My husband said to me -Do you want pizza for dinner??? and I said- Oh yes but today I will chose a good one, a different one... I was searching on Yelp and some other sites and we found Pizza Nova. We know this place, but it has a new owner... we like it after, but I feel love in the new administration... and we weren't wrong. We ordered a REGULAR CRUST pizza with fresh mushrooms & Paperoni. Pizza was delicious. Perfect temperature... "16" was more than enough for my husband and I.... I ate 3 slices; I use to eat 2... hahaha So delicious pizza!!! Thank you guys, keep doing a lovely work read more

See all

A good neighborhood pizza spot with a good variety of toppings. Tables to eat inside and street parking available. read more

Pizza Nova - Different pizza varieties - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

No offense to whomever was behind the previous place, but the sauce has changed and so has the size and portions. Either way, I don't leave reviews usually but the chicken parm is fantastic and their cheese pizza is awesome as well. Love the sauce! read more

Pizza Nova - Chicken Parm Hero - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

Got pizza from here two times now and both times the pizza did not disappoint. They do a good ny style pizza when folded doesn't flop. I got wings both times, and they were decent. The first time I ordered from uber eats they had free garlic bread with a $30 purchase and it was very tasty. read more

Pizza Nova - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Only heard good things and decided to stop by. Clean tasting pizza with good ingredients. Definitely different from very salty/buttery chain pizza that's sometimes good but hard to eat often. They were pretty generous with the toppings as well. read more

Pizza Nova - The Works Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Short and SWEET... this is the most DELICIOUS Pizza I've had since the brick oven I salivated over growing up near the village in Manhattan. I never thought I'd love it as much..or maybe MORE!! (Aaarrgghh!!!). FRESH & Delicious ingredients. Perfect crust. Just enough cheese to make you happy without being over the top "icky". Not to mention it's nice inside.. clean, seating and nice Staff. All this situated right in nice shopping area in Tenafly. Right now... no other pizza compares. Can't wait to have the Pasta!! read more

Pizza Nova - 2 slices of Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

The buffalo chicken pizza and the chicken parm sandwich was really good. The pizza was thin crust and the sauce was really tasty. The parm sandwich bread was really fresh and soft. I also got the garlic bread with cheese, I would pass on it. Wasn't worth it and had little flavor. Not that garlicky and wasn't really toasted. read more

Pizza Nova - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

Pass. Pizza is made on those wire mesh trays like at chain pizza places. It's to crisp the bottom but it gives an inherent cheap, frozen box pizza taste. Not a fan at all. Pizza in display is old and lacks any moisture. It's a dry brittle slice. They also seem to charge based on what they feel like it or who you are as the prices do not match what is on their display. $9.50 this time for a ziti slice and a reg slice. That is a cash price as I was told it would be more if a credit card was used. Hard pass. read more

Pizza Nova - This is two slices that they cut up for some reason. Plain slice and a ziti slice - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Had lunch with the family and the pizza was great but the highlight was hot zeppolis with ice cream! read more

Pizza Nova - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Horrible customer service after not getting my food for 20 minutes I asked the worker if I am getting my food and she told me to calm down

Amazing customer service and amazing quality. Family owned which means a lot of love goes into their business. My favorite is their chicken parm pizza. Every time I order for parties their pizza is the first thing to go! read more

Although they had just closed, she kindly gave us almost an entire pie for free. Pizza was great too and very affordable

Pizza was fine. Nothing to write home about. $11 for two slices is a bit unreasonable to me read more

Pizza Nova - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Amazing place! I love their healthy options, as well as the pizza .. I love the lentils soup and the vegan pizza when I don't want real cheese as I am lactose intolerant and sometimes don't feel like taking the lactose pill :) def recommend to try them out ! The staff was super helpful and friendly and patient enough to explain the menu to me read more

The pizza here has become mediocre and very expensive. The bbq pizza had no bbq sauce on it. We ordered from here because our favorite pizza place was closed for vacation. The cashier was super pushy about leaving cash tips as well, very uncomfortable. read more

Pizza was great Lemon pepper wings were excellent Good place to eat. Everyone was nice and service was on point. I would recommend this place to anyone and plan to return. read more

PROS: The staff here is very nice and attentive to what you're looking for. The tables, floor, and front counter were very clean. The menu options were plentiful like any ordinary pizza place and the pizza tasted great! There were also 5 different sizes of pizza pies to choose from. CONS: I felt that the prices were too high. For a 16 inch pizza it was $13.50 when normally in a pizza that price would be 20 inches. Meanwhile if you wanted just a slice or two or anything lower than 10 bucks they won't accept a card, just cash. Hopefully you can find a good parking spot on the street too since there's no parking lot OVERALL: Since they're clean and the food taste good I would come back, however, I'm just gonna stick with other pizza parlors in the area. read more

Love love love this place. My go to pizza joint, best I've had anywhere! Some say it's a little pricey, but hey you pay for what you get, so no complaints for me there.. read more

