Nicky Gs is under new ownership and it's gone downhill. Something simple like a slice of pizza was not good. It was definitely old. Plus the older guy (new owner?) wasn't wearing gloves and was using a dirty rag to clean the counters and then picking up pizza with his hands . I ordered a sandwich for my son and a slice for myself. My son loved Nicky's egg, cheese and potato sandwich. He said it tasted bad and just had 2 bites before throwing it out. read more

BAD REVIEWS ARE ABSOLUTELY UNSUBSTANTIATED!!!! Going here since 2019 religiously, never had a bad experience and owner always takes responsibility and handles any issues to the fullest! read more

Nicky G's - beautiful scenery and nice bathroom if needed - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Mid sized pizza spot with plenty of seating, went in for a quick slice but they only had plain slices left. Appears their pies are made when ordered. The have in house sodas which was crisp and cold! Pizza was ok, I like the crispy edges of the crust but it lacked flavor. Service was ok. There are beautiful pictures of Sicily and Italy on the walls making for a gorgeous backdrop. read more

See all

The pizza crust is very good. They are very light on the sauce and cheese or any other topping you ask for.

Nicky G's Pizza is one of my regular spots for solid, tasty pizza. The pies are always good--crispy crust, generous toppings, and a nice balance of sauce and cheese. But honestly, this review isn't just about the pizza. Last night, I went in to pick up my order. The guy who's always there (I'm guessing he's the owner) rang me up. I handed him what I thought were two $20 bills and asked for $15 back, leaving what I figured was a fair tip. Instead of just handing me my change, he slapped the bills on the counter and said, "This is what you handed me." To my surprise, I'd mistakenly given him a $20 and a $50. I had no idea. He could've easily just given me $15 back as I'd asked and kept the extra cash--a hefty tip I would've been none the wiser about. But he didn't. He was honest and made sure I got the right change. That's a huge amount of decency and integrity. If that's not the kind of local business worth supporting, I don't know what is. Huge respect for that guy--and yes, the pizza's great, too. read more

My favorite pizza in town! We always get the Grandma's Pie and a large cheese pizza, with a side of the garlic knots. The Grandma's Pie is perfection - the right amount of cheese, sauce and crunch. You can order online but I recommend calling it in & there is a cash discount. read more

Nicky G's - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Love their grandma'a pie! Best around! Taste so fresh and different from anywhere else I've had. We've been getting it from here for years! But you can only order a pie not slice for grandma pizza. We also got the calamari. The breading is flavorful and soft not chewy. It's a small pizzeria with not too many seats. Go to order to go. But if you do eat here head over to the Ice Cream station for dessert afterwards. Enjoy &! Then you go over to the Ice Cream Station. read more

See all

Delicious, definitely recommend . Good crispy crust, great sauce. Definitely one of the best pizzas in the area read more

Nicky G's - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Order a sicilian pie. This is what i received. Then they wanted to pick up this pie and remake it. Be more attentive when you take An order read more

Nicky G's - Not even close to sicilian pie. Guy told me they will pick up the pie. Not worth it. Be more attentive when you order. - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

First time ordering. Portions were great. Sauce also very good. I ordered eggplant parm entree with a side of spaghetti and a meatball sandwich. I wish they used the plastic containers rather than the metal with the plastic lid that you crimp closed. The eggplant is good but needs a bit more sauce because it's a little dry. A little more cheese on top would be nice too, but I'd order it again. (Eggplant is my go-to entree and I order from all restaurants that serve it). The meatball sandwich was also quite good but could have benefited from some more sauce too. The pasta could be a little more al dente. Mine was a bit overbooked. Just these small adjustments and then I'd say this would be one of the better pizzerias in the area. read more

Called to order a pizza at noon time, owner said it would be 30mins, decided to go to the store after 15mins and was met with a worker that had no idea why I was there. The only worker there didn't know how to make pizza and said he was waiting for the owner to come and make it. Since the pizza wasn't being made and 20 mins had elapsed I decided to skip on this place and cancel my order. Unprofessional. read more

Great pie, sauce rocks. Most times I goto get a pie they're closed though. Lots of places close early I guess.

