I'm a tall, mostly skinny guy in my 40s with a bit of that dad gut, so finding shirts that feel comfortable and look flattering can be tough. I own button-downs from brands like J. Crew, Brooks Brothers, Ralph Lauren, and Bonobos, but most needed tailoring after the fact, and even then, they weren't quite perfect. I actually came across Proper Cloth during a ChatGPT conversation about finding clothes that fit my body type. Well, the robot knew what it was talking about, because my experience with Proper Cloth was excellent! I'd never done the made-to-order thing before and wasn't really sure what I was doing. I started with a basic light blue chambray button-down shirt and made a few small tweaks, like swapping the default single patch pocket for double button-flap pockets to give it more of that workwear vibe I love. I clicked to create a custom size, did their questionnaire, and made a few manual adjustments--like adding a bit more length to accommodate my long torso. Some measurements I knew, but most I didn't, so it felt a bit like rolling the dice. However, I saw that Proper Cloth offers complimentary adjustments if something isn't quite right, so I placed my order and hoped for the best. The shirt arrived today, and wow! I was honestly blown away by how perfectly it fit, even with some of my manual tweaks being educated guesses. Their sizing algorithm is no joke. The fit was slim through the body and arms but not tight. I had full range of motion in the shoulders, and the high armholes kept it tucked in well even when moving around. The length was perfect--intentional when untucked but still long enough to stay tucked. The chambray fabric has a durable yet soft feel, like it's already been perfectly broken in, and the whole garment just feels quality and comfortable. This shirt feels special to me because I got to play a role in its design, from the custom pockets to the tailored fit, and that's not something I've experienced before with off-the-rack clothing. The site was easy to use, and even someone with little to no tailoring knowledge like me could navigate it and end up with a stellar result. To top it off, the shirt arrived a couple of weeks earlier than expected! Speaking of the shipment, this was the most eco-friendly packaging I've ever seen from an online clothing order. The box was cardboard, as was the bag the shirt came in and all the bracing inside. They even included a self-adhesive return label, which I didn't need because they nailed it on the first try. The attention to detail, environmental consciousness, and convenience were super impressive. I'm stoked to buy another shirt from them and would absolutely encourage others to give them a try! read more

I recently purchased several shirts from this retailer, and I'm thoroughly impressed with their exceptional range of shirt fabrics and style options. The selection includes everything from classic cotton and crisp poplin to luxurious blends like Egyptian cotton and linen, catering to formal and casual preferences. They also provide a variety of patterns--solid colors, subtle stripes, bold checks, and even unique textures--which makes it easy to find shirts that suit my personal style and professional needs. The fit is another standout feature. Unlike many off-the-rack brands, their shirts are impeccably tailored, with precise collar, chest, and sleeves measurements that ensure a flattering and comfortable fit. I opted for their custom sizing option, which was straightforward to navigate using their online guide, and the results were spot-on. Their standard sizes seem thoughtfully designed to accommodate different body types without feeling restrictive or baggy. The attention to detail in the stitching and construction further enhances the overall quality, making these shirts feel like a premium investment. The combination of diverse fabric choices, versatile designs, and consistently perfect fit has made this my go-to for high-quality shirts. I highly recommend them to anyone looking to elevate their wardrobe with pieces that balance style, comfort, and durability. read more

I recently ordered 2 flannel shirts from Proper Cloth. Oh, by the way, I am a woman. So to be clear, Proper Cloth will make shirts for anyone. In my case, I sent them a tailored (man's style) flannel shirt that fit me perfectly and added 2 details that would make a new shirt even better. I selected 2 flannels from their collection of fabulous fabrics from around the world. In my case one Scottish and one Italian. I got the first shirt back, in beautiful, eco-friendly packaging, with a request to try it on and make sure it fit as I desired. Proper Cloth instructed that it would be a bit bigger than the shirt I sent because the 100% cotton flannel would shrink a bit. They requested I launder it and try it on again. At that point if anything needed to be adjusted, I COULD SEND IT BACK TO BE ALTERED AT NO EXTRA CHARGE. Are you getting that? I could wash it, and still have it altered free of charge. This shirt cost $100. You cannot beat that price, quality, integrity, standing by their product ANYWHERE. Go for it, and look fabulous. Oh, and they do not make both shirts at the same time. They make the first, to see if the original measurements will remain, then they make and send off the second. Dealing with customer service is like dealing with your fairy godmother. read more

I decided to order a couple of Proper Cloth dress shirts for a wedding I was attending in Italy. Prior to placing my order, I took advantage of the fact that the site offers you the opportunity to send in shirts for measuring (so that the shirts you ultimately order will have the exact fit that you want). The entire process, from start to finish, was absolutely seamless--I sent in my favorite dress shirt, as I really liked the fit and wanted to use it for my future orders, it was properly measured and sent back to me (for free, I might add), and when I was ready to place my shirt order, everything turned out incredibly well. I mean, right out of the packaging, everything fit perfectly! And after having the shirts dry cleaned (the shirt dimensions shift a bit after the first couple of washes), everything still fit perfectly! All in all, I couldn't be happier with my purchase, including the wide range of shirt customizations that Proper Cloth offers. I think it's safe to say that I've found my new custom shirt order site, and I definitely plan on placing more orders in the future--thanks again, Proper Cloth! read more