4.5 stars This review is for their pizza because I have not tried anything else there. I have only been inside once and that was way back in 2005. We order delivery very often from here. Delivery is fast (30 min or less) and always the same delivery guy.....we only live a mile from here. Their pizza is really good. No complaints about the sauce, cheese or dough. It can be a little greasy, but I like a little grease on my pies. For toppings we almost always get garlic. Only once we're the toppings unevenly distributed. As an another reviewer mentioned, the sizes are different than other places. A large is 14" and a X large is "16. If you normally get a large at other places, go with the X large here. Prices are decent. Not the best, but I don't think they're expensive either. An X large pie with one topping comes out to $16. I've heard their wings are good. I'll have to try them soon. read more

See all

Got a works pie and a mushroom pie for lunch, love that the dough is made in house and the mushrooms are fresh not canned! read more

Pizza Nova - Works Pie - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

I really enjoyed the pizza. Excellent service with the staff and the size of the pizza was definitely worth the price. read more

See all

I saw the guy that makes the pizza touch everything he was putting on the pizza (cheese, toppings etc) with his bare hands without washing them after coming from the back of the restaurant doing goodness only knows what UGH DISGUSTING So many choices for pizza - eat here at your own peril read more

Tried the pizza here after my son's baseball game and we were not disappointed. Fresh pizza with quality ingredients. There are also many options available on their menu. Service is prompt and the workers were kind. The ambiance is quaint and clean. It feels like a warm neighborhood spot! Will definitely go back next time we're in Tenafly. read more

Great service and they greeted me. Amazing food and amazing customer service. If you order in person the pizza comes out pretty quickly if you order a few slices. Multiple variety of drinks and pizzas, including the classics. They also play Music sometimes read more

Stopped by for a quick lunch, fresh salad with lentil soup and garlic knots, best combo! read more

One of the best and most unique BBQ pies in Bergen county!! Love this place and they've been good for the better half of two decades

prices on menu board are outdated by 50%. could not cancel order, no manager to speak to. Expect to pay 50% extra for the order

I found so many tomato chunks in all there pizza the pizza tastes like trash and all the food does so as the service it sucks the cheese tastes like my butthole and the ambiance of the place is so unpleasant read more

I found at least 20 tomato chunks in my pizza yesterday. The service was horrible. The ambiance is horrible as well they don't clean their table. read more

not thrilled with a $1.50 delivery charge, but the prices are decent enough to absorb it I order whenever I stay at near-by Clinton Inn Hotel. Great Pizza, friendly staff Worth checking out read more

Had two slices the other night. I had meatlovers and my son had a regular cheese slice. Both were pretty darn good and they had great customer service and the place was clean. It was a Tuesday night so slow but still, had a good experience and I would definitely try again. read more

Best in Tenafly handsdown. Staff is mostly nice. Their slices are huge, they usually cut them in half to make it more manageable. They have a great selection of pizzas (different combo toppings [e.g. bbq chicken, veggie, meat trio]) and they always make my fav if I ask for it (it's a secret ;-) ) Good pizza, good people, reasonable prices. If you're in the area, check it out. read more

Pizza Nova - Outside Pizza Nova - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

I live in Tenafly and we frequently order from Pizza Nova. When I order a full pie, they once gave me a pizza that was pieced together from unsold single slices. Another time, they gave me a pizza that was clearly not freshly baked. Before leaving this review, I called the store to let them know of this issue as to hope that it would not happen ago, however, the owner was rude and aggressive and placed the blame solely on me. Local businesses should not treat their local communities this way. read more

I've admired their BBQ Chicken Pizza for years I actually haven't tried anything else on their menu, the BBQ Chicken Pizza is a 6/5 Stars for taste the whole place is a bit pricey for the quality of pizza however. I gave the place 4 because the dining experience is very very basic. the cold air often rushes in when the door opens the staff is friendly but nothing note worthy. the bathroom cleanliness is just okay. if you do take out or delivery, then you wont regret the pizza. read more

Not really the best pizza in the world but unless you leave in Brooklyn/Manhattan the chances you'll find an amazing one is not so great . The owner is really nice also his employees. Clean place that you know exactly what your getting and their always never a surprise. read more

Pizza here is pretty good. They have fast service and the staff are all friendly. Pricing to add extra toppings is a little pricey, but seems like that's normal with most pizza joints. I've always picked up instead of eat in. The place is a little outdated but okay for a equivocal nite if you want to eat in read more

Really terrible. The pizza arrived completely burnt. Also, the service was absolutely appalling. Extremely rude and unprofessional. Will never order from here again. read more

Pizza Nova - Pizza Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

I went to buy a slice of pizza and the guy who charged me did not wear gloves or wash his hands and served me the pizza, it gave me a lot of annoyance because especially in these times of Corina Virus we all have to be more careful. I will never buy again in that pizzeria and surely no one of my friends read more

The best pizzeria ive ever been to, tied with the fancy and more expensive "Brooklyn's pizzeria" Anything you order here is of high quality. Everything is very fresh and they make their food as healthy as they can and yet their food tastes better than all the other junk that is out there. The old italian manager is the kindest and sweetest old man ive ever met. The rest of the staff is always very kind as well. Definitely try this place out. Only warning: their pizza pie sizes. A large is only 14". Go with their extra large or jumbo. Jumbo is pretty darn big though. Extra large is like any other pizzeria's large read more

Been coming to Pizza Nova since I was old enough to eat pizza and I can't get enough. Honestly, don't know of a place that makes a better slice. From quality of food to service, they really know what they're doing. Every person in town knows that you can't beat their pizza. read more