Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pony Island Restaurant

    4.1 (86 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Pony Island Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    PONY ISLAND RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Quiet
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating

    More like Pony Island Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Pony Island Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Slim pickings' on the island, but it's good!
    Maria T.

    Pony Island Restaurant ain't horsin' around! Breakfast!! That's all they do! 7:30-11:30 ... then it's off to fishing! If you know Ocracoke, you know there's only a handful of restaurants to chose from! We were pleased that we stumbled upon this cute, rustic eatery which served a good, hearty breakfast! The pancakes were huge and the bacon & eggs were done to my liking. The grits were so-so. Pretty average service and prices, but all around a nice place to grab your morning cup of Joe! The bathrooms are in an awkward spot near tables and everyone can just watch you go on and out of the restroom. I would definitely make a small enclosure to separate the restroom from the rest of the place.

    a cup of coffee
    Staci K.

    Just what we wanted this morning before heading to the beach. Service is friendly, efficient, and attentive. Food is very, very good; not overly done. Sometimes cooks try too hard and end up messing up a good thing, but not here and not today. Husband had the taco omelette and I had a sausage, egg and cheese sandwich with a side of cheese grits. Very pleased! Definitely recommend this joint for breakfast. Atmosphere is very casual and neighborly. Thanks again!

    Michael H.

    We were here on a Wednesday morning in July visiting Ocracoke for a day. The outside appearence of the place was very welcoming and homey. We walked in with about a 2 minute wait. We got seated and it was nice. The drinks were great and in the bathroom there was good salt scrub. The food was typical for a breakfast establishment not bad priced right. The service was good and the coffee was good. It was a little dark inside. You must pay at the register after receiving the bill. It was next to a pony motel

    Cool pony windows to the kitchen

    Five out of five! Would definitely go back! We went at 9am, there was a line; we were told it would be a 15 minute wait but they got us seated in about 10. Only bummer was there wasn't much space for people waiting. Daniel was our waiter & he was superb, fast friendly & efficient. The food was fantastic! Pony potatoes were spot on, Salsa cheese eggs came with American cheese slices on top & the Southwest Scramble Tacos were thoroughly enjoyed. The banana hot cakes had the banana cooked inside & were delicious. They used a new towel to clean each table & threw it in the bin after one use (this may seem wasteful but with Covid I think this is great practice). They were busy & moving fast but they weren't rushing, they were efficient. They didn't rush us & were very friendly even though you could tell they were a bit overwhelmed.

    Tex-Mex Pancakes and Hash Browns
    Jason T.

    Went here for breakfast with my family and received great service! We got seated quickly and our waitress was very friendly. Additionally, the Tex-Mex pancakes and hash browns were phenomenal! Would totally recommend going here for breakfast.

    Entrance
    Patty R.

    Great place for breakfast at reasonable prices. The line was a bit long, but the tables opened up fairly quickly, and of course, 10:30am on a Saturday in season, you can expect a line! The food was hot, tasty and generously portioned. The server was terrific, and anticipated anything we might have needed. We were pleased with the pricing, also.

    Hot cakes and a licked cinnamon bun plate.

    See all

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    The place is clean, the service was fast and the servers were very friendly. The food was real good and very reasonable priced.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Pony Island Restaurant

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Yoder's Dutch Pantry

    Yoder's Dutch Pantry

    4.6
    (112 reviews)
    74.7 mi
    $$

    We were belatedly celebrating mom's 84th birthday, and she had not been to Yoder's in 10-15 years…read more Today was my first time. My aunt and cousin joined in on the fun, and it was my cousin's first time as well. Some in our party got the meatloaf, and exclaimed over how delicious it was. I got the parm chicken with rice, which was a little dried out and disappointing. Enter Yoder's cabbage and Dutch potato sides to save the day! Both were absolutely delicious! The cabbage was perfectly cooked and well-seasoned. I was delighted to find they were spicy, with visible red pepper flakes. The Dutch potatoes were creamy and cheesy...a new fave! The roll with the cinnamon butter was a treat indeed. And the tea? We like ours half & half...delivered in big cups with extra ice just the way we like it! I also got an English Toffee Latte to go...and it did not disappoint. Neither did the waitstaff, who were friendly, engaging and ensured our food was delivered with a smile. We left with slices of chocolate, coconut cream, and pecan caramel pie, a loaf of sourdough, and a mocha brownie treat for later. Ohhhh, and a ginormous cinnamon roll, cause why not?! The interior of Yoder's restaurant is a rustic place with a lovely shop to wander through while you wait to be seated. They have a lovely bird in the store that will sing you a song and tell you what the cat and the rooster say. So charming! All in all, I've been hearing about Yoder's for years and years...and it did not disappoint! Can't wait for a return visit!

    Our party called ahead the day before visiting the restaurant for Wednesday reservations. We were…read moretold to arrive around 9am the next morning. After arriving a few minutes early we were told it would be "a bit" before they could seat us. "A bit" turned out to be more than an hour and even then they sat us at multiple tables throughout the restaurant. After being seated, we were promptly ignored. Fifteen more minutes went by before our sullen, unpleasant server took our drink orders and eventually our breakfast orders. She was not only extremely slow and inattentive, but blatantly disrespectful to one member of our party by rolling her eyes and making gestures when she thought we couldn't see her. Once our order was placed, we waited then waited more. We had decided to leave if our food had not arrived by 12pm and go to Bojangles in Vanceboro, but at 11:50, over three hours after arriving, our food finally showed up. My omelet was enormous and overflowing with ground sausage. It was OK, but would have been better with less sausage. My shredded hash browns were cold. The biscuit that accompanied the omelet was cold and hard. My dining companion liked her french toast, but noted her eggs, though properly prepared over medium, were cold. Same goes for her home fries. However, the buttery syrup, served with her french toast, was served warm and was absolutely amazing. Wow! It made my biscuit edible and was the best part of our meals. The restaurant is attached to a hardware store in a rural part of Craven County. It definitely has a country vibe and was spotless. Incredibly slow and disrespectful service combined with OK-at-best food make it difficult to recommend Voder's Dutch Pantry in any capacity to anyone.

    Photos
    Yoder's Dutch Pantry
    1 order of Pancakes
    1 order of Pancakes
    1 slice of Gluten Free French Toast

    See all

    1 slice of Gluten Free French Toast

    Pony Island Restaurant - breakfast_brunch - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...