This was my first time visiting this location. It's a lot bigger than the other location. I'm used to. It was clean and well kept. The staff were all very friendly and helpful. The food was delicious! I will definitely be back. read more

See all

It's good for the price and what you're getting! They do coupons too if that helps, but having the pasta, salad, and pizza options is so great for big parties and/or groups with kids. The variety is awesome and the service was great! Our kids were in awe at the 6 options of dessert pizzas alone. The pasta was better than I remember. There are pros and cons to going on off times. Yeah you miss the rush, but I feel like the pizzas dry out more since they're not being rotated as quickly. I'd probably go when it gets a little busier to be honest. Try it out if you haven't already! read more

Excellent service all around. Got to meet the "Knot" manager as well as his right hand man...the "Other" Manager. Great atmosphere from start to finish. The food was very good (salads and pizzas were fresh) but didn't leave enough room for the dessert pizzas! Next time. The one thing is that they are Team Pepsi, but they did have my Diet Dr. Pepper so all is well. Overall, very happy with our service and with the food. Will be recommending to my Utah Valley peeps!! read more

Way better than Cici's. Top pizza buffet. Meet the characters requirements, Meet the characters requirements, Meet the characters requirements read more

Everything in a vacuum - I feel like the best you can do at a buffet is ensure that the food is rotated often and that it stays hot. Pizza Pie Cafe nailed that. There was the standard fare of pizzas, but also a few interesting ones. I enjoyed the experience and would eat here again. read more

We were invited to have lunch here with a big group. The price for a large family is right, especially since it's a buffet. The restaurant seemed clean and bathrooms were decent. The service was ok, not overly friendly, but not rude. The pizza was as expected, very similar to Peter pepper pizza and the salad bar wasn't bad. Overall, for the price and the large group that we had, it was a great family friendly restaurant. read more

See all

I live out of town, but I was make sure this place is on my list of places to eat while in Utah. All you can eat pizza and pasta, 2 of my favorite dishes! They have great variety of pizza choices, and pasta sauces. The service is always great and it's very family friendly, and affordable! read more

Food was great and the price was perfect. Definitely not overpriced and so nice it's all you can eat! The Oreo dessert pizza was fantastic. I would definitely go back. Frequently had people coming to grab our spare plates as well. read more

Great food, gear value and very clean. Perfect for families. By far is less than eating out at a fast food joint.

We've been eating here as a family once a week for over a year now because of the gluten free options, great pricing and our 3 year old loves it. It's made being gluten free easy for a toddler. Tonight we came on our weekly visit and were met with a completely new set of prices and huge attitude. What was mind blowing was that the women giving attitude announced herself as the "new owner" We turned around and walked out. Good luck on your new business venture treating your "regular" customers who bring you consistent business each week this way. Super unfortunate to be treated so poorly. read more

Food tastes great, the service was amazing. Loved the owner. And bathrooms were very clean.

Great service, nice and clean eating environment. Pizza was coming out quick and tastes great. The line got long for Oreo pizza and they started churning them out quick! 5 stars! read more

Food: Food Safety note first, I did notice them stirring and checking the temperature on the pasta sauces, thumbs up there. However, at 7 pm at night, the buffet was pretty picked over. Most of the Pizza was picked over and doesn't hold its heat very well. Signs on the wall say "Real American Pizza." Don't let a New Yorker or Chicagoan see that! I would have liked to try other pasta sauces on the bar, however their most popular Alfredo was empty, and I was told it was still cooking. 30 min later still no Alfredo. This wouldn't have been a problem if the staff was watching the levels on their bar. Service: Absent, except for the occasional busser walking by clearing plates. Other than that, no member of staff even bothered to say hello or ask me how I was, or my food was. Ambiance: This place is for kids, teenagers and weary parents that don't want to make dinner. If you are looking for a reason to go back it's probably because you have a large group of people that you enjoy their company. It's probably not for the food. Summary: This will be a miss for me going forward, I found the pizza to be bland. The pasta wasn't drained well after coming out of the boiler so it watered down the sauces. The salad bar was sufficient, but given the fact that it was the only thing fully stocked I'm guessing most of clientele aren't there for the salad. Shame, because that was the high point of Pizza Pie Cafe. read more

