So classic pizza of up Sunbury Road in Westerville is a tiny restaurant that puts out some amazing pizzas!!! One would not expect that, but I'm here to tell you they're the real deal. My order is always perfect and the staff is quite delightful. Thank u guys. read more

Classic Pizza - Perfect Pizzas EVERY TIME!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

You can never go wrong with Classic Pizza! I am always going to order at the OG location.

Food Is good but they cant figure out their wait times. Last time they told me a 55 min wait. Arrived to pick up and it was another 90 min. This time says 20 min wait. Arrive they tell me its another 20 min. read more

It was an extremely busy night but they had the pizza done at the time stated. As usual the staff was wonderful and the pizza was outstanding. read more

Why did I wait 9yrs to try CP? The phone recording encourages online ordering, but this first timer had questions. After friendly, helpful ordering, our order was delivered by their own delivery people. Prompt, and friendly service again. Pizzas arrived still over 130° hot. Thin crust that had a golden brown bottom, with just enough crisp to avoid limp or brittle. The dough was NOT over-mixed to create that gummy/chewy bite. Sauce was right on point with flavors of garlic and herb, rather than sugar. Cheese has a nice gooey pull without that rubbery snap-back. The enzo pepperoni and sausage was vividly flavored, and paired well with the sauce. We tried the recommended Italian sub pizza which uses the creamy Italian dressing for the sauce base. I'm so glad we did. It was a big hit. Our second visit we did carryout. Small place with a small grab & go private parking lot. Again with the friendly staff. No tables, no chairs. You pay, you go. Small interior for customers to loiter. I did like that they had the touchless TapPay machine to use your phone. Added a sub this visit. Worried the sub didn't even measure out to 7" was for not. The double meat & cheese Italian sub did not suffer a loss of contents. Well worth the price. I do require more than 2 slices of tomato, so I will order extra next time. Lastly, I always recommend people bring an insulated bag to carry your food home. You want that food as hot and delicious as the way they prepared it for you. Hope this helps. #UpCloseSavor read more

See all

Well done bake, light on the sauce - Classics has a crispy crust, and this was great read more

Classic Pizza - Well made pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

I received a free 1 topping pizza coupon in the mail and we ordered one for pick up that same day. We got half pepp (for boyf) and half chicken (for me). We chose the thin crust and it was really a great pizza. I want to try their cauliflower crust next time, and also a veggie pie. It's pretty close to home, and we are excited to use them. read more

Their pizza was pretty good...I sometimes prefer thin crust over thick crust, so I appreciate having a place to go to if I want thin crust; but I have to say this will not be one of my favorite pizza places...it is just okay for me. I am still on a mission to find the best pizza in Columbus. read more

There's nothing of note about this pizza. It's edible, but not great. The service was quick and friendly. read more

Classic Pizza - Classic Supreme Specialty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Great pizza awesome owners. The service is awesome. My favorite pizza and the owner is great.

Updated Review: not great this time around. Couple issues. I decided to order a 16" cheese, with a $2 off coupon it was $17.20, so pricing on their flyers/menu is off (listed at $17.95 less $2) including the one that just arrived last week. They do a good job at curbside delivery during covid...and i noticed the box looked like a standard large box when he was bringing it out, got home and checked...only 14" - which is the size of their large, a great deal on MON/TUE for 11.95 w/one topping Additionally, plain cheese was just not good...should have got pepperoni. Overall 3/10 read more

Classic Pizza - 16" XL Classic Thin Crust Pizza...only 14" which is the size of their large. Save and just buy large - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Classics Pizza is our go to for when we want to order in. Consistency is key for me in a favorite restaurant, and since we've been ordering from Classics sine the early 2000s, they certainly meet this criteria. My son loves their wings, and Hawaiian pizza with added jalapeños. I love the sauce, not too sweet or too tart. I also appreciate they have a gluten-free crust as a few of my friends are GF. read more

