This was a carry out experience. I chose the Mediterranean. The sandwich had grilled chicken, feta, zesty hummus, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and cucumbers. I got the combo so my chips were salt & vinegar and for a beverage an unsweetened iced tea. I liked the sandwich overall. I think just the small size next time as I ended up with half left from the medium to have for another meal. The tea was tasty and you can't go wrong with salt & vinegar chips. read more

I appreciate coming by this spot for lunch: a bottled or fountain soda and a turkey or tuna sandwich. We usually stop here for a quick bite and a cookie craving. Parking can be a bit busy and tight. However, if you have patience or don't mind street parking and a short walk, you'll have no problem. Friendly customer service and tasty bread. read more

I like Potbelly. I've tried two different locations and both were friendly and fresh tasting. Each sandwich I've tried has been good. Portions aren't huge but they're ok. Price is average for the type of restaurant. I like the set up of the stores and they're comfortable. Not my #1 pick for sandwiches but they're pretty solid. read more

Great sandwiches, great meats, I always order double meat and double cheese oh, sooo scrumptious....... L read more

Had the Steakhouse Beef sandwich. Really good. Liked the bread, it's different. Macaroni and cheese was just so so. Panera has a better Mac and Cheese. Had the Oreo shake and it's made with real ice cream. Would come back again. read more

Potbelly - Mac and cheese, Steakhouse Beef, OREO Cookie Shake - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

The cleanliness of the store was a little suspicious which had me wondering of the cleanliness of the food which followed with "was it something I ate" while hiking. read more

Fast, great service and lots of choices Convenient location. Decent pricing and plenty of seating read more

Huge delicious sandwiches. Sweet potato fries are the bomb. Gyros enormous. Indoor outdoor n upstairs dining.

Love the food and service. Kayla is quite good! My order is always correct and waiting for me to pick up!

My first time at one of these and I was pleasantly surprised. My Mediterranean sandwich was tasty and full of veggies. They seem to be following covid carefully (indeed three individuals without masks tried to enter and they were promptly turned away). For a chain, a decent lunch and several options for us vegetarians read more

The food was GREAT!!! The sour, bitter, mad, annoyed face of the manager there on 7/1/2021 says everything about this place. She doesn't greet you and when she finally does - she treats you as if you're bugging her. I felt bad for the girl she was training. I can't imagine being trained by her. Overall, I would order here again....but for pickup. And!!! Only because it's across the way from out hotel. Otherwise. I'd never step food in this place. Ever. read more

The sandwich was good....nothing special. The lady adding condiments was kinda rude and she kept coughing, which was a major turn off.

This sandwich shop is located in a little area near I-25 with a couple of other lunch options around it. The parking lot was getting pretty packed (it is spring break) but we did find a spot right in front pretty quickly. There were no other customers when we first got there and we were greeted and not rushed. There were signs giving directions on where to go to order and the menu was easy to read. My husband got the pizza melt on flatbread the way it usually comes (he said it was good but rated it 6/10) and I got the roast beef on white bread (8/10). We also ordered our daughter the mac n cheese kids meal which she enjoyed. The employees were nice and mentioned if our daughter found a hidden object in the shop she could get a free cookie (she didn't attempt to find it). I feel like its a great place to grab lunch to-go (if you order online you can pick up from a cubby right when you walk in). read more

See all

Wonderful food and amazing service from management as well as the employees all working together to get my last minute large order ready in a very timely manner! Loved the atmosphere, the food, and the service. Definitely recommend. read more

Highly recommend this cute sandwich shop. The two girls working there were so nice to my boyfriend and I. Must try the shakes and cookies! specifically the oreo shake and the oatmeal chocolate chip raisin cookies:) read more

I ate here a couple times last week I would definitely recommend the Italian! Also anything off the hidden menu is great!

I love me some Potbelly's and I was super excited when I found out that they had a Potbelly in Fort Collins (I previously have only had them in Utah). The food was exactly as I wanted it. I get an off menu supreme veggie, with bacon (I know, I know). Their shakes are pretty killer, as is their brownies and cookies. I'd give this place five stars, but the staff. I think the only place I've seen slower service is at the DMV. I literally watched a guy put one piece of meat onto the sandwich at a time. Ever so slowly. This is still somewhat fast food.. It needs to be fast. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Service was poor. The person behind the counter was rude and didn't even get the order right. Even after asking twice. Sorry to bother them during their work hours. read more

I work really close to the shop and tend to go there often! Friendly staff and amazing food!!! I am glad there are options for everyone here :)) love love love!!! read more

Great food, sandwiches and soups! Portions didn't match the bread but the taste weighed more!! I will return!!

Just ordered chicken salad sandwich and there was barely any on the bread only in the center and maybe a teaspoon of chicken If I was at the restaurant I would take it back Chili as a side no crackers and just ok read more

Horrible customer service, gave us a hard time because they thought our kids might be over 8 ordering from the kids menu. I asked if the kids could see the soup (because my kids are picky) and he told me no I can look at the menu (with no photos). Difficult to order because you can't see what any of the food looks like prior to ordering. We had a group of 6, meatball sandwich was cold meatballs toasted on the bread and they added sauce after. Turkey and cheese sandwich had no cheese and one slice of turkey. (See photo) Mushroom sandwich had a total of about 1/2 a mushroom on it and absolutely no flavor. Soup tasted like canned soup. Kids ordered grill cheese which turns out it's toasted cheese, kids were not happy with burnt edges which left them with little to eat. Overall lousy overpriced food made by people with an attitude. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I just went and ordered the A wack sandwich, I've had great ones in the past, but today, the meat tasted awful. I was going to call, but why would I want another sandwich? I even gave then a tip. I'm very disappointed. read more

