It's so hard finding good restaurants to eat on this side of Brooklyn but I'm glad I researched alil harder and found this gem! Because we were about to celebrate my 18 year old nephew at olive grdn . & my dad is hard to impress sometimes but he was VERY impressed with our food experience here. It wasn't super packed in here on a Monday night as expected so service was pretty good. We didn't know until the end of the night, our server was the owner. It's very chill and dark in there, the decor inside is simple but nice touch with the waterfall wall. Now for food.. I kept it simple with jerk chicken with rice n peas, it was nice and flavorful but I wish I got it with the pasta though. My husband got lobster pasta and I couldn't stop eating off his plate, it was probably the best thing we all ordered. My nephew got oxtail Mac and cheese and that was great as well, they just give you like 4 likkle pieces of oxtail though. Mom got the steamed snapper, was nice a soft and full of flavor. Dad got the honey glazed pork chops, and he enjoyed it. We also had a few drinks, beers, they were decent. Hoping the owner updates their site and menu online so people can know all the great things they offer here! Overall, everything was great! I'd def be back someday and highly recommend! read more

See all

This venue can benefit from more space, more seasoning, and a much better DJ or at least one that is willing to make some slight adjustments. High top tables are not comfortable and can only seat 4. The alternative is all the way in the crammed back space near the kitchen and bathroom traffic. (Yuck) Only one bathroom I might add. Horrible!!! DJ played quite a few dated, corny, very commercial music. PLEASE omit that and add more reggae and soca!!! Oxtails & Mac get a 7/10. More seasoning and sauce please! The salmon also 7/10. There is absolutely no need to destroy fish with an overly sweet glaze. I want to taste salmon not a lollipop. Ask for the glaze on side to dip unless you intentionally want to mask salmon with syrup! A lemon & basil glaze would be ideal. The drinks were fair. 8.5/10 for drinks. They can also use another waiter. He was forgetful, frazzled, could have been more attentive and reached OVER guest heads to hand plates! Big NO NO! Move around and to the side but do not handle plates over a patrons head! Basic etiquette 101. The place has potential, overall good vibes, fair happy hour prices. read more

Prime 623 - Salmón - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Mixed feelings about this place. Had an 8:30 reservation, but initially sat at the bar, but since there were wasn't a hostess I asked one of the servers, if we could sit at an empty table behind us. She said yes, but it was lukewarm, which actually was her entire demeanor, as she was our server. We cumulatively ordered salmon with mashed potatoes, ackee and salt fish, Parmesan fries, fried rice and for dessert cheesecake and red velvet. The salmon was okay, the mashed potatoes tasted like Idaho from the box, but the broccoli was good, unfortunately l, they only gave two pieces or so. The dessert was good and so were the drinks. The environment was Great-- the DJ had a wide array of music, both old and new school, of all genres. The backdrop waterfall I would say is a nice touch for photos. Overall, it was an okay experience. Not sure if I would return though. read more

See all

The food and atmosphere was very nice. Our host was the bomb. We all had a nice time. I was able to dance and celebrate my birthday there. It was about 12 of us. read more

Stopped here for a girls link up and we had a great time. The music was a vibe, great service and good drinks. What I ordered was cool but nothing I haven't tasted before. I had the esvotich fish with rice and peas. We tried the crab cakes and shrimp wantons. The fish had Great escovitch vegetables, fish was overcooked but full of carribbean spices. Rice was ok. The wantons was deelish but had to much sauce for me. The crab cake was a bit salty but came with a healthy salad which cut the salt. Prime 623 is a good local bar with a great vibe. read more

See all

Arrived here for a drink on a weekday night and was met with a bouncer who proceeded to check my identification, search my bad and patted my coat down. My friend with me asked" are you sure we came here to eat?" . I had the same sentiment The atmosphere is very lounge clubbish with high top tables and chair and the bar. We ordered a number of items: crab cakes, mussels, wontons and stew snapper. The passion fruit margaritas tasted like medicine hitting the back of my throat immediately with whatever syrup they use so the waiter was gracious to take it back and exchange it. The replaced drink wasn't any better but I drank it since the waiter was so nice. The best thing we got was the crab cake which was full of crab but for 22 bucks it better be. The food here isn't bad tasting but it also ain't mesmerizing, it's like eating at a regular West Indian food joint. read more

