If you ordered for delivery: "This is the best pizza around! We ordered thin-crust and it arrived hot, fresh, and not greasy at all. The crust is super crispy and the cheese blend is flavorful. Definitely a new place to order pizza ." read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

Best Thin Crust Pizza! Lots of good appetizers to choose from. Excellent Customer Service, and Affordable prices. Everyone is always friendly and helpful. Great atmosphere. Would 100% recommend! read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

See all

I had a huge craving for Argentinian pizza, nobody makes it better. We decided to try a new place because Lou or Rosati's do not come near close to the Argentinian style. Di Maria is a bit closer to what I was craving. We order a medium double dough extra mozzarella and it was good, it took care of my itch. Next time we are going to try single-dough extra mozzarella because it was "intense" according to my husband. It was way too much pizza for two people, sacrificing and eating leftovers today haha. Delicious treat, satisfied my craving, and we will order again. I still miss Fugazzeta! read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Di Maria's double dough extra mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

See all

Pizza here is always great ! People are friendly and helpful. Never had a bad experience here

Great service and food! We tend to do order the pizza and wings and they always deliver in a timely manner!

This pizza is delicious! I drive from near Roosevelt & County Farm and it is so worth it! I ordered a medium cheese, Sausage and Mushroom with an extra thin crust. The crust was cracker crisp and amazing! This is the best pizza I've had in decades! I will be a regular from here on! Just delicious! read more

The Sicilian is our favorite, extra thin, of course. Sometimes, we add pepperoni for a change, but it is always consistently delicious. Italian wedding soup is a winter time favorite, or even when you are sick, it is hearty and who doesn't appreciate tiny meatballs! What surprised us the most was the blt pizza, yum! Put it on the repeat order list. read more

See all

The ingredients were sparse. We got what we ordered, but it would be nice if they were a little more generous with putting on the ingredients. read more

The pizza is always great. Fresh ingredients and crispy crust. The good surprise has been the catering menu. People always ask where we ordered from. The Cesar salad, wings and chicken tenders are delicious. The chicken tenders are made in house, not frozen, with a light crispy batter. Every time I called the morning of for a specific pick up time later that day and it's been ready to go on time. I'd definitely recommend Pizzeria Di Maria. read more

After a disastrous customer service experience and dangerously raw chicken decided I'd give them another chance as they were our go to pizza place. Well tonight I had to continue baking the pizza once it was delivered as the crust wasn't cooked all the way through The owner chose to respond and apparently if you don't want raw dough you have to ask for "well done". Ordered a million pizzas in my life and have never had to order well done to not have raw dough. But this response was consistent with how they handle customer service so very helpful for folks. read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Not cooked all the way - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

They sure don't know how to make a shrimp pizza charge too much for hardly any shrimp I won't be coming back

A little over 3 stars, but not quite 4. So the best we can rate for now is 3. Pizza we'd rate about a B+. Decent, good. Nothing bad by any stretch, but not something that knocked our socks off either. Very similar to Sir Nick's Pizza in Carol Stream. Sausage tastes pretty basic. (Note - pizza has arrived PIPING HOT though, which is a plus. We live 5 miles away, and have been impressed how hot it has arrived). - Burger was just "okay." Quite pricey. Both times we ordered, the burger was almost pink on the inside, like medium rare at best. It tasted okay, but really wasn't cooked properly. And again, a bit pricey. - Fries - not so good. Very basic "battered" style. They do give you a lot, but they just aren't that good. Also, if you want fries with the burger, it's an extra $2.50 or so. - Wings - OUTSTANDING. That's so far what is saving the place. No complaints there - great taste, nice size, decently priced. Delivery has been on time, and as mentioned, the pizza was always piping hot. So - there IS room for improvement with this place for it to be even better - change up the supplier for a few of these food items (ie. get your Italian Sausage from Greco), and those food items will taste much better. :) read more

This is a solid local pizza joint. It's not the cheapest, and they do have coupons but nothing really ever feels like a deal. You can easily spend $30 on a gourmet pizza. That said, their Italian meatballs with giardiniera is a fave. And the bbq chicken. One thing that bothers me is that don't always tell you what's in the food. Like the poutine has bacon and they don't really know what's in their meatballs. I've called a few times and depending on who answers the phone it's pork, beef, or they don't know. In today's world I think it's pretty mandatory to mention ingredients. But that's a small gripe. The storefront is pretty bare, really just a pickup counter. Gets the job done Edit: they are beef! And it turns out there are better deals and coupons on their site. read more

