Such an awesomely decorated dining space. So many pizza options - I highly recommend the MVP (marinara, pesto, vodka sauce). Lots of different dinner, sandwich options. They have paninis and fat sandwiches. Food was good, staff were nice. Highly recommend checking them out. read more

See all

Heard many things about this place and it's in a really good location (next to Homegoods, Stop&Shop). I ended up getting a small marg pie with half pepperoni and it was okay. Not mind blowing but a great lunch pie. May try a different variety next time. read more

AJ's Pizza Butler - Box - Pizza Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

See all

Had the large cheese pizza with twelve wings deal. Pizza was delicious , tasted fresh. Wings were decent and well cooked. Service was quick ! I cannot comment on ambiance as this was delivered read more

AJ's Pizza Butler - Mild Wings - Pizza Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

See all

After 2 years I decided to try this place out again. Yet again they failed. Their baked Ziti was absolutely disgusting. No flavor at all. Stay far away from this place. Should have trusted my gut but wanted to give them another try. Would have been happier with a McDonald's cheeseburger!!!! read more

AJ's is one of the best around. Quality food, good prices, friendly staff, short waits, it's just all so good. We moved here after a decade in Brooklyn and good pizza means a lot to us, AJ's is top shelf. read more

Zuppa di Clams. A weakness of our family, along with mussels and shellfish of all kinds. AJ's Zuppa is up there with the very best of them. Everything fresh, seasoned perfectly and well executed. read more

See all

The best pizza and antipasto in Bloomingdale! We love it here. I love the salad pizza and eggplant dish.

Alyson is the best server! She gave me the best food recommendations and brought our food out quickly. Would 100% come back again!

Ok call me crazy. I felt like macaroni & cheese did a search & macaroni & cheese pizza came up. I was like no way. I said have to order it. It was delivered hot and fresh from Grubhub which I was very surprised was still hot. Nice & creamy macaroni & cheese pizza. To die. For. Was awesome. After 2nd slice I was done had to share with coworkers. Will definitely try again. They also have a huge menu of other appetizing foods. read more

See all

AJ's Burgers remains a gem of a casual restaurant, a staple in downtown New Rochelle, located just across the street from City Hall (which affords convenient parking). Excellent burgers, pizza, ribs, traditional Italian specialties, daily specials, desserts and more. read more

Had a grilled chicken wrap and a salad -- both were excellent. The chips were fresh and crispy just the way I like them.

We stopped in to grab a late bite. Sat down in the dining room and had to ask for help, menus. Girl came over took our order, didn't write anything down and of course messed up my order. We went there because we had an older gift card that they did not honor. They said they changed owners and the card was no good. The food was good but I will never go back! They seemed more concerned with closing than paying attention to their only customers. Totally disappointing read more

Virtually no sauce on the pizza, which most people I believe would agree is the most important ingredient other than the dough/crust. Not sure this is the right description but it tasted "dry." I'm on business travel and getting recommendations from the locals and this one was not a winner. Disappointed... read more

I heard they had new owners at AJ's so I thought I'd give them a try; even though many people told me they went downhill since they had the new owner. So I walked in and ordered a Ham and cheese Calzone to go. The girl behind the counter, maybe a college student. Said a cheese calzone? I said no!!!! a HAM and cheese calzone!!!. she walked away further into the kitchen near the ovens , She repeated again a cheese calzone? Again I said no!!! A Ham and cheese calzone!!!She said again, a cheese calzone? I said NO a HAM and CHEESE Calzone!!! I got the Calzone and left. When I got home I cut it in half and it was a CHEESE Calzone. I will NEVER EVER go there Again!!!! NO means NO!!!! read more

Has been my go to place for years. Last year or two has been so inconsistent, not sure what changed, maybe just got too popular. Food almost always arrives cold now and they never deliver when they say. Had many issues with orders over the years but it's a pizza place, have to expect that. Spoke to owner on recent issue and he is an absolute jerk, sure don't have to put up with that. Hundreds of orders, thousands of dollars, lunches, dinners, catering and one bad interaction with a owner who doesn't care is all you need to lose a customer. The food really is just ok, order meals usually once a week and pizza in Friday's and been going downhill for awhile. Lots of pizza places in the area, you aren't that special, arrivederci AJ read more

I've never seen a place disintegrate like AJ's has, even worse they've alienated their customer base and it seems like the new ownership doesn't care, so sad. They've done everything you are not supposed to do when taking over an existing successful business, I wish you guys the best of luck. read more

