Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pizzamania

    4.2 (5 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Pizzamania Takeout or Delivery

    Pizzamania Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pizzamania

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of D P.
    0
    5
    0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Pizzamania

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 15,335 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Eataliano Market & Deli

    Eataliano Market & Deli

    4.1(240 reviews)
    5.7 mi
    $$

    "Tell me what you miss most," Ava Fremont, a witness to a murder, signs and expresses to Detective…read moreFrank Shaw, who recently lost his hearing, in Director Brad Anderson's 2024 film, The Silent Hour. "My daughter, S A M," Shaw signs back, "playing guitar," as he makes hand motions. "Being able to hear that." "You don't need to. Every spring, I go to the Boston Pops." "Why?" Frank asks disconsolately. "To watch...the feeling...the musicians...to see their joy. It's enough. To see that, to share it." Watching Ava recapture physically not just the performance in her retelling but the appreciation from both musicians and concert-goers alike, Frank starts to rediscover hope, even as he and Ava try to stay alive from the killers hunting them. The appetizers, entrees, and desserts from Eataliano Market & Deli, located at 5325 Phelps Luck Drive in Columbia, Maryland, prompt similarly unexpected overflows of culinary memories and joy. Upon our first visit of what we hope will be many, my wife and I placed the following takeout order: 1 order of Baked Meatballs 2 orders of Garlic Bread 1 ten-inch Empire Pie (I requested no ricotta or extra virgin olive oil) 1 order of Rigatoni Meatballs alla Vodka 1 order of Spaghetti with Homemade Meat Sauce 1 slice of Limoncello Mascarpone Cake 1 slice of Pistachio Cheesecake The garlic bread and pistachio cheesecake alone conjured spectacular reminisces. The pizza is the best we've had in Maryland, although my wife regretted my choice of no ricotta; and we would gladly reorder our pasta dishes if we didn't have many more entrees that we want to try.

    What a fabulous neighborhood gem! How did I not try this place sooner? Eataliano is tucked right…read moreinto the Phelps Luck neighborhood, not far from Route 108 (Old Annapolis Road) and Columbia Palace Plaza. I had heard there could be a bit of a wait, which isn't surprising since this well-established market and deli draws not only local residents but also people from nearby businesses. I happened to be about 15 minutes away, so I placed my order through their website. By the time I arrived, I must have missed the lunch rush--there was no line, and it took just a couple more minutes for everything to be wrapped, packaged, and ready to go. The market itself is intriguing and packed with all sorts of house-made specialties and popular Italian brands. There were also plenty of brands I had never heard of, giving the place the feel of a little Italian countryside market. I can only dream of traveling to Italy someday, so for now, I'll happily get a little taste of Italy here! Parking: As mentioned, parking is very limited. The street alongside the shop was also undergoing some sort of construction during my visit, so be prepared for some roadside limitations. There is a small, intimate dining area with room for only about four tables, but I loved seeing the white-tablecloth treatment. It added such a warm and welcoming touch to what is otherwise a very busy little establishment. The staff were busy but friendly. With the back-of-house operation appearing to be quite busy and working within tight quarters, it was impressive to see how well everyone seemed to coordinate and make the most of the available space. What We Tried Eataliano Crab Roll -- A specialty my daughter had told me about after seeing it on TikTok, and now I understand why! Generously filled with a tender, tasty blend of lump crab meat and fillers. Definitely shareable--but only with your favorite people! 10" Margherita Pie -- A NY-style thin crust topped with fresh ingredients, including tomato sauce, house-made mozzarella, and whole basil leaves. Simple, fresh, and delicious. French Fries -- Crispy and crunchy, just as ordered. Sometimes you just need a good order of fries! Greek Salad -- A generous portion loaded with fresh ingredients: feta cheese, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, Kalamata olives, carrots, green peppers, and pepperoncini. Fresh, colorful, and plenty to share. Overall, Eataliano is exactly the kind of neighborhood gem I love discovering. Between the market, deli, prepared foods, and cozy little dining area, there's plenty to come back and explore. Definitely worth a visit--and I'm already wondering what I should try next!

