This place is a gem! Absolutely loved our visit to The Public House! Everything we ordered was fantastic--the buffalo parmesan boneless wings, pierogies, and chicken pub sandwich were all delicious and full of flavor. The spicy margaritas were perfectly made . Ally our bartender, was incredibly sweet, personable, and attentive, and her service made the whole experience even more enjoyable. The space itself is also adorable and has such a welcoming vibe! Everyone who walked through the door were greeted by name and had a cocktail ready to go before they even sat! Can't wait to go back!! read more

The first visit found 2 locals fist fighting in the parking lot and on top of my car - friends of the bartender! Ok - not their "fault", I suppose... Went back last week, stood at the doorway for 10 min, seated at a table we were told we'd be moved from once a smaller table was avaiable- sat for 10 minutes, got up and left after being ignored. Very disappointed, and will never be back. read more

Came here around lunch. Wasn't super busy. Service was pretty quick for the most part. Was a lil muggy in there but not terrible. The Shrimp was really good. The Buffalo wrap was tasty and had a good amount of heat. Would come again to try something else. read more

Publick House 23 - Buffalo chicken wrap - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

See all

Typical bar restaurant vibe. Staff is super nice. Walked in around 3:30 pm on a Monday. everyone was sitting at the bar and nobody sitting at any of the tables. We sat where we wanted and were given menus. We ordered a French onion soup, and pierogies for appetizers. Then got a burger and a fried chicken sandwich. I was excited to fries with the burger and onion rings with the chicken sandwich. Iced tea for our drinks. Everything was really good. I would stop here again if I was ever in this neighborhood. read more

See all

Good bar food, good local and regional beers, what's not to like? Was predictably busy on an NFL Sunday but service was still good. Reasonable prices as well. read more

Publick House 23 - Pulled pork sliders with sweet potato fries - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

Stopped at 11:30 on a weekday with a party of 6 co-workers for a quick lunch. Three of us ordered salads. Delicious! So fresh and the ingredients were combined perfectly. Huge portion, couldn't finish. Other people had wings and sandwiches and there were no complaints. A bit slow service or maybe because we were in a rush to get back to work. Also, some weird folks drinking at the bar at 11:30. Overall, however, I recommend this place for the great food. read more

Publick House 23 - Salad - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

I love this place ! Nice bartenders good service and the food is on point. They have big portions too so it balances out the price. I would never expect this place to have solid food as it does but I really enjoy coming here for drinks and food ! read more

After a wonderful day at Omega Institute, we were famished and checked Yelp, looking for a restaurant off Taconic. Since it was Labor Day and close to 9pm, our choices were limited until Publick House 23 popped up. We went, we ate, we loved it. Friendly service, great vibe (though the music overhead was loud ). The drinks and the food were tasty. I had a Publick's burger and fries, and ate it all, and my friend had a chicken sandwich and tater tots with enough left to bring home. We'll definitely recommend it to friends who live in the area. read more

See all

Food & drinks were fabulous! Their fires were particularly excellent. Nice vibe, cozy little sports bar. I took off a full star due to the lousy waitress. The buss boy was on point! I wish he was our server.... Yeah our waitress sucked we waited what felt like 20 minutes for her to take our bill. I was so missed while I waited, I drastically reduced her tip. She still got the 15% but I usually tip much better. read more

This is a quick review because we only ordered the wings to go. We had the PH mild wings and they were delicious. Large, meaty wings with nice flavor. 10/$13. We also ordered the Maple Cajun and Chile Sweet and they were very similar in taste which was disappointing hence the 4 starts. I would order the PH wings but hot in the future!!!! read more

See all

Food was good service took a very long time we joked that no one was on an actual "lunch hour" hahaha

We stopped in at the Publick House on our way home from the FDR presidential library. The food was absolutely delicious. I had a great Reuben, my husband had fish and chips, and our friends had burgers which also were excellent. Service was very sweet. If we lived in the area, we'd definitely frequent Publick House 23. read more