Prime 623 - Wontons - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I came here to have a girl's talk drink with my friends. I ordered a Frośe and Pineapple Habanero. My friend ordered Herbed French Fries and soda. The ambiance was nice. It was nice and cool inside on a hot day. My friend went to restroom and there was no toilet paper to be found:-(. When my wings came out. The did the ultimate offense. They "wings" came as all drum pieces. Unfortunately like most I am a flats gurlie. So it felt like they were passing allllll of the unwanted drums to me. I would not have minded if they gave me a mix but oh no. I won't be back. The Frośe was okay. read more

See all

This is a great restaurant that's always worth the trip to Carnarsie. I've been here a few times and had a great time each time. I love their Nortorius 6.2.3 frozen drink. I've been here for "Wine Wednesdays" for a couple of glasses of wine. I love the food here! From the Mussels to the Calamari to the Shrimp Tacos to the to the Ackee and Saltfish Tostones to the Salmon with mashed potatoes and vegetables. I enjoyed every bite! The servers here are attentive and deserve their tips. The DJ here plays great music that keeps the place lively and engaged. The restaurant is the perfect size with a cascading waterfall against the back wall. I'm looking forward to coming back! You get free shots here from time to time if you're lucky and exude lively behavior. read more

See all

My uncle and I stopped at Prime 623 to get a bite to eat. He's been there before, so he wanted me to try it out. Nice spot to chill and watch sports. The fruit punch was good, and the salmon tasted fine with the crispy skin. My mashed potatoes were okay. it could've been hotter, just my preference. Asparagus was cooked right, maybe a little more on the plate, though. My uncle enjoyed his food as well. The waiter was cool and attentive. We didn't have to wait long, like I've seen from other reviews. There were people at the bar, and as we came in the one table was leaving. So, I couldn't say how the service would be when there's more people. Overall, not in my neighborhood to frequent. However, security was very hospitable. He seemed like a good genuine dude. read more

See all

10/25/23: Decided to return and give a second chance. So glad I did. This time around all was amazing and on point. Our server Trishan was on point at all levels. Friendly, engaging, knowledgeable and all round good time. Note: place is on the smaller side reservations highly recommended. Drinks: wow the rum punch definitely smacks a punch Wray n his Nephew totally present in that drink. Food: was going to take away a star because the wait was a bit ridiculous but food was very flavorful and delicious so couldn't in good faith lower the stars. Appetizers: Ackee and Saltfish well seasoned and yummy Fried shrimp wantons equally yummy. Great flavor in the jerk chicken tacos. Would love to see this in a salad. My escovitch fish was huge taste wise I had no complaints. My friend ordered the lamb chops OMG that jerk flavor hit all the taste buds. As I'm compiling review thinking if they Uber eats to my home. Dessert we had the cheesecake not the best I've ever had but it understood the assignment and did its job for our palette. This night in particular live music on deck. Performer definitely had folks rocking in their seats. Their Halloween decorations were pretty good. All in all great time had by all. Def check it out! read more

See all

Great drinks and ambience Definitely recommend 10 out of 10 recommend Wings were great too read more

I truly feel locals have low expectations on restaurants because why is this place 4 stars ? This place gets busy . The music can be ok at times (depending on your taste) but the SERVICE ? Its horrendous . 5 of us sat . We all ordered the smallest things and EVERYTHING came one by one , with 20-30 min increments - my friend literally ordered sautéed vegetables and didn't get it for an entire hour after ordering , not to mention the food is flooded with salt & the false advertising. I ordered lobster mac n cheese and veggies, I got a bowl full of mac n cheese and 1 lobster tail buried beneath it all . Salty food and ridiculously long wait times. Once my friend finished his calamari the OTHER FRIEND GOT HIS VEGETABLES , ONCE HE FINISHED HIS VEGGIES I GOT MY FOOD - it really didn't make any sense - we were just watching every table get pieces of their order. Long story short I honestly wouldn't do it again - I hate poor service. read more

