I stopped in quick today for lunch. This was my second time visiting Pizza Man in the past three months and I had some hesitation about stopping again after my first visit, but I am glad I did. I only had a few minutes so I ordered my food to go. I asked if there were any daily lunch specials, but unlike most pizza shops, they don't have a slice/drink special so I ordered two slices of cheese. Slices were premade but reheated quickly in the oven. Slices were large this time - first time I went slices were small and a disappointment. Slices were a bit greasy but a few napkins soaked up most of the grease and allowed me to enjoy the slices. Restaurant is clean and well kept with limited indoor seating. Overall Pizza Man is still on my "undecided list"due to the variation between visits. I will stop in again, over the coming weeks, and allow that visit to determine if an updated review to 4 stars is justified. read more

First visit on a recommendation - a good one! Server was great & had my order in no time! I tried a Chicken Cheesesteak Sub & it was one of the best i've had in ages - chicken was fresh & grilled perfectly. Typical pizza-place® atmosphere. Tucked slightly out of the way...would call this place a quintessential hidden gem. Will definitely return! read more

Pizza Man - Lunch Specials - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Delicious Everytime! Clean, friendly and affordable We love their subs and pizza as well as cheese fries. The dinners are so good. Try the Southwest salad, it's my favorite! read more

Food is great and served hot. Waitresses are friendly and helpful. Friendly environment and clean read more

Their pizza is the absolute best we've found in south central PA and we've eaten a lot of pies ! Toppings are generous toppings and prices are reasonable. Nice atmosphere and even when they're busy the service is good. We can't wait to try the pasta and subs. read more

Absolutely delicious the whole family was impressed. And the service was absolutely amazing a great group of guys working and the prices are great for good food KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK!!! read more

Stopped by to get a sub all I can say is where's the meat, nothing like a salad sandwich

On a college search road trip, we found ourselves in Shippenberg, PA and had a craving for pizza while staying at the local Courtyard Marriott. I satisfied my pizza urge with a slice that was amazing but actually ordered the Chicken Parm as my main which was a huge portion served with Pasta, Salad and garlic Bread. I don't have a place this good at home priced at $13.99. Amazing. Highly recommended! read more

It was very greasy. We are not happy with it. It was delicious and non greasy the last time we got pizza from here. read more

Pizza Man - Very greasy - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

This hidden Gem is over by Shippensburg University. The food is good and service is fast. The atmosphere is nice with no loud music or obnoxious sports commentating in the background. It was quiet in there as it appears most orders are take out and delivery on a Saturday night. Want a quiet place to eat that's good on a Saturday. I'd suggest this place. read more

See all

I've wanted to try this place so this evening I did! Ordered a pizza and it did not disappoint. The sauce is more to the mild, which means it's not acidic tasting. The cheeses was fresh and of good quality. The crust was perfect crispy with the chewy needed for that perfect pie. The subs and assorted varieties of fries coming out looked equally appetizing. They are open till 11:30 Sunday-through Thursday, and 12:30 am Friday and Saturday. Not sure why some people are haters? I'd give this place a try, the staff seem to make any wrongs right! read more

Pizza Man - Cheese Pizza and it taste pretty darn good! - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

I come here all the time for lunch and always order one of their specials. For $5.99 you can choose a 1/2 sub, fries and drink or a salad, or for $3.99, you can get 2 slices and a drink. All of these are excellent choices (there are a few others as well), but my favorite is the buffalo chicken sub special. The waitress is very friendly and always pleasant. The owner always says hello and thank you and makes me feel like a valued customer. All around a great place to eat and I highly recommend it. read more

Pizza Man - Lunch specials - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Delivery was good just missing NAPKINS fast, courteous the taste could've tasted better. No problem but have to mention the pizza pie ordered was not sliced. But with all of this I would order again. For now I wouldn't recommend it until I give a second try WE all deserve a second shot read more

Nice local Italian joint. Food was solid and the service was friendly and attentative. The food came out within minutes after ordering. The spaghetti was cooked correctly and not over done. The sauce was more on the sweet side, but tasty none the less. Side salad was better then most and had homemade vinegarette. Price was reasonable for the amount of food. We had plenty to take back. Definitely recommended for quick local place. read more

