I've been coming here for a few years. The food is always flavorful. The people who work here have always been pretty awesome. There are a few easy go-to slices: Buffalo chicken slice, grandma, burrata, sopressata hot honey... And a few more I just can't remember. This is a good solid place to grab a bite. read more

I've eaten here about a dozen times. I'm a big fan of pizza, and even a bigger fan of quality service. I always get both here. My favorite slice is the Sesame Chicken so I ordered a whole pie for a family gathering, along with a few plain, upside down Grandma Vodka, Buffalo Chicken, a Portnoy...and Cesar Chicken Salad. Everything was a hit for a crowd that loves pizza. Great quality, great service. Highly recommend this establishment for anyone who appreciates one (or both). read more

This is by far the some of the best pizza on long Island. All the workers there are very nice. I have not had a bad slice there yet. Buffalo chicken, BBQ Chicken, Grandma alla vodka, margarita etc. Highly recommend this place for read more

Ordered a chicken vodka pie for delivery. I wasn't expecting the pie to be as heavy as it was when it was handed to me, even holding it with both hands I still had to be careful with its weight. That being said, I was full from half a slice. Other pizzerias I could easily eat 2, 3 slices at a time. So to me, this pie is absolutely worth the price as I have tons of leftovers for lunch & dinner the next few days! read more

Pizzeria G - Chicken Vodka Slice - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

The service here is excellent--they're always on top of things. My go-to is the truffle mushroom slice; the truffle flavor really comes through. Every other slice I've tried--though I can't remember all the names--has been equally delicious. The dining area is small, but manageable. I'll keep coming back just for that truffle slice. Recently, my son tried the chicken parm meal with penne in vodka sauce, and it was really tasty. They're generous with portions, too. Parking isn't an issue--there's a large lot on one side if the smaller area is full. read more

Pizzeria G - Truffle slice Garlic knot - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

Curbside outdoor dining. Staffing Family-friendly. Cozy atmosphere. Location was clean., including the restroom. With Each visit., I make it my business to try a new item on their menu. So today for lunch. I purchased four [4] pizzas: Chicken Buffalo ., Square pizza Burrata. Taken home square pizza MVP., Upside-down Sicilian., along with a tasty carbohydrates bottle beverage of Coca-Cola. Looking forward to my next visit.,for : salad & appetizers. read more

See all

My Job treated for Pizzeria G, On 7/24/25. I tried the pepperoni and I must say, I would eat it again. The pepperoni was just the right amount of spicy not to overbearing. The sauce was spot on and the cheese was nice and cheesy. The place looks nice and clean when I went by after work. read more

See all

Loved this place! I felt for a good brick oven slice and so my boyfriend and I went on google maps and saw this place had pretty good reviews. They have parking in both the front and back and the place is clean and spacious. There is also indoor and outdoor dining. The options were plentiful and all looked delicious! I went with chicken a La vodka (not pictured it looked so good I ate before the camera did, sorry!) and a grandmas slice and my bf with buffalo chicken and another I can't remember but it was all good. 10/10. The service there was also so great! They brought our food to us and asked us if we needed drinks. I also watched them clean a table outside as it had just rained for a couple that wanted to sit outside. I will definitely revisit. read more

Pizzeria G - Grandma Slice and Buffalo Chicken Slice - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

We have ordered from Pizzeria G many times. Everyone loves the pizza. The crust is crispy but with a doughy middle, the sauce isn't too sweet or too garlicky. Comes to us still hot every time. Super quick service as well. read more

I'd be lying if I said I knew about this pizzeria prior to Dave Portnoy's review but here we are! Went in to grab a pie for a guys night in and immediately my eye went to the "MVP Square Pie." (marinara, vodka and pesto). The medley of flavors in each bite were unreal and one of the best bites I've had in a long time in regards to pizza. Zero complaints throughout the room over the course of the night and by far that pie was the hit amongst all the food options. 100% would come back for that specific pie! read more

Pizzeria G - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

We were staying in the area for a wedding and needed a quick bite to eat for lunch. Pizzeria G hit the spot! Barstool gave them a 7.9 and I'd have to agree. We loved the regular cheese and pepperoni slices. The one that could've been better was the chicken parm slice - it was just ok. For four slices and two sodas our bill was a little over $40. read more

Pizzeria G - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

Love this place! Their penne a la vodka and salads are also amazing. And of course we love the cheese slice, pepperoni and the buffalo chicken pizza! read more

Pizzeria G - Pepperoni Slice White PIE - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

Pizza is great when it's fresh. Highly recommend the upside slice, it is a go too! Love where this place is located, and the workers are friendly. One of the best pizzerias in GC read more