We have wanted to come here for some time, and finally made it last weekend! It's a sub sandwich place, and I ate a huge delicious salad, while my mom had the soup and sandwich combo. The place was clean, the staff friendly, and we got our orders quickly. A nice shop to eat at! read more

This is a nice cozy little sandwich shop. They do have other options other than sandwiches. They have soup and salads which are very large portions. No Gluten free bread options. They have bottled drinks as well as fountain. Items are made to order and to go. They do have some sweets available such as cookies, smoothes and some ice cream. Seating area is open and comfortable. Good place to bring kids. Parking lot is easy to get to and there is parking very close to the door of this shop. read more

See all

Twice in a row had to wait more than 20 minutes after the stated pickup time for an online order. They don't prioritize online orders until you're there for pickup apparently. It's more than a little frustrating to watch hoards of people come in after you, place and receive their order long after you placed yours online. If they can't handle it, they should stop taking online orders and promising pickup times. read more

Walked in and said hi to the guy behind the counter. He just stares at us. We order 2 salads and a joke of a kids meal. The chicken salad salad was weak. There was two tablespoons maybe of chicken salad on top of a lot of lettuce. The dressing packet was bitter for balsamic. The two guys working are just doing nothing while the girl worker is walking around cleaning windows. This place is a waste of money and what is more awful is being so hungry and having such a cafeteria looking Hospital meal in front of you to eat. It will be good when this shop goes out of business and a good sandwich shop comes in it's place. read more

Customer service was below par. Wife and I ordered the same thing, yet her sandwich is MUCH smaller in length. Was charged for 2 bigger sandwiches though. Mac and cheese is way over-cooked. The sandwiches are about as big as a wrap, not much to them. $20 + for what?? Won't be back. read more

First time in pot belly tonight after lots of friends telling us to go. We loved it! Austin, Wesley, Sophie and zach took good care of us. Will be back soon! read more

Absolutely the best sandwich shop ever and their milkshakes are the bomb! We ate at potbelly often in VA and super excited to have one in our Ft Collins area and right across the street from my work! Oh yeah..... and the Broccoli and cheese soup is absolutely amazing!! Yum yum yum!!! read more

I placed an order for pick up. It took them over 30 minutes to get me my food. Meanwhile others that walked in and ordered received their food within minutes. Then when I did get my food it was all wrong and they had to remake it. The staff and ESPECIALLY the Manager were very RUDE! They saw me standing there with my kids and didn't offer explanation to why it was taking them so long to make! I do NOT recommend at all!! read more

Solid 4 stars for now. The employees are pretty nice and friendly. When I went in the line, they got everything right. When I made my first pickup order through the app, they didn't do so well. I was missing a side for my sandwich and I asked for a coffee shake with Oreo in it. There was no Oreo in my shake. I didn't have time to say anything, but I'm going to give them another chance soon. Hopefully they'll check things twice before they send them out. I love the Italian sandwich and their pickles are yummy. read more

Yes yes yes! I'm so happy Potbelly has made its way to Fort Collins. The sandwiches always taste fresh and are perfectly cooked. The staff is friendly and inviting. The price is PERFECT, in fact cheaper than most sandwiches shops that provide the same types of sandwiches. I've gone here 3 times in the past week. The atmosphere is fun and it's always busy. That being said, even when they're busy I find that they stick to their service promise of 8 minutes or less through the line. Also, I love that they offer both Pepsi and coke products. read more

I work right across the street from this shop and have been ordering from them since they opened. Food is great, however, it is expensive. A bigs sandwich and chili cup delivered across the street is almost 18 and some change. On top of this, they just raised the minimum delivery fee to 13 bucks? Sadly i won't be getting lunch for 18 dollars any longer. At that price, I will sit down and have someone bring me food to the table. Seems like a common thing here in Fort Collins. read more

The first two times I went to potbelly I liked it. Basic sandwich, decent soup. And I love a sandwich on my Saturday afternoon. But the last two times they have been SUPER stingy with the meat! I mean ridiculous. I got my husband both times, a tuna and I got turkey. They measure the meat, and that bugs me, but I literally got less than a whole slice of turkey! And a tiny scoop of tuna spread so thin my husband didn't know what kind of sandwich I got him!!!! I won't go back. The sandwiches are basically just bread. read more

Overpriced for the food quality, friendliness and customer service very poor. For the price we could have gone to a sit down restaurant!

Watch out at lunch time, lines can get a little long. Other than that, great spot. Recommend this shop if you like hot sandwiches.

Love their sandwiches and soups! I work nearby so I've been coming since it opened. I usually get the chicken salad or the grilled chicken and cheddar. My kids love the shakes and smoothies with the mini cookies around the straw. Love the enchilada soup! Gets packed at lunch and has outdoor seating but with DC Oakes next door parking can get tight. Love adding the hot pepper to all my sandwiches or you can grab some next to the register. Affordable and delicious! read more

Potbelly - Enchilada soup with onions added! Delicious! - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Lots of hype around FoCo for the open of this shop. Went in with my family and super open minded. Simply put Cheba Hut is miles above/better. *Hey five star folks--- check out Backcountry Deli in old town for. Real sandwich spot. #backeastsandwich read more

Great variety on their menu. Friendly service and a clean place. Just what we look for when visiting our son at college. A must every time. read more