Delicious food ! Not just pizza , yummy soups and sandwiches! Fresh salads and fantastic burgers as well !! You can't go wrong with your choices on this menu ! read more

We've been going to AJ's for many years. A few months ago, we noticed a change in the quality of their food. This was hands down my husband's favorite chicken parm. We stopped ordering from them, and have learned, as suspected, they were sold. The owners are cheaping out, and not using the same quality ingredients from their suppliers. Hopefully we get a good pizzeria in the area again. read more

Don't order from them. Totally hit the skids. We used to order at least $35 of food every weekend, so at least 4X a month. We just gave them a second chance and ordered a pizza. It made us ill. We only ate one slice each. The toppings and extra cheese were added later, and you could clearly see it, as the new cheese was puddled in the middle. It was awful. I should have called the health department. We threw the rest out. The zucchini sticks were a cheap greasy different brand, that smelled like they were coated with sugar. This new owner deserves to go out of business. read more

Placed a delivery order, it was late and incorrect. Gave them a second chance and called a week later, order was also delivered incorrectly. Ingredients seem to be a lower quality than in the past. The plain pizza was so bad we threw it out! It is frustrating when one of your favorite places is sold and the new owners try to lower costs at the expense of quality. They won't get a third strike, I'm calling Ferrati's! read more

****Update**** July 9th 2020 They have been messing up my order more and more. Had to call about 5 times already since last review because of missing food. They also recently gave me sour cream instead of blue cheese for a salad !!!! Probably won't order from here again until they get themselves together. read more

Solid Italian food. Our family of four have ordered here at least three times in the past week. The food is great! Portions are plentiful. I could easily make three meals out of one dinner portion. The eggplant rollatini is delicious! The wings are great too. They are always busy so use the app to order. Coupons are offered also so use them! read more

If I could leave more stars, I would. These guys are amazing. Their pizza honestly outclasses anything North Jersey. They've got solid service and their sides are just as good as their pies. 10/10 recommend. read more

Service sucks. Did not deliver and I had disappointed guests. Poor follow up and now customer service read more

Growing up in Butler, this was the family pizza place. I have always enjoyed their pizza, their sandwiches are huge (like three meals) and their small salads actually are filled with chicken unlike some places that charge big bucks for 90% lettuce. Visiting my mom's last week we ordered delivery (tip use THEIR website, it's easier to customize your meal and there are coupons and no crazy surcharges that DoorDash and Grubhub hit you with). Order came 20 minutes early, the driver was super friendly, food blazing hot butttt they messed up my buffalo chicken salad (I asked for grilled chicken...but there was no buffalo sauce but no big deal, it was still a delicious salad and they left off the onions thank god, so it's forgivable!). Happy to see this place still is turning out good food and reasonable prices! read more

We are on a mission to find the best Margarita, Grandma, & Grandpa Pizza in North Jersey! We gave AJ's Pizza, Butler, NJ a try. We ordered the Margarita pie, pepperoni pie, and a Grandma. Up first the Margarita pie: the dough was okay - a little dry/overcooked. The fresh mozzarella was placed on the pie perfectly, revealing the sauce. The sauce was very similar to the sauce used on the traditional pie. The basil did not have too much taste mostly due to it being baked onto the pie. Overall this was not a bad margarita pie especially for the price. What we really enjoyed with AJ's is their online ordering, prices, and coupons that can be added directly to the online cart! SO far this has been the easiest and best ordering experience for us. A job well done, AJ 's on this! The Grandma. No difference with the Margarita. Basically, they took the margarita and threw it on a square pizza. The dough was the same as the Margarita. We were missing the fresh garlic and sweeter sauce for this. Note: AJ's did not have a Grandpa (or upside down sicilian) on the menu so we couldn't give that a try. Instead we ordered a small pepperoni. The dough was fresher than the other two pies, cheese cooked perfectly, and not too greasy. This was definitely the best of the three. Onto the next pizzeria, we are trying one every Friday night. What else is there to do during this pandemic? Any suggestions on what pizzeria we should try next... let us know!!! read more

Excellent catering at excellent prices. Always delivery in a nice neat easy to serve container. When ever I have company I order a few half trays from them and it is always delish! Look for the 20% coupon on their website to save a few clams read more

See all

Worst pizza in the area, not sure why but i do not get my pies from here anymore. It went from ok too not so good. They have really good sandwiches. The pastas i have order is a hit or miss when it hits you are like there we go! But man when you get the miss! It takes me months to order again. read more

