This is a fantastic B&B! Only here for one night, I wish we had booked two. It's a great property well located and immaculately landscaped. The main house and the guest house are very comfortable, appointed with nice furniture & accessories. Hospitality from the owners is exceptional. Great breakfast too! read more

See all

Unfortunately, we were only able to spend one night at the prairie house - as a girls 1/2 weekend! The room was perfect for us for one night. If we had stayed longer- it may have been a bit crammed. Beds were not super comfortable but worked! Walls are very thin- as expected in a bed and breakfast. Breakfast in the morning was wonderful and they were beyond accommodating to our nutritional needs! So thankful for that. They do have a cat in the main house. As someone that is deathly allergic to cats- I wasn't able to go into the main eating area. Luckily, the weather was great! And we were able to sit on our patio where they served us breakfast! read more

The hospitality was really excellent-- nice people doing everything very well. What a nice break from nasty chain hotels that allow animals. Fortunately, none of the latter here. Good to know a filthy dog was not in my room the night before. We'll definitely return to Prairie if we find ourselves in the area again. We'll done, folks! read more

Prairie Guest House is one of the most unique accommodation options on Indy's northside, for a few reasons: + This bed and breakfast is located in a restored 1850s farmhouse, with spacious guest rooms and unique decor in each. + Fresh, homemade breakfast made by the owner John each morning in the guest house with an original L.S. Ayres tea room table and a bright porch where you'll want to spend the morning. + A yoga studio on-site, available to guests for a $10 drop in fee or to the general public. Owner Karen teaches! + Convenient location in Fishers across from Conner Prairie, one of the top local family attractions. Can't speak highly enough of the homey, personal experience you will get staying at Prairie Guest House. read more

See all

I can't say enough about John and Karen's absolutely delightful BNB. This is a BNB akin to what I remember from my youth - full of quaint charm, coziness, warmth, and absolutely scrumptious comfort food to match. Every morning (for about a week), I would jump out of bed eager to zip next door to their gorgeous breakfast quarters to see what chef (and owner - he was donning multiple hats while we were there during COVID season) John had created. The first morning's masterpiece was a quiche that I shall never forget. Beautiful settings combined with fresh cream and scrumptious teas and a different fresh country breakfast prepared especially for us each morning - heavenly is the only word to describe it. John had a delightful way of filling us up with lovely conversation, yet also giving us space while our coffee and tea soaked in. Karen has done a beautiful job of decorating the Prairie Guest House, and Karen and John's cat Fiona added to the charm. I slept wonderfully well there! My husband and I stayed in the Bransfield Room and enjoyed the private patio just outside our door. When I heard a bit of noise from above, a fan was delivered within minutes. There is a shared small refrigerator in a common area of the house that we conveniently used. I also appreciated many of the books that are kept around the home. Self-check-in easily accommodated our late-night arrival. The location was perfect for us, close to my in-laws whom we were visiting. Everything we required could be found nearby. I plan to stay here again and again. It is just the perfect combination of privacy, charm, and adorableness. Thank you for a really wonderful stay, John and Karen! read more

See all

The egg casserole for breakfast. The chocolate mint tea. The yoga studio in the backyard. Walking distance from Conner Prairie. Historical decor and feel of the property. All of it. From the minute I made my reservation with Prairie Guest House they made the experience so warm and meaningful. This new addition to Fishers boasts a historical and rural flair that makes you feel a world away from the city. The rooms range from two twins to queens with en suite bathrooms. Each of the rooms has a unique flare that stays in line with the history of the home. In the communal spaces of the house you'll find a hefty book collection, stationary and Kuerig coffee cups. Yoga classes are offered throughout the week but you can also schedule private classes. The full breakfast is offered on the weekends and kicks off at 9am with juice, coffee, tea, jams, eggs, bacon and potatoes. Their egg casseroles are filled with veggies like asparagus and zucchini. Note: they're aiming to convert the barn into a venue in 2016 for events (perfect setup for intimate weddings). read more

See all

Excellent getaway destination for our anniversary! My partner and I loved the homemade pancakes and omelets with homemade blueberry syrup, and we had a wonderful restful weekend together in the lovely Frederick room. Super spacious bathroom and a huge comfy king size bed. The Guest House is also right across the street from Connor Prairie and restaurants are all over the place, so there are plenty of things to do! So glad to have found this gem of a place for a little stay-cation just north of Indy! read more

Prairie Guest House - Dining room and coffee bar - Guest Houses Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

My wife and I had an excellent stay here earlier this month. We were in town for a family gathering, but all of the bedrooms in our family's houses were full, so we needed accommodations. The room was a bit tight but entirely comfortable, and it didn't matter because we spent very little time in the room (looking around the morning we checked out, when most of the other rooms were empty, it appeared that there were several rooms that were more spacious). We were arriving late at night, after their office hours, but the hosts were able to accommodate late arrival, just leaving the key in the door for us upon Breakfast is served in a cottage across the way from the historic building with the guest rooms. The food was flavorful and in reasonable quantity -- choice of teas or coffee, an orange/cranberry juice, a few strips of well-cooked bacon, a couple of pieces of sweet bread (mostly date bread), saute;d potatoes and onions or on one morning broccoli, plus an egg course that was different on each of the three mornings -- once it was an omelet, once a quiche, and once scrambled (I ma no a scrambled eggs fan but this worked for me). read more