Pretty solid food plus they host some fun events. I've gone to the Publick House for trivia and had lots of fun. You can go and get drinks and have food while having fun. I would say that this place is not necessarily for everyone though. A lot of people smoke right outside of the entryway so if you are sensitive to smoke, then this may not be the place for you. The food is pretty solid but the star of the show is the fries. They are nice and crisp and salty. Perfect. read more

Publick House 23 - Obligatory Chicken Tenders and Fries - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

See all

Stopped here on a whim coming back from a soccer tourney in Albany. This would be my spot if I lived here. Great service, awesome burger! Football on tv. read more

You instantly feel goodness and the energy when you walk into Publick House. The bar was busy but tamed. First impression, the crowd fit their motto; publick house is where good people gather for great food and an even better atmosphere. We started with the original publick wings - medium. They were bomb.com! I could see why they won BEST HVNY WINGS. I love that they have so many flavor options. I'm definitely looking forward to going back to try others. For my main, I went basic with the publick cheese burger, pepper jack cheese and bacon. This burger is far from basic though. A classic done right. Cooked perfectly to order and warning, the french fries are highly addictive...so good! read more

See all

Food is good - however I'd consider portions small; particularly fries (especially for $16 plus tax). This is the second time in a row that the French fries have been what I'd consider minimal for a bar food restaurant. See picture - food was untouched - you can see in comparison to ketchup packets. read more

Publick House 23 - Cheeseburger & fries - - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

I had buffalo wings and french onion soup, both excellent. Service was great, beer was cold. Looking forward to coming back

-tuna crisp with soy reduction and spicy -mayo scallop ceviche with sweet potato puree and jalapeño -stewed chickpeas with merguez and pita read more

See all

Wings are always a let down, descriptions don't match what you receive or expect, over cooked, "hot" is melt your face off, mild has no flavor read more

It's taken me a couple of days for me to calm down to write this review so please take it for what it is just my opinion and visit this place to make your own judgement not off this story! I just had to let the management know. So on Sunday night my buddies wanted to go to this place but only if the curly hair waitress wasn't working because of her bad service. So we walk in the door in front door and stop at the sign that said please wait to be seated. As we were looking for the curly hair waitress a blonde waitress with a red birth mark under her eye, says can I help you! My friend says I might just want beer but my friends might want to eat. She snapped back with a reply, well your going to have to get your own beer at the bar. I looked at the crowded bar and 5 of 6 empty tables. I said I'm hungry I'll take the table next to the beer board so I can read it without having to turn around and proceed to sit down as my buddies followed. As I'm headed for the table the waitress asks if we're gonna get something to eat, my friend points at me and says he might want something, so the waitress grabs a menu and throws it at me as I sat down and asks if she can get me anything? I just sat down I haven't looked at the new beer list or the menu yet. The waitress walked off in a huff rolling her eyes. I asked my buddies was it me or did we get another waitress with a bad attitude? My one friend said no it's her, because as we walked in the door she told me to get my own beer at the bar like she didn't want to serve us. She comes back to take our order and asks is there anything else? I said yeah maybe but it's hard for 4 of us to order something when we only have 1 menu, she walks off i with a mean face and brings back 3 more menus. We order and get our food and she asks if we need anything else with food in my mouth so I wave my hand and choke out the words nothing for me so she runs off again, while my friends said what about us we would have liked another beer! She just kept running away from our table to hang with her coworkers at the bar. We realized after 10 years of hanging out with each other we just got the worst service ever, liked she didn't want to be working there, even worse the the curly haired waitress before her so for the first time in my life it was decided not to leave a tip! Not even a very low or insulting coin tip! We wanted to make a point we won't tip for horrible service. What topped off the night was as we made it out to the parking lot the waitress came running out of the restaurant and yells excuse me guys did I do something wrong that you didn't leave a Tip on an $83 bill? So my friend starts out by telling her yeah my wife is in the service industry and the service you gave us was the worst I've ever seen! Especially when you tell me to go up to the bar to order my own beer like you don't want to do your job and waitress tables, and I chime in yeah like getting 1 menu for 4 people then trying to rush us to order and walking away when we try to order more drinks before we all had a chance to re order friend 3 chimes in and says and what's up whlith the rolling eyes and sarcastic tone? Her response was I was in a rush because the kitchen was closing soon. We said you never told us that or we would have ordered food faster but that doesn't justify walking away in the middle of reordering drinks! Her response was if you can't afford to tip you shouldn't come out to eat! And walks back inside the restaurant. So my friend opens the door and yells back in you shouldn't feel entitled to a tip with your bad attitude and rude service)! We couldn't believe the nerve of expecting a tip after being rude the whole night without even trying to get sympathy from us by telling us how tired she was. We plan to go back just to show a waitress we can tip well for someone who does a half way decent job and at least tries to do your job without a sarcastic attitude read more