Pizza Man - Spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Huge salad not disappointed there house dressing is outstanding ordered delivery online said 70 minutes came in twenty highly recommend can't wait to try something else read more

Pizza Man - Chef salad - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

Great experience!! We busted from maryland with our cheer team of about 30 people. The staff took us right in and gave an amazing service experience. The food was great and they were very patient with our athletes. The experience was so great we ordered dinner while we were in the area. read more

Ordered on Monday night and it was 2 hr delivery for a 15 dollar order. The food was stale, cold and tasted terrible.

This place has gone downhill, the past 2 times the orders have been 20 &. 30 mi utes late and the owners had no response. Go elsewhere where you are appreciated as a customer read more

I alway enjoy the food that they serve the only problem is when I get it delivery on to campus they are alway confused on where to go. It not a big campus and I alway give the hall im staying at name but it alway seem too be the problem. Other than the delivery I never had anything I didn't like. read more

Love this place. Best pizza around. Been going here for years. This is that kind of place that's so good there is no substitute

I love their pizza would definitely get there instead of other places also like there cheeseburger sub too

From Chambersburg, saw billboard on 11 on way to Shippensburg. Cheese steak sub looked awesome with ton of cheese. Stopped in to try. What a disappointing experience. I got there at 12:22 on 11/15, place was relatively dead for lunch. Was greeted at door and told to sit anywhere someone would be out to take my order. After 10 minutes of being ignored waitress came by and said she didn't see me sitting here. Guess I was hiding amonst the empty tables. Ordered the cheese steak special, asked for it as it comes with everything. I realize advertising doesn't reflect reality but this cheese steak sub was nothing like the picture. There was maybe a slice of cheese on it no flavor. Very disappointed. Guess I'll stick with Jersey Mikes. read more

Best pizza I have had in years! I took pictures and shared with so many people! They accommodated my complicatedness! I ordered it to-go and decided to eat in the restaurant. LOL They were happy to help me get seated and brought my food out hot and fresh! I had the veggie pizza and it was loaded with CHUNKS of veggies! It was tasty and the flavors blended well together nicely! Pizza Man: Please open a franchise in Georgia! You would do so well here! :-) read more

Pizza Man - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

The food was excellent and the delivery man was the best I've ever had. When I called in the order, my order was taken by Olivia B. She answered the phone by saying pick up or delivery. She never identified the name of the business. I wasn't even sure if I called the right place. I asked how she was doing and she cut me off twice and asked if it was pick up or delivery again. After each item I ordered she sternly asked "is there anything else". I didn't even have a second to pause. She got stern with me multiple times throughout the conversation. It was hands-down the most rude and ignorant person I've ever spoke to on the phone. read more

Normally this place is amazing to eat at or order from they are my go to place. I was left disappointed tonight. I got a ham and cheese Stromboli and it was almost all cheese. I know times are hard but you cant skip on the things that make your place so great. read more

Closest thing to NJ pizza that I've found since moving to PA. The cannolis are very good also! Garlic bread is also good. Tried the subs and bacon cheese fries but was not impressed with them. Overall, definitely worth it for the pizza. I've heard the penne vodka is also a good choice. read more

Review of Pizza Man, April, 2019, 201 North Seneca Street (off Earl Street), Shippensburg, phone 717-530-1607. Eat in or take out. Parking lot, open for lunch and dinner every day except Tuesday. My wife and I recently stopped in for lunch. We ordered drinks, a small Hawaiian Pizza and the hot Veggie Sub. $18.33. As the Germans say, "Die Pizza und das heiße Sub waren lecker." Pizza and the hot Sub were quite tasty. Nicely furnished restaurant. Extensive menu. www.shippizzaman.com. Mike Bannon read more

We stayed overnight in Shippensburg and ordered delivery from Pizza Man. It's good pizza, lots of cheese, arrived hot and fresh within 20 minutes. No complaints at all on the food. However - they got our order wrong. We ordered a large meat lovers pizza (which was perfect and delicious!). We also ordered their spinach pizza that was a specialty pizza on their menu. They sent a cheese pizza with just a bunch of spinach on it. It was good but not what was advertised on their menu. I think the person who took our order was confused, so if we ever order from them again, I would be more specific about what I want. Definitely would get pizza here again! read more

