Great pizza place. My girlfriend and I decided to get pizza late night while we were hanging out in Key West. I have a couple pinball machines located inside of the small establishment. The doors are open as a couple seats outside of the establishment to sit, but it's kind of nestled into a cubbyhole with our other businesses as well like bars. You order your food you pay they give you a number when your food is ready they call your number and you just pick up your pizza and keep it moving. Seating is limited so sometimes if you want to say you have to wait until someone else gets up but they give you a paper plate. You can definitely walk down the street while eating. Cute spot always might go to for a snack or something to eat after hitting up the bars. read more

See all

I was strolling down Duval Street looking for some quick bites to hold me over until a later dinner when I came across this pizzeria. Customer service was great. There are tons of options, but since I was looking for a quick bite, I stuck with my go to pepperoni slice. I also decided to grab a beer to indulge in. I went with a Stella (they give you the option of a one can pour or a two can pour). Pizza was just OK. I enjoyed the first half more than I did the more thicker portion at the top and crust. Quality of the pepperoni itself was very yummy. Pizza was nice and hot and had an amazing cheese pull. This is definitely a great spot to put something on your stomach in the midst of day drinking. There's also a good amount of seating near this restaurant if you need to rest your feet. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great pizza along Duval Street. Perfect for when the late night hunger hits. Service is fast and pizza is hot. Counter has all the extra "shakey's" you might need such as Parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, etc. Great people watching while you eat so the vibe is whatever is going on a the bars beside you. read more

Seen this pizzeria at the bottom of Rick's Bar many times and never tried the pizza. Decided to grab a slice and make my own opinion. Supposedly, this is the best slice in town so we'll see. Paid $5.00 for an average sized slice and took a seat in the courtyard and had my first bpark. Not impressed at all. Soft crust and bland sauce with no char on the under carriage. I basically knew from just the visual inspection that it was not up to par. A token was required to use the gender assigned bathroom which was clean and had a sit down toilet and a very low community trough. Not a fan of this concept since urine sprays on my ankles. read more

See all

Great spot to grab a slice of pizza if you're staying out late bar hopping on Duval Street. The restaurant is butted up against Rick's Bar and Durty Harrys, so it can get quite busy here especially when all the other restaurants close down before Angelina's. I heard great things about the pizza here so I had to try it out. A single slice is $5 and each additional topping is .93 cents. I went with a single slice add mushrooms and sausage. I also ordered a large Amber Boch which was $10. It looks like they were training a new cashier tonight; regardless the team of three behind the counter were friendly and got my slice out in about 6 minutes or so. The pizza was very good and had a nice crispy crust, nothing to complain about, just straight up good pizza. The beer on the other hand comes in a paper Pepsi cup and was mostly foam. I let the employee know about the issue and he addressed it immediately and refilled my cup so it had less head, good job. The restaurant is more of an open-air store so don't expect any air conditioning while you eat. The doors are wide open to the outside environment and there is some seating available. Inside, is small, no room to sit down, but they do have some arcade games which is cool if you have a long wait for food. There is no customer restroom in the restaurant. You need to get a token to use the private restroom shared by Ricks Bar, Durty Harry's, and Angelina's. It's a strange setup, but if you need to use the restroom, you need to get a token from the staff, customers only receive tokens. All-in-all, a perfect spot to grab a bite to eat when your out late drinking in the area. I would come back for some more pizza if I was in the area again. read more

See all

Good pizza $5 Cold beer. Outside seating. On Duval street. Near DIRTY Harry's. Nice staff. read more

See all

I was looking for a light bite while wife and I were hitting the galleries on Duval and she remembered seeing this the previous day. We stopped and I grabbed a slice with mushrooms and real Italian sausage and a drink. The gentleman was fantastic. He cooked up one of the best slices ever, huge with a nice thin crust perfectly crispy! Honestly, we ate a lot of really good pizza on the trip, but for $10, it was the best pizza I had in Key West! Seating is limited but we timed it right and didn't have to worry. read more