Friendly staff, very welcoming. Food was wonderful. Wings were coated with a buttermilk batter, crispy on the outside hot and tender on the inside. The french fries were outrageous, also crispy on the outside came hot to the table. The burger, though done medium was perfectly juicy. The salad with the salmon was outrageous. Highly recommend read more

Publick House 23 - Son scarfed down the burger! - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

See all

Great place. We're all from long island....great people good food and staff we've been here 3 4 times very a disappointment.... everyone friendly and inviting read more

See all

We ate lunch here recently for the first time. The food was very good with a wide variety of choices, esp. wings and burgers. The service was excellent! Melissa was a pleasure to talk to and took care of all our needs. The ambiance is nothing special, and on a colder day, it felt cold-both temperature wise and not so inviting. However, we will be returning because the meal and service were so good. Great to have discovered a nice place in town. read more

Love this place but god dang am I hot right now!!!!! No AC in this place . Gotta drink a cold beer on a Friday night to survive this joint. Please fix so I can come back!!! read more

Fourth chance gross!!!! Last visit I didn't even bother to leave a Review. The server said the "meat loaf was her favorite" YUCK, was served off the grill like a char broiled hockey puck. It was literally black. "That's how it's made" before the waitress flounced off. So last night I was sick. Ordered chicken tenders and a BOWL of minestrone soup. No veggies and no meat all supper salty soup and pasta. $6 for a tiny container. The "Tenders" were so crunchy I thought I needed to visit my dentist today. The fries were BEYOND salty. Gross. I tried 4 times!!!! Everytime was a disaster. I really try to support local places. Unless you're drinking ... Avoid this hell hole. Seriously!! We have good places in PV . THIS PLACE IS BEYOND GROSS. WTF IS WITH ALL THE PSYCHO SALT???? YUCK. read more

Food price / quality rating 8.5. Atmosphere is pub / tavern style, lots of wood, antique reproduction bar, large center island. Good size & well chosen tap list. We split a "Roosevelt's Rough Rider" burger. Was delivered as promised. The menu is pretty middle of the road with some innovative spins. Service was excellent even though a sudden rush buried the bartender who was serving the tables also. read more

See all

Outstanding! We live in the area, but surprisingly, never went there. Friends of ours recommended it, so we gave it a shot. The reviews on Yelp were very supportive. Mary had the chicken tenders and loved them. I was happily surprised about the choices of wings. It was the largest selection I've seen in ages. I chose the dry rub with jerk seasoning. Can't wait to go back, and try another one. The ambience was old fashioned saloon, down to the black and white tile-ish floor. Our server was very helpful. Plenty of parking. Kind of a unique ( strange) location, but GPS will get you there. read more

Good Food , Good service and friendship is how best to describe the Publick House 23. A locals place that is comfy for all.

Alyssa was amazing!!! We had a great party! She played music for us! She handle the craziness and loudness and was very attentive !