I stopped by this place today to get a slice. I walked in, looked in the case and stood at the counter waiting. I was the only one at the counter. All of the other customers were sitting down eating. One guy was preparing something but he turned around, looked at me and went back to his task. The other guy was standing at the counter on the other side, did not acknowledge me, just stood looking straight ahead. He saw me, just did not acknowledge. I waited a few and then I walked out. I was bothered because I did feel like it was because I didn't look like the other patrons. That was what I walked away feeling like unfortunately. I hope I was wrong, but it just didn't feel that way. Would I try again? Probably not. Would it make a difference? Probably not. I just felt bad,to experience this first hand. Sad. read more

I ordered from here to give it a shot this past Friday night because it always looks crowded and is conveniently located right in the center of Garden City with easy parking. There is a bunch of outdoor dining for takeout eating which is convenient. I ordered online so I didn't have to wait for anything. The grandma vodka slice is good and flavorful. The mushroom truffle slice is also very good. The lemon arugula salad with grilled chicken was good and the portions generous, I just didn't like the dressing because I think it had some honey mustard which I'm not a fan of but my husband liked. Luckily they served it on the side. The staff was also friendly. I'll definitely be eating here again! read more

See all

Felt like I had to write a review. Pizzaria G was our go to pizza until tonight. Ordered the grandma vodka pie and chicken roll through insta cart. The pizza had so much grease it was disgusting. Really, we couldn't eat it. The chicken roll was in a brown paper bag.... It's pouring out, why why why would you not put it in a container? Just soaked, couldn't eat it. Waste of $50.00 ... say good bye to a very good customer. read more

By far one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Don't care for the giant slices but crust sauce cheese was perfect.

the slices are amazing every time. best pizza that everyone will love. service is too notch. friendly staff. modern design for all ages. bring your family and smell the fresh basil in the air as you walkin! read more

See all

Friendly staff as always, got a selection to try a few and my feelings are the same. A good pizzeria with a large selection. Nothing blew me away, but everyone was satisfied. Only complaint was that everything seemed a little greasy today and I don't recall that last time I was here. read more

Pizzeria G - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

On the pricey side for mediocre pizza, we live on Long Island, there are plenty of other spots with better pizza. It was ok. If you're around that area I guess try for yourself read more

I was in the area for a training class and stopped in based on Portnoy's review. One bite 7.9 The pizza is solid. I especially liked the eggplant slice. It was tough to make a decision since they had so many choices between round pizzas and squares. Too bad I don't live in the area so I could try more of the slices. Good stuff. read more

Pizzeria G - Eggplant and cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

Good Pizzeria. A lot of pizza choices. Plenty of seating indoor & out. Place was clean, and they took my order as soon as I entered. We'll definitely come back. read more

See all

Updating my last review 2 months ago. Since then, I have returned to Pizzeria G in multiple times and have never had a "bad" slice there! The crave-ability of their slices is off the charts in my house! Between the high quality used and the scrumptious sauce, it is now the only pizzeria we frequent in the neighborhood! PS don't let the crisping fool you! It may look plain but the flavor and textures are wild! read more

Pizzeria G - Clockwise: Chicken Bacon Ranch, Pepperoni, White, PPP, Sopressata & Hot Honey, burrata, gma vodka, sesame chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

OOF! is what you'll exclaim after ordering your first specialty slice. Over $6.00 for it plus whatever else you get. Place is nicely designed on the interior and there's some outdoor seating with umbrellas for shade as well. Table and bar seating by the windows. I ordered the Sesame Chicken Pizza Slice. It's as expected. Sweet and salty. They have a TV for the employees and visitors to enjoy whatever sports are on. I think next time I'd order a more traditional slice of pizza. The staff are kind and helpful. Definitely good for groups of 2 or more. The tables appear to not be fixed to the floor. Happy eats! read more

See all

Looked forward to visiting this place that touted the freshest ingredients and amazingly delicious pizza. WOW- what a disappointment $5.20 for one plain slice purchased with a credit card. Crust tasted like Costco, soggy. Sauce was too sugary and tangy and the cheese was filled with greasy oil on top. Maybe I wouldn't be so hard on this review if the price wasn't the highest on Long Island. read more

Garden City now has a great pizza place! Take for example, yesterday a few of the guys brought in two speciality pizzas. One of them was my favorite, the grandma pizza. When we opened the boxes, all of us shed a small tear. From the crust to the fresh ingredients, this is one of the top artisan pizzas on Long Island. Me? When I go, I haven't tried anything else except the G Pizza. Made with fresh mozzarella, sauce and basil with an olive oil drizzle. Did I just describe heaven? I want to order a Burrata pizza, the words are almost out and then I say: G for me. One day I'll have the Burrata pizza. For now? It's kind of easy when you listen to the g-dub sound. Pizza crust bubblin' as I smell the slice now.. The best pizza on Long Island for 2022. read more

