Old school gem of an environment gone by man I wish I'd known about this place much sooner , absolutely love it the pizza is first rate the vibe and surroundings are straight out of the way it used to be love it , keep doing what you do ! read more

Great size and quality for the price! The veggie pizza was loaded up with toppings. The stuffed breadsticks were super garlicy and tasty. Ready quickly, open late, a solid choice on this side of town! read more

Absolutely the best pizza I've had first time having their food and definitely will return again

I was looking for pizza online and this place came up with a great pic. So I drove 25 minutes to get there. I was completely surprised, what a throw back in time. The pizza was very tasty and some "activities" were taking place there that were popular in the 1980's if you know what I mean. Kind of a dive bar where lot's regulars hang out. I will go back....friendly people. read more

I was staying at the Clarion Hotel after working the day and just wanted pizza. The front desk suggested several chain places, but I wanted something other than a chain for dinner. So Yelp came out and pizza was to be found. I order a large veggie and a side of pepperoni garlic bread sticks... yep you read that right... I went veggie for the pizza and meat on my garlic bread... I was told 45 plus minutes for delivery, I looked and they were 8 minutes away via car. So me being me, I was already wondering if I was going to get an amazing pizza or okay with bad delivery. Well to my surprise my pizza showed up around 55 minutes. Again it takes 8 to 10 minutes to make and bake a pizza so, 45 minutes to go an 8 minute drive. Okay, the pizza was pretty good, the pepperoni bread was very good till it started to get cold which sadly didn't take long as it wasn't extremely hot when it arrived. I may try them again, but next time it will be in the location rather than order for delivery. read more

Some of the best pizza. I don't know what it is. The flavor that this pizza has isn't just cheese and sauce. It has a distinct taste.

I'll start by advising they are not on Mann Road anymore they are 707 N Lynhurst. I called a little before 7:30p to place an order and she immediately advised the wait was 1.5 hours, which I thought was odd because we've ordered her many times and the longest wait was 45 minutes. So, I started my order by asking for the Family Special which online advises (copied from their website) Friday & Saturday Try our Family Special for $22.99. Rolyno's Family Special Get an extra large pizza with 2 meats and 3 veggies of your choice, 2 orders of bread sticks, and a 2 liter of your choice for $25.99. She advised me that the Family Special does not include 3 veggies, and you cannot pay extra to add any veggies, because "it wouldn't be a special anymore". I asked why, she first advised it was because of COVID-19, then she advised it was because of the location. She also advised the pizza was a large not an extra large. So, I ordered the Family Special with sausage and bacon, when I asked about the 2 liter options she said they don't offer it. I also ordered a large sausage, bacon, green peppers, and banana peppers and pizza. The total came to $42.30 I got to the location at 9:02p, and I quickly realized why the wait was so long. The new location is actually a bar, so I can only imagine the small oven they have to work with. None of the employees that I saw had on masks or gloves. The pizza and bread sticks were in a warmer and had clearly been sitting longer than the 2-3 minutes. The pizza was warm, not hot. Taste wise, it is not the same quality as when the location was on Mann Road, it was just okay. The only way I'll order from this location again is if I do a sit in order OR order as soon as they open. I was really disappointed. read more

See all

Pizza is always a good idea especially on a cold rainy night in February. Our food was done faster than the estimated time frame. The bread sticks were nice and crispy. The cheese sauce was room temperature. The pizza was not thoroughly cooked. Some slices were crispier than others. The toppings were good quality. I love pizza that is made with the cheese covering the main toppings. I ordered for carry out and they have a convenient pick up window. The staff was polite and not frustrated that I ordered so close to the end of the night. Next time I plan to dine-in so I can experience the food right after it's been cooked. read more

Very solid pizza place! Staff was very friendly! Good family atmosphere, and the place looks nice inside. We got the daily special which was an XL pizza with 2 meats and 3 veggies. It also came with 2 orders of breadsticks, cheese sauces and a 2-liter of pop for $20! You really cant beat that deal!!! The breadsticks came out piping hot and were really buttery and delicious! Pizza was super cheesy, only complaint would be that they could use more seasoning (garlic, italian seasoning) Other than that the whole experience was on point! We will come back again and again! read more