The aroma when you walk in is wonderful... you know you're about to pick up an amazing pizza! Staff is friendly and efficient. We ordered ahead, and I paid when I arrived a few minutes early. The pizzas were ready exactly when they said they would be... 20 minutes after the order was called in! While I was waiting they prepared pizza after pizza... nonstop. They were doing a great amount of business! There are lots of pizza choices in the area, but many are chains or sit-in restaurants too... Classic is strictly takeout... basically a counter and a kitchen... just like most of my favorite pizza joints! The pizza held its temperature well by the time we got it to the house... and proved to be the best I've had in Westerville. Square-cut (on the thin crust deluxe), sweet sauce, and generous toppings. We had both a deluxe and a pepperoni. The pictures say it all... beautiful and delicious. This will be our primary Westerville pizza choice from now on! read more

Classic Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Amazing pizza! Small little shop with carry out only. Subs and wings are good but the pizza is top notch.

This was, at one time, the BEST pizza in Westerville. Now unfortunately, very inconsistent and this time, just...AWFUL. I decided to give them another chance. The last time I ordered, I wanted it delivered. After an hour and 15 minutes, I called to ask where it was. The employee that answered said, "oh someone messed up. It's sitting here for pick up." I said no thanks, I'd rather not have a pizza that had been sitting for (??) hence, salmonella, etc. So I ended up eating elsewhere. I ordered half cheese, half sausage, for pick up this time. Well, the sausage half was edible, but not very good. The cheese half was burnt and too hard to eat, but needless to say, didn't look very appetizing, anyway. What has happened to Classic Pizza? I would have rather had frozen pizza from the store, than paying $11.25 for really, half of a very mediocre pizza. I won't get "burnt" again! read more

Classic Pizza - This is cheese pizza?? Burnt...:/ - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

I had a pleasant experience with Classic Pizza, and I have no complaints. The friendly guy who answered the phone let me know that on Mondays you get $3 off of a large pizza! (Whatever comes after 12") so I went for that deal. It ended up being the same price as my medium I intended to order. I don't eat meat so I always appreciate when a pizza place has something unique to offer us veggies. They did! Their Greek pizza has mozz, feta, tomatoes, onion, black olives and banana peppers. I did enjoy it. I just wish the crust was a tiny bit crispier. Solid choice if you like a crust just a notch crispier above donatos. Definitely would order again. read more

Classic Pizza - Greek pizza- 1/2 no onions and half eaten - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

I called to order a pizza at 8:55 but was hung up on. So I decided to order online. My order was placed at 9:03pm around the time the pizza was supposed to arrive. I was quoted 55 mins. Around 10 I checked my phone to see that the driver had texted me 30 mins prior saying the pizza was on the porch. I looked and there was no pizza. I texted back but got no response and the store closes at 10. This store doesn't seem to answer the phone after 8:30. Definitely going to be calling tomorrow for a refund. read more

Ordered delivery didn't get all my food called back they said they could deliver but I would have to pay for what I didn't get the first time. Long time customer just lost over a order of French fries. I'll take my business else where. Thanks Mike read more

I was looking for a pizza place for saladsvsndbpizza while visiting a friend in Westerville ( Emerson Park apartments ) Did a quick google search of good pizza places in Westerville and decided on Ckassic pizza based on reviews and it did not disappoint . We ordered two small house salads and a small green salad, they were very fresh with the appropriate amount of cheese and veggies versus lettuce ( which was shredded to my delight . We also ordered a small white pizza and it's is so delicious and one of the best crusts I've ever had on a pizza We also ordered a large bbq chicken pizza and it was very tasty, but it could use a splash more bbq sauce on it, but the crust is amazing with the right number of ingredients . read more

This was our go to pizza place. Never again. I had so many problems, it is not even funny. I honestly am so frustrated that I can barley type. We have 2 pies sitting in the fridge now. Never again. read more

Classic is our go-to pizza delivery. The special with banana peppers added. 10 wings in hot sauce with an extra cup of sauce. The crust is fantastic. The toppings are fresh. The sauce is awesome. We are really mindful to provide a really strong tip when our food is delivered. Those guys drive to our place any season, any late hour, it's always fresh and hot when delivered and it's the least we can do. Good pie! read more