    Photos
    Eataliano Market & Deli - March 2023

    March 2023

    Eataliano Market & Deli - The Real Philly Cheesesteak

    The Real Philly Cheesesteak

    Eataliano Market & Deli

    See all

    Stella Notte - Shrimp and Scallop Primavera

    Stella Notte

    3.7(214 reviews)
    4.5 mi
    $$

    We love eating here for a date-night dinner. The food and service are usually excellent. We always…read moreleave with a full stomach. Lots of options on the menu at a reasonable price. Dishes seem to be clearly explained on the menu. Most recent visit, I ordered the Stella Note pizza with the cheese bread as an appetizer. The table also gets bread. Heather was our server, and they were wonderful. After our entrees, they'll bring out a dessert sample platter so guests can see the dessert options before ordering. It's purely to look at and not taste. The restaurant has a whimsical atmosphere with dark, sultry lighting and fake vines and string lights draped across the walls and ceiling. From a distance I thought they might be dusty, but up-close they appeared surprisingly well-maintained and clean. I really appreciate that, as dirty/dusty props hanging over my meal are a major turn-off for me. The place overall, seemed very clean and tables set up neatly ready for customers to sit down. The main flag for me is the building itself. There are several uneven points in the flooring to trip over - even some ramps. The dim lighting can make things difficult to notice. Finding the restrooms was confusing even though there were small signs because it was dark. The route via the signs also seemed to lead through the drink area where cups are kept. I feel like that's not very common for restaurants to have you walk through so it made me question if I was going the right way. The ladies' restroom had small tight stalls. I didn't notice any accessible stalls or restrooms. To be fair, it is possible I missed them due to the low lighting. Overall, I would give the food and service 5 stars. The building itself is the reason i have to give an overall 4-star rating. I appreciate how strongly the restaurant remains loyal to its whimsical ambiance while still serving tasty dishes. Eating there reminds me of the cozy 90s sitcom settings for example from Friends or Sabrina the Teenage Witch. At the same time, we are now in 2026 and I think accessibility and ease of navigation are important considerations for customers. The restaurant serves well for me personally, but it may not be as comfortable or accessible for every guest that dines-in.

    We made a reservation for eight people. I don't usually choose Italian food, but this was my…read moredaughter's graduation celebration and she wanted Italian cuisine. The ambience was wonderful -- warm atmosphere, birdhouses with mock birds, and even a tree inside, which was a nice touch. Everyone enjoyed their meals except for my wife. Her river shrimp had a very unpleasant taste, and she couldn't eat them. The staff handled it well and quickly replaced the dish with chicken. Our waitress provided excellent service and checked on us often. Their napkins are made of high‑quality paper, which I really appreciate. Overall, we enjoyed our dinner very much and had a great celebration.

    Photos
    Stella Notte - Interior

    Interior

    Stella Notte - Fettuccine alfredo with shrimp

    Fettuccine alfredo with shrimp

    Stella Notte - Dinning area

    See all

    Dinning area

    Scittino's Italian Market Place - Porchetta (house made) Giordano

    Scittino's Italian Market Place

    3.8(269 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$

    Came here to get a pizza for dinner. Now I have passed this place plenty of times and decided to…read moregive it a try. Upon entering, you walk into a full service, but small, market specializing in Italian grocery items. The ambiance was homey, perfect for a small neighborhood specialty grocery. They also have a deli counter, meat counter, hot food bar, and Italian dessert section, to name a few. They also have pizza kits to take home to make your own and pasta and other food items prepared and ready to go in the refrigerated section. The pizza counter is located in the rear of the store. They also sold other items such as sandwiches. We were greeted by a pleasant young man and ordered our Italian sausage and pepperoni pizza. Scittino's has seating to enjoy your pizza in store or outside. Our order was ready in no time. We opted to take ours to go. The pizza was fresh with a great yeasty crust. The toppings were good and ample, the tomatoes sauce fresh with just enough cheese to pull it all together. The pizza was really good. All in all, another pizza spot to add to our growing list in the area.

