Unpleasantly greasy pasta sauces and marinara actually made me shudder. Most of the pizzas were okay, but a few were total disappointments, which was weird because I'm not hard to please in this category. Enjoyable: pesto, fireman, cheese sticks, oreo pie. Disappointing: buffalo chicken pizza didnt taste anything like buffalo sauce, very plain and slightly sweet, weird. The staff were all super nice and helpful. The place seemed pretty clean. Fun environment with TVs going and 70s/80s rock playing. Vintage 50s decorations abounding were fun to look at. I'll give this place one more chance with the kids since there is so much variety and great potential for a wonderful time. Maybe I just caught them on a bad day and ate all the old or mismade food. read more

I would think a place like this would flourish in Utah County. Perhaps it does. The place is yuge inside! I've been there for lunch three or four times. Sign up for their text club. You'll get all sorts of offers. It's like $6.00 for all-you-can-eat pizza, salad and pasta. The salad bar is good. Nothing fancy and it's not going to win any awards but it's fresh and veggies are supposed to be good for you. The pasta bar is nice. There's a half dozen pasta types to choose from and as many sauces to slather over said pasta options. Tucked back neatly at the end near the wall is shredded Parmesan. I know, right?! The pizza is average. Stay away from the crust and you should be fine. Or don't, I'm not your mother. There's a wide variety including bread sticks with and without cheese. Don't forget the dessert pizza... It's bizarre but now and then there's a slice that isn't half bad! If I were in my early '30's with a couple of little kids and a tight budget, I imagine I'd be here on a weekly basis. But I'm not so I drop by about once a month for lunch because I'm too lazy and unorganized to pack my own for work. read more

Used to come here all the time for lunch in highschool but the quality and service have complete plummeted in the last year. 3/4 of the plates we were given were dirty, all our utensils were dirty with chunks of food on them. Had to ask for clean ones. Salad bar and pizza practically empty DURING lunch time. Pasta sauce looked like it had been there days with crust littering the outside and inside of the pots. Soda machine low. Someone came in not in uniform and went behind into the cooking area just hanging around obviously either a friend or worker off duty which is completely unacceptable either the state the place was in. Overall probably my worst restaurant experience of my life. To be fair the staff did their best but honestly it is definitely a lacking in the management and unacceptable. I understand covid times are tough and they may be lacking staff but there has to be a line somewhere, it's not like they were busy either maybe 3 other groups in the place. read more

Nasty and low quality on most of the pizza. They do have good desert pizza though, and the pasta and salad bars are pretty good, but the actual pizzas are pretty crappy. Just go to a good pizza shop, and don't waste your time, calories, or money on low quality crap. There's some great pizza shop in the area, so just pay a little more and get good pizza. Do not take a girl here on a date because it screams cheap and low quality. read more

The pizza isn't very good and the pie doesn't exist. However, the pasta and pasta sauces are good. Mix the alfredo and roasted red pepper sauces and dip the cheese bread and pizza (which are otherwise too dry and bready) in them to liven up the fare. Coupons are easy to find. Don't go without one. You can get in for $5, which isn't bad for unlimited pasta and alfredo. read more

Generally, on coming across a pizza buffet, I would turn around and leave, as I nearly did today, however, pizza buffets do have uses, albeit somewhat limited. One of them is having pizza ready on demand. I needed a quick lunch today and obviously, everything is all ready to go. I also have been still craving pizza for lunch and really expected to just pop in and grab a few quick slices. As it turns out, for all you can eat pizza & salad bar (I didn't partake of this as I couldn't look at myself in the mirror if I went to a pizza joint and bellied up to the salad bar and at some point, I will need to use a mirror) and whatever else for $7.25, you can about figure out what you're going to be getting and the pizzas ranged from tolerable to not worth eating. None of them rose above average, though, but one of the nice things is that you can try several different pizzas, though most of them will have been under the heat lamp for a bit. I tried quite a few: Acceptable (in order of tastiness): Firefighter, Hillbilly, PPC's Combo Flavors I didn't get much past half a slice: Chicken Alfredo (worst and a waste of the bacon that was on it), Buffalo Wing Thing (did not get much of the buffalo flavoring at all, mostly dreadful), Hawaiian (how they screwed this type of pizza up is beyond me), peach pizza (as "awesome" as it sounds), Cheese Stix (about Little Caesar's level and the best of this list). The rest of the pizzas either had onions or were a nasty gloppy sugary concoction that looked frankly disgusting. If anything, this tastes like a chain pizza and I'd put some of it below Domino's and Pizza Hut, but generally in the area of them, Papa John's and so on. But still, at that price point, with the groups coming in the door as I was leaving, it highlights another thing that pizza buffets are good at, which is feeding a group of children or teens. It's usefulness to me, outside of me trying to fill up one of those two groups, is very minimal, though. read more