If you are a business traveler or if there is any chance that your plans might change, stay away. They are completely inflexible. In today's world with so many options, you should stay where the owners understand that things change, and they want you happy. Being a small business is not an excuse for poor customer service, particularly in the hospitality business. After traveling all day, I arrived around 9:00 in the evening. There is no one on premise to greet guests in the evening and no one answers the phone after 4PM and they apparently do not listen to messages until it is convenient for them. There is no way to reach anyone. The next day they returned my calls and shared that they expected me the next day. Probably my bad but I would have loved to have spent the night there if someone had been on site or answered a call. I had no choice but to find another place to stay that night. I understand them keeping the deposit, but they refused to refund my payment because I had not canceled EIGHT DAYS in advance. They are quick to say that they strive to give each guest a pleasant experience, but they do not back that up. They rank as the least customer friendly, inflexible business I may have ever worked with. After trying multiple times to get them to refund my payment, they pointed me to their rules and refused. read more

I had the pleasure of staying at Prairie Guest House this past weekend. I found this bed and breakfast to be beautifully quaint, quiet, and inviting. We stayed in the Atkinson room which was tastefully decorated and very clean. I loved that it had a back door that led directly onto the wrap around porch. Yes, the hotel was beautiful, but another important factor in my five star review was the staff. Both Tami and her husband, James, were friendly and super accommodating. And did I mention Tami's cooking? One would think that an omelette is an omelette and potatoes are potatoes, but the way Tami prepared breakfast was oh, so delicious! As we ate our breakfast we tried guessing the ingredients so we could try it at home. Luckily for us, Tami generously shared her recipe for both her omelette and potatoes. Just good, down home cooking! If there was one down side to our stay, it would have to be that our schedule didn't allow us to stay longer. Next time we visit (and there will be a next time), we will definitely extend our stay. read more

This review is for the new yoga studio! What an adorable space. I just love the wide windows and airy feel. Beautifully repurposed to help you get centered and find your zen. Located in the guest house side of Conner Prairie, the studio is a perfect addition for guests looking to get a flow on during their visit. read more

What a wonderful mini-getaway for Hoosiers! I went for girls night in February and it was a lovely stay. I appreciate how they really preserved the historic architecture in both the guest house and the main house where the kitchen is. Breakfast was delicious. It's a set menu and an employee gets your meal started as soon as you sit down. They had it ready pretty quickly. The rooms were very comfortable and they even accommodated to us wanting to have all six of us girls stay in the same room together by providing a roll-away bed. The bathrooms had been tastefully renovated. If I lived in Fishers, this would be a perfect way to have family stay close by when they visit. It would also be a perfect set up for a bridal party the night before a wedding. read more

My husband and I have stayed here twice. The staff is great, the breakfast is yummy and the rooms are spotless! I hope to go back!

I had the opportunity to stay with John and Karen for three months to learn about the hospitality business, and their hospitality is truly second to none! They are the warmest, kindest, most accommodating people you will ever meet. John and Karen are passionate about what they do and the guest experience really reflects that. The whole staff at PGH is incredible, from the sunshiny Amber at the front desk to Heather, Dawn and Grant who are impeccable housekeepers. (Plus there's Fiona, the best feline innkeeper around). PGH has a 'home away from home' feel to it. I hope to come back for a visit soon. read more

I stayed at Prairie Guest House for one night while visiting a friend in the area. The B&B is easy to get to, with lots of parking, super cute and immaculately clean with all the creature comforts & amenities. Breakfast was absolutely delicious. There are lots of stores and restaurants within driving distance. I'd return in a heartbeat! read more

Prairie Guest House - Scrumptious freshly-made breakfast - Guest Houses Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We got married at the Prairie Guest House. The owners, John and Karen, were great hosts! All of our guests had nothing but great things to say about their stay and about the wedding. I really can't say enough about how happy I am with our experience. read more

What a wonderfully quaint place to stay. I stayed here during a ladies weekend. Although, I had driven past this place plenty of times I had no idea this place existed. Although it is on a busy road once inside you feel like you are staying out in the country. The rooms are clean and tastefully decorated. The building next to the house is where breakfast is served and was avaialbe to hang out in later in the evening. The breakfast in the monring was fantastic and it was so much fun to sip tea and sit in the sun room. They also have a yoga studio on site. We didn't get a chance to attend a class but I would love to in the future. read more

Warm and inviting. We were looking for something more comfortable than a hotel and we definitely found it. Our room was exceptionally clean yet not sterile feeling and pleasantly decorated. The bedding was super soft and comfy. We appreciate the personal touches as well. Great stay! read more

This is a wonderful place. We found it last minute on Yelp. Karen and John are lovely people. I wish I could have taken advantage of Karen's Yoga knowledge. John makes the best breakfast ever! read more

Beautiful rooms and beautiful property from the outside out. I would recommend it to everyone. I did specifically let the hotel know about allergies to tomatoes and strawberries and yet that is what they served. Please please please follow up with them. read more

I can't say enough about this cute little B&B. The owners are sweet and welcoming, the food is delicious and the room is gorgeous. I can't wait to stay again! read more

A wonderful place to stay. Interiors were well appointed. The check-in greeter was very helpful. The meals provided by chef was outstanding. I l love the quality and ambience of this Inn, I highly recommend staying here! read more

Had the most wonderful and relaxing stay. John and Karen are extremely gracious, generous and kind owners. Thank you for everything! . Lynn

Beautiful appointed rooms with comfortable beds. Updated bathrooms with wonderful towels. Coffee machine and refrigerator available for use. Several gathering areas and breakfasts are delicious. read more

My wife and I stayed over last weekend at Prairie Guest House. John and Karen's Hospitality is superb. They are very responsive to their guests needs. It is a warm and friendly atmosphere. John's cooking skills are great as well. Highly recommended. read more