See all

Food and drinks were amazing. Service was, eh. Not bad but the bartender was the server. Only one on. Seemed annoyed by everything. But the food was so good I'm definitely going back. read more

I dined here last night. The space is a small neighborhood gem. Soca and R&B to jam to while you drink and eat. The air was not working which is why I gave 4 stars. Thankfully, I travel with a hand fan. I ordered the blackberry margarita, mussels, and fries. It took over 40 mins for my food to come. I almost didn't notice because I was enjoying the music. Once my food finally arrived a third of the mussel shells were empty. However, I informed a lady I didn't know was the owner at the time. They took a few dollars off my bill and the owner and I did a shot. Nice gesture. The only negative I have is the gratuity was included. I wasn't aware. For someone who sat at the bar, the bar tender wasn't too attentive. It took 40 mins to notice I hadn't received my food and not that he was super busy. I'm a tipper so I would've tipped...but accordingly. The owner asked how long I was in town and suggested I return before I leave the city. Her hospitality and that of security would get me to return. Nice spot with an unexpected warm welcome. read more

Prime 623 - Flavor Margarita Blackberry - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Amazing everything was great about it definitely going back. The lobster was very good drinks was xtra strong and the D.J was on point

We had Ackee and Saltfish Tostones Buffalo Wings BBQ Wings Prime Pan Seared Salmon Filet Mignon Cocktail THE NOTORIOUS Cocktail made for me by the bartender Marley I thoroughly enjoyed everything I tried, except for the steak. The steak needed a little bit more seasoning for my liking..Must haves are the jerk chicken tacos, fried chicken, wontons, calamari, and salmon. Marley the bartender did his thing with my cocktail based on my flavor palette strong, sweet flavorful. The DJ was really good. however, towards the end the service could've been better especially for amount we didn't. But I will still come back to try other food items and also their drinks as well for happy hour. read more

Definitely a lovely spot. DJ was spinning them tunes and the drinks were strong. Hookah available The food was good with a likkle kick of heat. read more

See all

I recently heard about this place. They recently opened in November. So we came to try it on a Friday night. The place was crowded around 8 pm but crowd grew more. Not an extremely large space, but decent size. High top tables and bar space available. Lower tables in the back. we were told upon entry that ordering apps at the bar would be 30 mins and entrees at least and hr so we ordered a bunch of apps. (This was not the case) Food: 9/10 Prime festival mussels: the sauce is amazing. The mussels were cooked well. I recommend Fried shrimp tacos: (serving of 2) large grilled tortillas with fried shrimp in a jerk mayo with mango and cabbage slaw. Honestly could have used more cabbage. Flavor was not my favorite. But okay Jerk chicken taco: (serving of 2) large grilled tortillas. Chicken is well seasoned and juicy and served with mango chutney and cabbage. I have the same thoughts in this that more cabbage should be included as the tortillas and large but not a lot of filling. So you're essentially eating tortilla by itself at certain points. Grilled shrimp was my favorite. Very tasty, light seasoning but yet so juicy and flavorful. I personally would not serve with tarter sauce. Maybe opt for jerk sauce or idk a soy ginger or garlic butter. Ambiance: great music playing (old dance hall/ reggae, old & new R&B). Loud enough to vibe to but not good for intimate convos fyi. Decor is nice and simple yet inviting Staff: extremely friendly. Not the most attentive though. But I will say again it was busy and they seem like they are trying to work out a seem less flow. It took entirely to long to be served drinks and food. 20-30 min for a drink. 1hr+ for apps. I'm going to say it's because they are still getting into the swing of things. I will definitely come back as this place has great potential. The staff are so great and friendly and the food I tried is worth coming again. Hoping there is a better process in the upcoming months. Rooting for y'all! read more

See all

I came here with my 75 year old mother not knowing it's mostly a younger crowd. She loved it! The Manager was kind and accommodating. He made sure we were having a good time. Even the security guard took care of us. The bartender knows how to pour, ok! The drinks were so good I would've had more if I wasn't driving. Between 3 of us we had the jerk chicken tacos, parmesan, fries, mango habanero wings, and lobster with the creamy pasta. Everything was good! I need that pasta again. The DJ is a nice added touch. He played all genres of music. We sang, we ate, we had a great time. It's a really nice addition to the neighborhood. Will be returning for Brunch. And they stay open til 2AM on the weekends! Just go! read more