See all

What happened to the original Rolynos??? They do not deliver anymore, the pizza tasted burnt, I ordered half cheese and half meat lovers. The pizza was 75% just cheese. This used to be my husband's favorite pizza place, unfortunately we will not be ordering from them again. read more

You get one star because it wouldn't let me give zero stars!!!! I waited 10 minutes to talk to someone only to be told I'm out of their delivery area. I've ordered for delivery from there at least 10 times in the last 6 months and have never had an issue. I live less than 10 minutes away. I try to buy from local places to keep the little guy going. I guess I'll give the other place close by my business from now on. Keep treating good customers like this and that old Donatos building will be sitting empty again real soon. Good luck read more

Great pizza and breadsticks.glad the original is back .great new owners.they had us try a new cinnamon and sugar pizza they are going to put on the menu that was amazing .good too see one of the great indianapolis pizza places back. read more

Rolynos Original Pizza - a stop sign in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Delicious pizza and breadsticks! Fast and friendly service! The Friday and Saturday night special is the best deal two meat three veggie topping XL pizza, double order of breadsticks, and two-liter of soft drink for $20! read more

Good deals, good pizza and breadsticks, very friendly people there. Found it randomly driving through the neighborhood, after I had to detour past a car wreck. Well, there you go, my good luck. Pizza was cheesy and breadsticks were filling for my kids. I'll give my recommendation here. read more

I have been in search of the best pizza on the west side for quite some time now. After trying this place my search will continue. The pizza wasn't bad, lots of cheese and toppings, but the crust reminded me of frozen pizza crust. Also this place is no longer on W Washington St. Better than Domino's and it's similar to my favorite pizza place but I will keep searching. read more

Rolyno's is THE pizza from my childhood while growing up in Indy. Now I live away from here, I dream of those Friday night pizzas while watching the "Sammy Terry Show!" Thank you for having that same pizza!!! This was a bucket list moment for me!!!! Next time we are in town, we will be back!!! read more

Grew up on Rolyno's Pizza and travel to the opposite side of town to get my Rolyno's fix today

When this location opened I would have given them 5 stars. They are going down hill. Don't plan on going back. Trying Inner City Pizza today. read more

Absolute trash, I ordered a cheese pizza, waited an hour then was told they didn't have sufficient ingredients

Staying here in Indy for the Miracle Ride this weekend. the kids wanted pizza for a snack. After looking up several pizza places decided on ordering from here for delivery to our hotel room. Said it wld be 45 mins to an hr. It took 25 mins and was piping hot. Orders half cheese and meat lovers and garlic cheese bread. WOW. VERY IMPRESSED. WE LOVED THE PIZZA AND CHEESE BREAD. The pizza was loaded up like a homemade pizza or old fashioned one. The cost in my opinion very reasonable. Wish we lived closer. Will be back just an hr away read more

We are happy to give a thumbs up to our first experience with Rolyno's Pizza. Our carry out order was a large, deluxe pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was loaded with all the toppings along with generous portions of meat. There was a nicely browned layer of cheese on top. I ordered buffalo wings, but they forgot the sauce. The wings were especially good just plain. Their breading was nice and crispy, so we had to forgive the error. read more

Been ordering from here for years, back with Margie owned it. Pizza has always been great, but today I ordered my pizza from the Mann Road store and when I went it to pick it up, waited patiently while the owners daughter took orders on the phone. When it was my turn I handed them a $50 dollar bill on a $25 dollar order and was told we can not accept these..... I was told they no longer accept 50's only 20's or exact change. I could have understood if they didn't have the cash to make change but there was a basket of tickets with $20's in plain view. The owners daughter told me I had to go break my 50 and come back - they would sooner give up a customer than accept my 50 which they had change for. I was also told they did not care if they lost my business.... Rules are rules they said. Sad that I will not have these pizza anymore... back to Mickey and Bill's read more

Waited on hold for 7 minutes to order delivery... at 9:12 PM and then they come onto the phone telling me they are closing for the day and their hours on yelp say until 10PM. Never eating here! read more

In town for a Colts game figured I'd fire up yelp to find a place that delivers. This place had 4.5 stars so gave it a shot. I highly recommend the pepperoni cheese bread. The pizza was also good. Price was reasonable. Only real complaint was I was put on hold for a good 5+ mins when I called (Sat night) and delivery took over the hour I was quoted. Probably just a busy Saturday night so I'll give them a pass on both. read more