Awesome pizza joint. Passed through on a long drive and ended up eating half a New York style pizza.

Neat little pizza place that has some decent pizza. Some styles better than others. Amazing Zeppoli!! Not sure I spelled that right . It usually takes them a while to make stuff. read more

I've made it a point to try out most of the pizza spots in the area. I can genuinely say Nicky Gs has the best pizza I've tried in NJ and NY. This place is special. I can't find pizza like this in Florida and pretty soon "you can't find pizza like this anywhere" Thank you Nicky Gs. read more

Nicky G's - Classic cheese slices. - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

First, we are in the food industry & normally would hate to leave a review but we finally ordered from Nicky G's last Friday night 11/4 & we so wanted to be a fan. My hubby is definitely a pizza connoisseur and we heard from someone the Grandma Pie was supposed to be decent, we definitely should have stuck with our go too. We normally have our staples: Anyhony Franco's & Neil's for Grandma & Donnas for Sicilian. It s hard to explain: cheap cheese, a drizzle of what might have been Pesto ( why) and brunt crust ( THE WHOLE BOTTOM OF THE PIE). Normally we have a slice or 2 each and always freeze the rest, this went right in the garbage. And the cold Antipasto, overall everything was just way off I hope they were just having a bad night, just wish it wasn't on our $$. FYI: my husband is insisting when we first moved here in 2018 he grabbed a slice and it was awesome..... read more

I love Nicky G's. They have amazing zeppoles and the pizza is fantastic. The workers are very kind and it's great service. Highly recommend.

Amazing!! The stuffed shells are the best I've ever had! The pizza is also fantastic! They deliver and it's also BYOB!! Love it! read more

Nicky G's - Soda - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Amazing pizza place along Colfax Ave in Wayne New Jersey. Came here to get pizzas for the boys playing in the nearby (not so near) Battle Creek paintball place! The whole cheese pizza is $12.50 then if you put one topping its gonna be additional $2 (i guess) I ordered a whole cheese pizza and a whole pepperoni pizza! But try their pizza! It is really delicious, the thickness of the crust is perfect! The breadcrumbs they used are of superb quality, it has crispness of the crust and chewiness inside, the sauce and toppings are in good proportion to the crust! The place is small, simple, no fuss pizza parlor, the crew are really nice! Will come and try this pizza again soon! read more

The food is okay, but more than once I've had my credit card hacked after buying from this place. Pay cash only.

I am really picky with my pizza, but I've recently started living in Pompton Lakes and do not know where to find good pizza. So I decided to try Pat's since they are down the road from me. I just got a large extra cheese for delivery. It was delivered within 30mins and was still piping hot. Once I let it cool(dont want all the cheese to come off the slice) I finally tried it and OMG I think O found my new favorite pizza. The pie was cooked perfectly, cheese tasted amazing, dough not to chewy or hard, and even amount of sauce to cheese ratio. The sauce wasn't too sweet or tangy so overall a perfect pie and all it costed was $16.53. So anyone around the area should at least give this place a shot because you will not regret it! read more

Nicky G's - Eating a cold slice hours after almost eating a whole large to myself - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Nicky G's Grandma Pie is out of this world. Everything about this pizza screams with deliciousness. Other menu item favorites are his antipasto salad with the homemade pesto dressing and of course his garlic knots and pinwheels. Nicky does pizza right and has me coming back over and over again. read more

Nicky G's - Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

This is the best pizza in the area. Both the regular pie and the Grandma pie are not only good, they are great. The sandwich and dinner options are also great. Large, tasty portions at reasonable prices, even lower than you might expect. We order from Nicky G's once or twice a week and everything is excellent. read more

ordered from Nicky G's tonight for dinner. one Italian sub sandwich, meat lovers Stromboli, hot chicken cutlet sandwich, and French fries with cheese. all was delicious. sandwiches are big enough to have some for leftovers. read more

See all

Nicky G's pizza is similar to Pats but more semolina crust. Great pie with no flop, heavy on the semolina crust all around. Cheese has good texture, sauce not overly sweet, and semolina crust gives it that extra crunch. Grease is non existential this pie! Only negative I'll give is I prefer a crispier crust and less dough! read more

