First thing I noticed when I walked in here was the Calabria poster. That gets you an extra star in my book. As usual I tried a plain cheese . I also got white slice. Plain cheese was very good. A little flop but not too bad. Nice sauce and good cheese. The white slice was ok. A little too much ricotta but overall was decent. They had a great menu of Italian food. I noticed all the customers there ordered a bunch of things besides pizza. Everything looked good. I would go again. read more

Vincenzo's Pizzeria - Plain cheese and white tomato slice. - Pizza Near Me - Elmira, New York

For this area, pretty average (horrible food in this area). Compared against food spots in general, not good. Positive was fries were crispy even after sitting in container for 15 during my ride home. Pizza has some sort of really strong cheese flavor that is non typical and over powering. read more

Delicious, quick, satisfying. Went back for seconds. Will definitely return whenever I'm in town

Excellent food, delivered hot and fresh. I ordered a meatball pizza, an antipasta salad and a grilled chicken salad for delivery. Joey my delivery driver was very courteous, professional and efficient. I will definitely order from Vincenzo's and request Joey again read more

We have ordered from here many times because the food is awesome and have never had any issues .. called as usual for a delivery and one item was a chicken cheesesteak with mushrooms onions and peppers. The person taking the order then in an arrogant voice said "I don't make it like that, I put lettuce tomato and onions on it" I said excuse me? he then said "I'll make it this time" so I let it go gave my card info and then the line went dead he hung up on me! I called back and a different man answered. I explained what happened and asked who that gentleman was he said my boss I said the owner? he said yes. I made sure the order was being made for delivery and told him the owner needs an attitude adjustment. Vincenzo's pizzeria has lost my business. read more

We ordered the Vincenzo's specialty pizza togo opened the box before leaving, and it was much smaller than the the 18 inch pizza displayed on the counter. I asked them if it was the same size and they replied Yes, but it could've shrunk a little when putting it in the oven. .OK, whatever sounds good. Also, my daughter found a few long hairs in the pizza when we got back. Definitely not the most pleasant experience. read more

We came here to try out the pizza in the area. This one was recommended on one of the Facebook pages, Elmira area restaurants. The staff was very friendly and seem to know who their regulars are when they came in. We ordered a large pie and it came out right away because they just had one fresh out the oven. My daughter loves pizza and definitely approves this place. We will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Vincenzo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elmira, New York

See all

Best pizza in the area. As a transplant from NJ it's one of the only pizzas we eat. The crew is always helpful and nice.

Great, quick service. WiFi to work while I eat. Phenomenal food! One of the best cheesesteaks I've had in this area. read more

Vincenzo's Pizzeria - Cheesesteak loaded with mushrooms and onions - Pizza Near Me - Elmira, New York

Online menu shows two slices plain pizza and one order boneless wings are about $13.00. I was charged $21.50 and told their online menu prices are out of date. That's an understatement! read more

Best pizza in Elmira. Also, appreciate that they sponsor the River Sharks. If you're searching for NY style pizza, this is the place.

Made a quick stop here on a long drive. Found this pizza/sub joint on Yelp and it was exactly as advertised. I ordered two sub/hero sandwiches to have a good sample. The turkey hero was fantastic. Full of meat and veggies and slightly warm. The second was a chicken parm hero. This one was good but not as good as the Turkey. The chicken was slightly over cooked and dry. Luckily the red sauce made up for any shortcomings. Both sandwiches came with perfect cooked fries. All in all this a good place for subs/ hero sandwiches. The pizza also looked fantastic but I did not try it. read more

See all

Excellent thin crust New York style pizza. Oh, their white garlic pizza and cheese calzones!

my first stop in my hometown. incredible all around. consistent through the years, fast paced and friendly. 12/10

Had our 3rd large white garlic pizza with in 3 months. One word to describe the pizza is FABULOS. It was light backed like we asked and the staff came thru again,Vinnys staff know what there doing they are great and very friendly. Thank you so much. read more

Great subs! A bit smaller then a normal sub but the roll is amazing! I drive all the way from Buffalo just to get these subs (I also purchase extra rolls when visit). The rolls are a must eat! read more

Right in the middle of town, old school pizza shoppe. Been there twice in a week for a quick lunch while working construction in town. Very good thin crust New York style pizza..... read more

Nothing bad to say here. The place can get a little crowded at lunch time. Pizza is probably the best in Elmira. Top 3 for sure. Hot meatball sub is amazing read more

Great pizza! Perhaps the best, no it's the best in town! Great variety of toppings. They usually have at least one unusual pizza available by the slice. Casual atmosphere. Modern music, but not so loud that you can't talk. They also serve classic glass bottle soda. Usually pretty clean, though they often get busy. A little pricey compared to chain pizza, but way better! So worth it! Tasty subs and salads too. read more

Vincenzo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elmira, New York

See all

The pizza is fantastic! Good salads and garlic bread. The pastas are pretty watery and bland, the only thing we've ordered that we were unhappy with. Customer service is always very friendly and quick delivery. read more

True thin crust, well seasoned pizza like you'd expect in NYC. I just wish it had more space because it's usually crowded when I go in at lunch and everyone is struggling to find a place to stand read more

Don't let the fact that that this place is in an old strip mall. They have the best pizza hands down in the city of Elmira. And don't forget to order an antipasto salad. read more

