I have been here a few times with some friends/family. The service is always very good and the staff is polite. The prices are good and the food is great and there are many varied options for picky eaters such as ourselves. I ordered a shrimp po boy. Mine food was great. The decor is nice, and if you like the food/atmosphere you could also try one of their other restaurants, like the Library Cafe in Farmingdale. We enjoy this place, and frequent when in the area =). read more

They did a good job with a large group of nearly 50 people. It can be hard to make sure everyone's food is fresh but they pulled it off. We had a pre-set menu of a fresh salad with a balsamic dressing, choice of about 8-10 entrees, and cheesecake or apple crisp for dessert. The place was an old post office and has the feel of a bar/restaurant that's in a historic building. The roast beef sandwich with mozzarella was enjoyable and the beef was fresh and tender on a garlic bread type of roll. It came with hot and fresh waffle fries. I also ate way too many of the rolls they bring to the table. The cheesecake was good but the apple crisp is really worth a try and I'd recommend that. I didn't have a drink but they seem to have a large beer menu with lots of local selections. I'd come back here and have another meal and a local beverage if I was in the area. read more

See all

Had a large party of almost 30 for a luncheon on a stormy day. The tables were set and the fireplace lit. The team did an amazing job with service and the food and drink were fabulous. read more

Just had my daughters rehearsal dinner for her wedding. We had such a wonderful dinner! Food was amazing, service spectacular and every detail was totally taken care of!! I am so impressed with the Lessing's Team! Thank you for the wonderful memories! read more

Post Office Cafe - American Near Me - Babylon, New York

The Post Office is a great local restaurant that has very nice decor, friendly staff, and plenty of tvs so you always look like your talking to the person in front of you. They have a vast and eclectic menu for both food and drinks. We had the Cheese Quesadillas which were a little greasy but very good, The Pork tacos were amazing but slightly greasy as well. They are served on wonton noodle shells, and were loaded with flavor. The marinated steak on garlic bread was cooked properly to order and was excellent as well. For drinks we had the red sangria, very enjoyable. We skipped on desert this time but will definitely check out the chocolate banana empanadas next time we visit. read more

See all

Had the beyond burger with a side of quinoa and chick peas. It was decent. My son had the Mac and cheese. It comes in a cool skillet but just average. The waitresses were nice. It was pretty noisy as the dining area is near the bar. Hard to have a conversation here. It's a great place for drinks and is a step up from the typical bar type food. I would come back. read more

I was hear for a wedding dinner. The food was really good especially the steak. I was amazing how tasteful the food was especially because they had buffet style because of our party size. I wish the drinks were stronger or in bigger glasses or it would have been a perfect 5 stars. read more

Food eh.. service was horrendous.. if it weren't for Jenna being a doll we would have to walked right out

Food was good, I WOULD URGE MANAGEMENT TO CONSIDER THIS There is a gas fueled rock fire place that is separated by a table in the back room. There is NO signage or protective covering of what looks like harmless glass. That glass must be 500 degrees and could cause severe harm if touched. You should consider adding protective covering or have very noticeable signage of this danger. read more

So I'm not sure whether it's a YELP issue or Post Office but I ordered delivery through the YELP app. Food was pretty good with the exception of the order comments not being followed. Ordered the crispy chicken wrap asked for no tomatoes and it had tomatoes. Ordered the steak sandwich and wrote the steak should be medium rare, also paid an extra $2.00 to sub the bread for a wrap. My sandwich came on a bun and not the wrap I was up charged for and the steak was unfortunately cooked more than medium rare. Not sure where the miscommunication is but YELP should make sure that they're providing all the order information and hopefully next time Post Office will better read the order. read more

Post office is one of my favorite places in Babylon. Whether it's date night with my hubby or family night with my daughter, we always enjoy! The servers are friendly, the food is great and I really like the live acoustic music they have on some nights. Our favorite food is probably the French dip, or maybe the steak sandwich, or...too many to choose! They also have a good selection of beer, wine and cocktails. It's a no brainer. read more

Soooooooo disappointed with this place. It has been going down the drain for years . We figured we would give it one more try for Breakfast with Santa today. We had a party of 8. The manager promised us that when we made reservations that although we would be at two tables- one table of 5 and a second of 3 we would DEFINITELY be seated next to each other. Of course, when we got there they had us separated. There was an empty table right next to one of our tables!!! The hostess said "oh no we can't sit you there we have the entire place mapped out. " I said soooooo why can't the other table of four be seated where you want to put us?? She said sorry we can't . That table remained empty the entire hour we were there!!! The entire experience was ruined. The point was to spend it TOGETHER. Oh well, this was the final straw we will never return . read more