I been a strong supportive client since 2017. I'm up to 76 shirt orders and could not be more thrilled. Today I called in because frankly I lost a lot of weight and I needed to revisit some sizes from 2019. I found the shirt that I wanted but I could not find the size that I wanted and the actual measurements. Therefore I called in, and they were so helpful and so giving and even reminded me that I had one free remake that I never took advantage of. Long story short, I called in for one shirt, and I left with four. Love you guys! It is so easy, so clean, so well fitted, done perfect the first time virtually every time, and the quality can't be beat. I had a conversation with a gentleman on the phone about trying other companies in person and Online and just could not compare to the quality, the fit and the finish of Proper Cloth. If you're a clothes horse like me, the detail that they asked for is significant, but I'll tell you it's worth every second you spend putting that together. You're fit will make you look like a million bucks. Thanks PC! read more

I love Proper Cloth. I wouldn't think of getting a dress shirt anywhere else. Why would I? Proper Cloth has everything. Their selection of fabrics and styles is several factors of 10x greater than any department store or online offering. The shirt fit perfectly every time. Instead of hunting through the racks I can scan through hundreds of beautiful fabrics on my computer. I can select from a multitude of style choices for things like the collar (button down or not, collar width, collar points directly below my chin or off to the side). Similar variety for cuffs, the placket (where the shirt buttons), pocket(s). They've got shirts that are price competitive with store-bought and they've got shirts with expensive and luxurious materials. And when I get the shirt, if I'm not quite happy with a style choice, they will gleefully remake the shirt for me. Why would I get a shirt anywhere else? Proper Cloth is too much fun! read more

I've ordered several shirts per year from Proper Cloth for probably 10 years now, and every one of them has fit perfectly right out of the box after one wash. I won't buy shirts from anywhere else. I should add they all have lasted well for all these years with day in and day out wearing. PC is a blessing for those of us with unusual shirt measurements. The distance between my neck and my wrist is extremely long, so with every single store bought shirt, even with the "Tall" sizes, the end of the sleeve end up landing ridiculously at the middle of my arm. The only drawback is I get people asking me all the time where I get my shirts from, evidently they look good. I don't buy the shirts for the looks, and I don't like getting noticed, so this is why I say "drawback."Ultimately though I see these as compliments to PC for making a d*** nice shirt. read more

All these years, and finally I am learning all about tailoring, cloth, all the little details of style choices, buttons, collars, plaques, hems, pockets, etc. They replicate the measurements you give them perfectly, but getting those choices correct is surprisingly tricky, and that is why they give a free redo. It takes engagement, thoughtfulness, effort. Once you nail it, the result is a revelation. Wearing any garment that fits perfectly, terrifically, and the material is exactly the material you love and admire, and all the style details are exact as chosen, well, its like being rich and it feels so good. Best of all, it costs no more than any similar garment from a top company, but what you have is what you chose, a top fascinating wonderful fabric and perfectly made to fit you and your style. I mean, seriously, its perfect. read more

Stop what you are doing, break out a measuring tape, and get a shirt made. How many shirts do you own that don't fit quite right, that are not put together quite right, or that aren't quite the right color? Enough to make up the difference in cost of getting the perfect shirt every time? You bet. Do it. Even if the first shirt isn't perfect, the experts will work with you to get the fit just right and discount your next purchase, and that's only the beginning! The ONLY shirt company that lets you can add half and inch to accommodate your wristwatch. The ONLY shirt company that will let you specify a soft collar for your business casual Oxfords. The ONLY shirt company that will make you shirt to fit your body and needs exactly right. Working with them is like working with a high-end personal tailor. Just do it. read more

I had an excellent experience working with Gem at Proper Cloth. From the start, she made the process easy, professional, and enjoyable. She picked out the right clothing for me, answered every question thoroughly, and gave spot-on suggestions that fit both my style and needs. What stood out most was how personalized and thoughtful her guidance was--it wasn't just about recommending clothes, it was about helping me build a wardrobe that really works. Thanks to Gem's expertise, I ended up purchasing more pieces than I expected, and I already have ideas for future orders. The virtual help was exactly what I was looking for, and Gem absolutely exceeded my expectations. She's top notch, and I'd highly recommend her to anyone looking for great service and styling advice at Proper Cloth. read more

You can basically specify every dimension of the shirt -- yoke width, sleeve length, chest, waist, collar size, cuff size. Then you can choose collar style, placket style, cuff style...and even the angle of the collar front-to-back. And if you want: pocket(s), locker loop, split yoke. You can also specify where you want the second button to start -- an inch closer to the top is what I have been choosing, so that you can leave the top two buttons undone without looking like a disco guy. Then there are the fabrics.... As a skinny guy with a 14-inch neck, but with 35-inch sleeves and wide shoulders, I need to wear a custom shirt. These shirts, once you get it dialed in, are dead on, and at that point you can choose among styles and fabrics and still get the same fit each time. read more

customer service has been pretty good thus far. my initial shirt order when received was not exactly right, however they allowed two remakes. The second remake)was perfect in every way, and it came back promptly. i sent it to the cleaners to be pressed with light starch and it fits perfectl. My only concer is I ordered two of the same shirts, one "White, one " Black" and I haven't received the black shirt yet, it's been two week??? I think the value is reasonable for tailor made shirts if it within your budge. if you shop Nordstrom you'll pay $150+ for a well made dress shirt that is not tailored to your body, and you'll be stuck with whatever type of collar, sleeves, excess material etc......I paid less for a tailor made shirt fit for my physiqu! read more