Spaghetti Carbonara & calamari were excellent. Nice place to relax, casual. Would say best Italian in the area.

Pizza taste is a very personal choice, but service quality is universal. We were greeted warmly, and service for Dine-in was pleasant. I ordered a "white" pizza, with artichokes and spinach. Toppings were fair and well distributed, and the crust was crisp and firm (I hate pizza that comes out "wet"). Cheese was melted to perfection. I'm really surprised we had not come here before but do plan to go back. read more

Amazing fresh pizzas and delicious garlic knots, but their pastas are not fresh and are store bought. Unsure if desserts are as well. Staff seems a bit unhappy as well, except for those who are apart of the owners family. Decent interior and overall a good place to pick up a slice or share a pie as a group. read more

I can't speak for any of their entrees, because I've never had them, but their pizza and subs are some of the best around. They don't skimp when it comes to their subs. You can't even close them and they make a mess, because of it, but they're absolutely delicious. The steak and cheese with banana peppers is one of my favorites, but their Italian sub is the best Italian sub I've had. I cannot say enough good things about their margherita pizza either. It's by far my favorite. No wonder it's in their name. When I want pizza and subs, this is the first place around that I think of. I've been going there for well over 10 years and I've only had one bad experience. We were the only people in the whole restaurant. We ordered subs and after waiting 15-20 mins we asked if they were almost ready. They admitted that they forgot to start making them... somehow. If the food wasn't so good, I would have asked for a refund and walked out, but I had my heart set on that Italian sub. 10+ years (possibly 15+, now that I think of it) of great food and customer service. I'll let one slide. read more

This is the place for great pizza! Always a staple for our family. We've never had a bad experience. They consistently make great pizza that tastes delicious. read more

Loved the Foccacia pepperoni bacon ranch pie. Crust was well done and crunchy like a foccacia pizza should be! Also, they didn't skimp on the bacon crumbles. Pleasant service too read more

I have been to Pizza NY Margherita twice now. Both times the food has been outstanding! The Service is outstanding as well. The Spaghetti Carbonara with added Sausage is perhaps the Best Pasta I have ever had! Their Pizza is excellent as well. The Ambience is that of a very nice Italian restaurant. When I went to get a Cherry Coke, it was out of syrup. The Girl at the Register saw me and asked was the Soda no good? Then Joe the GM or owner told me it is out of Syrup and will be fixed ASAP. I did not need to go tell anyone or wait in a line to tell them as I would in so many other restaurants. Again, Top Notch - Ritz Carlton type service! I would highly recommend going to Pizza NY Margherita as a Family, with Friends or by yourself for a Really Excellent Italian meal. read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Spaghetti Carbonara with Sausage added - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

This establishment had very unpleasant service below expectation the food was good but let me start from the start my family and I had come to this place and we got seated and then our fries were really good and the girl that gave them to us was fine not then we were sharing them and then she gave us chicken Alfredo and then the girl that gave it to us went through the employee only door and started laughing at us like right after she got in the door and while looking at us after that the guy that was working the register came and had given us one of the pizzas and we told him the situation and he was very nice and professional and then he said that he was sorry about the situation and then the rest of our pizzas where given then i saw a girl and she was holding a cloth over her face and she was laughing and looking right at me after she saw me looking she walked away i don't know if this was the same girl but my family is saying that she was a different one but after that we had left I would eat again but only pickup and not dine in also you know that the service is bad because there are 4 other reviews about bad service including this also all of them mention a girl (i think she thought we were poor because we had around 10 people and she gave us 1 dish of Alfredo) . read more

I've been going here for years and this will always be my favorite spot for pizza they are always so nice and the food is always amazing my son just had his first pizza today read more

Pizza NY Margherita - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

We came in with over 25 people and the staff took care of us fast. Our orders were delivered fast and fresh. This restaurant has an amazing bar selection. The wine was excellent. A very comfortable experience with friends and family. The tomato sauce on the pizza was fresh, the toppings spot on. The wings were crispy. Everyone enjoyed their pasta. Great Job. read more

See all

The food was pretty good, the staff at the counter were nice, however the short lady(there was another lady, however she was nice) who came and gave us our food was extremely rude. She placed down our food and as she was heading back to the kitchen she started laughing. Once we looked over she and another employee were laughing while looking through the window in the employee only door. We found this extremely disgusting as not only her, but her other friends were laughing directly at us without any care. Overall, the food was good. The staff was not. read more

Simply, simple pizza done right. Great ingredients used to make delicious food. This review platform, however, is very unsavory by making me write more than I wanted. read more

The service was excellent and food was fantastic. Would highly recommend. Staff was fast and took take of me and my needs