Prime 623 - Habanero wings. - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here midweek during the afternoon for lunch with the family and it was a nice surprise. Been hearing about this place from friends. It was pretty empty when we came in but the music was still on point with a chill vibe. If you like strong delicious drinks, then Omar is your man. They were on point. For appetizers we had the jerk chicken taco and they definitely were on point. For main I had the escovitch snapper, hubby had the pork chops and my mom had the salmon. Everything was just absolutely delicious with the right combination of spices. My mom cleaned her plate which she never does when we go out lol. read more

See all

This was my first time here. All of the food was incredibly good. We had the chicken wings with Buffalo sauce, the pasta with lobster and the jerk chicken tacos. Everything was delicious. It was happy hour so drinks were also discounted. They were just right. Not too strong, not too sweet Service was good but it could definitely be improved. It was a long wait for a menu and a server. It took multiple attempts to get the attention of the bartender or server. read more

See all

The food was tasty, the server didn't engage much but I guess that's because they were one of the only ppl working and had to work the bar as well. The second time I went I had a different server but they also didn't engage much I guess because there was a table with a larger crowd keeping him busy. Outside of that, it's a cool spot to visit the drinks were okay as well. Just on the pricy side compared to other local places. Overall, I'd go back again. read more

This restaurant is truly a hidden gem. Checked it out the other night with some friends and enjoyed the entire experience. They state on their website that it's fine dining, a great ambiance and good vibes and they didn't lie. The space is nice. Caribbean music was bumping. It was definitely a vibe. Drinks: Went with the Ginmonade and the Old 623. The first is gin, muddled berries, lime Juice, triple sec, simple syrup; light and refreshing. The latter is their take on an old fashioned with a 6 sec pour of whiskey, 2 dashes sweet vermouth, 3 dashes of bitters, simple syrup, garnished with orange peel and cherries. My friend ordered the Old 623 and enjoyed it. They had their own bottled wine that they wanted us to try. We had one of their red blends and it was delicious and paired well with the meal. At the end of the meal the bartender brought a trio of flaming shots. A green tea shot, blue kamikaze and a red spicy shot. I had the green tea shot and my friends had the others. We liked them all and the presentation was cool. Appetizers: We started off with their pineapple habanero wings. They had the perfect balance of sweet heat. We all loved them. Next up were the fried shrimp tacos d with guacamole, mango slaw & jerk mayo. They were super flavorful and tasty. Entrees: We ordered the Prime lamb chops. They were grilled and marinated to perfection and served with mashed potatoes and asparagus. We also ordered the grilled Maine lobster that came with mashed potatoes and their Prime butter sauce. The two together was delicious surf and turf. We also ordered the Alfredo pasta and topped it with grilled salmon. Every dish was delicious/ Dessert: We ended with red velvet cake served with a sparkler. They had 3 slices for each of us. The cake was decadent and delicious. The entire meal was great and the service was excellent. I highly recommend going there. Follow @ms_new_foodie on IG & @msnewfoodie on TikTok read more

See all

Craving Jamaican food my friend and I came here on Monday night. Inside is small but beautifully decorated. For a Monday night the bar was empty but there were people seated at almost every table so I could see how they get very busy and packed. The menu is quite limited and very small. There's really not enough choices but I was able to find some stuff to try. My server was sweet but definitely not attentive. I received my drinks fast but the food was another story. We waited at least 30 minutes for our appetizers we had to flag our server down to ask her where's our food or just cancel it. For you not to notice your customer didn't receive their first course after waiting sometime, no bueno. When the food did come out though it was tasty, everything was spicy as hell. We finished our water trying to wash our food down and again no one even came over to refill our glasses until we waved someone down. I did not like the rum punch the Wray and nephew overpowered the juices. It wasn't tasty just strong something you would probably enjoy if your at round 2 not while your dining. The entree my food was really good but my homegirl escoveitch fish was not. Though fried very well and a good size snapper there was basically no vinegar flavor on the fish nor season as well. We was able to get it removed off the bill and the owner friend got me a drink on the house. If service and food quality improved I could return but for now no they need to get it together. read more

Prime 623 - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great experience. Inviting ambiance. Food was very good. And service was quick and easy.