I would give 0 if I could. We payed $17 for 3 kinds of pasta sauces (didn't even get my right requested pasta) and they only had 1 desert pizza with maybe 6 real pizzas where they should have it full. The pasta sauces were watery and disgusting, the pizza was wheat which isn't horrible but definitely changes the bread. The workers are soooo disorganized, super disinterested, the floor was super sticky by the table we sat at. Just not good service and not good food. The Provo one is better quality and nicer people. Orem lost our business today. read more

First of all our plates were not clean, then all the pizza looked 2 days old and we wanted Alfredo for the pasta but they made the excuse that they were closing in 1 hour. As doing so they refused to make any ignoring the fact of customer satisfaction. And lastly none of the tables were clean or open. read more

I enjoy taking my girls to this place and the food is pretty good for the price. It just seems that when I come here during the day there is a redhead (they don't have name tags) who is pretty miserable and she seems to not care to portray that to others. I will continue being a customer but I will go to the Provo location. read more

Got here two hours before closing and they already mopped up and ready to clock out... and the pizza? nah they don't cook after 7

This restaurant has really done amazing things above and beyond all the other locations that I have known of. The genuine pleasant disposition of Mary Ann as well as Cory is contagious in their whole store and the staff. read more

This place was a mess. There were bits of food all over all of the food stations. At first I thought I had just gotten to the salad bar a few moments after a horde of children got there but then I saw the other stations. There multiple pieces of upside down pizza in the pizza serving area the whole time we were there. In the pasta area there was enough pasta sauce drippings on the counter to cover a whole plate of pasta. The worst part was that, besides the cheese pizza, every single one of their dinner pizza options had meat on it. Yuck. read more

Great value for the price! Their pizza is pretty good and they have a large selection. The salad bar and pasta bar were good too. I tried two pasta sauces, alfredo and red pepper, both were excellent. Staff was very friendly as well! read more

A great variety of pizzas and awesome freshly cooked pastas make for the perfect lunch!

It is what it is. Mediocre pizza, Ok salad and pasta bars. Over-priced unless you have a coupon or it is their equivalent of happy hour. The kids enjoy it, but they also eat peeps, so their opinions are invalid. read more

Their gluten-free option (+$2) is a great way to get pizza for people who can't have gluten for any reason. The manager was fantastic at making sure our GF pizzas were not cross-contaminated and pointing out the GF pasta sauces for the GF noodles. Less expensive than Pizza Hut's GF pizza, but just as good, I think. Would recommend for a relatively inexpensive pizza buffet. read more

I should probably own this place we go there so much. Best value & pizza for gluten free babes! Whoever thought of cookies on pizza is crazy but a crazy GENIUS! So yummy read more

The good thing about this place is that it's a super good deal! I mean, their pizza isn't amazing, but it's good. I think buffet style is definitely the way to go with pizza! Plus, 8:00pm is their happy hour so it's an even better price, then! If you're looking for a good deal, and good food, you found the right place! read more

Okay for a all you can eat pizza buffet this is pretty great! The price is fantastic (especially if you are on there texting list). The pizza itself is ok (you get what you pay for). My favorite thing is weirdly enough to the pasta bar. It is very simple but I love the pasta because of the texture. The sauces are not the greatest but if you mix a few of the sauces together it's delicious!!! The place is always packed which for a buffet that's a good thing because you know the food is coming out hot. The customer service is great! It seems like the employees are always running around getting things done! My only complaint is get more silverware!!!! We had to wait to get clean silverware and when it came out there was a line just for that! . The staff is very friendly and the employee t-shirts are always fun to read! read more

Cheap pizza buffet. Expect the topping to go half way down the slice. Lots of variety. Pasta bar is surprising good. The pizza has bubbles. Lots of teenagers working. Usually very busy since it's a cheap place to eat. Loud environment when busy. read more

Sometimes it's hard for them to keep up with the crowds, but they give it a great effort. I love this place and the food is pretty consistent. The raspberry dessert isn't very consistent. It's always made differently. Good salad bar. read more

WARNING do not go when it's graduation time or anytime it could be crowded. The dining room is rather small and the are unable to handle the rush. The food is OK though. The FIreman Pizza was great and the other choice were good. The pasta was great and I had the smoked pepper sauce was tasty with a hint of heat! The Salad bar was average and could use some more choices. We will probably go back, hopefully we will be smarter and avoid the crowd. You have been warned!!!! read more

This is the worst freaking pizza I've ever had. I have no idea how anyone can give it a good score considering it's cardboard with marinara on top. I wish I could give it a negative score. But hey they are polite and the dessert pizza isn't too bad but it's not enough to make up for the bad tasting pizza. read more

