Great first impression, our dishes came out executed well and tasty! We will certainly be returning. We typically go to Columbia Family Res. up the road, but their lobby was FULL and out the door, and we didn't wanna wait. Noticed PROSPECT DINER was nearby and thought we'd try em Got the chicken & biscuits, and she got the chocolate chip pancakes. We both thought the home fries and pancakes were great!! This place is smaller with a limited menu comparatively , but we found the service to be comparable if not better, as well as the food and price. Can be a bit loud when the staff and regulars recognize each other and catch up, but we found that endearing - nice ambiance ! We will be returning to try out more of the menu! read more

When you walk in, the first thing you notice is the cleanliness. This diner is from the 50's and they manage to maintain a clean environment, including the restrooms. Most of the servers are friendly to the point you could joke with them. Everything that I've eaten there has been good, hot, and quick to come out of the kitchen. From first appearance as you drive by isn't all that impressive like a large chain restaurant, but all the locals know this small family diner is the go to place read more

This is a quaint little Diner on one of the main roads to York, PA. It's hours are limited to breakfast and lunch...pretty much 7am-12pm, the menu is down to earth good Diner food at reasonable prices. Service was very good from an out-front staff of 1 server and a young lady helper. She was hopping and very efficient, also knew the menu well. The coffee was hot and fresh, many of the locals there have asked the owner to not change it, just keep it coming as is. I had creamed chipped beef over seeded rye toast and a side of bacon. My husband had the ham and cheese omelet, rye toast, and homefries. If we are out this way again, we'll be sure to stop by. They do it right. read more

See all

I have eaten at the Prospect Diner 3 times in the last 2 years and every time it's been excellent The diner doesn't look like much from the outside but inside it's very clean and pleasant The menu is limited to mostly breakfast cooked to order and very reasonable I'm looking forward for my next visit read more

Love this little diner. MaKe sure to check out the specials on the chalkboard behind the counter before grabbing a booth or a stool. Booths are old and the seats were comfortable 20+ years ago but i guess that adds to the classic space and vintage vibe. The menu is creative -- only breakfast here--and the prices are very reasonable! The food is the star of the show, it's actually just delicious. Specials are creative and the rye bread/toast is an absolute must order! Hours are limited, the regulars will be at their habitual stools, the staff is friendly, definitely worth the stop on this busy stretch of road. read more

See all

I passed by this diner as I was driving somewhere, and decided to pop in. I'm so glad I did! It is a super old-school diner, but clean and nice! The waitress was welcoming, friendly, and attentive. The prices are fantastic. Menu had lots of options. Food was brought out quickly, and tasted good. Basic, but fantastic. I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

I've driven by this roadside diner for years and resolved to wake early and visit for breakfast today. I wasn't disappointed by the friendly service or the very large and good omelet. We shall return for another great meal. read more

Prospect Diner - Southwestern omelet - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

See all

Who doesn't love a diner? I've been driving past this no-name diner for the past year marveling at the number of cars I'd see in the parking lot each morning. Had to be a good place, right? Right! Decided to try it for breakfast while my son was in town last week. He ordered pancakes and I ordered the omelette from the children s menu. (My only other option was a FOUR EGG omelette! ) His pancakes arrived. They were light and fluffy-- and the size of a dinner plate. So delicious! My sweet little ham and cheese omelette was accompanied by a single piece of buttered toast and some fried potatoes. Delicious. Never ending coffee refills. For those who want up know, the diner was spotless and the atmosphere reminiscent of a time we all miss. I'll be back! read more

Nice old school place. Open only for breakfast (maybe other items but closes at noon). The booth seats are suffering from too many years of big'ems crushing the springs, but you won't mind much since the food is great. Daily specials that are creative and well-executed, but your regular staples as well. The servers aren't your average wait-trons these days and actually seem to like their jobs. (Hell, who wouldn't with a 5 hour work day). They wear company shirts with,"This ain't no stinking country club." Imprinted, but don't take offense, just don't look for champagne or caviar on the menu, but if you wanna a good breakfast without getting brow-beaten by a miserable sever, highly recommended. Eggs Benedict, omelettes and specials highly recommended. read more

We are so glad we stopped at this local hotspot! Wonderful people, great food, served fast and with a smile. Great sausage biscuits with gravy, grits, and eggs. Also seasonal specials. Don't hesitate. Just go! read more