The spot is a little vibe, with bigger vibes as the night goes along. The windows are blacked out from the outside. Once you enter the spot's decor is sleek black and grey, with a water accent wall. 3 tvs, so sport fans will be entertained during sporting events. Music is cool and vibey. Food is prepared good. Service was efficient and pleasant. read more

See all

I'm here on a Thursday. They have happy hour mon-thurs 4-7. Prices are good. The place is small. However, the vibes' service and food are definitely hitting the mark. A dj is here playing a mix of r&b, hip hop, soca, and reggae. I had the jerk tacos you get 2 for 7 for the happy hour. I had the parmesan fries and an order of mussels with the garlic toast.i had the sucker punch for my cocktails. Very strong worth the price! The server Bella is very attentive and friendly! I'd come back here again mid week read more

See all

Visited this bar/ restaurant for my friends bday. Walking in the ambience if nice, water cascading water wall, high top chairs and tabletops, at the back there's a few standard chairs and table. The space is small so it can get crowded really quick, there's a love DJ, so it's not the space to conduct business but to have a good time. Our waiter and servers was extremely polite and friendly, answered any questions we had about the menu. We ordered the bbq wings, corn on the the cob, fried shrimp, grilled shrimp, Parmesan fries, mussels and Ackee and saltfish. The broth in the mussels was a bit to salty, the fries was soft and didn't taste fresh, the corn and wings were amazing those were the top foods. The down side about the space is trying to eat while random strangers are standing above your table while you try to eat have some conversation and the wait time just to get a drink is extremely long. It's a cool space overall if you're looking to hangout, hear some good music or watch a live sports game. read more

Prime 623 - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I wanted to treat my sister and cousin and pulled up for Mothers Day dinner, and it was super busy. The owner, Tanisha, had an inviting smile and placed what presented as urgency to seat us. We waited about 30 minutes before being seated as a party of 4 adults and 2 kids. I came for the Saltfish and Ackee Plantains, and unfortunately, we didn't get any, as they were sadly "out" of it for the night and highly pushing the Mothers Day Menu. The fried rice (not pictured) is bussin' delicious. Lambs mashed potatoes could've been a 10 but I can't place my finger on what's missing. Tacos tasted lightly toasted last time Overall Food was 7/10 as you will leave full. read more

See all

New hot spot in the neighborhood and it's amazing. Love the ambience and the food is delicious. The owners are friendly and inviting. We had a great Friday night enjoying the Music. The vibes is nice and comfortable. I definitely recommend you check them out. I suggested making reservations for large groups. They get packed fast. read more

Texroy (server) was amazing!!!! Food was good s f drinks even better!!! Highly recommend!!

10, 10, 10s across the board! Called to make a reservation, no one answered. I left a voicemail and received a call back within the hour. Booked the reservation with ease. Nice ambiance. Greeted warmly upon entrance. Had small talk with the owner. And now the food.... Hands down worth all the coins it snatched out my purse that night. I sampled everyone's meal and was not disappointed. Def would return. read more

Friendly staff, good food and vibes. Dj on Tuesdays, but any days is good...All Day Happy Hour.. read more

Prime 623 - Jerk chicken tacos, shrimp traits and jerk corn...also recommend the Henny wings... all delicious. - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is a whole vibe. Went Wednesday night and From the time we walked in we felt welcomed. The ambience, staff, food, DRINKS and music was on point. Our waiter Justin was pleasant and helpful. Go check this place out. Shrimp tacos 10/10 lamb with mash potatoes and asparagus 10/10 read more

Prime 623 - shrimp tacos - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The space is small but well decorated and the DJ was on point with the music, which was a mix of afro beats, old school r&b and hip hop. They do ID you in the front before entering. Our waiter was very helpful in answering questions and getting our order in. For drinks, we had the primarita, the old 623 and the sucker punch. They have some of the best drinks I've tasted thus far. For appetizers, we had the grilled jerk corn and shrimp tacos, which were both well seasoned and had a nice sauce at the top. The appetizers did however take a long time to come out. For entrees, I had the prime fried rice with shrimp, and my friend had the half a jerk chicken with mashed potatoes and asparagus. The food tasted good but we did wish they had more options on the menu overall. Other things to consider: there is one bathroom for everyone and happy hour is only Monday through Thursday. Overall I would go back for a happy hour. read more