Definitely not too bad. The young man that took our order was courteous, friendly and offered up a $2.00 off coupon. It's a carry out / delivery only location, so don't plan on dining in. for our first trial we tried went with 2 7" pizzas and small order of wings. The supreme combination specialty pizza was pretty good. At first I was a little disappointed the veggies were raw, but it wound up working out well. the bell peppers offered a nice crunch against the sausage and pepperoni. The white pizza was a bit on the salty side for my tastes, but it was nothing a little squirt of Ranch dressing couldn't fix (no judgement). The wings were shockingly LARGE, i thought they lacked in independent flavor just a bit but the garlic bbq sauce was on point! Classic takes home an extra star for conveniently being located next to a gas station. order, pump gas and multi-task (im just saying) was shocked by how long they have been in business as a neighborhood pizza shop - not too shabby. read more

Out driving tonight. Grew up in Westerville and drove to Sunbury Rd shop. In parking lot, dude w Classic pizza shirt asked if I had a pickup. Said no, needed to order. He said I couldn't go in and order. Wanted to view the menu. He then brings up, since the pandemic..... So no couldnt order, I guess without calling? Bizarre business Appears we won't return. Sad, heard it was still good pizza. Off to Vicks, where they want you to come in and pickup. read more

I just picked up my first ever Classic Pizza. I got in the car and decided I didn't want to wait until I got home. I took my first bite and audibly went "mmmm". A lot of thin crust pizzas claim to be thin and crispy, but most wildly miss on the crispy part. Not Classic Pizza. I got an audible crunch with each bite that made my ears and mouth very happy! The other thing I noticed was the sweetness to the sauce. Not overly sweet or unpleasant, but something memorable! Did I burn the roof of my mouth diving into my pizza fresh out of the oven? Yep. Would I do it again? You betcha! read more

We really enjoyed this pizza last night. Ordered carry out around 8pm on way home from kids softball game. Guy told us 15-20mins. We got there about 15 minutes later and pizza was hot and ready. This is strictly a carry out/delivery location. Pizza was delicious-hot and cheesy with a nice thick sauce. Nicely baked. We are usually too lazy to pick up pizza (and we are out of delivery area) but this was good enough that we will pick up again. Packed leftovers for lunch the next day and it was even better! read more

Classic Pizza - Pepperoni deliciousness - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

My new favorite place for thin crust delivery. They got here really quick and everything was perfect

We drive almost a half an hour to get here just to get burnt subs. I wouldn't even of served it to my dog. Definitely our last time.

Wish I could give them 0 or less. Multiple times we've ordered only to have the order either forgotten or delivered well after the quoted time. On this occasion we were placed on hold immediately upon calling, and had to call back several times. We finally managed to speak with the owner's daughter (later explained as the manager on duty) where she took our order and informed us it would be approx. 1 hour to 1 hour and 15 minutes for delivery. I called back after 1 hour and 22 minutes to determine the status of the order. Another person answered and looked up the order, then placed us on immediate hold. The "manager" picked up after several minutes and informed us our pizza was coming out of the oven and being cut for delivery? After 1 hour and 22 minutes it was just being cut? My guess would be the order was "forgotten" again! For reference, this was a Thursday night with no major events. The "manager" informed us she would take $10 off the order for our inconvenience which I thanked her for at the time. When the pizza finally showed up (almost 2 hours after our original order) this is what we received (see attached pictures). On top of that, the charges on our CC did not represent the $10 off we were notified of when we spoke to the "manager" earlier. I received the order and tipped the driver over 20% as it wasn't his fault for the poor service thus far. Once I opened the box I immediately called back where the "manager" again answered and without any discussion immediately put me on hold. I hung up and called back 5 times and each time the same happened. After finally holding for a few minutes the manager picked up and informed me they had a line of customers they were dealing with - which is why she placed me on hold without discussion over and over again. I decided to jump in my car and return the pizza....when I arrived the "manager" was in the back of the cooking area with at least 5 employees playing with a toddler - there were NO customers in line when I arrived. If you decide to visit this place, or order delivery from them - good luck.... read more