I have dined here many times over the years and even had business lunch meetings with sales representatives from other companies and they have all enjoyed the food. When coming in to the restaurant you are greeted at the counter by a staff member and will be given a menu to place an order at the register and then you will be given a number card to place at the table you select to dine at if dining in. The staff will then bring your order to the table once finished, there is really no table service other than someone bussing the table after you have left. Sodas and water are self serve in the dining area with free refills of course. Beer and wine can be ordered at the bar or register also. The restaurant appears to be kept clean and orderly and is well lit with lighting and a corner location with windows on both walls. My trip in today had me ordered the fried calamari and the Chicken Marsala. The calamari was just the rings no tentacles served with a semi-spicy dipping sauce that was sprinkled with crushed red pepper flakes. It was a nice little starter. The main course of the Chicken Marsala was served with Fettuccine pasta and mushrooms in a wine sauce with 2 slices of garlic bread. The chicken is beaten flat and tender when eating and the noodles were slightly chewy and seemed to have soaked up some of the sauce which was nice as you don't see that in some other restaurants. Other foods I have enjoyed at this location are the pizzas, steak and cheese, and grilled chicken Caesar salad. My favorite though pizza are the Pizza Napoli and the Pizza Margherita. read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Fried calamari - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

See all

You can tell if they make good pizza when you order a very basic plain New York style pizza and this place failed it miserable. This pizza doesn't taste anything and sauce and cheese is unbalanced. Where the f is the pizza sauce??? Waste of money. read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Where is the sauce bro - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

The service was AWFUL! Our pizza was tasteless and burnt. Our table was served by 3 different people at random times. Not one person could tell us where to get our drinks except a very brutish Italian woman. We have learned our lesson and will not return. There wasn't any ambiance that you would accept for the hype. read more

Good pizza, they seem to cater to regulars as well as new customers. Confused if they are going for NY or Italian style?

Ordered pizza by the slice, lots of options. All were excellent and price was reasonable. Got the dessert which was also good. Kid got to sit where he could watch the pizzas getting made. Thumbs up read more

Awesome veal parm sub. Friendly staff. Going back to try the pizza next, maybe entree items.

I come out to meet my buddy for lunch and no matter whether I want pizza or a good meatball sub, they never let me down. Order ahead and your food is ready when you get there. Staff is friendly too! read more

I came away disappointed and my wife only slightly better after dining here on an early Saturday night. It started off poorly right away as we walked in and literally didn't know what was on the menu. Since we wanted a couple of slices of pizza we walked to where the pies are on display. Despite there being no less than eight employees standing behind the counter, they can't actually help you. I had to walk to the end of the counter by the register to place my order. Well guess what, there are no signs to identify the pizzas so I had to walk back to where I just was to point to the cashier which slices I wanted. Strike one. My wife was excited to see one slice of eggplant pizza left which she snagged along with a side Greek salad and a glass of Chianti. I picked two slices of their special pizza with a Peroni. We paid, got a number and found an empty booth. Our food ended up coming out in waves. First we each got a slice of pizza on too small a plate and hanging over the edges. Really? Why not throw them on a pizza pan. Next wave my second slice arrived. No sign of the salad so we went up and asked and it was delivered a couple minutes later. Finally on the fourth visit, the garlic bread arrived. Why can't we just get everything at once? Strike two. My pizza looked good up front but was delivered luke warm and tasted like pizza I would reheat in a microwave at home. My wife's pizza slice had wonderful flavors but was only luke warm as well. The high point was the garlic bread and Greek salad. Both generous portions and very tasty. Strike three though for luke warm, bland tasting slices. Three strikes for me and I'm out. I won't be back but suspect my wife likely will be as eggplant pizza just isn't easy to find. read more

This was my first time here. I was shopping at nearby Total Wine around lunch time. I was hungry for a quick lunch, therefore, I asked Total Wine's cashier if the pizza was any good at this nearby pizzeria. She said it was good, therefore, I walked over. They had lots of pizzas with different toppings on display. I opted for a single slice of pepperoni pizza. They gave me a number for my table, which I inserted into their table display stand on my table. I was served with a large piece of pepperoni pizza. I noticed the pizza was oily from the pepperoni. Other than being oily the pizza tasted average at best. I may return here again for a different slice of pizza or something else from their menu. read more

Good pizza, good selection of food items and beer. Only issue...got a slice of pepperoni and sausage...really small, yet I saw others with slices much bigger. Inconsistency is not good business. read more

Ordered a large cheese and Greek salad. Both were spot on what I wanted, but I have to admit upon entering the Restaurant for pick up I regretted getting anything so plain. They have a vast array of pizzas by the slice that looked amazing. Next time I order here I will habe to get one of the more amazing pies that have on offer! read more

I really tried to like this place. Ordered take out a few times. Orders were wrong. Asked for specific things not to be put on the food because there's an allergy. Ordered the Veggie pizza and it was not good. Nowhere on the menu does it say it's sprinkled with Parmesan cheese. Pizza came covered in it. Parmesan cheese is nasty and smells like dirty feet. I had to scrape off all the toppings because that nasty foot cheese was everywhere. So essentially I had expensive bread for dinner. read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Pizza was covered in stinky Parmesan cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Friendly and kind staff. Very generous portions! Comfort food. Nice and clean inside and out. Fast service. Great for take out too! Outdoor patio. It checks all the boxes! Wow! read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Chicken Parm is perfection. It's so crunchy and gooey, all at the same time. The garlic bread is delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