Just received my food and I don't normally review on yelp but I felt the need to do so. This was my first time ordering from here and based on other reviews I decided to give it a try since it's right around the corner from my house. I ordered the fusilli alla vodka, which came with pasta which is no where near the shape of fusilli pasta that I've ever seen and the vodka sauce is flavorless, almost as if it came out of a jar. For $15 I was expecting a lot more. read more

Nicky G's - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

The pizza and calzone are the best at Pats. Haven't had much else there so I can't comment on that. Have had the mussels and sorry to say they are average at best. Sauce is way to oily and mussels are small. Prices are fair and service is always good. Enjoy read more

Nicky G's - Grandmas pie. The best - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Don't order, they use a 3 rd party delivery service and food took over 2 hours. If you want hot food forget it, order somewhere else. Pizza was burnt and cold, quite a combo. Ordered sausage, no bread was included with any meals. Sandwiches were made poorly. First and last time I will order from here read more

Best pizza crust around. High quality ingredients makes a big difference! The garlic knots are amazing too!

Great place to have dinner, the service from the owner is really friendly and nice. Food is always fresh made to order, any special requests are honered. The atmosphere is welcoming and always a smile as you walk in. Keep up the good work. Thanks read more

Being we've never been in the area, I came here because of yelp reviews. We ordered 2 sandwiches; 1. Egg with cheese and potatoes. So delicious! So tasty! The combination with the fresh roll ...yum! 2. Tuna with lettuce and tomato. Again, delicious and tasty. We will definitely return next time we are in the area. My only disappointment was that the order went through Grubhub. I would rather go directly through the restaurant/food establishment. read more

WHAT? You haven't eaten at Pat's. This little neighborhood pizzaria has THE best vegetable pizza you will ever taste. I discovered this place the day I mentioned to another local resident that I was going to go buy a pie at the local big pizza place in the shopping center. He told me to go to Pat's and get the "Veggie Special" and if I didn't like it HE would reimburse me for the money I spent. I have been going to Pat's ever since that day. Try the Grandma's Pie which is my other favorite. The crust on all the pizzas is always just right, never burned, never soaking wet. Even the plain pizza is great - with great flavor and not too much sauce or too much cheese. I've eaten the calamari marinara over pasta which can be made spicy. It is the best! read more

Very delicious pizza. I would highly recommend the Veggie Pizza and Grandma Pizza. If you enjoy just a plain cheese pie you won't be disappointed, it has a nice crunchy crust and good all around read more

As far as I'm concerned Nicky G's has the best pizza in the local area, The crust itself is the tastiest and the sauce and toppings are just perfect. All around Best Pizza for miles. read more

Went the other night for first time. The mussels were very tender sauce had nice spice but not crazy hot. Had sausage parmigiana. The dish was very good. The cook was involved in the customers request. Remember this is a small pizzeria not a formal sit down place but has some tables. It is popular with the HS kids who go out for lunch. read more

The food is great and definitely has a small town pizzaria vibe with it. Th prices may be a dollar or more than a normal pizza place but would you want a Toyota or a Ferrari? The pizza is bomb, the chicken marcella was delicious as that was what my brother ordered and for desert we got the Nutella zeppole and that are mouth watering. I grabbed a menu and I am going to go down the menu and check off thing so I can get the full experience of this place. Little set back is the seating with five tables but the food is well worth it! Next up for me will be the sandwiches, I already had a half of an Italian sub and man that bread is good. They pay attention too so much detail on the food, you really can't go wrong for what you want! read more

Great little pizza place, great price, and a super nice owner. The owner made me a slice of veggie pizza and loaded it up with vegetables! The crust was really good too. read more

best white pizza!!! we are 1st time customers. pizza was not greasy... just perfect will definitely order from again

The grandma pizza is the best. Better than any place I've had it. Pat is always in the kitchen and while it's on the small side the food is always great. Lots of good pizza places in the area but pats does a fine job and it's always consistent. read more

This used to be Pats, but the Grandma's pie is still on the menu and is just as good. We're big fans!