The food is good, but nothing special. They only have teenagers working and never any adults, not even for the managers. They are past slow at the register and it takes for every to ring people up. The last three trips the salad bar is empty and it takes for ever to get pizza out. And to top it off, the parking is a complete joke. The gym over runs everything, the landlord needs to take care of this, fix the parking problem, threw more than one store in your parking lot. read more

The service was really good. The pizza was okay at best. The pasta was pretty bad. Definitely not a place I would seek out again.

The workers were so mean! My pizza was raw. AND it's was friends birthday and we asked for a birthday treat and when they delivered it they did it in disgust!!! IT WAS HORRIBLE !!!!! read more

THIS PLACE IS MY FAVE! They have a great deal on the starving student card, are so cheap, have so many good flavors, and the best vibes. They're not the most classy, but honestly, that's why I love it here. Yours truly read more

Made a carry out order received the confirmation text it was ready for pick up. Walked in and was told 10 more minutes , took another 40 min to get my pizza. Costumer service was terrible. Will not be coming back here. read more

The pizza here is really good. My favorite is the Hillbilly pizza. Really good service. The place was kind of crowded, but it wasn't really bad. I've read other reviews that said there's hardly any food available here, but I didn't have that problem. My family and I love it here. read more

I'm not one who gets food poisoning often. I think I have had it once in my life before. I'm not joking or exaggerating when I say I literally threw up everything I ate in the parking lot afterward on the way to my car. We first got to the restaurant and all of the tables were dirty so we had to wait for one to be bussed. Like lots of empty dirty tables. All of the pizza looked like it had been sitting out for a good while (sweaty cheese) and the salad bar was not chilled. In fact I think their dressing had been sitting out all day and this is what made me hurl. None of the buffet counters looked like they had been wiped down for a good while as well. Both their soda machines were out of ice and the soda was flat. I was pretty disappointed because I have been to this chain before and enjoyed it but I will never be going back after this. All of the staff I saw were teenagers which might've had something to do with the way the establishment was being run but like, damn. Good thing it only cost $9 I guess... read more

The service here sucked and they took over half an hour to bring out a single birthday monster. We had to ask three times before they brought it out. Turns out they hadn't put it in and brought out others birthday monsters. We had a sign and everything. This ruined my brothers birthday. read more

So me and my boyfriend came to pizza pie last night for dinner around 7:00, and were extremely disappointed. This is our favorite place to eat but i don't think we'll be coming here anymore. The entire pizza buffet was empty except for the specialty pizzas. 0 desert pizza, 0 garlic knots, cheese sticks, cheese pizza or pepperoni pizza. And the staff didn't even seem in a rush to get anything out. Next, the pasta bar was completely out of most of the sauces. No Alfredo, no marinara. And it was a huge mess. The salad bar was also a huge mess, half empty, and what was there was half frozen and inedible. We ended up just leaving because there was literally nothing to eat. All the food we usually get there was gone. Very disappointed, will be going to the Provo location from now on. read more

See all

I love this place. it has an awesome variety of pizza. the pasta is awesome, I recommend the carbonara sauce. the service is awesome. while sometimes it can be a bit slow when it's busy it always follows through. read more

Lots of pizza & lots of kids. Great for large families. Pizza isn't that bad and salad is pretty good. Real issue is the waves of people that are there when you are. Food cones in waves and there are times when it's slim Pickens. They have pasta that I was told was good. Gluten free pizza is available but you wait for it! It's a family place and caters to big eaters. $ 7.95 for lunch and all you can eat. Works for some. read more