First off, this is a counter order, serve at table place. You can order just a single slice if you're in a rush. Definitely a casual vibe. But the food takes it up a notch for me. We've had dinner here several times over the last couple months and very much enjoyed the food and experience. We ordered their NY style pizza and found the toppings generous in the meat lovers pie. Drinks are self-service. read more

Good food, large menu, good sauce (very important). Even has open wireless!! They have the typical array of Italian pizza parlor features, pizza (NY, sicillian, brick oven), calzone, various pastas, salads, soups, and have a decent selecton of wine and beer. Open spacious attractive atmosphere, televisions, open kitchen to watch (clean!), friendly service (+!). A nice place for a casual date or a family. Can accomodate a large group (table for 20). And for us iPhone users, open wireless!! Will be making this a regular place for the Cerniuks... Especially when the gelato arrived on the menu! read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Saturday note, busy but great service still! - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Since I could chew, I was always selective about pizza because most places put way too much sauce on. For the first time in my life, I've found a place I can walk into and not have to say "light sauce." While that may seem ridiculous to many, it means the world to me. Thanks so much. And you will have my business for life. read more

people leaving good reviews have never had good pizza / pasta. soggy / floppy pizza, gross.. I would choose dominoes over this place.

We love the pizza and chicken wings. My husband thinks their chicken wings are the best and no establishment wings can compares

Was very disappointed in their pepperoni roll. Way too much cheese and very little pepperoni (see photo). $8 for a blob of cheese. Also the ends of the bread were so hard and chewy (burned). I had to throw them away. read more

Pizza NY Margherita - Pepperoni Roll $8. Wasn't good. Where's the pepperoni?! 1/25/22 - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

We happened to be in Gainesville on a Monday afternoon and were so hungry and really craving pizza. We were so happy we found this little hidden gem! Having grown up in Northern Va, you expect a lot of pizza places to be similar, but honestly, the flavor and freshness was awesome! My son (who does not like spaghetti and meat sauce) could not stop eating off of mine. The meat lovers pizza was and the steak and cheese was so hot and juicy! It was perfection. If you find yourself in Gainesville, definitely check it out. Oh and to boot they have this delicious gelato that my kids were raving about lol "the birthday cake (ice cream) even has pieces of birthday cake " read more

See all

I have been going to pizza margherita for years. they have the best pizza and subs and salads. I hadn't been in awhile and I had the caprice salad for lunch and Joe and his team did it again. it was amazing. the customer services is always friendly and everyone is willing to assist you with any questions you have. I will be back. Thanks Joe Christine Duran read more

I'm pissed. This restaurant uses a 3rd party online service for placing orders online. This system took my money and didn't transmit the order? I have a pending charge and my money is being held for up to 10 days!!!!! Who cares how great your food is when you have a jack up system for delivery! Awful!! read more

Pizza tasted great and was quick to deliver. Staff was very chill. I felt like i walked in on a family. It's missing a star because the iced tea tasted a whole awful lot like dish water. I was too thirsty to complain. Also - message to manager. I like the efforts in creating a holiday-like atmosphere. I recommend you have an activity for kids, maybe pizza toy giveaways where they make their own pizza. Or placemats that they can color. Lots of kids coming into the shopping center and this would attract the families for sure. Good luck! read more

Stopped in on a whim and was immediately impressed. The place was clean, seems to be family owned and ran. The menu was amazing. Went with a simple margarita pie and it was more than I expected. Was just like back home in Jersey. Fresh mozzarella and basil. Plenty of sauce so the pizza wasn't dry and the perfect crispness like a real pizza should have. Can't wait to go back and try some of the other items on the menu. They even had cannolis (which looked delish!). Beer by the pitcher ($10). Me and my parents ate the entire pie and by entire, I mean the crust too. It was just that good. It's really hard to find "real" pizza down here in Virginia. Already picking a day to go back. Ten stars read more

The opening notes of Metallica's "Enter Sandman" began to filter through Yelp... Another entrant into the Greater Haymarket/Gainesville area megaplex pizza wars has made it's debut - enter "Pizza NY Margherita" For those of you that are fans of Tony's NY Pizza in Fair Lakes - you may also like this place - the same folks own and run the place. The joint opened just over a week ago according to the girl at the counter. I called in an order for pickup: one 14" New York Style meat lovers pizza with mushrooms added, and an order of spicy chicken wings. Pizza and wings were tasty. The only thing that I would ding them on is the meats on the pizza needed to be cooked a tad longer. The wings were the breaded and fried variety - so the breading contained the spice - their spicy is not that hot to me. I whipped up a small bowl of Frank's Buffalo wing sauce to dip my wings and flavor them. The consistency of the wings were good, crisp, cooked perfectly, and with a side of Blue Cheese dressing. I wish the Blue Cheese dressing were a bit on the chunky side. The menu contains a variety of offerings: appetizers, subs, Calzone, Stromboli, pasta, veal, and more. For eat in diners - the interior of the place is quite spacious. Was a decent crowd eating in and picking up on a Monday evening. Will be back! read more

Great food and great friendly service always perfect and great tasking food. Highly recommend.

Staying in town and tried their pizza. It was amazing!! My man loves their meatball sub too. I did not like their steak and cheese. read more