Unfortunately, my husband and I will not be eating here again. The food was bland and dry. The salad bar was out of about 80% of the toppings and dressings. We were able to get one fork when we got there and then the restaurant had no clean forks for the next 45 minutes. It seemed like half the staff was just eating the pizza and pasta the whole time and did not even step aside for actual customers to get some food. I even had a worker squeeze between me and the pizza counter (literally bumping my elbow with his head) in order to wipe the counter off instead of waiting about 5 seconds for me to grab a slice and walk away. Then he wiped the crumbs right onto my feet and said nothing as I proceeded to try and get the food off my sandals. I did not go into Pizza Pie Cafe expecting a gourmet meal, but I did expect food to actually be warm and to have a clean fork to use. read more

Went there once with my husband and daughter. Everything was bad except for the Pepsi. Will never go there again even if someone is offering to pay for us. read more

Great food at a great price and good location. Not a big fan of the ambiance, but other than that, always love going here.

Good price, but not great pizza. The non Buffett pizza is a lot better. But the buffet had some pizza that seemed old. I like their jalapeno pepperoni pizza is good read more

I have not enjoyed a single piece of pizza--dry/overcooked. Desert pizza was not bad. The salad bar, ok.

The raspberry dessert pizza is to die for. We like coming here a lot. They let you in pretty quick. The Orem restaurant is better than the Provo one. :) They have a sad bar, pasta, and of course lots of pizza. The soda always seems to be watered down though, so we now get water instead. read more

Awesome experience! My kids got free buffet coupons for achievements at school, so that is what brought us here. Around 6:30pm on a Saturday, $8.50 for an adult buffet isn't bad. I signed up for text deals so that will be even better! Pizza, pasta, & salad bar were ALL very good for a buffet. The pizza varieties were never empty, they definitely kept up with demand. Previous reviews had me worried, but this place exceeded my expectations. read more

Good place to eat for a good price! The pizza was good, salad ok, but the pasta rocked! I'll definitely go back but I'll probably do it closer to lunch so they have more of their pizzas out. The place is pretty big and their wasn't much of a crowd at all. "I'll be back!" :-) read more

We're usually hoping for, at least, a 3-star pizza buffet for when our kids make the request. Is this location getting worse? I'm unsure if other locations are better. The whole place was a mess. The sauce bar, pasta bar, salad bar, and the pizza bar were all filthy with food and spills everywhere, including the floor. Someone had attempted to sweep but left the pile in a corner in view of some tables. The light-dimmer switches at the booths--that my children like to play with no matter how much I beg of them not to--were sticky and visably dirty. The food was very low-quality. The selected food was either wilted, dried out, stale, lumped/stuck together (pasta), separated (sauces), bottom-of-the-barrel, or gone. I winced when my children asked to go to the restroom. As expected, I advise you to hold it. I'm not sure if they were short-staffed despite how many workers were there, or if they haven't been efficiently trained, or if they didn't care about their job, or if it's poorly managed. Who knows? As I looked around, people didn't seem to care, and it made me lose a little more faith in humanity. How do these places stay in business? read more

Been here a couple of times now and had great experiences. The pizza varieties are more than any buffet and some of the best dessert pizzas. read more

Went there for lunch at about 12:45 and there were only one and half pizzas available the whole time. Such a waste. I would've expected more food to be available especially at lunch time. Disappointing buffet. read more

For the price that you pay you simply cannot beat the value that you are getting here. Their pizza is pretty good and they have lots of different thing to choose from. I personally like the Buffalo Wing Pizza, but they also have a salad and pasta bar as well as desert pizza. So for me although its not the most amazing pizza in the world the price (6.50) makes it for me as good as it gets. read more

All you can eat pizza, salad and pasta. With that offering you know good is not going to be amazing but it's quite decent for what you pay for. Good variety on pizzas and pasta, would like to see a better salad bar though. But at the end of the day, you get what you pay for read more

I love this place when I feel like a salad, pizza, pasta, and a drink for a reasonable price. Keep up the good work!

Sign up for the text program, you will not regret it! Who would want to miss out on the sweet deals? Great salad bar, pasta is always good. Pizza is great when fresh, you can always ask for a refresh. The decorations are fantastic. The service is generally very friendly and helpful. I would rate this place as a solid resturant. Great place for families group functions. read more

I'm on the text program so I can't complain about price. The food is worth what you pay for! If you don't see a fresh pizza, ask for one. The employees are generally nice and helpful. Sometimes the eggs are out on the salad bar and that's always disappointing. The red pizza sauce is.. mediocre at most. Other than that, the other pizzas are tasty and the salad and pasta bar are good side fillers for when you're not chowing down on pizza. read more

very very surprised at the lack of respect that the employees have for the customers. a couple of my friends work there and i was sent some screen shots of there group conversations they have with each other about there customers. very disappointed won't be going here again! read more