We stayed in town and saw this pizza place pop up. It only had one other review but it was a solid…read more5 stars, so I figured we'd give it a try. I'm so glad we did. We got a sheet which has 24 square pieces and it was delicious! Great customer service, we got there before it was done so he said he'd bring it out when it was ready. He did so and was wearing a mask. We have 4 kids, 2 young and 2 older teens and they all liked it. Nice chewy crust, sauce that isn't too sweet (I'm not a fan of sweet sauce). I would have preferred more pepperonis on such a large pizza but that's not worth knocking off a star.

The gentleman who answers the phone is incredibly friendly. Great first impression. This is our…read morefave local pizza especially because of the quality of the toppings! The pizza is presented as you pick it up which is a meaningful, classy touch. Thank you for your devotion to the details Fratello's!!!

Great pizza! We were just passing through and decided to grab some takeout. The pizza had the…read moreperfect amount of sauce and cheese, and the thin crust had just the right amount of chew. We really enjoyed it!

Paid $40 for pizza that was completely burned on the bottom (including $3.50 each for small…read moredrinks). Since I saw the cook checked the bottom of the pizza, and box it up, I assume they care more about closing on time than quality. Not a repeat for me.

Very good pizza,as close to Brooklyn pizza you can get up here. Their sandwiches are very good as…read morewell. Highly recommend. Excellent service as well.

Great NY style slices! Not much to choose from at the Mall, but there is still pizza!read more

Ok wow. From the outside you wouldn't know your about to have the best garlic knots ever!!…read more Inside is quaintly decorated in an Italian theme, Our waiter was fine and answered our questions. Honestly the best part is the food here, everything we got was amazing. The only down side was no Coke Zero

The pizza is decent and it is nice that you can just get a slice. There is some seating inside,…read morebut not a ton, and also a few seats outside. You order at the counter. I would grab a slice here again, it just wouldn't be my top choice.

The pizza here is delicious and the slices are huge! Truly one of my favorite pizza places. My…read morehusband and I also got subs the last time we were here and they were also gigantic and really good! You order at the counter and then your food is brought to you. Everyone we interacted with was friendly enough. The ambiance is similar to your typical fast food place. Definitely recommend if you are looking for a good slice of pizza!

Still cranking out some of the best NYS style pizza in the area. Went for lunch on a Saturday…read moreafternoon. Packed. Tables full. Line by the door. Thankfully, we were seated promptly. Locals know where to go, and when we return for a visit, no trip home is complete without a pie from Aniello's. Mangia, mangia!!

Great spot , always a line out the door. The vodkaroni & the creamy Alfredo are to die for. The…read moreprices are really solid for the quality - ambience wise it is a bit loud for basic conversation but not horrible. Overall if you're in the area this is a just visit

Amazing pizza. I wish they were open every day. Yummmmyyyy yum so delicious I can't wait to go back…read moreand get another meal here Yum!!!

There is no better option than Horseheads Picnic Pizza. I am a chicken wing pizza fan, and these…read moreguys knock it out of the park every time I go there! The service is amazing. You are always greeted with a smile. Great atmosphere. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone looking for great food!

Paid over 40$ for a large pizza with pepperoni, half sausage and a large soda. Expensive for no…read morereason.

4.5 stars We stopped…read morehere on our way down from Niagara Falls. We were hungry and in the mood for pizza. Rico, the owner, recommended the Big Game special - which was a large cheese pizza, 10 wings and garlic knots. Garlic knots (at least 8, maybe 10) were fresh and coated in a delicious buttery garlic sauce. The pizza was decent, fresh and cheesy. I prefer my NY style pizza to be super crispy on the bottom, and this one came out normal. The wings were the highlight: steaming, freshly made and large. I hate paying for dinky small wings and these did not disappoint. The service was even better - Rico was very friendly and promptly brought out food, plates, waters for us, etc. When we first pulled up, there were some friendly state troopers having lunch here, so you know it's well enjoyed by the locals! Definitely worth a visit! Tip: the marinara that came with the garlic knots was yummy and great for dipping pizza crust too, and Rico was nice enough to give us some extra garlic dip that the garlic knots came in. Great dipping sauce for pizza crust!

I had to visit beautiful Horseheads, NY for work. Each town I visit I must try the pizza. I chose…read moreto go with the plain cheese but they had a bunch of flavors ready for the lunch rush. Cheese was good and sauce was decent. They could have left the pie in the oven for at least a few more minutes. It was a little doughy. The place was clean and the staff were friendly. Not a bad place to grab a slice.

First thing I noticed when I walked in here was the Calabria poster. That gets you an extra star in…read moremy book. As usual I tried a plain cheese . I also got white slice. Plain cheese was very good. A little flop but not too bad. Nice sauce and good cheese. The white slice was ok. A little too much ricotta but overall was decent. They had a great menu of Italian food. I noticed all the customers there ordered a bunch of things besides pizza. Everything looked good. I would go again.

Hi , Absolutely disgusting food I said to my girlfriend just…read morethrow it away . Breadsticks were fused together with the cheese that erupted out of them and the pizza was bland with poor quality cheese that wasn't even fully melted . Cheesesteak was so dry and the roll ha . I can go to the grocery store and buy mozzarella sticks and and ellios pizza that would put this place to shame . 26$ and it's in the garbage .

Ordered a meatball sub , with cheese and we got meatballs a roll and no cheese and no sauce on the…read moremeatballs. Disappointed Staff pleasant

Went into Sopranos for the first time yesterday, and as soon as I walked back to the deli to order…read moremy food, I was completely ignored by the blonde staff member sitting on her phone. Very upsetting. But, after I was finally helped the food was quite delicious!