Stopped in on way back home. Always up for trying new pizza. Pizza was good. Crisp underneath, outer crust was ok. Good sauce, not too sweet, balanced well with the cheese that was not overly greasy. Not a lot of cheese stretch but a good pizza all around. Lots of delivery people in and out so they just be doing something right. read more

See all

Very impressed with the food from this place! I loved it as a kid but moved back to the area and sometimes what I loved as a teenager I don't enjoy as an adult. Husband's small chicken parm sandwich was packed with chicken, cheese pie had a stellar sauce (just a little sweet how we like it) antipasto and Miami salad were both packed and scrumptious and the best part? The delivery driver didn't have the salads on top of the pizza in the car and he was super nice! read more

Great food and delivery service- love the promos - thank you very much for such ease of ordering

Ordered the all meat pizza and large tossed salad. Both were excellent Pizza had enormous amount of meat, salad was fresh. read more

Pizza One - Tossed salad - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

See all

Good pizza and food, reasonable prices. The young woman on the phone was friendly and accurate taking my order and the delivery driver was also friendly and prompt. Overall, a good experience, I was not blown away, but Pizza One seems to be a good reliable pizzeria that we can count on for a good meal. read more

My office frequently orders from here - and its the best around. The pizza is very good, not the best, but the rest of the food makes up for its 5 star status. Typically i order sandwiches, paninis, salads, or their buffalo chicken Mac & cheese! I think the prices are good, they have a lot of options, and EVERYTHING is delicious. The service is great - inside they have multiple POS units to handle the lunch crowd, the delivery is typically fast and the staff is nice. This is hands down one of my favorite spots for lunch or dinner and i would recommend it. I have never tried their other locations but the Haskell location is wonderful read more

Looking a for a great filling pasta dish to have delivered, I stumbled onto Pizza One. The spaghetti I ordered was very well seasoned, and even though I don't usually like thick spaghetti noodles, it was just right! And the wings?? My roommate took one look at them and ordered some for herself! I had a whole second tray left, which was intended to be eaten with the spaghetti.. a meat sauce with deliciously hearty chunks of sausage. It was enough for two more meals! I will definitely be back, and I look forward to trying more menu items! read more

We recently ordered an eggplant wrap buyer beware!!! The eggplant slices were very very thin and probably sliced on their cold cut slicer. Let's put it this way the breading was thicker than the eggplant! There was no eggplant taste!! Paid $10 for a bread crumb wrap!! They don't care and got over on another sucker! Me. We also ordered buffalo cauliflower that was a box half full of tiny nuggets of cauliflower! Not really a pizza place just look at the menu! With all the competition around I would go elsewhere. No more P 1 for us !! read more

Pizza's decent & entrees (I've tried the chicken parm, chicken Marsala and a few dishes no longer on the menu) are good. But they have the best lentil soup I've ever had. read more

Great food. They deliver too. Try the Zeppoles! They deliver. I'm still typing to fill in space lol

The Ringwood ave location suffers from the attention given to the Sparta location. Still good food and pizza but could use a menu update.

I just have to review again. I think Pizza one is one of the best restaurants in our areas. I've had just about everything on the menu and it is fantastic. Have no idea of why it's only a 3.7. read more

Very disappointed to find a live bug in my salad before I even took the lid off. Called to get a refund and they gave us one for our salads, but not the pizza (which in my opinion they should have as an apology). Apparently they said they are having a problem with their veggie distributor, but why are they serving veggies they are having infestation problems with? We won't be coming here anymore, my whole family is disgusted. read more

Pizza One - live bug in salad - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

This place has been our go to since moving to pompton lakes 5 years ago. Everything is fantastic, honest to god. From Individual slices, to the parm subs, the wraps and hot sandwhiches to the dinners and more. Mozzarella sticks best around. Last night I got a cheesesteak with American cheese, cheese whiz, and onions. This is the first time it was open faced and I hope it's like that every time because it was loaded and delicious! Onion rings awesome! Keep it up pizza one read more

Pizza One - Cheesesteak and Onion Rings. Mac & Cheese side. - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

Lasagne is absolutely disgusting... this is indicated as a customer favorite on the menu but there is no way that's true lol. Gave you 3 stars because everything else for the most part is good. The lasagne comes in about a half inch of grease and is not edible. read more