So we have been faithful customers for about 3 years now and thought I should put my two cents in. This is actually a 3.75 star review. There's a reason we keep ordering. First, I appreciate that you don't have to pay for a third party delivery, and if you call, you can get the best service. The pizza is consistently good. All the people are friendly, helpful, delivery people are very nice. There was an error on one of our orders and we were comped when I called. Prices are fair. Wings are surprisingly good for a primarily pizza place - wished they would have come with celery. I enjoy their Chicken piccata which is on special once a week. I love the Caprese salad primarily because they have tomatoes that are actually RED unlike many places. This is super important to me. Tiramisu -very good! Also, I truly believe that they are always trying to please their customers! And yes, that guy below for sure is a troll.... there is no way they would have treated him badly, I can vouch for their customer service!!! Constructive feedback for the owner because I care and want them to succeed - or maybe I've been watching too many episodes of Kitchen Nightmares. I'm seeing quality struggles - probably trying to cut corners to improve margin.. Just don't. My complaints would be: #1: PLEASE STOP using jarred, pre-chopped garlic. It's terrible and ruins all your pasta dishes so we don't order them anymore. Fresh garlic is so much better, cheaper, and not much more effort! So what you lose in money for labor to smash and chop a clove you make up in food cost. :) Also please watch the overcooking on the pasta dishes. If you are re-heating, consider slightly undercooking for prep. Seems to be frequent. #2 Ranch dressing is not good. Get the Hidden Valley Ranch Mix and make it fresh every week - you will sell so much more salads or apps with a good tasting ranch option! I have actually avoided ordering things for me and my kids due to the disappointing ranch dressing and I think another reviewer said something about it too. hint: Red Apple has the BEST ranch dressing in town and we sometimes go there to eat just because of it! #3 The calamari used to be my son's favorite but I think they are using a different supplier and as another reviewer mentioned, they are just like frozen rings, no good. Please go back to the prior brand! #4 also agree with another reviewer that the Vesuvio lacks, for sure. i would order this often if it were good! Chicken rubbery, potatoes too big and mushy and taste mediocre. What about using bone in chicken? Cheaper than breasts anyway and would be juicier and tastier... This is an easy, traditional recipe that can be excellent if executed well with better quality ingredients! I will update the review and add a star if #1-4 are improved! :) Happy New Year, Di Maria read more

Very yummy pizza ! Love the Florentine cauliflower pizza ! Delicious! Pizza Di Maria always delicious! read more

Excellent dinner! It takes a special touch to add broccoli to Fettuccine Alfredo - fresh, still bright green, yet tender. The portion was generous, the pasta done just right and the Alfredo smooth as silk. Started with Italian Wedding Soup, again fresh ingredients with plenty of sausage. Enough for 2 servings. In-house delivery driver was fast and pleasant. So glad they have their own on-line ordering rather than those 3rd party sites that cost so much and add no value. Better to put the money into a local restaurant than read more

Great pizza! Our neighborhood go-to. Carryout/delivery only in a small strup mall, Pizzeria de Maria has terrific pizza and consistently good quality. Friendly staff as well. read more

easy to see the entire menu, and process my order, but I did not know I was using yelp. it stinks. the profile it shows is not me, and I could not correct. it has wrong e mail address, and wrong info about me. i hope my order went through okay. read more

Well my update for today is after I left my honest review, I got a tongue lashing and a bunch of name-calling by somebody who calls himself the "owner" and if anybody would want to do business with somebody like that that's on you, but that reeks of unprofessionalism. Happy to let anyone see the NASTY RUDE UNPROFESSIONAL reply. What is a "costumer"? Do you mean customer? Sorry if the truth hurts! Any "business owner" replying in this manner should look into something else. Fix the problem, don't blame the COSTUMER. UPDATE now I'm getting harassed and still name called and we will see if I'm a "troll" when I call the police for harassment All because I left an honest review ?!? as you can see the problem is very internal and starts at the top. First of all just because I leave two or three a day doesn't mean I visited on that exact day and where do I get the money from? IT? it's called working a job, like more normal people.... third of all I had to get the police involved to make this stop and I have a police report number so anybody wanting to do business here you go ahead but buyer beware. read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Nice way to talk to a COSTUMER - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

See all

The pizza was cooked well, with a good amount and spreading of toppings. I got the XL thin with pepperoni, mushroom, and 1/2 black olives. The pie was cooked evenly. Even sauce, even cheese. Nothing sparse or overcooked. I ordered the appetizer sampler /assortment. A good variety; mushrooms and zucchini were favorites. I didn't much care for the breading on the mozzarella sticks and jalapeno poppers: too thick and bland. I was happy to have ample ranch and marinara sauce. I'll be ordering again though: I like that they're close by. Solid pie. read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Appetizer sampler - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

See all

We have been ordering meals from Pizza Di Maria for many years, and it is by far the best pizza and traditional Italian food available in the Carol Stream area. The staff is always pleasant and polite. Their delivery and carryout are consistently timely, and the food is always hot and delicious! Would give 10 starts if available! Keep up the great work! D. Kapp read more