I got two regular cheese pizza's last night, as soon as I opened the box I realized something was odd, I then read here the place changed ownership. The crust was horrible, tasted like someone didn't know how to make dough. The cheese so so salty it was overbearing. now that I know its under new ownership Im done with this place. Lakeside Pizza in Kinnelon is much better. read more

Ordered here for the first time today for my business of work and holy shit this is the new spot food was so good and they even included serving utensils for the trays of pastas. read more

I don't know if this place fell off or they're just giving up but it's not what it used to be.. I just ordered a buffalo chicken sub with lettuce, tomato, blue cheese and hot sauce and all I received was chicken cutlet on a roll with blue cheese. Really disappointing; the last time I order from there for sure. read more

AJ's Pizza Butler - Pizza Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

We use to go to AJs Pizza at least 3 or 4 times a month and it was great! But since they changed hands it has gone down hill. The food is not that good anymore and the last time we got food from there not only was it not good it arrived 30 minutes after they'd said it would and it was all cold! Never again! read more

The place used to be awesome with the previous owner, with the best hospitality, laughs, jokes you felt like you were at home .. Once the place sold under new ownership, food quality has downgrade it. It does not taste the way it used to taste. Went to order a sandwich and a Gyro on January 14 at 2:45 PM. I took a picture, the baldheaded guy in front I believe he's the owner or manager told me I have no right to take any pictures and told me to get the f*ck out and to go f*ck myself. I've never ever been treated the way I've been treated there. The hospitality is the worst hospitality I've ever gotten from any ownership or management.. I would never ever recommend this place !!!! read more

I can't say enough good things about the food and service from AJs. It's been my go to for pizza for several years and it is always delicious. They are one of the few pizza places that has things like grilled chicken parm and whole wheat or gluten free pasta on their menu--no awkwardly asking if they have it. The different pizzas they have are amazing. Some of my favorites is the eggplant rollatini and the cheeseburger and the bruschetta pies. Best part about the pizza- if you can't decide get a few personal or small ones!! There can sometimes be quite a wait for delivery (about an hour at peak times) but when the food gets here it is hot and fresh not lukewarm needing to be reheated like a lot of places- so it definitely makes it worth the wait. Their app makes ordering effortless and there is generally a coupon for almost everything in the app you can apply. We've never been disappointed. read more

I really don't ever leave negative reviews but after the last 4-5 deliveries consistently sucking I figured why not. You give the options for "crispy" and "well done" and time and time again I get a half cooked pizza with raw toppings. I get you guys get busy and have to get orders out but cmon... this place has gone very downhill. I won't be ordering from here anymore read more

The guy behind the counter he was so nasty I don't recommend that pizzeria with that kind of people

This was my go to for pizza and pasta. There vodka sauce doesn't have prosciutto which is a plus. There Zito was thick and hearty. There plain pie reminds me of my days in the bronx. Really fast delivery despite covid. They had numerous delivery cars which kept of with the demand. read more

I usually pickup pizza. Once in a while I have it delivered when I am to busy to pickup, and always tip good. Tonight I ordered online. Pizza arrived early, so I opened the door, took the pizza, and was going to go put in down so I don't drop it, as I have done before. As I took the pizza from the driver, he says "thanks for the tip". I didn't even get a chance to turn around and put it down, and take the tip that I had on the stairs, and give it to him, and I get a sarcastic "thanks for the tip"???? I turned around and instantly decided he now gets $0, and thought to myself, "LEARN MANNERS AND MAYBE YOU WILL GET A TIP" This driver OBVIOUSLY has zero patience and ZERO UNDERSTANDING OF "CUSTOMER SERVICE" and will never get a chance to bring delivery here from AJ's again, because I will never order from AJ's again, strictly because of this driver. There are at least 5 other pizza places in the area, where I will order from. WHY ADVERTISE FREE DELIVERY, AND SOMEONE HAS THE INTENT TO GIVE A TIP, AND CAN'T EVEN PUT THE PIZZA DOWN, AND GETS A SARCASTIC REMARK?????? read more

This was my first visit to AJ's Pizza in Butler. It was a Wednesday at 2:45pm. After I located the menu, I ordered the large eggplant parm sandwich. I enjoyed my meal while watching and listening to ESPN on the televisions. It was a great super hot lunch and as expected, I needed half of it to be wrapped to go. There were thirteen types of slices available, many more than the Route 23 location which I assume is set up more as an express style. I appreciated the super friendly staff as well. read more

Deceivingly great food! The vodka sauce is the best I've ever had! The place is typical for a pizza joint inside, but the food is much better than that! LOVE their fat sandwiches, even though I shouldn't eat them. read more