    The sandwiches and pizza here are elite and they have some things you can get from the market…read more(pasta, fresh meatballs, etc.). If you are ordering from the restaurant I wouldn't recommend ordering ahead of time so it does take a while for it to be ready.

    Photos
    Scittino's Italian Market Place - Indoor seating

    Indoor seating

    Scittino's Italian Market Place
    Scittino's Italian Market Place - Sign advertising the 20" cold cut

    See all

    Sign advertising the 20" cold cut

    Grano Pasta Bar

    Grano Pasta Bar

    4.0(352 reviews)
    6.7 miHampden
    $$

    I didn't really get much here but I did enjoy it here!!…read more Staff was so nice and vibe was chill. The spritz was amazing and the anchovies were nice and citrusy and bright as were the olives. If I was hungrier I would've loved to try their pasta.

    A W F U L went to…read morethe front door and a grumpy woman snapped "GO AROUND THE CORNER FOR DINING!!!" I didn't understand what this meant . I was the only customer. I waited 20 minutes in the hot sun to no avail . Eventually I went back to the front door of the business to let the angry woman know I was still waiting . She snapped "GO TO THE CAFE!!" Cafe?? Eventually I made my way into what looked like a TOTALLY separate business . This I presume was the "cafe"?? Once there a woman claiming to be hostess also snapped at me and said she was "just out there!" really ? when ? the Devonian Period? I saw no one . The owners and her laughed at me and said "there is a sign on the front door that tells you to come to the cafe ha ha " I guess it's the customer's job now to find tiny signs and play guessing games with Nurse Ratchet . -like can I just give you my money and you give me food? It was dinner time and they had zero customers but still they acted like it was opening night at The fucking Ritz My 4 friends and I ate across the street at Tony Foreman's new spot (a place that gets customer service) and was packed and was phenomenal. Skip this place like one would a dreary fog over a haunted morgue. Who's laughing now ? Maybe you can make a tiny sign that says "not worth the bullshit" .

    Photos
    Grano Pasta Bar - Interior

    Interior

    Grano Pasta Bar - Mussel pasta

    Mussel pasta

    Grano Pasta Bar - Carbonara

    See all

    Carbonara

    Tino's Italian Bistro

    Tino's Italian Bistro

    3.7(359 reviews)
    5.5 mi
    $$

    This was our first time dining here, and my husband and I were not disappointed. The white…read morewine-steamed mussels were perfectly prepared and very flavorful. For our entrées, we had the Ravioli Chesapeake and the Baked Ravioli, and both were excellent. The highlight of our visit, however, was the prompt and well-paced service. Our server, JoJo, was pleasantly attentive without ever being intrusive--a real gem! We would certainly recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning.

    A friend and I happened into Tino's on a Thursday evening for dinner. Tino's was a favorite of mine…read moremany years ago, so I was excited to return. Unfortunately, this visit did not live up to my memories of the restaurant. We started with the Caesar salad to share. Unfortunately, it was severely lacking in acidity, and the large croutons could have used more garlic and butter flavor. For our entrées, I ordered the Chicken Florentina, while my companion chose the Veal Saltimbocca. The Chicken Florentina did not include the tomatoes or peppers listed on the menu and was instead served over fettuccine with spinach and mozzarella on top. The sauce had a strangely sweet flavor and, although the portion was very generous, the dish overall was lacking in seasoning and flavor. My companion felt similarly about the Veal Saltimbocca, which was also quite bland. Honestly, we were both very disappointed. While the portions were generous, the most flavorful thing we had all evening was the olive oil we dipped our bread into. Unfortunately, I personally would not choose to dine here again. That said, if you prefer very mild or lightly seasoned food, Tino's may be a good option for you. They also offer gluten-free options.

    Photos
    Tino's Italian Bistro - Interior

    Interior

    Tino's Italian Bistro - Fresh bread with olive oil for our table.

    Fresh bread with olive oil for our table.

    Tino's Italian Bistro - They served generous portions, and we took a lot home!

    See all

    They served generous portions, and we took a lot home!

    Pizzamania - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...