Great pizza every time! We're getting our Friday pizza tomorrow as we did for the last 3 Fridays. Pan pizza is meh. We go to Lou Malnati's if we feel like pan pizza. But always order the thin crust from here. read more

Great pizza! First time trying Pizzeria DiMaria and I believe I am a convert! Great salads too! Pizza was cooked perfectly and the thin crust is great! read more

Got a slice of cheese. Very tasty. Good grip, no flop and crispy. Just how I like it. Ranch on the side could do better. Pizza gets 4,7/5 and ranch 3/5. Girl at the counter was very nice, Caitlyn or Katy forgot the name. Over all good and willing to try their extensive menu next time. Was hungry enough for just a slice. See ya next time. read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

Excellent thin crust, and they LISTEN when taking the order! Perfect pizza every time. Nice employees, too!

It's taken us several tries to find a great traditional Chicago tavern style pizza in the area and we finally found it! Pizzeria di Maria is exactly what we've been looking for. I can't say enough good things about this pizza, it's cheesy and delicious! It l's our go to pizza night pizza. We're never disappointed and look forward to it every week. We've only done delivery and the pizza always arrives on time and piping hot. read more

Excellent Food! We have loved everything we have ordered. Have tried a variety of pizzas and they all were excellent. You can tell they use fresh, quality products. The vodka sauce is also great! read more

SOLID, craveable pizza! We usually get pizza from Al's in Warrenville but took a chance on delivery from Pizzeria Di Maria on a night we didn't want to go out and do pickup. Was tipped off by a friend. Best thing we ever did. We are hooked! Dough, sauce, sausage, ingredients, all top notch. Kudos. read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery called a half hour after the pizza left the restaurant and they said it'll be here soon. Called again 45 minutes after and got the same line. Called AN HOUR after the pizza left the restaurant and the owner told me they accidentally put the wrong time in for when it left the restaurant and it only went out 10 minutes ago. It finally arrived and the delivery guy confirmed that he's had it for an hour and that he's "very busy." The pizza was stone cold. They gave me a $5 credit on my $40 cold pizza. Heating up the oven now so the pizza can get warm again. Nevermore. read more

My neighbor recommended this place, and so happy we took his advice! Pizza was so good, the lasagna is delicious. The owner is so nice and friendly, would definitely say this is the BEST place to order from (very yummy)! read more

I had NO idea this place had the same owners as Mama Maria's in Elmhurst! Yay! I used to go there as a kid up through high school and loved their sausage pizza! We ordered a couple of pies for a game night with friends and it went over very well with our guests. We got 1 pepperoni and meatball and 1 veggie, with a free cheese pizza from a coupon. It was just as I remembered. :) My husband wasn't as thrilled with it, but I can't understand why! I guess he's just used to his usual place, a place nearby of which I won't name (our usual place recently changed the type of cheese they use, and we didn't like it - so, we're shopping around for new pizza places). I'm putting this place on my list for sure! read more

Tried this new pizza place tonight. We had carry out thin crust well done with sausage and roasted red peppers. Yum! I can't always find roasted red peppers as an option, so this place is right up my alley. Friendly owners and a convenient location means we will be back for more. read more

Just opened! Ordered half sausage half pepperoni and two side salads. Salads were great with fresh meat. Pizza was great and cooked perfectly. Crust was crispy but thick. Meats were layered on pretty good. Menu has a decent assortment that we will more than likely try soon. Staff was friendly when picking up. Can't really ask for a better pizza experience. Good pizza, friendly service, good ingredients. read more

I ordered the Rigatoni Di Joey from Pizzeria Di Maria this evening and it was absolutely delicious! Everything about this dish is a winner from the savory vodka sauce and sausage to the fresh pasta. This restaurant is a hidden gem in Carol Stream and I cannot wait to order again real soon! read more

This pizza is made the way a pizza is supposed to be made. I'm so glad we tried this place which is new to the area but not new to the pizza business. My wife had the gluten free pizza and said it was the best she has ever tasted. read more

Great pizza, very tasty! Ordered a classic large pepperoni pizza and mozzarella sticks. Very tasty pizza, lots of cheese.z would definitely order here again. read more

Pizza is great. Mozzarella sticks are even better. Service is always great. My wife swears by the meatballs

The pizza is amazing! Very quick and accommodating with everything that is going on. This is my first time trying, since I'm visiting a friend, but I will definitely be back! read more

Pizzeria Di Maria - 14" Pepperoni pizza, well done, pie cut - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

This is the BEST pizza in the area and trust me we have tried them all! It is always very consistent and delicious! So glad we found this place, it will forever be our go to pizza! read more

Never thought any other pizza could lure me away from our go to but this one certainly has. GREAT pizza with a delicious not to sweet sauce. Yes, they made a mistake with our order one night but went over and above to fix it. Glad they are in our neighborhood! read more