Classic Pizza - Complete JOKE! - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Alright Yelpers, I think you've been sleeping on this one. For some reason Westerville doesn't have a ton of pizza options, so when I drove past this place I knew I needed to try it. I'm a fan of giving any dive looking place a chance. I ordered a large pepperoni on their thin crust. I live about a mile away and they told me 10 minutes. It was ready just as I pulled up, super hot and I was greeted with a smile. Prices are definitely reasonable as well. The crust is crispy and salty (in the perfect way) just enough sauce and cheese, pepperoni was crispy. Perfect pizza. I will be back! read more

A family favorite! We always order for pickup and the staff are very friendly and accommodating. The Pizza is fantastic, bread sticks are delicious, and the wings are great. read more

Personally I thought the service was less than exemplary. After being on the job from 4:30 in the morning I called Classic Pizza on Sunbury Rd.in Westerville, OH for delivery around 8:30. They told me it would be 45 minutes I said great make sure it is 45 minutes as I have worked all day and need to shower. While showering they tried to deliver and would not make an attempt to redeliver. I was emphatic about asking when they would attempt to deliver, person I spoke with said I was shouting, I don't think I was and they would not deliver and just hung up. They'll not miss me as a customer nor will I miss them pizza vendor read more

Well, I know we have gotten pizza from here a few times now and I thought that I had left a review, but obviously not.... This is a decent place to get pizza, and their prices are reasonable enough. Not as cheap and reasonable as about 5 years ago, but in line with other pizza places in the area. We are a little limited on the pizza places who will deliver where we live, and I think that Classic is one of the better pizzas. They take a while to get it out to you, but it's always fresh and hot when it comes. The boy who typically delivers is always very nice and friendly and is very sweet to my daughter (who thinks that anyone and everyone is her best friend). The last time I ordered the taco pizza and they forgot the lettuce and sour cream to go with. This time it was not an issue, as the delivery driver had everything with him. I really like to taco pizza they have here. I am not usually one to stray from the usual toppings on a pizza, but this one is pretty tasty and the jalepenos add a good spice to it. It's yummy.....and a small is plenty for me (since my husband and daughter won't touch it). We will order from here agian in the future for sure! read more

Ordered pizza and wings, when the wings arrived they were completely raw. I called to let them know, and the manager was overly rude and stated that his brother in law watches every single wing being cooked. I offered to send a picture, and he declined. They offered a $10 credit, and a case of salmonella read more

Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

I work close by and was told by a coworker this was good pizza. I am not a fan of Donatos and don't know why people in Columbus think they are so wonderful. So since I'm always on a quest to find good pizza that is NOT Donatos, I was hopeful. A coworker and myself went here and purchased two pizzas. I loved my pizza and she did not. She thought it tasted like Donatos. HA! The pizza was flavorful, the service was excellent and I will definitely return. Unfortunately, my coworker won't be returning. read more

This pizza used to be delicious. I have never in my life thrown a pizza away...until last night. I picked up what I was expecting to be a glorious cheat meal; however, when I got home I couldn't believe what they served to me. A completely burnt, tasteless cheese pizza. Yes I tried it with the hopes that the look was just deceiving. Nope, it tasted like greasy cardboard. Into the trash it went. I hate wasting food and money. Highly disappointed!! read more

Classic Pizza - Tasteless, burnt cheese pizza. This is acceptable to serve to a customer? - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Best pizza in Westerville!!! Not too saucy, not too cheesy-- just right! The prices are great and the staff is always nice! My family and I order pizza from them a lot! And we love it! You can't go wrong here! read more

Growing up in a Ohio, I am a big fan of the midwestern style of pizza, that being thin pizza cut into little squares. Classic's does this style very well and on the cheap. Service is always fast and I have never gotten a bad pie from this location. Yum :) read more

I have to get this pizza whenever I'm in town. Yum. I would like to see fresh mushrooms available for order, but that's hardly a legit complain when I love this pizza the way I do. read more

Good pizza always hot and ready when I pick it up ,curbside bring out was a good addition help has always been friendly as well

Tried this place for the first time last night because it is very close to my house. It was pretty delicious!! Got a thin crust pepperoni pizza & bread sticks. The breadsticks & marinara were super good. I would recommend this place & I plan on trying more menu options in the future. read more