Came here during opening week to check out this new Pizza Pie Cafe location. I rarely go to pizza buffets, but if were to go more often it'd definitely be this place. The service was tops, everyone was very friendly and making sure we had an enjoyable experience. They had a great selection of pizza's sure to appease most palettes as well as a great selection of dessert pizzas. The salad bar was decent as well and there was plenty of space around the buffet areas. The pasta however was my favorite. I only tried one type of pasta (whole wheat penne). The pasta was reheated in boiling water on ordering, and was surprisingly well cooked. I tried each of the sauces available and each were delicious. Apparently they're made fresh every day, so none of that nasty canned stuff. My favorite was the roasted red pepper sauce, but the spicy sausage alfredo and marinara were also delicious. For the price (about $7 for unlimited pizza, pasta, salad & drinks), this place definitely can't be beat. read more

See all

We came in at 2:30 and we had to walk around the entire store to find a table that didn't have dirty dishes all over it. They also only had about five pizzas ready for us. I know that 2:30 is during the slow time, but that doesn't excuse poor service. There was also spilled food everywhere. Not a great environment. We ended up leaving after 20 minutes to go to the Del Taco on he other side of the parking lot. read more

Terrible customer service. Had to wait forever for them to make more pizzas. Workers made pizzas if they got around to it. read more

This was the worst experience we've had at this location. Normally it isn't great, but not bad by any means. We came in for an early dinner, and the place was a mess. The workers looked like they couldn't care less that the pizza display was mostly empty, even though they were starting to get busy. We waited at least 15 minutes before any fresh pizza came out, which was gone almost immediately with how many people were waiting. It went like that the entire time. The salad bar was borderline disgusting. The fact that a preteen boy was ducking under the plastic guard and hovering all over everything to scrape out the last little bit of cottage cheese didn't help. This is probably the last time we come to this location. read more

Tried to find a place to eat all tables where empty but needed to be clean, I had to literally ask for them to. Lean them up. Which took forever so I started doing it myself RIDICULOUS. This used to be my favorite place. Stop hiring lazy people. read more

There's no place better to hate humanity than a buffet. Noisy children? Check. Mass quantities of decidedly average food? Check. Dubious salad bar? Check. Free refill sodas with Pepsi products only? Check. High decibel environment? Do you have to ask?! I give you 2:1 odds of stepping on spilled food on your way to a table. So why go here (or to any buffet for that matter)?Because it's what the kids want, that's why. That's the only reason why. The only other reason is to hate humanity. read more

I had high hopes for this place since where we moved from had Cici's pizza buffets. We went for lunch and the staff could not have been more disinterested. We were not greeted when we came in and then they never asked us if we had been there or how it worked. We understand the concept but it would have been nice to at least have been greeted with a "hello, welcome," or something. Every booth was dirty and I had to ask some dude behind the counter to get some to clean it so we could sit down. I counted 11 people in the back of the house and only ONE person ever came out into the dining room and she was horribly rude. The pizza buffet was missing the pepperoni, a staple, and the cheese was dried out. I tired the terrible barbeque and chicken wing pizzas and then had an acceptable combo. People in line were commenting on the weird combinations and didn't want to try any. How about the regular pizzas guys? Sausage, pepperoni, and Cheese. Try those next time. The salad bar was an absolute mess and when the manager finally asked some to clean and fill it, the girl came out and scooped the mess with her BARE HANDS into the hole beneath the condiment container. Gross. Needless to say, we wont be back. read more

Great price, big selection, and OK pizza. But one of the better pizza buffets out there. If you get the pizza when it comes out fresh, it's pretty darn good. Plus they have salad and pasta as well. Which means...MORE SAUCE FOR DIPPING! I never waste my appetite on salad or pizza crust though. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Orem, Utah

Worst service in the history of service. My 400 pound grandmother and I were waiting in line for pasta and they cleared our table and gave it to someone else. Doesn't make any sense. Make sure that you know people are done with their tables before you clear them. This is the second time this has happened to me. This would never happen at any other buffet style place where people have to go and get their own food and bring it back to their tables. Pizza is just decent. Normal pizza could be compared to chucky cheese or something like that. read more