The BEST pizza in shippensburg HANDS down!! This is real pizza shop pizza. It's not the fake stuff like Pizza Hut or dominos. They also serve really Italian deserts! read more

My boyfriend and I have always loved this place and typically order here once or twice a week... idk if they have changed hands or are just cutting corners. I understand covid may make prices change or cause some ingredients not to be available, but the quality and consistency continues to fall below acceptable. I ordered a pizza one time and it had no sauce?! Had to return and get a new one.. two hour ordeal. Next pizza had so much sauce it drowned the pizza and we had to scrape off the sauce. Last time we ordered our sauces didn't come which we were charged for,and I was missing my salad. So tonight we ordered two cheesesteaks, cheese sticks and a salad. $29. They finally got their sub rolls back so we were looking forward to this. Bf ordered extra cheese on his, but said they must have put the extra on my sub? I'm like I don't think so, did they put my steak on yours? Unbelievable. I think we have given them enough chances. Going to have to order somewhere else. Red rooster is good. read more

Pizza Man - Cheesesteak with barely anything on it. Where's the beef?! - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Summary: (sing it like Spongebob) Pizza man pizza....is the pizza....for you and me! When I come home to visit my folks, one of the things I always look forward to is knowing that I will have at least one meal...probably two....hopefully three...involving pizza from Pizza Man. You simply cannot go wrong with anything you get from this place. The pizza is flavorful, has generous amounts of toppings and folds very neatly in your hand to eat. I've never ordered anything on their menu that I didn't enjoy and find well worth the cost. Bottom line: There's no other place in Shippensburg that measures up, so there's no reason to go anywhere else. read more

If I could give ZERO stars I would. I spent $40+ on food and it was disgusting. The delivery was fast which was nice because they had said 45 mins; it came in about 15 minutes. Even though the food was delivered fast it was stone cold, my pizza wasn't cut, and my cheeseburger sub was soggy. I mean falling apart soggy. Even the foil was soaked. When I called back and spoke to the manager he told me there was no way it could be cold or soggy. He told me there was nothing he could do. $40 down the drain. If you want Pizza in Ship I urge you to go to ANY OTHER PLACE!! Please don't waste your money on them. Never ordering from them again. read more

very nice place.. awesome food and Jess was a super nice waitress.. highly recommend

Just a quick stop into this pizza joint on my one day trip to Pennsylvania. The pizza was hot and fresh had good flavor and the customer service was very good not much more to say than that. read more

Management is very rude. And they suck wouldn't recommend eating here at all WORST EXPERIENCE EVER

I had a small meat lovers Stromboli,,, hate to say it was pretty much cheese an dough ,, hardly anything inside as far as meat ,,, couple slivers of ham ,, 3 pepperonis,,, an tiny pieces of chicken,, an couple pieces of sausage in 2 pounds of cheese ,,, an ranch dressing is definitely thinned out like milk! read more

Pizza is okay. Forgot some crucial stuff (Garlic powder, hot pepper) I called and they pretty much told me, "too bad". I won't be eating here again not worth it. read more

Great service great food only complaint I have is delivery said 30 minutes food was delivered after 15 which was really awkward considering the delivery guy knocked on the door while I was balls deep in his girlfriend. read more

I ordered delivery here the other night and it was absolutely disgusting. Next time I will stick to a franchise. During this Covid I was trying to help small mom and pop shops because our communities need them. But I made a mistake. Everything was cold and they refused to do anything about it. Please go to any other spot. This spot isn't worth your time or money. read more

We were just traveling through the area and staying at a local hotel. We didn't feel like going out driving around for a restaurant. We read Pizza Man's menus on line and decided to try them. We ordered two different salads. Both the chef salad and the tuna salad were extremely fresh and large. Excellent in every way. Next time I'm in the area I will have to try some of their specialties-subs,pizzas,and Italian dinners. read more