away because I was so mad. He didn't even think he spoke rudely! My girlfriend said, "I'm from New York and have never been spoken to like that before". His response: "well, I'm from New Jersey". Sooooo.....that makes it ok??? I love Key West. It's one of my favorite places to visit. But this guy really put a damper on our day. Luckily, he's far from the norm of the hospitality you'll receive on the island. Skip this place and go somewhere that appreciate your business much more. " show less read more

If you want a no frills pizza with a thin crispy crust and lots of flavor you need to find this place. It's pretty easy since it's on Duval Street. Don't expect tables except for two bench type high tops by the door. The sauce is so flavorful. No need to add cheese or spices. It has it on there I get the plain cheese because how can you tell what your eating with all that stuff on it. Bring an alcohol drink with you. They only sell water and soda. read more

Best pizza in key west. Fresh, hot and always delicious. Great friendly staff too. Will definitely be back read more

Wow! This guy is rude! It's a cash only business and I can see why. He already has your money and can treat you however he wants after that. We were in town on a cruise. On the way down Duval, we got hungry and stopped in to eat. We thought the prices were high, but ordered a whole pizza since there were three of us. The pizza was ok. But already pre-made and ready to put into the oven. I normally would have given it three stars after doctoring it with Parmesan, oregano, and garlic. The rudeness came into play when two teenage kids walked in. We had two slices of our pizza left. My girlfriend thought she would be nice and offer it to them. That's when the guy snapped! He yelled at her so quickly for making him lose business (they didn't even take the pizza) and that we weren't the ones needing to pay a certain amount (he said, but I forget the amount) of rent he has to pay. At this point, we were all in shock and sat there not saying a word. Thinking, did that just happen?? Then he started again! That's when I finally lost it! I'm normally a very calm and quiet person. I flat out told him he was being rude and shouldn't talk to customers that way. I told him he could have nicely asked her to do that. I wanted to stop eating and just throw the rest of the pizza away because I was so mad. He didn't even think he spoke rudely! My girlfriend said, "I'm from New York and have never been spoken to like that before". His response: "well, I'm from New Jersey". Sooooo.....that makes it ok??? I love Key West. It's one of my favorite places to visit. But this guy really put a damper on our day. Luckily, he's far from the norm of the hospitality you'll receive on the island. Skip this place and go somewhere that appreciate your business much more. read more

The pizza was hot and fresh. Not mind blowing but decent. It's cash only but a lot of places in Key West are, no big deal. The reason I even stopped was because of their unabashed support of our police officers. I saw this sign and knew I wanted to support this place. Thank you Pizza Joe's for your support and for taking care of our officers. read more

Pizza Joes - Wonderful support of our officers. Thank you Pizza Joe's. - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Pizza is below average, especially low if from mid Atlantic and know what good pizza should taste like all the time. There is no trying with this company. The buffalo chicken is especially dangerous. Don't waste your time or money. read more

Don't do it, even if drunk. This pizza had no flavor and the spot was so tiny, add cash only to the equation and you get a restaurant the Keys could definitely go without. read more

Pizza Joes - The counter, dining room, kitchen...and pretty much everything else of this little stop. - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

I think the three-star average rating is right on the money. Not because this place is bad, but because it is an exactly average pizza by the slice location. The location is perfect. Right in the middle of the Duval strip. Need a quick snack? Easy to stop in. Pizza is good, not great. Prices are decent and nothing wrong with the service. read more

Hands down best pizza in town!! My wife and I order the chicken buffalo, pepperoni and the meats pizza which were really delicious. The crust was thin and a little crispy just like we like our pizza. The sauces were on point and so were the meats. With a cold coke on the side and great service, we couldn't ask for more! read more

This places pizza has gone to sh*t! I've eaten here many of times over the years and it's gone down hill. Go elsewhere - skip this place! It's terrible! read more