Once again we used Pizza one for their catering services. Everything was excellent and all of our guests raved about the food. Thank you again for your courteous staff and delicious food. Steve Frast read more

We were visiting in the area and everyone had something good to say about this place. We tried it for ourselves and it didn't disappoint! Staff was nice and the food was great! I even took some home because there was so much. We had the dining room to ourselves and it was a great atmosphere. read more

Pizza One - Spaghetti & Meatballs Rodeo Burger - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

Food was really good! Had to wait a long time though, service could've been better. However, overall a really nice place which a retro design to it- close to where I used to work. Not super cheap but for good food its reasonable. read more

Sandwiches are big and good, pizza is average, salads are good, don't order soup. It's 7$ for a cup of soup that's supposed to be 12oz but it's actually much much smaller than that. Pasta is average. Ordering on the phone is hit or miss with if they're nice or not. Would not recommend eating in. Take out is much better. read more

Pizza one is excellent. Food is delicious, staff courteous and cost is reasonable. We order often and highly recommend it.

The fact that the owner decided to comment fake news? I even called the store after it happened and let someone working know in a polite way. Utterly disappointing. That aside, I used to love pizza one. I ordered again not too long ago but the quality of the food itself has seriously gone down. We ended up throwing out the sandwich. From someone who used to order frequently from here, please go get your subs or pizza elsewhere. Not worth it even with the convenient location. added photo bc owner deleted the comment. embarrassing. read more

Pizza One - since owner deleted it lmfao. what on earth is this customer service? yikes - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

Ordered take out from Pizza One in Haskell last night and once again their salads and wraps were excellent! Personally I'm not a fan of their pie, but the Ava's Favorite whole wheat wrap is on point! Loaded with good portions that keep you returning. The Miami Beach salad with grilled chicken never disappoints as well! Together bill was $22 Keep doing what you do Pizza One. read more

This has been my go to Italian delivery place since I moved to the area in 2009. I have even used them to cater parties at the house. I never really had a problem, food was always good. The pizza is good and probably one of the better delivery pizzas. Recently the food has taken a drastic change for the worse. Besides the dinner menu getting cut in half, the quality is down. No more Marsala, they never served a piccata, now only francaise and parmigiana. That used to be served better. What happen to the veal? Did it run off the menu? If it did, the chicken should be great and it's not lol. The grilled chicken for the salads is rubbery and dry. The salads are really good and there are plenty of choices. They have become a pizza, appetizer and salad place. read more

Pizza One - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

See all

Great little pizza shop. Always stop when I am passing through town. Wife likes specialty slices and they have a great selection. I go for the Sicilian, slices are large. Food is great, people working there always very friendly and accommodating. Stop in for sure. read more

Delicious pizza but the service was not catered to everyone just selected people. We sat down at a table, waited for someone to ask if we needed help and nothing. As per employee, orders had to be placed in the front area. Another group came in and immediately someone's came to get their orders. I love their pizza BUT never again!! read more

Pizza one is one of the best pizzerias around. Food is really good especially their wraps and pastas.

If the calamari was that bad, Durante should have offered a refund. If it was served at a table in his establishment, would he make the same comment? read more

Order a Meatball Parm and they gave me Chicken Parm and when i went to pick up my order there were people returning food that was over or under cooked. So i would probably not be going back anytime soon read more

I like their food. The pizza is good, they'll create whatever you like. The appetizers are good. I went to order online and they changed their "tip" area, it's almost mandatory. You could put 0 in but I'm not doing that. I always tip cash, and more than most, but this change annoys me. I'll look elsewhere... read more

The pizza itself was good but we waited an hour and a half for the delivery. Also the pizza had obviously been sitting for awhile and it was not even warm. Very disappointed. read more

Pizza one is my go to place. I moved to Ringwood and have a hard time finding good food here. I order from pizza one on a regular basis. I love the order online and delivery option. My food always comes really fast and I'm able to customize my food in so many ways. I get salads a lot which are delicious. The small is big enough for a meal for me. Pizza honestly isn't great I would go elsewhere for that but I would choose pizza one for food anytime. read more

Pizza One - Tropical salad with grilled chicken and mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