I enjoyed my time at Prime 623. The food was really good. The salmon was very tasteful and well cooked. The mash potatoe was just the perfect side for it. I enjoyed the ambiance as well. I went on a Monday afternoon and the DJ had us dancing! We were definitely on our toes. The service could have been better. It was a staff outing and it took a long time honestly for us to get our drinks and some of my colleagues had to keep asking for their food. Will I go back? Oh yes! I loved everything else about the place. read more

See all

Went here for fight night... I ordered a mango margarita. I git tequila, sprite and orange juice. The place looks good, they have a dope vibe but th drinks are trash. read more

My husband and I met friends here last Saturday night at the bar and were very disappointed since food took forever to come out and there was only one guy working behind the bar, it took forever for us to get his attention to get a drink, he came back to me 4 times after to remind him what the drink was. I was hesitant to order another Don on the rocks 2 lime wedges, Henny on the rocks and a Red Bull but I did , I watched him eventually pour 2 drops from an empty bottle onto ice and hand it to me. Terrible! Worst $20 drink I've ever had and the service was worst! Prime do better! Hire more/ better bartending staff since the location, Dj music and decor is great! read more

First of allllllllll I need TEN stars for this place!! Came here for my sissy's bday and this is my #1 spot now! I am veryyyyy picky about food (bcuz I'm a caterer and I'm a foodie), but Prime623 takes the prize! Let's start with service... from the door, to the bar, to the table, EVERYONE was very nice... and everyone was together like clockwork.. It's not a big place so I suggest making reservations... also I wouldn't rate it as kid friendly just bcuz in my opinion, it's the perfect setting for "adult time". The vibes were official!! Nowww the food... O. M. G!!!!!! Listen here.. from the apps, to the meal, it was DELICIOUS!! You don't taste "seasoning" or "salt".. u taste FLAVOR!!!! In every bite it was FLAVOR!! We had the pineapple habanero wings , the jerk chicken tacos and the Parmesan fries... the entrees were Lamb chops and Jerk chicken. The chicken was falling off the bone! (It was authentic jerk, I'm a Jamaican lol). The lamb chops were amazing..(I personally would go for a little bit less on the rosemary), but all good!! The drinks were perfect.. Had the Rum punch and the Primerita. Our server Nancy was theeeee BEST.. and Evens was on top of everything that was needed in that place! Very attentive to the guests... you never had to look for anyone.. they were always there. If I had to ask for any area of improvement here, it would be one simple fix... the music was a bit too loud.. to the point where even the bartenders had to shout across the bar. A couple notches down and it would be fine! I have to say this was money well spent, and I will DEFINITELY be making this my go to spot. Thanks Prime623 for a GREAT night!! read more

My cousin and I were looking for a spot for our bi-weekly dinner date. She sent 3 locations. As soon as I saw the photos for Prime 623, I told her "Let's go here! It looks like a vibe!" When we walked it, it was definitely a vibe!! Our host, Trish, immediately greeted us and seated us. When I asked for a cocktail recommendation, she suggested the Primerita and said she'd ask them to add extra berries so I'd have the sweetness I craved. The drink was delicious. We ordered appetizers (mussels and shrimp) and our entrees (lobster and salmon). After about 45 minutes we were asked to move our seats to where ever we'd like because the table we were at was reserved. As I looked around, the empty restaurant we had walked into, was now packed. Our only options were the bar or by one of the table by the front door. I was already cold (disclaimer: I'm always cold) so by the front door wasn't an option. So the bar it was. But I am never comfortable dining at the bar. I only have appetizers and drinks at the bar. So we canceled our entrees. The Manager was gracious enough to comp our drinks for the inconvenience. That is the only reason I did not give it 5 stars. The appetizers and drinks were great. The service was exceptional! And just the energy was everything. This place is close to home, so I look forward to returning and trying the food. read more