There are some great things about this gym and some negative. The staff for the most part is really…read morenice and helpful. They are always nice at the desk welcoming you with a hello and saying goodbye when leaving. The cleaning crew are always cleaning and the place is spotless. You always have cleaning wipes to clean down machines. There is rarely dust anywhere and the bathrooms are always clean. There is a large parking lot but it does get filled up quickly so give yourself ample time to look for a spot. There is brand new equipment as of the beginning of 2025 so you are basically working on everything New. The price of this gym is expensive. if you just use the gym area you are paying for the whole gym. Pool, and other amenities and such. This is though I think the best gym so far I would say on the island for the money. Nice people working here , nice clientele, clean atmosphere. It does get crowded at times but tell me what gym doesn't.

If you are a woman be prepared there will be male workers coming into the locker room or even the…read moreshower room unannounced. I witnessed it twice. Even a YMCA staff escorted those maintenance workers into the women's locker room and shower room the Y staffs would not make sure everyone aware of it. I personally don't feel secure in this environment. I understand things broken and need repairing. It's impossible to closed down the entire locker room for just maintenance purposes. But the management should do a better job on this. I don't blame those maintenance workers. It is 100% responsibility of the YMCA management to pretect their members. They should have trained their staffs better to make sure everyone aware of the situation. No one wants to experience surprises like this. ***Updates: Thanks for writing back. Here is more information about both incidents as requested. Look forward to seeing any improvement. The first incident happened sometime last year. Once I walked out of the shower room I heard some men talking in the sauna room. I quickly ran back in the shower room and told the cleaning lady what happened. Then she talked to the YMCA female staff who accompanied the maintenance workers. She then walked them outside and asked me to finish changing in one of the stalls in the locker area so the workers can continue the repairing. I was not notified by any staffs about the situation when I was in the shower. The second incident just happened couple weeks ago 9/26. When I entered the shower room from the pool I saw a YMCA female staff standing in the hallway and sipping ice coffee. I saw one of the shower stalls occupied at that time. As soon as I entered one of the shower stalls I heard a man voice. He was supposed to check which showers were broken. I was not being notified when I walked in the shower room even the staff saw me.

Awesome gym with everything you need. Clean, spacious, and the staff is great too. Definitely one…read moreof the best gyms on Staten Island!

Very well equipped gym. The managed team keeps things fresh with the introduction of new equipment…read moreand properly maintaining the existing equipment. Staff are very friendly and knowledgeable. Been working out on Staten Island for several decades and this gym is one of the best. I highly recommend for hard core athletes as well as those just starting out.

great gym, love the community, always clean and spiffy... would recommend…read more Alan is the fucking guy Bruce and Edward's legends new equipment in the daily and even free shakes...

I was gonna cancel my account because I go to vacation but they say we can stop the account so i…read moresay stop my account but they won't tell you they still charge money $10 every month so guys if you are going to some where just cancel you account if you call back the lady will told you that you have to sign

I started training with Coach Phil in February and almost immediately felt stronger, more…read moreconfident, and energized. Phil is extremely passionate about what he does, and it shows in everything he does at the gym. He works with people of all skill levels to help them achieve their fitness goals! He clearly takes a lot of pride in his business, and it shows in the way he keeps the gym in impeccable condition. Everyone who trains there is expected to put things back where they belong, and as a result, the gym is always spotless. This creates a really positive environment that makes it a pleasure to work out there. Phil knows the name of everyone who trains at his gym. Not only does he greet each person by name when they arrive, but he also takes the time to introduce everyone to each other. This creates a sense of community and camaraderie that is all too rare in today's world. Overall, I can't recommend Phil and his gym highly enough. Whether you're a seasoned athlete or just starting out on your fitness journey, he will help you achieve your goals in a welcoming and supportive environment. If you're looking for a personal trainer who truly cares about his clients and takes pride in his work, look no further than Phil and New Dorp Fitness.

Love this gym! Came here 2 years ago for a 30 day trial with my wife and have been here since…read more This cozy place has everything you need: dumbbells up to 100lbs, barbells, cable set ups, medicine balls, kettlebells, plate loaded machines, and stack based machines. There is ample cardio equipment as well such as ellipticals, stair climbers, hand bikes, cycling machines, etc. The owner Phil is very knowledgeable and treats you like family. His knowledge of excercise science is second to none. He runs a tight ship and any trouble makers will not be allowed to return. The complete lack of riff raff and friendly members make this an ideal gym for the professional. There is never a wait for a machine or bench. Staff is friendly and professional. Has a parking lot which is nice. I can't recommend this place enough.

Terrible staff at this location, a bunch of young guys that fool around while on the clock. Messing…read morearound with their friends while people are working out, today I saw a group of them standing in the middle of the gym in a circle wrestling each other like this is a playground.

This place is absolutely filthy Bathrooms are dirty workers…read moresitting around goofing and watching tv in lounge there are holes in gym flooring pool looks filthy also Weights and dumbbells scattered all over the place No of the members had towels. No spray or towels to wipe off machines. It just seems like workers gave up. The gym is in a good location. This gym needs to step it up. So disappointed.

My experience at OTF South Shore was truly transformative. They have helped me step out of my…read morecomfort zone. It has also helped me commit to a fitness regimen and also found joy in it. I joined the Transformation Challenge and took advantage of the treadmill, rower , strength and nutrition workshops. These workshops educated me on the concept and helped improve my form. The rower and I are becoming friends. I reached the red zone unexpectedly on the rower. It was such an emotional and rewarding moment for me. This was proof of how much progress I have made. Thank you Coach Sean! The coaches and staff have supported me along the way They are passionate and motivational. Shout out to Coaches Jen, Christina, Vanessa, Amanda, Lotts, Evan, and Kerry. I enjoy the community aspect of OTF that they support and make inclusive to all. It really highlights what makes OTF special. I look forward to continuing my journey with OTF. Why don't you give it a try and see what I mean! Patricia/Trish G 16

Everyone was super nice and my husband and I enjoyed the workouts. It's just very expensive! SInce…read moreI no longer work we couldn't afford it comfortably so had to cancel our membership. We had no issues canceling. Of course they tried to get us to stay but we couldn't. Because of the ease of canceling I would definitely re-join if my situation changes.

One star because it's as low as it goes The manager charged…read moreme 2x before after saying my card was 'pending' she also made me pay cash , charging me 2 months instead of 1 . Bathrooms always smell like throw up Showers smell like fish and piss Gym is always full of steroid junkies at all hours Weights always all over the place while workers hang out and talk around the entire gym . If you want to do treadmill or cardio there aren't enough machines because they're all taken . Customer service is horrible , if you ask for a massage machine they will make you wait and not tell you when it's ready . If your looking for a reliable gym ,Best option is to find another one .Planet fitnesses I've went to are cleaner and newer nowadays for half the price smh , how sad .

I originally came to Crunch as a guest, but after taking Gigi's class, I was hooked! that's what…read moremade me join! The classes are amazing: great music, fun vibe, and such an energetic atmosphere. Huge shoutout to GIGI, Astrid, Michele, Lou, and the whole team for bringing so much passion and motivation every time. Also, for the Tool commenting on instructors' bodies is unnecessary and disrespectful. The instructors here are strong, inspiring, and create a positive, inclusive space! Only small note: it would be great if the weights were updated/replaced in the classes. Other than that, I highly recommend!