Pizza is a tough business and I am not easily pleased with so many options around. I like their pizza good sauce, hand tossed crusts, but I've gotten some almost raw, always underdone for me, and never a crisp crust. Subs and fried foods are good. I'm a big fan of their cannoli, if I catch it on a day the crusts are crisp and fresh. read more

Randomly stopped in Elmira while we were on our way to Buffalo and had their pizza here. The NY pizza is alright, but the service was meh. The cashier couldn't crack a smile and worst of all, he handled the pizza with bare hands and used the same hands to handle cash. Not very hygienic if you ask me. read more

Vincenzo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elmira, New York

Must stop when in the area, Vinnie has been making pizza for decades and their attention to detail and favor makes this a top location. Sometimes I have the sausage and peppers that are cooked to perfection in the pizza oven for that complete experience. read more

Great food! I'm from Buffalo, NY and this was the best sub I've ever had. The fresh bread puts it over the top! Great prices too and all the the employees were very welcoming and friendly. read more

Pizza has funny taste. Like parm. Was put on it. Not enough sauce. Just not my favorite

So I been in Elmira for a little over a month. I have tried a bunch of different pizza places Gino's, Pudgies, O.I.P. and Vincenzo's. This is by far my top ordering location!!! Pizza is amazing and I usually order the calzone with ham. Calzones are 7.00 and a lil more with ham and ONLY one size.. The food is just breath taking! Whatever they do with the dough is great! Ricotta and mozzarella are amazing as well. There chicken cutlet parm sandwich is amazing as well!! No I wasn't paid to leave this review as I live to let people know what's good and what's boo boo. I only wish their delivery minimum wasn't ya have to spend 15.00. I would order more often!!! Also hey guys ya should make a small and LARGE calzone sizes like other pizzeria joints in the neighborhood... (just a idea) read more

I called for 4 pizzas delivered to my hotel. Had I known how long the delivery would take, I would have ordered breakfast pizza. When the pizza finally arrived all of them were over done. But at least they were tasty...tasty bad. read more

Best pizzas in the area. Usually a nice selection of slices available and great menu items for take out. The dining room is basic but clean and friendly. read more

My daughter and I came in for a quick bite tonite. We didn't know what time they closed and we got there about 20 minutes before closing. Big Mike was steering the ship tonite and he let it be known it was no problem that we were there so late. Everyone in the staff was super friendly and accommodating.. My daughter got a slice of garlic pie and I got an Italian sub. Surprise! It came lightly toasted and with delicious fries on the side . We stayed till after closing and nobody stared over our shoulders tapped their foot or looked at their watch. Big Mike has a great crew they look like they truly care and enjoy their work even when they were cleaning up to go home. I've eaten at greasy spoons and restaurants where the soup was $20. But when u have a balance of great food AND great service, yeah, you deserve a five piece all day and all night. Delicious food, great service, friendly employees. The only thing I can say that's negative is I wish I didn't live an hour away! read more

The crust on the pizza at Vincenzo's was good, but all other aspects of the pizza were mediocre. Overall, I would say that the food here was edible, but truly nothing special--nothing that would inspire either of us to want to return in the future. The service was adequate, too, but definitely not friendly or welcoming. Granted, we were there during lunchtime, but the place was not busy and could have used a bit of cleaning, too. read more

Worst calzone of my life. Ordered a buffalo chicken calzone that was completely soggy and had no buffalo chicken sauce in it, I'm pretty sure it was canned chicken. I never write reviews of any restaurants but this calzone was so terrible I NEEDED to write this. read more

Nothing to write home about or quit eating mom's food. The ambience was not up to my standards. I am a stickler for cleanliness and I wouldn't come back because of that, but the pizza was really good. Was it worth $3.50 a slice? I'll leave it up to your imagination. read more

See all

Was working across the street, I asked my coworkers where I should go to lunch and got enthusiastic reviews I went in and ordered the meatball park, came with fries if you eat in. The roll was very tasty, the meatballs and sauce we great. I will definitely add this to my Elmira lunch rotation read more

Took a short ride off I86 for dinner and found a local gem. Our meal started with a delicious garden salad with a homemade dressing, which was very flavorful. Our pizza was loaded with green peppers, fresh sausage, onions, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese, with a very nice crust. Crust was flavorful and not thick and doughy like many local places. Our pizza maker and host extraordinaire, was well versed in local history, and aside from being an excellent chef, was a wonderful ambassador for his town. If you are thinking of stopping in Elmira for food, skip the fast food joints and stop here. You will not be disappointed. read more

Saltiest pizza I have ever tasted--hard wings without much meat--also highly salted. 1 small cheese pie -one medium plain cheese pie--2 orders of wings --over 60 dollars-- clearly no repeat business from me read more

Their pizza was fantastic. Their subs, not so much. Only had their thin crust pizza which was very good. The sub (Philly cheesesteak) had meat that was impossibly chewy and the roll was tough. Other subs family got were so-so. Get the pizza. read more

Great pizza! Probably the best I've had here so far. Mushrooms were great and the sauce tastes really good. The meatballs on my pizza were crumbled and it tasted heavily of breadcrumbs so I think I'll pass on the meatballs next time and just get a mushroom pizza. read more

One of better Pizza places in the Elmira area! Prices might be higher than your local chain pizzeria, but this is REAL pizza. Around $14.50 for an extra large. It's a NYC style of pie. Nice and thin. They also have a two slice special for $5 dollars; if your in a rush. Been in there a few times. The Staff is friendly enough to serve pizza, but seems like they rather be elsewhere. I'd order from them again. read more