I have been ordering from here for a few years now and I have never been disappointed! Everything is always so good. I do delivery and pick up orders from here and everyone is so nice and welcoming! They also go out of their way, in my eyes anyways. Tonight I ordered late and they close at 8:45, they still took my order even though it wouldn't be delivered till 8:40. I can't say enough about this place and hope everyone tries it at least once! read more

It's good there they have good pizza and subs. All of the staff there are always so so nice to me and my family. It's very cozy and warm there and makes me feel like I'm in Italy read more

Randolph Cafe - Thumbs up - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

Started coming here for the chicken alfredo. The alfredo sauce was given generously. Unfortunately it is no longer that way. Still tasted good but just too dry. Wish i took a picture. read more

Staying nearby for a regatta on the Charles River. This place was recommended by the hotel staff for some quick take out. Drove there, walked in, nice young lady taking orders. Scanned a menu and ordered some garlic bread sticks and fish and chips. It was ready within 10 or so minutes. At best, barely passable fare. The garlic bread was very poor quality. Fish and chips hardly much better. Very little fish, limp and greasy French fries. This would be a one and done for me. read more

Mean spirited and vindictive. Myself and colleagues have experienced this: you raise a concern like arrived late or too early or wrong order. Next time you order online...they cancel the order and you're waiting for lunch at work it never arrives then you call "yes we cancelled it because you were rude last time". How mean. Can you imagine 8 people waiting for lunch during a limited work break window and then this happens. Don't support meanness with you business. Besides there are plenty of mediocre pizza/sub spots around. read more

Ordered a chicken Caesar wrap and it came with three large chicken pieces, not cut up and three pieces of lettuce. What happened to putting effort into making food. My mom ordered a chicken finger dinner. Fries were cold and chicken fingers were so flat and hard you could have broken a tooth on them. No chicken in them just breading. Very disappointed. read more

I've been coming here for 10 years as it's down the street from where I work. The staff is super friendly and pay attention to detail which is hard to come by in a sub shop business. Big fan of their salads, but specifically their chicken salad salad - my favorite of all time. Nowhere else I've been to compares. read more

I've never experienced any issues with the staff be it picking up or delivering. The staff has always been friendly. I tend to order the same thing all the time. Large tuna xtra provo, hots and tomato's. My family has been going to Randolph Cafe for about 20+ years. No complaints here. read more

Randolph Cafe has gone down hill. This used to be our go to place and loved supporting a local business. This was our second disappointment in the past couple of months. The pizza we ordered yesterday had a soggy crust, hardly any mushrooms, raw chopped onions, flavorless sauce, and rubbery cheese. They no longer serve our favorite pizza, the clean palate, though it's still printed on the menu, very disappointing. read more

horrible customer service. i received the wrong order and called the store over 6 times and got no response, i let the delivery driver know it was the wrong order and he told me "ok bye" Never received my order. I got delivered an order worth 19 dollars and in total i payed 27 plus tax. Never buying again. Hopefully i will receive a refund or Finally get my order after ages read more

Ordered a pizza to our hotel. They left it at the desk. Stone cold by the time we got it. Not impressed

We stopped here for lunch. The prices are reasonable and staff is quite friendly. Pizza and Ravioli tasted okay. Garlic bread and French fries were the best. read more

Randolph Cafe - Ravioli Alfredo Spinach and french fries - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

See all

NEVER EVER AGAIN... how in your own consciousness do you become a cook or chef with no aspirations of making meals? No shame in letting wack meals get delivered? I ordered the worst chicken Alfredo in history!! Me & my wife only ate the broccoli because the soggy chicken & pasta was horrible. They probably used laxatives mixed with w.e Alfredo sauce they put in there. THESE ARE FACTS PEOPLE! STAY AWAY WE JUST WASTED OUR MONEY FOR NO REASON. ITS A SIN THAT WE HAD TO THROW AWAY AWHOLE PLATE OF FOOD. I WOULDNT EVEN GIVE IT TO THE HOMELESS. UNBELIEVABLE !!! it's insane that Randolph cafe is even open on a main st. How are they not shut down They called me saying the owners were on vacation and if I want a free meal?! I SAID NO WAY! ONCE THE TRUST IS GONE ITS LONG GONE.... 1st impression leaves impression and that's why restaurants need to be cited on yelp for there horrible lazy meals. NEVER LET THEM SLIDE PEOPLE!! A chef supposed enjoy cooking meals to make people happy n full. Not throw anything together to take our money. THESE ARE ALL FACTS! read more

See all

Randolph Cafe is a solid standby. Food is fresh, if not inspired. I generally opt for their sandwiches, which are reliable and affordable. Good cheesesteaks, although I am a fan of their Greek Salad Wrap with chicken, and their excellent meatball sandwiches. Sadly, it has become less attractive and clean during Covid; I am counting on that improving in the future! read more

I go there weekly to get my grill chicken Caesar salad yummy . and price reasonable. meatball subs are great.