I will only comment on the old fashioned fried chicken. Amazing! Loved it, big boneless pieces of chicken deep fried with some tasty spice. The mashed potatoes were also delicious and the gravy was chunky and tasty and well just fantastic. Had this during the lockdown so only encountered one person but she was so friendly nice and efficient. Maybe 2000 calories lol, who knows. I could only eat half. read more

Publick House 23 - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

Ok.... I've been an executive chef for 20 years from pretty much around the world and then all over NY. I live and own my own restaurant 5 minutes from this place and, I have to say I'm really annoyed with myself that I haven't tried them before because, it's the first meal I've had in a very very long time that was just exceptional! Alex and Dana c are the girls that helped us this evening and they also were exceptional! I have to say I'm very pleased with the food and the service! Not a single mistake! Excellent excellent! We will be patronizing this place any time I don't feel like cooking! It's that good ! I even called them to tell them that! Just try it and you will see! read more

Publick House 23 - Order - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

I'm not usually one to review a place, quite often I feel it becomes a place to gripe about a place and it's very selective. However I am posting my first review of the Public House tonight, quite honestly after being a regular customer for over 15 years... (Since they opened) First off, if you've never been there, you have missed out and need to go. The food is phenomenal and their staff exemplary. So at this point someone reading this might wonder why after 15 years I'm choosing to post a review. A valid question I might add. This year has been a bit melancholy for me, getting into a "holiday spirit" has been lacking. All of my children and subsequently my grandchildren are living out of state now so the holidays seem like a "regular Tuesday in New York. I decided to go to the valley tonight to watch the parade and see if that might spark some joy for the season. I went into the Public House prior to the parade and found one of their"taglines" to be correct. "Camaraderie"... I saw folks I knew, no surprise, however the place is so festively decorated that if you can't find the"spirit of the season", you're not looking. The place is so decorated it's a sight to see. I stayed for two hours, chatted, laughed and left before the parade because I found what I needed.. I'm thankful for the Public House for a great many things, but now I add one more, reminding me that family is indeed not always about blood and that joy is always around, you simply need to see it... read more

We stumbled upon this place while visiting a farm in the area. And what a great find it is!!! First off, our server was kind and courteous. Our food came out super quick. Definitely order the garlic parmesan wings. Just like the menu says, they're prize worthy. The Harvest salad was absolutely delicious. It was probably one of the best salads I've ever had while dining out. The fried chicken sandwich was outstanding. Crispy fried white meat chicken with tangy cole slaw. The food came out of the kitchen quickly and hot. The only thing I'm sad about is that I don't live closer to enjoy this awesome restaurant. Don't hesitate. If you need a quick bite, a causal spot with friends, or a place to grab a drink, then Publick House is your go to! read more

We've never had bad food from Publick House 23. And I think we've tried everything on the menu! The BEC burger rocks! As do the Casino wings. Whatever you order you're sure to be happy you did. read more

Had the mahi mahi special tonight with spinach, pineapple salsa and Jasmine rice....DELISH!!!!!

This is a an average place to have a casual drink. The bartenders are always friendly but the drinks are weak and the food isn't always the best but it's not bad for bar food! Wine glasses are small, and mixed drinks are weak. It seems if you like beer and sports this may be your spot. It's clean but the bathroom floor and walls could be way cleaner. I think with some small improvements this place could easily be 4 stars. read more

Publick House 23 - Quiet birthday! - New American Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

First time to the Publick House and enjoyed some very tasty wings and pierogis. Service very good, drinks good.

We live in town and get take out from publick house often. Everything we've ordered has been great, quick, with friendly service. My one complaint is all the styrofoam! For the price point I would think they could spring for paper take out containers. It may seem like a small detail to some but it makes me not want to order from here even though I like the food. read more

Great food, drink and friendly service! Excellent variety of wings and tender steaks.

Delicious!! Fresh ingredients, party in my mouth!! They followed extra instructions I entered for my online order. Looking forward to going back. read more