My go to pizzeria when I am in Huntington. Great variety of pies and great quality ingredients.

Heavy on the toppings, greasy, no crisp, and a lot of flop. I'd say this NY style pizza might have been top tier decades ago, but not in today's pizza game. That being said, it is better than a few other places in town which are just down right terrible. Also, the guy behind the counter was not a friendly dude and seems like he can't wait to get you out of the way for the next customer. I won't be back just based on that alone. read more

Very good pizza nice portions and decently priced. We always get the chicken broccoli slices and we get the mozzarella sticks. They have an upstairs and downstairs and it's always packed when we go. There is an outdoor table so if you have your pup with you you guys can enjoy it. read more

This pizza was just okay. The crust was quite thick and the toppings were generous though almost too heavy. The grandma slice was much greasier than expected and kind of difficult to bite. The veggie pizza was piled high but with very little seasoning on them, making the pizza slightly watery. Many pizzerias to pick from - won't be returning here. read more

Ordered a pie, picked it up got home it was the wrong pie. Called up and whoever answered the phone was a rude MF. Said he gave us what we ordered and he's been doing this for 50 years and he told me what I ordered is what he gave me. I clearly ordered a different pie but I was wrong lmao. The reason I know what I ordered is because I've only ordered from this place six times and I get the same thing every time. SAME EXACT PIE EACH TIME!! don't tell me what I ordered and don't be rude. What you should've done is said I guess there was a mixup bring it back and I'll give you what you ordered. So now you just lose a customer and you can take your pizza and shove it You know where. I'll order a pizza from now on from one of the other 20 pizzerias in this town. read more

With all fairness, Rosa's deserves a 3.75, the pizza was excellent definitely one of the best regular slices on Long Island hands-down and the upside down. Sicilian was also delicious. The gentleman who help me was super nice and I told him "nice and hot" he knew exactly what that meant. Only issues I had was it was freezing inside, so I guess the owner didn't think it was time to put the heat on and eating there was very uncomfortable and we had to rush out and also on the TV there was playing mass from church kept hearing "our father" while I was eating just created a weird vibe, I almost felt like I was in confession lol the inside is not great for staying in and eating, but the pizza was outstanding ! read more

Wish they would stop heating the salad slice that would be amazing! Bc a cold salad slice heated is just gross. Otherwise I love the pizza the there. But man that salad slice warmed just really pisses me off! My daughter tried to stop it but they move so fast or they just ignored her but bad service with her way. Listen to people calling out to you. Always busy lots of seats bright and clean. read more

Forget the negative reviews about the temperature inside, the owner's attitude, or the bathrooms not functioning -- none of that matters once you taste the pizza. This place makes the best Grandma's pizza anywhere. The crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese melts just right every single time. You can tell every pie is made with care and tradition. If you're a true pizza lover, this is where you go. It's not about fancy décor or perfect service -- it's about the pizza, and it's unbeatable. One bite of that Grandma slice, and you'll understand why people keep coming back. Now let me give my negative, as I deducted one star for this. Every time I take out or eat in, my total cost is different, even though I am ordering the same items every time. Nothing is ever itemized, nor am I given a receipt. The owner who's also the cashier tells me the total amount and boom it's paid for. Cheers. read more

Rosa's seems to be the hub for pizza in Huntington, every time I've passed it by it's packed. Dinner time? Packed. Lunch time? Packed. Breakfast time??? PACKED! Maybe that's a reach but I think you know what I'm trying to say. This place is POPULAR among locals and I can understand why, this is a rather spacious pizzeria that holds two floors of seating so you shouldn't have an issue finding a table. Though I love a pepperoni topped pizza, the only way to judge a pizza location that generates this much buzz is the original way, plain cheese. This was a solid slice. The cheese was salty and stretchy, the sauce was a bit sweet, and the crust was crisp and airy which is a plus, I'm not fond of dense crusts. Is this the best cheese pizza I've had though? No. But I don't think that's why this place is so popular. The place itself just seems to be the perfect go-to spot for you and friends given the space and relaxed atmosphere. This place is meant to be enjoyed with company after a good night and it does a good job of encouraging it with their noticeably late night hours and solid 'za. read more

Rosa's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

Best pizza in NY! Been coming here for decades and their red Sicilian (upside down slice) is the best pizza I've ever had. They also make a great regular pie as well. They recently renovated to make the place bigger which helps since they're always so busy and popular around dinner time. read more

Rosa's Pizza - Rosa's Red Sicilian Pie Large 18" - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

The pizza was good, the staff was rude to a child making a comment in front of their face.