Really disappointed. I booked here because it was close to the Argyle Theater and had a kids menu for my son. We arrived as soon as they opened- but as we walked in there was a table for 25 or so people there already for a party. What was strange was they set that table up right in the main room next to all the booths. We were trying to enjoy lunch, but service was so slow and it was distracting to have a party of that size directly next to us who were asking to get a new table top, moving their chairs, etc. Besides that, food was awful and they didn't even offer their brunch menu because of "Sunday parties" ( we didn't find that until we arrived). Such a let down when we could have just went to the diner down the street for brunch options and a kid menu. read more

You know I've truly tried with this place it's in my town and the food...well it use to be Good now ehh let's just say every other time I order from hear they don't follow directions, if you got an allergy or allergic to something this IS NOT the place to go I TOLD THEM 10 times NO PICKLE and guess what I get a French dip with a pickle on it ushaly it's on the side and I can just eat around it but no not this time I had to call them and tell them because this happens like almost all the time here they don't follow directions. And I rilly like this place I would like it if they followed directions and also the au jus for delivery should just be automatically wrapped up in surran wrap because every time I've gotten it delivered it always had spilled out in the bag and I'm left with a soggy sandwich witch was not toasted when I asked them specific to toast the bread, look I'm not a person to write yelp reviews but it's just frustrating when I get food from here often and they just mess it up and Uber never give Me my money back so it's an all around L, look I understand what's going on in the world with this crazy out brake but just take a minute and read the ticket when your preparing food or platting, I worked in the food business for years I know how it is it's just I'm annoyed about this because I can't even eat my Food read more

Always a great experience at The Post Office Café. Food, Drink and Service are always solid. The Classic Rock Music at the correct volume added a nice touch to my dining experience. My Wife and I eat out quite often, and seem to always gravitate back to The Post Office. Patrons are mostly locals of Babylon, and are always friendly. Overall, its always a Pleasure at The Post Office Café. read more

Post Office Cafe - American Near Me - Babylon, New York

Wowee, wowee. Let me tell you somethin about the post office cafe... bitchin' good time! I went with some family because friends are few and far between, just kidding! I have friends... they just always happen to be busy when I ask them to hang out.. he he. I forgive them though. Anyways, Shannon with the lovely golden locks and smile like a rainbow served us. She was professional and informative and very charming. I wish everyone in that one horse town could take a page from Shannon's book, being that there's quite a few Karen's and footballs stars from 30 years ago that never seemed to have left... maybe they think it's like pleasantville or the Truman show and they can't leave if even they wanted to? Lol, look at me, ranting again on unrelated topics. Well, we ate food there. The food had ingredients and it was good. I had a hot pretzel with cheese. I shouldn't have, my mouth really enjoyed it but being lactose intolerant and having ibs the rest of me didn't so much. My family got a few other things that they loved. The drinks, had alcohol, which does it for me. They were cold because they had ice in them, which I LOVE!!!! But I have to say the star of the show was Shannon, Brava Brava!!! Speaking of Brava, maybe I missed it but I didn't notice potatoes Bravas on the menu... something to consider? I could always send you my recipe if you like! I won't charge you guys to use it either.. well maybe put a picture of my face next to said menu item.. I will be sure to include that along with my potatoes bravas recipe (you're welcome). Cheers to you Post Office cafe... I especially liked all the cool old stuff hanging on the walls, I get bored easily and it gave me something to think about, "how did they get those up there and keep them up there.. definitely not sticky tacky". Thanks Post office for a riveting experience and thank you to Shannon who fixed our family! Below is a picture of me giving the thumbs up at home watching tv later and writing this review because I forgot to take one at the place. read more

Post Office Cafe - American Near Me - Babylon, New York

The huckleberry mule with ketal one is soooo refreshing , the salmon dish was delicious light meal, the tuna tacos where so fresh and the Thai calamari with peanuts was a great appetizer to start with. read more

Post Office Cafe - American Near Me - Babylon, New York

Post Office Cafe has such nice people, will go next time I'm in town! Online ordering is convenient.

