1990s charm & prices. Everything made fresh to order. Quality & value but patience is a must if ordering here, don't be in a rush. Bergenfield Pizza - In! read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - In action! - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

See all

Great little gem in Bergenfield - transported to 80s style pizzeria. Nice owner and down to earth prices and good pizza/italian dishes. Good for takeout!! read more

See all

PROS: Very nice owner of the shop and its spacious inside. Food tastes good, menu variety is plentiful, and the prices are unbeatable! Nice amount of parking here as well CONS: The pizza slices were smaller than usual and they only have a one person bathroom which can cause a lineup OVERALL: I will definitely come back here in time cause the prices are amazing and the owner is very nice read more

Good pizza and inexpensive too. It reminds me of the places I used to go to in the Bronx where you can get a slice for $1.00 or even less when I was younger. Gumba, (not his real name) the owner is always there, he practically lives there and makes some really nice big sandwiches too. He has a loyal following of customers and it helps make him successful. A staple in Bergenfield and I hope he continues to be there. They offer very friendly service, ample seating, as well as convenient parking so it is a good spot for a quick lunch. read more

I usually get my Italian food somewhere else but since my spot was closed, I ordered from Bergenfield Pizza. I ordered an Eggplant dinner with just sauce, no cheese. While the food took a while, I didn't mind too much since the place is really neat and well kept. I enjoyed the smell of Italian food, the tv in the background, and just waiting curious about how my meal would come out. The meal was beyond good. I don't get paid for reviewing this place, but I will say honestly best eggplant meal ever. I'd recommend Bergenfield Pizza to anyone wanting to enliven their taste buds. Thank you! read more

I wanted a chicken parm sandwich on a random Sunday. This place was just down the street from me, and I decided to give it a try. It's a cute little local business, and the atmosphere reflects the mom and pop business feel. I got the $13 chicken parm sandwich, but I somehow left the place with a sandwich that's longer than my torso. The sandwich was pretty solid overall. It could definitely feed at least 3 people. read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

See all

The best food for your money. prices are good. I think they have not changed their prices since the 70s. And I always like to order a nice salad. read more

Extremely Disappointed Twice in a Row I wish I were exaggerating, but my experience with Bergenfield Pizza has been nothing short of frustrating. On two separate occasions, I called ahead to place an order, and each time the owner assured me that the pizza would be ready in 15 minutes. Both times, when I arrived to pick up my order, the pizza hadn't even been put in the oven yet! The prices are lowest I've seen in town, but that doesn't make up for the overly greasy pizza and poor service. The first time, I thought it might have been an honest mistake, but after it happened again, I realized this is just how they operate. This level of disorganization and disregard for customers' time is unacceptable. The first time the owner was openly drinking but I decided to give it another shot and my second time going the TV on the counter was facing the workers and not the customers lol. I won't be returning, and I certainly wouldn't recommend Bergenfield Pizza to anyone. Save yourself the hassle and go somewhere that values your business. read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

I got the eggplant Parmesan and it was delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant. I'm sure the rest of their food is delicious too.

I use to come here like 40 years ago when we lived in the area and it's barely changed at all from the enormous heros to the absurdly inexpensive slices. Seriously, slices are under $2 while many places now are at the $3.50 mark. How do the owners do this? And the pizza is good and exactly the same as in the 1980's. Bravo! read more

I love this pizza, taste very good! Ordered the large chicken parmesan today, and WOW!!! Check out the size! I placed a bottle next to it, so u have an idea. The lasagna was good, a little on salty side. The garlic was delicious!!! Prices are very good! read more

See all

Solid pizzeria for the area. I'm not gonna lie that the pizza sometimes is a hit or miss but you go here more for the environment. Clean place too the solution they clean the floor with literally is steaming. The guys working here are chill especially the old Italian guy who owns the place. Overall 4/5 stars read more

I love my love I love the pizza and the chicken, Parm hero, and the best in town. I moved out of town about seven years ago and I still think about this place. I used to go there about 4 to 5 times a week. I know they miss me.Lol read more

I ordered 9 pies for an outside, socially distanced and mask wearing mind you, event. Pizza was ready on time and owner gave me a 10% discount. Cheese pizza was fine, could have used a bit more sauce, but the pepperoni's were good. I've come here several times. Nothing fancy here or spectacular but a solid consistency and just fine if you want something simple. read more

I enjoyed the baked ziti and the price was reasonable. The pizza was very tasty. Staff is very nice.

