We've been in Fort Wayne for nearly three years now and have driven by Oley's hundreds of times,…read morebut never stopped in... Boy, have we been missing out. We ordered pizza on a random Friday and were blown away by this gem - The pizza is some of the best, if not the best we've had in Fort Wayne. It's kind of a mix between Giordano's tavern style and Riverbend, but my God was it good... Outstanding crust, good red sauce, and loaded with toppings. We couldn't be both more pleased and surprised... We will definitely be back. Dave Portnoy 8.2

Oley's Pizza is hands down one of Fort Wayne's best pizza spots. The pizza always arrives hot when…read moredelivered, and ordering over the phone is super easy -- the staff are friendly, patient, and helpful every time. The house salad dressing is a standout -- very, very good. Honestly, anything you try here is likely to please. The atmosphere inside is great, making it perfect for large groups and families looking for a comfortable place to enjoy a meal together. Whether dining in or getting delivery, Oley's consistently hits the mark.

I've been here twice now - March 2025 and June 2025. Definitely one of the top 5 best pizzas I've…read moreever had. Neither trip did I slow down long enough to get any photos... but I order whatever their version of the meat lover's is & you can bet I'll get it next time too. The service has been just fine both times and the order comes out quickly (as quick as it takes to make and bake a pizza)!

Really like the baked spaghetti, taco salads, and of course the pizza. Good variety of different…read moretypes of pizza to try. They're generous on the toppings and you won't leave here hungry. Very spacious restaurant for your large family gatherings. Highly recommend

My husband and I popped in for dinner on a whim and we were not disappointed! I had the Italian…read morebeef sandwich and the garlic Parmesan fries. My husband had the spaghetti. The food was delicious, and our server Joy was prompt and very friendly. We will definitely be back!

Having eaten at the Chicago Giordano's many times, this is the first time we've ever tried the Ft…read moreWayne location. Why?!? No clue! We were greeted warmly, asked for a booth and were seated promptly. Ordered beverages and each tried a side salad: one the house w/shaved fennel, the other the starter Italian salad (oh my, both so good!). Loving extra thin crust, we ordered their newer Chicago Tavern Style (different from their tradition thin crust). CRAVE-ABLE! We ordered the Pepperoni Chicago Classic (pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions) and added sausage and green olives to it. I kid you not, the BEST pizza we've had in this area for a very long time! Their extra thin crust is made on premises (not premade elsewhere as so many do), and comes in 12, 14, and 16 inch sizes. Highly recommend!

The facility is still nice...especially the patio area. Everything is clean and in order. The…read morepatio is covered so it blocks the sun and rain. The team today was very friendly and helpful. Papi's is located on the Columbia Street Landing. So it's a nice place to people watch and drop in...without reservations...and a lower cost...unlike the other places on the Landing. On this occasion we were after a smaller amount of food instead of a large pizza. So this review does not reflect their ability to make pizza. The cheese bread was much larger than we thought. It had a heavier garlic taste with a decent amount of tasty mozzarella cheese. The bottom of the bread was burnt in places. The sides had some crisp cheese edges. The marinara sauce was slightly sweet and delicious. The meatball dish was rather small. The meatballs were smaller and somewhat difficult to find in the small dish that was covered in marinara sauce and cheese. The meatball often broke apart which made it easier to put on the small crispy pieces of bread chips. I didn't detect much seasoning in the meatball...at least not enough to make it stand out. The bread chips were plentiful but very crispy and hard. Overall these items were okay...but not particularly appealing. I'm hopeful that their pizza selections are outstanding.

Delicious! Very good choice for lunch, since you can pizza by the slice. Very friendly service. The…read moremusic choices are upbeat and pop, and I love it. Chiki's Bacon Ranch Slice - $5.50 - Thin style. Very good, made with chicken breast and green onions. Undercarriage is good. Crust has good flavor with a hint of sweetness. Big slices of chicken. If you like chicken pizza, go for this. 5/5 stars. Pepperoni Homie - $5.25 - Thick Sicilian style. Pillowy soft texture but a good stable crunch on the crust. Good high quality pepperoni. Also very good. 5/5 stars. Next time, I'll get a whole pizza to go. Thin or thick doesn't matter, both are excellently prepared. Highly recommend!

The thin crust pizza is cut in squares just like I like it. Taste really good. They have a pretty…read moregood pizza.

Good pizza, ready on time for pickup. Nice staff. Will order from them again. Got it home and the…read morecrew enjoyed the pizza.

I dropped in on my lunch and was happily greeted by a polite pregnant lady. She made suggestions,…read moreshe listened and made my pizza like it was Art. It was perfect!

Giving it two stars because the employees were mostly helpful…read more Admittedly, we haven't visited in a long time, and after this visit we won't be back. First let me say, my husband and I both hate the menu changes. I'd hardly call these artisanal when they are all bland choices you can get at any pizza place. I did a build your own because they no longer had my simple pizza choice. It was impossible to see the labels on the ingredients and I felt really rushed trying to choose ingredients for a salad and a pizza simultaneously. Once I received my order, the salad and pizza ingredients just tasted bland. I'd rather buy a frozen pizza and a premade salad from the grocery, pretty much the same effect, and possibly even better tasting. The icing on the cake was the practically shot glass-sized cups we were given for water. We had to go fill them 5-6 times just to eat our meal. I'd gladly have paid a dollar for a regular cup I could put ice in if that's the problem. My husband said to me "I'm fine with never coming back", which is exactly what I was thinking when we walked out.

The first thing you notice when walking in to the restaurant is it's nice and clean. It's on the…read moresmall side but big enough to handle most get togethers. I was met by the owner of the restaurant and he was extremely polite and friendly. I ordered a Hawaii pizza. with bell peppers. The pizza looked delicious and let me tell you it came with a nice amount of cheese. Now this restaurant puts the toppings under the cheese. At first glance I thought where's my toppings, then I could see them in the cheese. I have to say it was a very tasty pizza. Cooked perfectly and it was delicious! I highly recommend this pizza place! Great food clean restaurant and friendly staff. I'm sorry I didn't have any photos as my phone had died at the time.

Had delivered from DoorDash twice. Great both times. Wings also excellent. One of the better pizzas…read moreof the surrounding area.

Ordered exactly the same pizza that I would order from a competitor. Ordering app is okay, order…read morewas timely and ready on pickup. However, this pizza was about $8.00 more than the competitor and it didn't taste any better. Each of the corner pieces had no meat on them at all, and I ordered pepperoni, sausage and chicken. None. So, bottom line, this was not cost effective purchase without any quality to redeem it.

This store continues the tradition of good carry out pizza. The on line order process is easy to…read moreuse. I love the communications when the pie is in the oven and done. The store team was very friendly and accurate with my order. The ingredients are still very fresh and tasty. The pie is cooked to perfection - no burnt crusts.