1 Star for the hair on my fork, the busted soda machine, gross neglected salad bar, the dirty plates and the fact that all the pizzas were gone. Decided it wasn't worth it and asked for a refund and left. I would send my worst enemies a gift card here for Christmas, yeah it's that bad. read more

I've been to this location a number of times. This location is good if you're not in a hurry. The eating area is large. The place is always clean. Parking is decent and it isn't as busy as the provo location. Over the past 6 months the staff has gotten slower. The common issue I've experienced is the pizza choices are constantly empty and the staff appears to be doing there best but just can't quite seem to get it together. I waited at the pasta bar for about 10 minutes before any of the staff decided to help me. 11 out of 15 pizza choices were empty for a period of 20 to 30 min at a time. By the time something new came out most people in the place jumped at the opportunity to eat it. We got here at 820pm on a Saturday evening. I ordered a specialty pizza. By the time it came out they made a half order and it was gone before I could get to it. I mentioned it to the staff and they told me they would cook another and it never happened. As far as I can see there's a lot of movement happening but no direction. Not sure we'll come back to this location for a while and hope in the meantime they can fix some of the issues they've been having. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Empty spaces for the last 20 min. - Pizza Near Me - Orem, Utah

I've been here a bunch of times and I have to say this place keeps me coming back! The service is excellent and the staff is quite helpful. The pizza is always delicious and they have a great variety - which, I guess is to be expected from a pizza buffet! The pastas are also tasty and I highly recommend the pasta carbonara. Although I'm not a salad-eating-when-I'm-at-a-pizza-place kind of guy, I'm glad the option is at least there and adds another variety of dining options (i.e. various salad dressings that become my pizza dipping sauces!). The atmosphere is fun and light-hearted which makes it a great place to take the family. I also think the romantic booths are fun, hilarious, and would be great for a casual/relaxing date night! Above all else, the cafe is quite clean! Go and Enjoy a night out! read more

Our kids love this place...and what's not to love? They've got a variety of pizzas on their buffet (including dessert pizzas), a decent salad bar, Pepsi products, and a pasta bar. Our favorites are the garlic bread twists, Buffalo chicken pizza, and radiatori with a mix of carbonara (bacon!) and roasted red pepper sauces. We also love the cookie monster :) This restaurant is generally less crowded than the one in Provo. read more

This place has a killer buffet. I mean, it's not the type of pizza you stay up dreaming about. But this place is as solid as a lunch location as there is. I would say it single handedly took me from a 34 waist to a 36. Bravo. read more

Have been to Pizza Pie Cafe in Provo and had ok experiences. This time was anything but ok. The were often out of forks, and all the pizzas. They did have a steady supply of plates, but that's all they had going for them. It was a holiday weekend and staffed with teenagers. The adult manager or shift leader should've made sure they were well staffed when they left for the holiday. The kids were polite when we complained about our gluten free pizza taking over an hour to be done. Really bad experience. If my kids want pizza pie cafe again, we will head to the other location. read more

One of our family's favorite places! The dough is a tad on the sweet side, but that makes it work for both the regular pizzas and the dessert pizzas. The salad bar is decent, and I absolutely love the pasta bar. I actually crave their pasta sauces. The noodles are cooked absolutely perfectly as well. They also have gluten free noodles, which are cooked in a separate area from the regular stuff, so I don't have to worry about cross contamination for my 5 year old with celiac disease. She also loves their gluten free pizza which costs $2 more at this location, and is worth it as it lasts her for a few meals. Between that and the salad bar she gets a big meal. Sometimes the pizzas seem to have been sitting for a while, and sometimes there's a fresher one behind it, and they'll happily push the fresher one forward if there are just a few pieces of the older one left. Love their dessert pizzas. A worthwhile family dinner as we all get to eat our fill of food we enjoy for less than $30 for a family of 5. read more