40years and still going strong! Bergenfield pizza never disappoints. Where can you get a meatball slice with more meatballs on it than most places put on the whole pie!? Love this place. Definitely value for your $$ read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - Meatball slice - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

I'm in agreement with other reviewers that this pizza leaves much to be desired. It's literally a hot mess as previously mentioned. You know there's a problem when it's sliced into 8 and the lines are no longer there 5 minutes later... Then you go to grab your slice after cutting away at the connected bits and the cheese starts sliding right off. The issue appears two-fold: there's too much cheese for the paper thin crust to hold and pools of grease help lubricate the slip-n-slide effect. Now when it comes to pizza, I'm big on crust, so I set aside the messy exterior and opened myself up to the possibility of some serious FLA-VA FLAVE. For pizzas, like books, and people... or really anything on this planet...should not be judged by their appearance. I went ahead eating my first slice away and came to the conclusion that this poor pizza might very well be one of the few exceptions to an otherwise solid rule. I'm not sure I would describe it as "ok", I'd probably opt for just "edible". All the ingredients just seem to be piled on top of each other without any thought given to quality, construction, or freshness. I won't argue the cheap prices, but if you get what you pay for, is it worth it? Other side notes include: a 30 min. take-out really being 50, an empty lot and seating area when I arrived, a huge out of place TV resting on the counter instead of on a wall, and old outdated menus, signage, and decor (which could have been a plus if they kept this "dive" alive). As for the owner, I have no complaints, but in trying to prioritize like Frost: "I have [other pizzas to eat], and miles to go before I sleep." read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - After cooling at home - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

See all

The food is excellent. Wait time can be long, end result makes it worth it! I usually order pizza both regular and Sicilian, he does it and way you want. We go for well done, he doesn't burn the cheese! read more

Soo good! Love this place and the owner is so great. Pizza is amazing and subs are too. read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - Half plain, half mushroom onion - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

If I could give 0 stars I would do not go here the worst so called pizza you'll ever find ordered a "margarita pizza" got a regular cheese with slices of tomatoes on it wtf I've never even seen this shit before. My other pizza was mad undercooked the paper melted into the cheese couldn't even eat it lost out on 3 slices. Had to go home & cook the other half of my pizza. Waste of time and money! read more

See all

My husband loves this pizza. He says it's like Good old school pizza. We order from here regularly.

Food is very salty. Prices were fair. Orders take a long time. It's worth a try for the price but don't expect a mind blowing experience. Need to have realistic expectations for the money your paying. read more

The food is always amazing and always fresh! And the staff handles themself with the highest regards! Saw a woman come in super obnoxious and rude for no apparent reason! The owner handled the situation perfect! Its a shame he should have to deal with these type of customers. read more

I love this place! Their food are great and reasonable. The owner and his staff are very friendly! Highly recommended +++++

Used to go here all the time because he opened late. One night, we called for pickup and ordered a large pie. When my bf went to go pick it up 30 minutes later, they just had put it in the oven. My bf questioned him about why he did that. The guy said he does that so the pizza isn't cold when we get there. So, my bf said that's the point of calling ahead for pickup. That when we arrive, the pizza is done and we don't have to wait. Ever since then, we haven't gone back. read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

Food is fresh depending on what you order. Don't waste your time ordering by phone because he would put your order in once you walk in.

Good decent pizza shop in Bergenfield that serves pizza, pasta dishes, wedges , and more. Picked up a large regular pie and large square for take out as indoor seating is limited. .my troop enjoyed both but the garlic knots were a bit too oily. I called before pick up and I didn't have to wait no more then 3 minutes . A pizza shop on south Washington in bergenfield that will get my business again when its in the cards . read more