I was visiting from California doing some business and helping a dear friend of mine move. I stumbled on this place but after the first slice of pizza I knew I found a gem! Later on that evening I took out the veal francese with a salad it was absolutely delicious! Can't get enough of this place...tonight I took out the muscles marinara they were fantastic and I got a dozen of them love this place authentic Italian food great service good price! read more

Pizza One - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

The service at Pizza One is undeniably what keeps me coming back over and over again. The variety and quality of their food is what keeps my family and friends happy whenever we are really hungry and need to eat. Their eggplant parm and penne with vodka sauce are incomparable, their burgers are ample (I like the rodeo burger), they carry an exciting variety of salads, their sandwiches are always fresh and overstuffed, their pizzas are never short on toppings, their sauce is fabulous. And, the fried pickles are great! The chefs, servers and drivers at Pizza One are a well-oiled machine, and their system for keeping track of your preferences just works. I am extremely thankful that these hard working folks have made a home in my neighborhood and that they care so much about keeping their customers happy in every possible way. read more

Spent $17 on Cavatelli and broccoli and couldn't eat it. It was cold, no flavor, and the pasta wasn't cooked.

I've been away from Pizza One for a while, and started coming back last year. The pizzas are great and the lasagne, eggplant rollatine, chicken francaise and parmigiana, and shrimp parm dishes are really good, some better than Italian restaurants in the area. My only complaint is that when I order a large pie, one-half sausage, pepper & red onion and the other half black olives, they sometimes mix them together. This depends on whose making pizzas on a certain night. My wife can't eat the onions, and orders the black olives, while I eat the sausages, onions & peppers. So, Dante, tell your guys to watch for half and half pies. Thanks! read more

Problem is what is there to not like I spoke to the owner told him how much I loved everything and asked him to make a special pie for me a slice of every pie they make in one pie but that's never gonna happen I can wish though lol ....... Can't wait to come back in read more

Any place that serves Fat Sandwiches is a good place in my book! We ordered food from here the other night while visiting friends in West Milford and it was great. They have your average pizzeria food (Pizza, Hot & Cold Sandwiches, Pasta,ect..) what I really enjoyed seeing was that they offered fat sandwiches which can be hard to find in some areas. I ordered a cheese steak with just onions and cheese, my friend ordered chicken fingers with fries, a personal pizza, and my boyfriend ordered a fat bastard. The food showed up about 20 mins after we placed the order and the food arrived hot and fresh. My cheese steak was pretty good, not the best not the worst I've ever had I would order it again. My friends really seemed to enjoy their food as well. The highlight of my evening was getting to watch my boyfriend demolish his Fat Bastard (cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, chicken cutlet with fries and mayo). I will definitely be back to try out some more of what pizza one has to offer! read more

See all

Just so happened to drive-by and was looking for a place to eat. This place happened to be on the map and according to google the seemed like a great place to eat in the middle of no where'sville. Atmosphere: The place was located on the side of the road with a parking lot. They apparently have more than 1 location. The place was clean which is definitely a plus. The seating area was a darker tone which made the place a little more romantic, but bringing a date to eat pizza doesn't scream romantic. Service: The place has a hostess during certain hours, but we sat ourselves because we were there during a time without a hostess. We ordered the pizza at the counter and the front counter brought us the food when it was done. He also made sure we had everything we needed. Food: Food was eh, I've had better pizza in New York, but now we're just comparing Apples to Oranges. They had plenty of flavors to try, but at $4 a slice is pretty steep for pizza. All in all it was a good place to stop by and 4 stars for great service. read more

Pizza One is a solid pizza option with a ton of different choices to choose from. Their pizza's are always freshly made and with the same consistency each time. They are always pumping out the pizza's and will keep the specialty slices available for walk in's. I highly recommend the chicken parm, vodka sauce pie. The cool wrap ranch is also really good. read more

Pizza One - Chicken parm vodka sauce pie - Pizza Near Me - Haskell, New Jersey

Everything here is good! The specialty pies are out of this world and the sandwiches (especially the 5th ave) are spectacular! They're always really busy, That being my main reason for 4 stars, since they are busy I feel like things like dressings, or dipping sauces, extra bread etc, have been forgotten a few times. Other that. That the food has always been prepared correctly and tasted great. read more