For years I've passed this diner, which has a sign featuring a .99 cent breakfast weekday mornings. I was always intrigued but never stopped. Many times it didn't appear to be open. Other times we were on our way elsewhere. The outside is totally 1950's and it's placement in the fork of a road is a little strange. As is the small V shaped graveled lot that borders a main route. Finally we took a gamble and stopped. Our expectations were low as the steps leading to the diner were crumbling and weeds protruded thru the concrete, however once inside we were transformed to an era long gone. All the 1950's details are intact. The interior is remarkably very clean. Regulars sit at the counter and turn to check out the newbies. There's one lone waitress and she seems to know everyone's name and story. A board of ever changing specials is above the counter, and a menu with their regular breakfast offerings on the tables. I was surprised at the variety of the specials - including a stuffed French toast with a drizzle, and a baked oatmeal complete with raspberries and an icing glaze. The prices were another shocker as they were very low. The menu featured more basic offerings and a few kid and al la carte options, again all very reasonably priced. The .99 weekday breakfast special is only a $1 more on the weekends - imagine that. The food was good and the service was fast. Hubby didn't care for his coffee, but also was impressed with his meal, a larger platter which was enough for 3 people. I'm still in shock over the prices, where a party of two can have breakfast, coffee, and juice for less than $10 with waitress service. Amazing! My dad said this diner has been around since his youth in the 1950's, and although the outside surroundings have seen better days the inside is probably exactly how it looked when it first opened. Some things to know......I believe breakfast is their only meal, and I'm unsure exactly when they close. Parking is a little rough due to the odd shape of the lot and the proximity to a busy street. Someone with disabilities will need a hand making their way inside due to the condition of the steps but don't let that discourage you. This place is a gem. read more

Prospect Diner - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

The Prospect Diner is a unique place to have breakfast. Their coffee is really good. Old fashioned diner style. Food is very good. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

Great food. Great atmosphere. The breakfast was hearty. The kids enjoyed Mickey pancakes. Our server was smiling and attentive despite being slammed with a late morning rush. read more

I love finding awesome little places like this, and Prospect is one of my favorites! I'm a lover of biscuits and gravy, and their Chicken and Biscuits is so good! Biscuits topped with chicken tenders and awesome sausage gravy with eggs and home fries? Yes please! And where else can you get breakfast this good at such a great price? If you love a step back in time with good food and good company, stop by Prospect for breakfast. You'll be treated like family and eat like a queen! read more

Prospect Diner - Chicken and biscuits! So good! - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

We went on Monday, Memorial Day at about 8:30 AM before our big day at the Salunga / Landisville town wide yard sale and flea market. Pull into parking lot a few cars not the usual packed lot. We go inside and not very busy. One waitress on duty. She greets us and tells us the corner table is ready and open. Get to table no place settings. There's a older gent setting the table right across from us when he's done setting up table just walks away and doesn't pay no mind we are sitting there with no settings. After 5 minutes and getting ready to leave the waitress shows up and takes our order. Food came out pretty fast, hot and correct... Leaving full and hunger satisfied. We settled the bill and To our surprise the bill was cheap! They were honoring their daily special prices on the holiday... Kudo to them for not gouging the wallets on a holiday! I am giving them a 4 star rating because thier food is came fast, it was hot, it was delish, inexpensive and not for the service. read more

Prospect Diner - Nice hardy breakfast special - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

I have passed this small diner countless times without ever stopping in. They advertise $0.99 breakfasts on their windows that is clearly visible when driving by. While this price is true it is only on weekdays. The diner has a very classic, old school vibe. There is one main dining room with red and black colored booths or seats at the counter as your seating options. The decor is stainless steel accented with classic Americana adorning the walls. Menus are already at the table so do not wait for a server to bring one to you. They offer classic breakfast items from omelettes, french toast, pancakes, creamed chipped beef, and eggs benedict. This morning I chose the Benedict for $6.95 which I discovered includes home fries and bottomless coffee! The ambience is loud, a mixture of locals sharing news with each other and the din of clanging dinnerware fill the air. The server I had was friendly and helpful with guiding my breakfast choice. read more

Prospect Diner - Benedict with homefries and coffee included - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

See all

Cute little old school diner, staff was really friendly food was decent prices are pretty low as well read more

Prospect Diner - Chicken and biscuits platter - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

This diner is amazing! The prices are good and their waitresses are very kind. The food was ready really fast and it tasted AMAZING. I would highly recommend! (their grits tastet like heaven) Solid 10/10! read more

Real deal diner. Total dive, and I mean that as a compliment. My kids couldn't get enough of the super hero stickers everywhere. Kid-friendly, and just friendly in general. One customer told me her sister was one of the cooks. We were clearly outsiders and we were welcomed and served very well. We will be back when passing through again! read more