I called in to place my order and was able to pick my order up within 15 minutes. This place was quick and easy. I ordered a chicken cutlet and a side of spicy fries. The fries were not spicy at all, but still good and crispy just how I like them. The chicken cutlet was pretty big and well worth it, however it was a bit dry. read more

Randolph Cafe - a fried chicken sandwich with french fries - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

See all

The absolute WORSE PLACE IN THE WORLD to get a chicken parm pasta. So many things wrong with this order. I used to order from here with no problems but it's been getting worse and worse. * ordered a chicken parm with specific request, they said they can do it - crispy chicken on top of the cheese and sauce - what I got? SOGGY chicken... with NO cheese. Oh and no flavor. * the delivery took 1 hour and 10 minutes. * called them back and explained all of that, the girl's excuse was that that's just how they make the pasta... if that's the case, she could have just said they can't take my request when I first asked. Anyways, they said they can make a new one if I return the 1st one. That means 2 hours before I can eat. Because they couldnt make it right the first time. * told them it's fine they said they will make sure the next time and I said it's fine I wont be ordering from there again and the girl laughed. * barely ate half of it, had a bad stomach ache an hour after eating it. It was really not worth it. Cant get the food right and then is rude and disrespectful about it when confronted. $12 to learn my lesson with these people. Better than consistently supporting a business that don't really care about their customers. The food is the absolute worse too. Never tasted a chicken parm this disgusting. Waste your money and learn the hard way like I did or just read these reviews and stay away. read more

Randolph Cafe - Soggy favorless chicken parm - gave me a stomach ache. Never again. Save yourself the time, money, stomach... and just order somewhere else - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

Boss bought us lunch from here. I got an Italian sub that tasted a bit off. Never a great sign when that happens. Three hours later, I'm feeling a bit queasy. My suspicion is the Italian meats they use are trash. Buyer beware. Update: boss again got lunch from here. I actually didn't know we ordered from here until after the fact. Got an Italian wrap this time. Same result: stomach ache, trips to the bathroom. This place serves unequivocal trash. read more

Got a chicken chaser wrap today-- so dry! Could y'all have spared some dressing! Sheesh. It's like a drop of dressing in this whole wrap. And the lettuce is minimal! This was my first time preceding from here. Not sure I'll be coming back. read more

Decently priced, place to park and many selections to choose from, such as pizza, subs, etc. I ordered a large meat lover pizza and steak and cheese sub. All decent size and very flavorful. read more

Randolph Cafe - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

See all

Valid eats, really like the steak and cheese. Pizzas are also amazing. Service is quick and timely.

Ordered a chicken and cheese wrap. At the last minute I asked to change the wrap to a wheat wrap and they refused. You would think it would be easy to unroll the wrap and change it. So anyway, I take it and get home....and bite into 4 long chicken strips, in a wrap!!! They could have cut the chicken up!!! They also didn't add the Mayo I asked for...... read more

Randolph Cafe - Just uncut, long chicken strips from my wrap. - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

Food - excellent ! My favorites = Greek Chicken Salad w/ blue cheese dressing & steak tips There are two reasons as to why I did not give 5 stars is because customer service is poor & presentation of food I think could be better read more

Randolph Cafe - Steal Tips & Rice - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

I've always loved Randolph Cafe, and the owners are amazing, but something happened to their calzones..... now I'm not posting this to be negative but I'm hoping their calzones can return to normal. I came here for buffalo chicken calzones because they were a real calzone unlike most pizza shops nowadays. The crust was actually filled with stuff and then baked. It was bigger, it was cheaper, and it tasted much better. I bought them on a weekly basis. Now, they do the pizza shop thing that most pizza shops do to ruin calzones: they dont stuff the dough all the way, so its completely open on top, and then they smother the top in cheese. Yes, on the outside. I hate when pizza shops do this, and Randolph Cafe was the last place around to have a good, real calzone. Not anymore. Now its just a taller pizza. Its not the same. They also changed their blue cheese, from the good kind that goes with buffalo chicken, to the dressing kind that has that rotten taste that everyone hates. Somebody else here posted a picture of a comparison of their new ones to their old ones. Look at the picture and youll know what I mean. What happened??? read more