I got garlic bread from here first time while doing laundry nearby and it was one of the best garlic breads I've had. The guy made it fresh to order out of pizza bread and the garlic seemed fresh. It was also a giant size bread and was no more than $2 so a great deal there. I came back a few times since and haven't tried anything but their pizza and garlic breas. The only downside is when they get busy they can get pretty backed up. One time I called my order in ahead and came 20 minutes later and after waiting in like for about 5 minutes i told the man what i ordered and turns out he completely forgot and didn't even start my food. He started making it after i told him my order again. If the food wasn't good as it is or the prices weren't so low i would definitely never come back due to a mistake like this. read more

I just love this place , their pasta is really good , so yummy , their baked Ziti so good , one of the best pizza places in bergen county NJ

Poor guy running this place, stopped in on a sat night. No drinks except diet coke, not even water, fountain machine wasn't working. Poor exhaust system so when we left after eating our clothes smelled like burned toast. Pizza was super greasy and the cheese slid off. read more

Love the pizza here! Super original, love the sauce they use in the pizza and the combo with the cheese is just great! Since it's close to my job anytime I'm in the mood for good pizza I like to come here ! read more

An old school, extremely underrated and satisfying pizza joint. Crust is good and the cheese is tangy. Owner takes his time making each pie by hand. read more

Do not go here. Don't normally put posts on yelp but had a such a bad experience here. Ordered a pie to go and first of all the cashier and owner have no sense of urgency, didn't even say how much longer it was going to be when I came to pick up and it wasn't ready. They eventually took the pie out and it still was not even close to ready. I politely asked the cashier if he could put it back in for a little bit because it was not done, he just left it on the counter until the owner noticed 5 minutes later. The owner got mad at me saying I didn't ask for it to be cooked well done. I told him sir, it's not even done. He gave me a lot of attitude and just started making another pie. I told him I didn't want to wait another 25 minutes for a pie and took the old one. Very rude owner, and no personality with the cashier. Stay away!! read more

Bergenfield Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

See all

My in-laws have been going here for over 10 years. Needless to say, every holiday when we're visiting, we love ordering a plain pie. The crust is perfectly cooked and not too thick. The sauce is delicious. A real family-run business. Forget Domino's or Pizza Hut. This is where it's at. read more

Best Pizza in North Jersey, no joke! If you like real cheese and some grease, then you are in luck! Slices are always available. Also, if you get their subs, their large sub is literally 2 feet long and most are under $10, with the small being 1 foot. Ignore the previous reviewer who just wanted to slander a great business and made up stuff about them in their profile. read more

Pizza was a mess too much cheese got it home wasnt even cut I had to cut it myself. Sauce wasn't good and Ished for it well done but got tired of waiting read more

Delicious. My favorites are the hot subs which are enormous. Their small is about a foot long. Everything ive ever ordered was so big i rarely finished everything. Shockingly it is very affordable. They only use fresh ingredients. They are very nice people as well. The only reason they get 4 stars instead of 5 is because they will tell you that your food will take 20 minutes to be ready and most the time it will take a lot longer. read more

"GUMBA" That's what I call him! He is the best Italian/Sicilian pizza hut I know. All of his dishes are great+ the portions are hugh. Check out Bergenfield read more

Okay, I've lived less than 2 miles from this place for 10 years. First time there last week as I was craving eggplant parm. Crazy good food. I felt like I was a kid at my Italian grandmother's house in CT. The ziti was perfectly cooked. The eggplant parm was excellent and their sauce- off the hook. As an amateur home chef, I always say if you don't have good sauce, you don't have good italian. The sauce was probably the best restaurant sauce around. So, less than a week later I wanted pizza for a quick dinner. There sicilian pie was great. If you like thick crust pizza (that's why it's Sicilian), you will enjoy this. Great cheese, the same sauce that was used for the eggplant parm, and real sausage slices - not the crumbled mess you get at other places. Hands down, my new go-to pizza spot in the Englewood/Bergenfield/Tenafly areas. read more

The pizza is very good - it's just too HOT! So hot the toppings melt off of it! That's a problem! Because it's messy. But it's tasty! I like mushrooms and he uses fresh. It's not a very inviting place - tables and chairs are from the 50s!! And it's dark and grungy!! wish it was nicer inside cuz we would go more often and even being groups. Looks like they haven't put a dime into the business for years. I guess it's just too expensive to keep it up! BERGENFIELD could use a great pizza place (like Rays in Cresskill - a place to hang and have a weeknight meal) read more