Pizza not bad Owner or manager parking in front of his store is a bit weird You park and walk You got customers that will use that spot Besides you got the pick ups for all the deliveries taking up the handicap spots And a proper greeting or thank you goes along way I go where they receive you Welcome you And a re grateful to you for deciding to go to them rather than the other places literally down the road. So again not bad pizza It's actually good Management can use a lesson or 2 on How to run that place And treat his customers right. read more

I just gobbled down two of Rosa's vodka slices and they were out of this ever-lovin' world! I cannot even describe how good the sauce was, and how the slice held together, unlike a lot of real soupy and slidey vodka slices, but the absolute best thing about these slices was the SIZE!! Longer than a square, they were like French bread length. It was like getting 3 slices for the price of 2... Absolutely delicious!! I can't recommend Rosa's high enough! GET THERE!!! read more

I have been here many times and usually eat it in here but after last week- never again. I'll eat it when I get home. There is this very gross smell of some kind of cleaner that they use and it fills the air - so when you eat your slice - you can almost taste the cleaner ON your pizza. The other thing is- I have smelled this same gross VERY pungent cleaner smell in other restaurants. It's NOT an ammonia or bleach smell - much much worse. I am wondering if ANYONE ELSE has noticed this ? read more

100% Huntington's locals favorite pizza place. Pizza, rolls, hero's all super delicious. Generous toppings and hero's. Reasonable for 20222. Huntington seems to be a village that attracts good restaurants. This one has been here for decades and looks to be the most popular. Never seems to go down in quality. Always a small crowd but fast and efficient service. Pick up or casual sit down tables. read more

Good pizza really good pizza nice customer service and friendly tile me 20 minutes but didn't even make the pizza when I got there and just put the one that was on display in the oven read more

Really enjoyed this casual pizza spot. They have lots of options and have a quick service perfect for a quick lunch or late night snack. They have a salad slice that is vegan with sauce and a heap full of veggies. Just add a little red pepper flakes and salt and it's very tasty. They also have garlic knots, many appetizers, and entree options. The slices are pretty big and reasonable. read more

Rosa's Pizza - Vegan Salad (Slice) - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Decent Pizza. The Children and park slice was amazing. According to my husband his gramma meat lover's slice was good too. Definitely coming back! read more

Rosa's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

The pizza is good, but the attitude is awful. The guy taking our order was rude, and the guy at the register was disgraceful. We asked if the channel could be changed because it was once again a religious station holding mass. The man said "absolutely not" and walked away. Also, for the past year or so, they have hundreds of pizza boxes piled up on the stairs and in front of the windows, blocking all views. It makes you wonder what's crawling in and out of those boxes at night. Never going back. read more

Open at very late hours at night (4am). When nobody else has you Rosa's does. Decent plain slice and hero

Ambiance: I agree with the reviewers about the atmosphere inside. There is just a weird vibe. The TV volume is aways high so its hard to ignore the often very distracting programming on the TV. It is often too cold in the restaurant. Service: The owner is the cashier and he doesn't ring up individual item prices. He just comes up with a price for everything together and I have noticed that the total cost is not always consistent every time I visit this pizzeria although I purchase the same items regularly. Food: Good pizza. read more

Always solid here at Rosa's pizza, and that doesn't even count when you're at the bars or drunk lol The vodka square pie/slices are amazing as well as the grandma square slices Traditional margherita was also great, my only gripe is sauce is a little too sweet sometimes Chicken Caesar slice, chicken ricotta both solid too Can't go wrong they have so many options read more

See all

BEST PIZZA IN HUNTINGTON VILLAGE! I'll say that again......best pizza in Huntington village! Now, we all love Little V's after the bars..it's a classic stop before heading home. I personally don't care for cold cheese on my pizza but it's a popular item at Little V's (Little V's pizza is just fine without the cold cheese). But if you want a little variety...you'll have to walk over to Rosa's. Their selection of slices is second to none! Everything is on display and read to be scarfed down. My go-to go-to slice here is the buffalo pizza. It's probably more chicken than anything else but I savor every bite! The chicken cutlet is chopped up perfectly. Make sure you get a side of blue cheese. Long live Rosa's! read more

See all

Loved the meat lovers pizza. They tend to go well done on the pizza temp, I like that, my son was on the fence though Great sauce, good slices, fun euro beat music, clean bathroom They keep the Parmesan in the fridge, smart idea. read more

I enjoy eating at Rosa's pizza! opened late and has hard working staff. They have all my respect.