The price is right, but the pizza itself isn't much to write home about. It's not bad, by any means. It's just very basic. The breadsticks and cheese are the best part. There's a nice kick to the cheese. If you're looking for a cheaper way to feed several people this would be a good spot because they've got great deals. read more

If you're looking for a cool hole in the pizza joint then this is the place. Great unique pizza with awesome and quirky staff! You won't regret it! read more

The older white woman with a wristband on at the counter was very rude very very rude. I think she was mad because me and four other employees walked in two hours before they closed I'm assuming. I guess she did know that I tip very well. She gave us the meanest expression when we walked in the restaurant. I had to ask her was she okay and she looked at me and said yeah "can I take your order" real quick and real hateful like. Gotta admit, was good. read more

This is the first pizza that we purchased from Rolynos that was not very good. When we opened the pizza box the toppings had slid off and were stuck to the box. And the crust was stuck to the box. read more

Great pizza and deals! Sketchy neighborhood, don't go alone after dark!

Was a favorite pizza place growing up and now my kids love it. Friendly staff great food for a great price and cant beat the daily specials. read more

We were in from out of town for the Indy 500 and I went to pick up pizza thinking that would be faster. 2 people working, credit card machine was supposedly down, no one was in the restaurant, but it took 45 mins. Restaurant was locked when I got there due to crime in the area and then to top it off the pizza was awful. Crust tasted frozen and like cardboard and meats were not fresh. read more

This location is still getting started but don't let that keep you away. They have daily specials. Like them on Facebook so you don't miss them. The cheese with the breadsticks is absolutely amazing! The breadsticks are also great. The pizza was extremely cheesy. Not many places are these days! We got an XL pizza half and half with 4 toppings, 2 orders of breadsticks and cheese and a 2 liter for $20. Great deal! All the ladies working were friendly. This is a great addition to our neighborhood! This is our new pizza joint! read more

Pizza tasted badly, bread sticks were burnt. Will not return!!! Also website special, wasn't available when I called to place the order.

Excellent excellent excellent! Trucker parked for the night nearby and I've tried a lot of delivery places from all over and this pie was delicious. Got the deluxe and they don't skimp on the ingredients. Definetly the best option for pizza in this area! read more

The number 1 thing I rate a pizza on is its crust and unfortanately this pizza fails miserably in this regard. The pie looked tasty, and the sauce, cheese and toppings were proportioned right. Then you hit that crust. It was as if they sauced and topped the lid of one of their pizza boxes and I had to throw out an xtra large after just 2 pieces. Too bad! read more

I remember eating Rolynos pizza almost weekly when I was little. I would save the little plastic "Barbie tables" in the middle of the box. I still eat Rolynos from time to time for nostalgia's sake and it is still just as yummy. read more

Pretty good pizza. Just don't expect to pay the prices advertised on their website. Order by phone and you'll pay more when you pick it up

Save your money. They are slow and the pizza is subpar. Missing something. Very bland. You are better off getting a frozen pizza for a third of the price. It will be more flavorful. read more

Best pizza I've ever had bar none! The building doesn't look like much but don't let that fool you. At first I thought the pizza was expensive and then I saw my pie being pulled from the oven. Wow! The toppings were pilled on like crazy. The staff was great even though the one dude couldn't make up his mind what sports team he liked! read more

I grew up on Rolyno's pizza. I would order a pizza almost every week. When they closed and reopened the taste wasn't exactly the same but pretty close. Not sure what has happened in the time since but the ingredients/supplier has changed dramatically. First bad experience was at 8 seconds saloon. They sell Rolyno's pizza there at the snack bar. This was about a year ago. It had a really weird industrial like taste. It's almost as if the pan it's baked in had a bunch of non stick spray on it. I couldn't even finish it. I tried it again a month later, same weird taste. Also the crust used to be slightly crunchy on the very bottom. Now, it's soft and chewy. Reminds me of high school cafeteria pizza. I tried Vinnies drive bar, same taste. I then tried the actual Rolyno's shop and the taste is the same. Not sure what you guys changed but you killed the taste of what was once a very good pizza. read more