Pizzeria G - G slice - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

Recommend this to my family & friends. Customer friendly service and the workers bring the pizza to your table! Place is clean, and my second time here read more

See all

First, I just have to say that the menu here is amazing! So many wonderful choices and delicious with a doubt. The freshest pizzeria I have ever dined at. 10s across the board! read more

Pizzeria G - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

I was sooo excited to try this pizzeria! Came here during lunch at work and so happy I did. It is amazing decor and even better pizza which was hard to do! I got the Buffalo chicken & pepperoni. It was honestly hard to decide. Next time I want to try the sausage broccoli rabe! Will most definitely make this my pizza Friday spot during lunch! read more

See all

This is a new pizzeria that opened on 7th street a few months ago with many different choices of pizzas, salads, and heros. Inside it is very modern and clean. There is also an outdoor area with tables and chairs. The staff were also very welcoming and very friendly. My husband and I had a Sesame Chicken slice and a Chicken Bruschetta slice. I liked how crunchy and thin the pizza was, but don't get me wrong it is heavy with toppings. The sauce on the sesame chicken slice was also very delicious. I would definitely come back to try other slices or something different from their menu. read more

Pizzeria G - Sesame Chicken slice (left) and a Chicken Bruschetta slice (right) - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

Location is very appealing. I wanted to walk in bc it looks like such an nice cool pizza spot. The location was clean. The gentlemen that work there are fresh faced and friendly. These guys get to work and get your food ready to go. I am not a regular slice girl. Ive been to a few specialty pizza spots and for some reason the dough isnt it. Its not the case here. The dough was perfect with both slices Perfect softness perfect crisp. The pricing is actually decent in regard to specialty slices. Id def come again and keep trying different ones. The sesame chicken slice... slaps. Do it.. read more

Pizzeria G - let the sun hit these babies.. - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

OK, so let me start off. I had two specialty slices sesame chicken slice and another slice. I forget what it was called even so I had that +3 garlic knots and a bottle of water talking about getting raped $25 never again. Am I going there? read more

Overpriced! $5 for 1 slice & $4 for a small bottle of coke! They should consider people struggling with the cost of living!

I've walked by pizzeria g so many times and have always wanted to try their pizza. Not the best pizza I've had, but not the worst. It had a little bit of a saltier taste, which to me really stood out and I didn't like that. I think my favorite was the grandma slice though, but still salty. The plain wings are pretty good though. Service and location were fine, its just like a pizzeria with seating. It's not an incredibly big place, but overall no complaints there. They have some pretty unique slices like a sesame chicken slice, but not sure id actually try it. read more

Pizzeria G - Upside Down Sicilian Slice, Regular Cheese Slice, Grandma Slice - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

Pretty good pizza, I'd give the place as a whole a 3.5. Tried the honey spicy pepperoni- it was very good. Tried the vodka grandma- it was just ok, which was surprising because vodka slices are usually my favorite. Tried the Portnoy slice- alright Frankie- it was somewhere between "okay" and "pretty good". It's almost TOO thin and without enough sauce. I'd say.. 7.2? Also it was $5.50 for what essentially is a half-size regular cheese slice. The over charging of the slices is what brought this down to 3 stars. If they were more reasonably priced I'd give the spot a 4. read more

These prices are more expensive than nyc. And proud of a portnoy review ? I would not advertise a 7.9 review regardless of who it is. The service was okay and the pizza was okay. read more

Mediocre at best...and $6 a slice. (Plain with some mushrooms) I kid you not. Rude counter guy told me that I was rude when I questioned the nonsensical price. Stay away....crapola with high prices. Yeah...Garden City. read more

Great pizza and huge slices! Excellent staff - friendly and they go the extra mile! I definitely recommend them.

My son-in-law, an Italian Long Islander from birth, knows his pizza !! This restaurant specializes in what they call "specialty slices." They create fancy pizzas with all kinds of toppings, and when you get there, you order whatever slice(s) you want from the choices on hand. Not being familiar with the process myself (and not that hungry), I only ordered 1 slice of the Marguerita. My daughter and son-in-law each ordered 3 slices of different kinds, and they shared. I should've ordered more, but you live and learn, right? I really enjoyed the Marguerita. I tasted the mushroom truffle that my daughter ordered and would've gotten that for myself were I hungrier. It was delicious. I'm not one for a bunch of "salad" on my pizza, nor do I like any fruit or bacon, so that knocked out a good 5 or 6 for me right there. That's fine because between the variations on crust thickness, the types of sauces, not to mention the variety of toppings, they offered so many different kinds of pizza. It was really impressive. read more

See all

Def not a 7.9 pizza. I dont mind paying for good pizza, but that wasnt a $5 dollar slice at all. Super oily and cheesy. Not impressed at all. read more