I am a regular customer of the Post Office Cafe . From the moment you walk in , you are greeted in a friendly and caring manner. We were seated immediately. The atmosphere is fun and lively. The food is always tasty and served in a pleasing manner. The food temperature was perfect. They have a varied selection of cocktails to choose from. Our waitress was attentive to our needs. We felt very safe there. The restaurant follows protocol for COVID-19. We will be returning soon. I highly recommend this place great food , fun atmosphere and great prices read more

Great food here, definitely a great atmosphere and it's a local staple. However, service has never been the best anytime we've gone and it always seems like we were forgotten or not a priority. Our waitress at one point was on her phone watching videos when we were waiting on drink refills. Definitely recommend the boneless wings just be sure to clarify that you want the celery and it's included in the menu, they tried to charge us for something that should be included with the dish. read more

My hometown bar, this is the place I used to watch Met's game when they used to stink and hang out for chicken wings and their great super combo basket of all fried delicious heart attack waiting to happen goodies. One one side is the 40 foot bar with the carousel animals hanging above and one the other side is the restaurant and the bacl has a great fireplace and a little sitting area. While waiting for dinner you can test your logic and trivia chops on there place mat teasers. The food is always good and the beer is always cold. Most night the place is hopping and most nights there is a band or a DJ, Great place for a first date or a night cap after the movies. Never had a bad meal or a bad experience. A must try. More recently is probably more famous for being the place next to Peter's on the premiere episode of Gordon Ramsey Kitchen Nightmare don;t let that from you trying this wonderful place. read more

Post Office Cafe - POst Office Cafe - American Near Me - Babylon, New York

Decided to go to the Post Office Cafe tonight ~ had a reservation ~ the host was very nice as we had to wait for our table for about 15 minutes because it was very busy . Server took our drink order and we waited awhile before our drinks came ~ no problem as we realized it was busy~ Our entrees came out and the food was fine ~ the problem didn't start until we wanted to pay . We asked for the check and just handed the server Elvis a gift card without looking at the check . When he brought the gift card back ( without the original check ) we asked to see the check as to leave an adequate tip And he had added a 10$ entree . Not good Elvis . We are in the service industry as well and thought this was so bad . read more

We had our twin daughters first birthday at the post office cafe! Everyone had such a great time ! food was great ! The servers who worked the party was nice and friendly ! everyone was great from the booking of the party until we left the door. Everyone went above and beyond ! Me and husband love eating here! Thank you for everything and making our daughters birthday so wonderful ! Zach and the other managera were great ! Always helpful and very fast answering my emails with questions that I had. thank you !!!! lisa Cohen read more

While this is my first check in, I've been here many times. Great vibe, friendly patrons and fantastic food. Bartender Regina is a real sweetheart and damn good at her job. Attentive, kind and conscientious--all great qualities you want in a bartender. Bring 10 of your closest friends with you. You won't be disappointed! read more

Really cool place. Warm and cozy and I can tell that it would have a cool vibe at night for drinks. I went for lunch. I would have given it 5 stars, but my boyfriend's food wasn't totally hot. Everything I had was great and I'm now obsessed with their French onion soup ;-) They have a martini menu, wine menu and plenty of beers of tap. Also was impressed by the nightly deals! Overall recommend and I will be returning. read more

See all

Throwing a surprise party for my son's 18th birthday was a BREEZE with Danielle and her staff. Everyone employed here is kind and courteous. I was able to email back and forth with Danielle about last minute changes and questions I had about the food. She replied promptly and was affable and accommodating. I hosted a buffet dinner (marinated skirt steak, stuffed shells, chicken breasts stuffed with broccoli and cheddar / fruit platter and fresh mozzarella and tomatoes) with hand-served appetizers and an open bar for guests over 21. Everyone went back for seconds and more! One of my guests is vegan and they created a special quinoa and vegetable bowl for her when she arrived. The barkeeps/servers (Zach and Heather) were on top of every aspect of the evening, serving and replenishing drinks before they were ever asked for. They hung coats, seated our guests and just made the event run seamlessly. It was wonderful to have wait staff who understood my vision for a fun (hassle-free!) party. My son was totally surprised and the staff helped with that, too. They brought him and his friends down a side entrance to the semi-private party area. It was great! The venue was clean, bright and warm (with a gas fireplace to add to the fun atmosphere)! Everyone complimented me about the food, including the cake (from Black Forest Bakery in Lindenhurst). And they sent us home with TONS of leftovers, packaging them up for us along with my son's cards and gifts. I spent about $35/person and the open bar was not too bad. I feel that the overall experience was super positive and competitively priced. Should there be another occasion for a party in our family, I will be calling Danielle again to book it here. Thank you for everything! read more

My family came to the post office for Easter Sunday brunch. We come here every year for Easter and Mother's Day. Grace was our waitress, she was attentive anytime we needed drinks or plates cleared. She was polite and helpful anytime we needed anything. We're making our reservations again for Mother's Day. The buffet had a great choice of breakfast and lunch options. read more

Poor service (really poor). Food was just ok. Cobb salad was not that good - chix was overdone, Below average at best. Reuben is thin and just ok, nothing to ever get again. The burgers looked ok. read more