Don't order a veggie pizza, raw crunchy veggies suck on a pizza! Very dissatisfied. Every bite is like eating a salad.... never again

Manager was very rude,disrespectful with poor people skills, the workers hair was all in their faces with no cap,hair net ect.. it was disgusting!it was unorganized when walking in was not friendly you didn't know who was ordering are waiting. There fries were soggy. read more

I received the completely wrong order and while I can completely understand that mistakes happen, it was the way the manager handled the situation that drove me to write a poor review. Originally she had assured me that I'd be credited on my next order. Out of the $30 screw up, I only received a measly $8 discount. Upon addressing this, she then assured me another $15 credit. Fair enough, I didn't plan on penny pinching over $6 since I know they're trying to run a business. My next order came to $11 to which the manager asked "WERE EVEN NOW, RIGHT?!" In a loud/rude tone. The food was bland, cold and all the cheese on my calzone was slopped over to one side. Beyond cheap, very bad customer service and extremely bland food during even moderately busy hours. Only go here when it's dead, but be sure to inspect your order before leaving since it'll be an irritating process trying to get the situation rectified. read more

They didn't give me the right order and planed it on me as I never get pepperoni and end it up in to er and throwing it away and the manager said it was my fault they get an F. From me because I never order pepperoni as I'm allergic to it customers now what they eat shame on you you should listen to customers read more

Deliciously addictive pizza dough. Toppings need to be worked on (seems as though one slice gets all the deliciousness and the rest is scarce). Employees dont know the menu off the top of their head which resulted in the wrong pizza a couple times. Good: delicious food. Nice staff Bad: toppings need to be spread out. Staff needs to learn the menu. read more

This is our go to place for lunch or dinner. The food and service are always great. The quality of food is above what you typically expect at a pizza place. You can not find a better grilled chicken. The cheeseburger subs are one of our favorites. I do wish they would add grilled fish instead of fried but, there is plenty more to choose from. The owner and staff are amazing. They are so involved in their community, it's refreshing. Most business owners don't get too involved if they don't live in the same town but, not here. They are wonderful people. That adds flavor to the food! read more

Always the best! Great pasta dishes, pizza and dinners. The staff is always friendly and helpful

Good place to get quick food. We tried ordering buffalo wings, but the lady gave us grilled chicken with buffalo sauce...hmm..odd...still delicious haha read more

It is really sad when a restaurant bans you and your entire family which had nothing to do with it because you complain about their mistake after they mess up not once but twice...just do better.....I won't say the food is bad because it is not but whatever you do do not complain if they make a mistake or you will never be able to eat there again... read more

I like the service very family oriented I only wish if they could get fresh mushroom/ all veggies. If not why not Pizza sauce could you some spices other then that keep up the good work. read more

Got the jumbo tenders with honey mustard. They are regular size tenders so don't get caught up with the name. The sauce is what killed it for me, taste more like just regular mustard. Also way tooo much sauce read more

Randolph Cafe - Jumbo tenders honey mustard - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

We're not ordering from this place anymore. We order often enough from here and the last few months, but they've been bad lately. 3 different times now, they've either forgotten a drink or clearly put the wrong drink in the bag. The first time, I let it slide. The 2nd time (the very next time), I made them aware and brought me the correct drink. Now, we're at the 3rd time and the driver said someone would come with the drink in 3-4 minutes....its been about 40 minutes now. At first, my fiancé called and they basically said "oh well". I called back and she offered to bring the $2 refund which is a bad business move. Is it a huge deal?? No, but it's the principle. Who wants to eat their meal and then get their drink 40 mins later which has turned into not at all?? Not to mention, they keep changing their food vendors to vendors that don't taste good! We're going back to Zorba's down the street! read more

The steak tips and salad were delicious!! My mom had the roast beef wrap and she loved it as well as the onion rings. The staff was pleasant and helpful. I would definitely recommend it. read more

I ordered delivery. The customer service was pretty good. But the food was not worth the money at all. I ordered two small pizza they weren't anything special. I ordered two dinners fish and chips and a gyro. They skimped on bland tasting fries the gyro had too much onions and the fish was bland. The cole slaw tasted like raw fish. The only thing that was pretty good were the wing dings. read more

Randolph Cafe - not worth the money - Italian Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

The most amazing customer service I've ever experienced. Great food and great prices as well. You can't go wrong with the jumbo chicken fingers. read more

I'm always happy with both the food and the service at Randolph Cafe. The counter help is always friendly and on top of things and the food, in a word, YUM! Definitely the best Mom and Pop shop in town. read more