I hadn't tried a lot of Long Island Pizza so I Rosa to the occasion and came here. My friends and other Yelpers absolutely love the pizza here, and I liked it a lot a couple of years ago on my only visit, so I came back recently to see if it was still as good, or better than I thought, and they had closed down. I think they are renovating but hopefully they come back with full force, I can stop by again, because I used to love their stuff but want a do-over. The closing was kind of without warning and the internet didn't have anything about it so I'm not going to give them 5 stars until they open back up and prove to be as good as I remember. read more

Rosa's Pizza - Rosa to the occasion - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

I've got a hand it to them. Their pizza is good, consistently so and their customer service has improved as well - seemingly for me at least. It is my spot for pizza in Huntington, all said, go and get your slice and enjoy. read more

Thankful they are open late on the weekends !! Great food and they answer the phone and take an order late!!! Thankful

The pizza is delicious, but unfortunately, we were met with a rude people. there's no reason for a woman to be treated a negative way for no reason. What a shame. Good food, but the employees are not up to par. read more

Best pizza in town. Has so many slice options you have to get more than one. Chicken Caesar slice is my personal favorite. I've gotten probably every slice in there. Worth the money. The guys in there are incredibly Italian. They know what they're doing. read more

Always have a bunch of different types of pizza to choose from. Always fresh. Open til very late, which is great. I love that they aren't "cash only". Very convenient Definitely THE Best pizzeria in town. Possibly best pizza on the Island. read more

BEWARE - Sunday, June 28, 2020 at 7:55 PM ALL SERVERS working behind the counter were NOT wearing masks. On the door it states that all patrons must wear masks to enter, but how bizarre that the four young workers (making pizza, taking orders, serving and cashier) did not have a mask on. This lack of desire or care to follow NY State safety guidelines during COVID-19 is appalling and downright scary. Every patron waiting on line were wearing masks and took the safety standards seriously! When I confronted the workers for not donning masks they all just gave me a blank stare. Needless to say we walked out and won't be back. UPDATE: August 20, 2020: 2 photos taken showing owner and workers not wearing masks. read more

Rosa's Pizza - The owner does not follow guidelines for wearing mask and either does the workers preparing the food. - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Terrible service. Absolutely atrocious. I went in with my girlfriend to get some slices of pizza and did not get my order taken until I got to the register; when I told the cashier what I wanted to order he told me to get to the back of the line since they were too busy. I then said I will wait and he repeated to me to get out of his way. I then said all i want is to order pizza, i am a paying customer. The chashier then asked if i wanted a medal for being a customer so we both walked out. Terrible customer service. Will not go again. 0/10 read more

Always a line but it's always great pizza and great staff. I'm new around Huntington so it's always a pleasure to find great places to eat at read more

Good grandma slice, decent ravioli slice... Their sauce is tasty but their plain slice is a bit bland, doughy, and while I did like it, it wasn't the best. read more

Rosa's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Once again They have come through.Ordered the Chicken Frances's It was absolutely delicious. I thought They forgot to give me pasta with lemon sauce On the side but it was on the bottom of my chicken franchises. I asked for an extra piece of chicken which they did at a minimal fee. Once againThey have surpassed their reputation,Delicious food. read more

See all

The interior is cold during the winter season and it's good pizza when you're drunk I guess. Some of the channels on the TV are weird choices one time I came in and the P Diddy documentary was on. Not really appropriate but whatever. It's a shame because the pizza is really delicious but the customer service is lacking. For a few weeks I've been stopping by for 2 slices and this is probably my last visit. I got out of work and asked for a Sicilian. Saw the guy put a new Sicilian out but they still gave me the old one and up-charged me. Prices are always different and this last time it was 7.75 for 2 slices, which is just crazy. The owner shook his head judging me because I didn't buy drinks or more food. I'm sorry I don't spend all my money here but after this interaction they just lost a regular. read more

Went back recently and the service was a little better.. but the main reason for this update was that the pizza was the legit. The vodka slices are amazing- some of the best pizza I've ever had. The margarita is damn good too, though the sauce is a little too tangy. Pepperoni and grandma slices are on point. Talking this pizza by the slice as good as a fresh pie.. but the winner by far is the vodka slice. It's phenomenal. The BBQ and buffalo chicken slices are still weird though.. not terrible but not great. Way too much chicken (hard to believe there could be too much chicken but there is) and not nearly enough mozzarella or blue cheese. read more

Good specialty slices and upside down Sicilian there very busy for a reason God bless

Absolutely love Rosa's. Used to work across the street and ate there almost every day. read more

Rosa's Pizza - The best Buffalo Chicken slice in the world. - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York