Place is small with limited parking, but the food and portion size was excellent! Reasonable prices for what you get. We went on a Sunday at about 1030. $7.95 omelette that was so big, you could have feed two off one plate. I had the Bacon omelette with hash browns and chipped beef poured on top with toast. The only thing that was a negative was the wait time to order. I think they only had one waitress on that day. The waitress was nice and tried her best. Would recommend a go with this place! read more

I have been living here for 30 years and only after my boyfriend took me for breakfast 5 years ago I passed this diner many times but never stopped to go in. Now we eat here pretty regularly. The food is really, really good and there always is plenty of it. Try the County style open face omlet is what I order all the time. All the food on the menu is great, the country style is just my personal favorite. How ever no matter how hungry I am, I was never able to finish it! So you can either take it home, or your husband or boyfriend will finish it. That's what usually happens in my case. Best breakfast around for $. Check out the black board for the daily breakfast specials! read more

We love this place! It's actually Conroy's Prospect Diner now. Great service by sassy waitresses, home-cooking, friendly atmosphere, great specials like their "Reuben" omelet and banana bread french toast. Very reasonable prices. If it's a slow time, they're very laid back, so if you're impatient, don't go if there are few cars in the lot. Otherwise, food is great, very friendly atmosphere (we're regulars there and as soon as we sit down, the waitress brings our drink order without asking what we want. I love it. Lots of friendly banter between waitresses and customers. We tell newcomers, nowhere else will you get breakfast with a show. Our schedules are such that we've never had lunch there yet, but we'll get there sometime. read more

Lol. Where do I start. Bad service all around, and I'm only writing this review for the sake of others not wasting their money on this establishment. The server Cheryl is very dismissive and knows nothing about the menu. She argued with us about what we "really wanted" on our food, and confused our orders 3 times and then blamed it on us that we had confusing orders. No Cheryl, you are the one that is confused. The servers shout back and forth to each other and to other customers instead of walking the 10 feet to them and using adult inside voices. The way they behaved was almost comical, and fortunately for them the regulars seem to enjoy this drama that fills their mundane diner-regular lives.As someone who wants a regular breakfast, shouting across the restaurant for every little thing is not normal behavior. The servers were also eating in front of guests at the bar top, and heating food in a microwave essentially right next to a place setting. This is a food violation. As for the servers attitudes, i get it-you work in a diner and you hate your life. I also once worked in a restaurant and hated it, but I still treated customers with respect and did not do whatever I wanted and said whatever I wanted. A server then stood up on a bar stool right next to a guest and attempted to stop a ceiling leak with duct tape, another food violation. Also a dumb idea as the adhesive will not stick if it's wet. Besides all of these violations, the food was not great and the potatoes were mushy and looked like they had been prepped earlier and sat in the bottom of a stock pot.. If we hadn't already ordered drinks, we would have left before the food was ordered. Lancaster is known for some really good food, but this does not live up to that reputation. This is a grimy little diner, not the nostalgic small town treasure you are looking for. At checkout Cheryl confused my order 3 more times about what I should be charged for. I ordered one meal with a glass of water. No substitutions, no additions, just an eggs Benedict and water. Cheryl could not get this simple check written up, and couldn't remember what she herself even served me. They really should rename this place the twilight zone diner because I have never in my life had such a strange and bizarre food experience. read more

If you're looking for a quality greasy spoon this is it! Delicious, reasonably priced food in a clean classic diner environment.

Awesome little diner off of Rt 30; a small old fashioned diner with home style breakfast; the omelets are wonderful; generous portions of well prepared food! Great prices and great service! Highly recommended! Limited seating, but that's a part of the charm! read more

Was headed to McD's for breakfast (traveling through the area) and passed this place and stopped on a whim. Had to stop because of all the cars parked all over the place (means something must be good inside). So glad I did! Had a properly greasy breakfast and an entertaining conversation with a few locals sitting next to me at the bar. If you're into health food, stay away, but if you want a nice greasy breakfast for cheap, pull your car up next to all the others and go on in. You'll be glad you did. read more

Prospect Diner - Grease done cheap and right! - Diners Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

Food is not bad. Only serve breakfast. But, the wait staff, if you can call it that is horrible. Rude and could care less. If you can get over the rudeness, then stop in for breakfast. read more

Great baked oatmeal, best grits too. I am usually here once or twice a week! Good service, friendly waitresses, reasonable prices! Check it out. read more

Myka P's review of the place is spot on. I prefer not to share this diamond in the rough, but they deserve the recognition. read more

The food in this little jewel is incredible!!! Creative, delicious, large portions. We had a crab cheese macaroni omelet that was fantastic. The specials are innovative-combos that I would not think of putting together. Wonderful, friendly servers-Kristine and Ceci handle a packed house easily. We drive 40 miles to come for breakfast and it is worth it. The best breakfast in Lancaster County. read more