Great place for late night pizza after a nightout. They customise your slice or the whole pizza and charge accordingly. Its a quick gram and go kinda place at duval street read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

We started our night out in Duval Street at Angelina's with a slice of cheese pizza each and loved it so much we can back after our bar crawl to and the night with the same. The service was friendly and fast, and the vibes in that part of key west are automatically fun and lively. There is seating available right next to the pizzeria to enjoy the slice and get a drink from any neighboring bar. I think it was a great go to for an easy bite to eat read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

They say closest pizza to nyc style. Would not say this but as a late night treat it has good flavor and quick service. Great for beer munchies read more

We stopped at Angelina's Pizzeria on our way to watch the sunset at Mallory Square in Key West. From the moment I walked in the smell of garlic and tomato sauce was very evident. The slice of pizza I ordered was just the right temperature and texture. read more

See all

Sign says 'Best Slice in Town' but it was just a basic slice of pizza. The location is great right on Duval Street. Nobody inside here tonight so the pizza was ready within two minutes. All cheese slices are pricey at $5.00. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

I walk by I was craving a slice of pizza and there it was Angelina's by the slice pizza we stopped in for a slice in a cold drink and enjoyed some of that video games that they have inside. Pizza was good size and delicious. read more

See all

Open super late. I got a whole pizza and they do have ricotta!! Very nice staff and the pizza is good and fast. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Cheese pizza with ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great place to grab pizza by the slice. Open late with a good variety of options. Bonus points for having ranch!

I am glad that this pizza place is open. There was one pizza place on the same street that is open. Kinna pricey the 14" pizza, we paid $30 but the choices of food around 130am is limited the service was fast. They credit card. Some of the pizza place only takes cash. read more

Love this cute little place! They have to be the cheapest eats on the key! 3 slices and 3 drinks was only like $28. The pizza is hot and fresh. It's not anything that will keep you coming back again, and again, but definitely a solid choice. They have tables, fans, and a restroom too! There is lots of writing and stickers to look at on the wall too! read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Nice place for a quick bite. We were very hungry, the pizza was good. Bathrooms are close. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Decent pizza spot in the heart of Key West on Duval Street. We were in a rush to eat after finding parking in downtown Key West and this was one of the first places we passed so yeah of course we wanted to eat pizza, who doesn't. This is a small but quaint business that has a very friendly pizza maker/cashier/possible owner. Super eager to help with a friendly attitude which I loved. There are a few arcade games in the front to keep you busy until your pizza is ready. They serve by the slice as well as whole pies and many other Italian dishes. The pizza was good, no complaints. A fresh pie was served to us within about 15 minutes two of us ate the whole thing. They are reasonably priced so I would recommend stopping by if you're ever in Key West. read more

See all

Wow- absolutely amazing pizza!!! Who is Dumbledore please accidentally and I'm so glad we didn't. This will definitely be a spot that we come to every time. We are a key West. read more

The pizza was pretty good. Keep in mind if you eat at a table here, birds consider this a safe place and will be all around you as you eat.

Stopped in for a slice and was happily satisfied. Fresh from the oven, piping hot! There is a small table for seating and a countertop with all the usual pizza condiments to shake on for extra flavor. We took our slice togo and walked back down Duval. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great location. Fast service. The slice or pie is always tasty. Several seat between the tree bar and there to enjoy it.

In Key West for a couple days and with the time zone shift needed to eat while on a bar crawl and this place got me a hot and tasty slice of pepperoni and black olive in 5 or so min. And it was delicious- I gave my friend a bite and she was impressed. We bought 3 pizzas for an impromptu pool party at the hotel and all were excellent and on time! Sorry others had issues but not us! Owner was out side and he chatted with us while they made the pizza. staff were joking with us as we got a couple with 1/2 toppings, etc. great taste and perfect for our situation. I will go back next time I'm in KW. read more

The pizza slices are good and fresh. You have several toppings to choose from, and there is an up charge for the extra toppings. The service was good, everyone is friendly. The ambiance is open where you have the option of sitting or standing. When you're walking, Duval Street in Key West, stop for a slice of Angelina's pizza pie. read more