1st time at Post Offie Cafe and won't be our last. Terrific pub food and service par excellent with Dillan who made sure we were well taken care off. read more

Very good service and food. You might think the place is a bar with bar food but the food is fresh and a decent quality well beyond your typical bar food. The wings and the steak sandwich are a must have. Compliment that with a full bar with plenty of tv's and you have a great place to hang with friends and watch a game no matter what the sport. read more

As the boating season comes to an end, my wife and I visited one of our favorite places in the town of Babylon. The Post Office. We have been a patron here for almost 15 years and I've never had a bad meal. Their burgers and cocktails are some of the best. The service is always extremely friendly. It seems on Wednesday nights they now have live music. Say hello to Zack the new manager. I hope you enjoy The Post Office restaurant as much as we do. read more

The food was fantastic. The mac & cheese is fresh and full of flavor. I had a delicious crispy chicken sandwich. The salads are large. Everyone enjoyed their meal. read more

Food is good every time however we ordered the boneless wings and I got jipped hard, 8 wings for $15 , that's ridiculous. If you're charging that much for an appetizer there should be at least 10 wings, that price is the same as many entrees cost at this restaurant. read more

Such a fantastic staff! Food was excellent! Zach was amazing - so attentive and kind. LOVED their coconut martinis. Can't wait to go back! read more

Post Office Cafe - Coconut martini - American Near Me - Babylon, New York

There was a kid's birthday party that took priority over people coming into dine. Over an hour wait for my dinner, we decided to get it to go. When we opened it up at home the order was wrong and already paid for the bill. Sticking with the bar at this place might be the move. read more

Not a good food experience, wouldn't try again, ordered multiple items, everything was just mediocre at best. Even the coke wasn't good, didn't taste anything like Coca Cola or Pepsi, no idea what I drank. Place looked good from Instagram, not sure if corners are being cut or what, it was disappointing though. Oh and the Mac and cheese with the bbq chicken that looked and sounded delicious, (Mac and cheese was fine) but the chicken was just grilled (and dry) with some bbq sauce squirted on top, it wasn't bbq chicken at all. read more

Such a cute little place. Got to enjoy brunch with friends. Prices are great on all the food and service was spectacular.

I came here on a Sunday for lunch. When we walked in, there was no hostess stand but we saw some empty seats at the bar and decided to sit there. The hostess stand is actually in the back, I saw this when I went to use the restroom. The menu was interesting, they had regular lunch options as well as a separate brunch menu and a shareable apps menu. We decided to share a hot pretzel, the spinach & artichoke dip, and southwest egg rolls. During brunch they have $5 sangrias & mimosas which is a good deal. I looked over their cocktail menu and saw some cocktails I would try on a future visit...that is until I asked the bartender for a straw and he told me "we don't have straws" I could clearly see the straws at the end of the bar under a tv, so I asked him again if he was sure. He then told me "well we are not allowed to give out straws" At this point I was really confused and asked him "why aren't you allowed to give out straws?" And before he could answer, an older man with a sports jersey came and handed me a straw. I think he is the manager bc he was in charge of the remote and I heard the regulars ask him to put on certain games and such, he seemed nice. I just thought that straw incident was really weird, and I still don't understand if he was joking around (he didn't seem like it) or being serious, but it was just very strange and would make people feel uncomfortable. I would totally have rated this a 4 star experience if it wasn't for that. It's just a straw, my boyfriend ordered 4 drinks, I only asked for 1 straw! Anyways, the food I thought was really GOOD! I loved the hot pretzel, it was so soft. The spinach & artichoke dip was also really good, it came with chips and pita bread, I really liked the pita bread. My boyfriend said the south west egg rolls were good too. It was really crowded at the bar halfway through our meal, no empty seats, and everyone was watching the Giants game and really into it (except my bf, he wanted to watch the Rangers game). Seems like a fun place (older crowd tho) for Sunday Funday but bring your own straw LOL read more

See all

Came here for the first time Saturday and will be returning! Had James as my bartender, what an amazing man! So sweet, had an amazing conversation. Handled the crowd like a champ! read more

One of my all time favorite Babylon spots. Love to go here to watch sports games, have drinks or even eat. They have something for everyone. The bartenders are amazing and so friendly. The food is always top notch too. They have the best pretzel with cheese dip I've ever had at any restaurant. They always are rolling out new specials and different foods so you gotta keep an eye on that! They also have one of my favorite nights in all of Babylon, lifeguard night! They get an awesome crowd throughout the entire Tuesday for the entire summer. This place really is great for just about anything your looking to do, watch a sports game, grab some food, have some drinks, it has everything and a very large bar read more