See all

me and my husband stopped for a quick snack it was good and a slice of pizza for $5 it was pretty big small little place but we got our food fast i definitely recommend read more

This place is just weird, and not Key-Westy at all. My wife and I stopped there after a tour. I was in the mood for pizza, but also had to go to the bathroom. You need a token to use their bathroom. Super strange and questionably legal for a place that serves food. Ordered two slices and was given a token and a terrible attitude after forgetting to provide my credit card while briskly moving to the bathroom, with token in hand. The bathroom was honestly another level of weird. After the token strangeness, you literally pee on the floor. After unlocking this sacred toilet with my well earned token, I took some splash on my ankles from another dude. Pizza came out, but was served up with more weird attitude for not knowing the laws of the token. The food i receivedpppp looked like pizza, but I left it for (hopefully) the exact person they attempt to deny the decency of a safe bathroom. If not, maybe a rooster. The pizza may be decent (?), but there are definitely better looking slices in the northeast. However, this place does not match Key West's friendly, accepting atmosphere. It's food may be good (or bad); but buyer beware on the lacking Key West experience. You may end up with some pee on your ankles. read more

Despite the mediocre reviews, we stopped in here for late night pizza after hitting other joints for drinks. The staff was friendly and the pizza was really good! They'll make basically any combo of pizza and sell it by the pie or slice. Prices aren't bad. Location is great, it's right in the middle of the action. I would return! read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Slice of Pepperoni & Jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Best pizza all around on Duval street. Willing to hear gripes about who "might" be better than them in another post.

We stopped in here for a slice before heading back to the room. You hate going back to the hotel only be be hungry in the late hours. Pizza wasn't even fair. My pepperoni was tasteless and just a few scattered pieces, along with a sauce that was fair at best and a crust that sucked. Don't wast your time. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Had about 4-5 different pizzas on this trip. Best pizza so far. Hawaiian was a hefty slice. Great value. Service was great as well! The people watching scene is great too. read more

When you are hungry, it's a great stop. We had a slice and a drink at the bar (another review) next door. It's Key West and all is good. The number system is a great touch. Keep your ears open for your number. HaHa! read more

We were partying at 3am on a weekend when my whole party were craving pizza. This came up on the map and was one of the few places open so late other than a hot dog stand. It is a very small location with some outdoor/indoor seating. Menu is hung up easily for all who enter to see and prices are very fair. The Team members were laid back and served us quickly. We arrived and placed our order with a very short wait time. You get to see your pizza be made right in front of you. Pizza was great and fed everyone in our party. If you're in a pizza mood while in the city I highly recommend this spot for a quick bite! read more

Excellent pizza. Staff were great. Our pizza was cooked to perfection and our salad was very fresh.

workers skimmed my card. horrible customer service. why even have a establishment open if you can't make money.

Cool place! We made one stop at Angelina's Pizzeria in our trip to Key West and we loved it. The sauce on the pizza was amazing! The crust was just perfect!! So good! A bit pricey but I guess they have to pay for the location! Overall I recommend this place!! read more

It's not the sexiest pizzeria in America but their slices are cheap, they're open all of the time, they have really cold beer and wine AND the people here are nice. Who doesn't want a slice of pizza when they're prancing around Duval Street?! read more

Rudest service I have ever had. The guy in the photo was the worst guy we have ever dealt with and we were just trying to order a pizza with half pineapple . Apparently that was too hard for this guy , he rolled his eyes , refused made it a huge deal and then mentioned he was going to slap me because I had vaped on accident in front of him . Whoever this guy is needs to be fired he is turning away customers with his bad attitude. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Rudest guy you will ever meet - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

If your a northerner you get Angelina's pizza by ricks bar and across the street from Irish Kevin's. This place is off the chain slamming. If your hiring hit me up. read more

Angelina's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

It's bar pizza and that's what you should expect- quick service and chaotic ordering but decent pizza. I think the crust is too thick, I personally would prefer a thinner crust but the taste was good after a night on Duval. Asked for side ranch and they delivered, two even. read more