Went on Christmas Eve right at opening and had a great lunch at Rotolo's Pizzeria. The food came out quickly. We shared a fresh garden salad and ordered the Krewe calzone and deluxe combination calzone -- both were hot, soft, and packed with toppings. It was Wednesday $7.99 calzone day. We split the salad, drank water, and each bill was about $13, which was a great value and kept us full the rest of the day. Excellent service even with only one waitress handling lunch. Casual spot and the calzones were just as I remembered. We'll be back. read more

See all

The Prairieville Rotolo's continues to disappoint. Our waitress forgot our appetizers, left us waiting for drinks, and charged us $13 for plain spaghetti noodles because she didn't know how to ring it up properly. We just paid and left out of frustration. They also rarely have the beers they advertise, and when they do, they're often warm or taste off. The food is good, but the service and bar management really need improvement. read more

I received an email for a free king cake calzone, which sounded kinda good, and since I hadn't had Rotolo's in quite a while, I decided to give it a shot. The pizza I ordered was OK, but the calzone - which was supposed to be filled with cream cheese and cinnamon - was a HUGE disappointment. There was no cream cheese in it, not even a little bit. Zip, zero, nada. Basically all it just dough with some cinnamon sprinkled in the middle and folded over, with some colored sugar sprinkled on top. I felt that this promotion was their chance to attract new customers, or people (like me) who hadn't eaten there recently. Unfortunately they failed in that regard. read more

As always, friendly service and clean, nice interiors at Rotolo's Pizzeria in Prairieville. But the Deluxe Calzone? Wimpy, bready, empty. Nothing deluxe about it. Mostly bread and very little stuffing. What little vegetables in it (peppers and onions) were fresh, but, well, mostly air-filled bread. Not the calzone I had last time here. Or like at Reginelli's on Jefferson in Baton Rouge. Might have been a bad night, but if I come again and it's as dreadful and dry, I won't be back. Do better Rotolo's! This isn't you normally. read more

I haven't had Rotolo's in several years. I used to love the Krewe pizza. I ordered one tonight, and when I bit in, there was hardly any sauce. The sauce is the best part of a Rotolo's pizza. I did not indicate easy sauce on my order. Not how I remember Rotolo's. Disappointed. read more

Ordered the pepperoni pizza just to try for the first time. There are several locations around here and I've never tried them before. First I would say it was cooked to perfection. The crust was exactly what I love although it could be a little more buttery. Just my preference. The ratio of sauce and pepperonis were fine, it just that it had a sweet flavor to it that I didn't care for. Not sure if this sauce is a standard for all they have or just an off day. It definitely wasn't anything I would eat again. Just kinda wondering if that sweet sauce was a mishap. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

See all

Eww. Spinach and Artichoke dip tastes metallic and was served to me cold. Accompanying bread was hot, seasoned and cheesy. 8" pizza was obviously made with too large of a dough ball, as the crust was about an inch thick and the cornicione took up half the pie, so only got about 2 square inches of actually cheesy goodness, which tasted okay. Prices are reasonable. Service was friendly and welcoming, although they had the poor server literally by herself at busy lunch rush with no one to manage the bar, answer the phone, take or fulfill carryout orders. She was all smiles and sweet as can be, handling everything in stride and very professional! Poor thing, I hope she abandons this sinking ship! I didn't complain at all to save her the trouble and made sure to tip, but this place sucks for both customers and staff. Avoid at all costs! read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Not heated prior to putting in steam well. Not made with cream cheese and broiled with cheese on top, so be aware! Spinach & Artichoke Dip - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

Great pizza! Quick service even when they are busy. They are super efficient while making some of the Red Stick's best pizza. read more

WHAT HAPPENED Once upon Rotolos pizza had amazing quality but now their pizza is something you can get out of Walmart at a better price and quality. I order a cheese pizza from them and it tasted like I was chewing cardboard. read more

I hate that the food is good here because the service consistently abysmal. If you've got boatloads of time and patience, this is the place for you! Be prepared to get up for your own plates, napkins, utensils, drinks, etc. Don't bring a hungry kid if they have more than 2 tables. You'll constantly hear wait staff apologizing for long waits with no real reason. To-go order lines waiting almost to the door. Managers standing out the back door smoking with the door open. Always understaffed kitchen. General poor training and management. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - The Krewe Cheese Sticks. - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

Great pizza and atmosphere!! Service is the best, especially Heather at the bar. She always has a smile on her face and always so attentive!! read more

My FAVORITE pizza place! Their calzones are basically all I get from here now. Their pizza can be hit or miss but their calzones seem to be very consistent. I have placed an order before, forgetting that our fridge quit working, thus calling them within 5 min after the order was placed , to request ranch, and the lady happily willing to put some in our Togo order, only for it to never have happened. I feel that they are extremely strict/ greedy with things like that, if you don't pay for it, you're not getting it, now if I tried this more than once okay , but it was the first time I ever asked. This store would get 5 stars from me if they recognized their regular customers (Togo and dine in ) but due to either forgetfulness or greediness, they truly don't care unless you pay up. Bottom line, I love their calzones, there's non any better. I hope one day their repeat customers will mean more to them than .50cents for a ranch. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Garden Alfredo calzone - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

See all

I love ordering food from here. The service is really good. I also enjoy the ambiance provided, very chill and kid friendly.

I ate there Saturday night Cute little place. Small. had a patio if you want to eat there service was fast. Pretty good menu prices are fair. ordered a pepperoni mushroom pizza. Nothing to write home about really greasy. The dough really didn't taste like it was cooked through, but everybody in the group swore by it, but I'll let you guys decide if you go there. I would not go back though personally, but the help and service was excellent. read more

Ok if you want amazing pizza this is the place!!!!! I love the crust and the sauce of course! Always great service

Sent garlic bites with nothing on them. Hard to order and don't care about customers. When I called, I was told "oh, well".

I almost did not go to this Rotolos location because of reviews. I am so glad I tried it anyway. We went for $5.99 calzone Wednesday's. The food was just as good as any other location. The staff was very accommodating for our kind of large party. Our server Dane was awesome and very attentive. We ended up hanging out for a while because the staff and service were so good. Favorite calzone is the CHICKEN FLORENTINE. Definitely a must try. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

See all

Went in to pick up a to go order and saw a man with ear rings on vaping in the kitchen. I'm not a sanitation expert but I definitely feel this is a sanitation issue read more

I would give it zero stars if I could. Terrible service. All the staff was either on their phone or talking with other people/staff about whatever gossip or "bitchy" customer they encountered earlier in the day. Took ten minutes for them to even turn around and notice we had sat down at the bar. And it just continued the entire time we were there. Terrible representation of an otherwise fairly good Italian food chain. read more

Majorly disappointed. Ordered this huge pizza for kids. Imagine their faces when this showed up. I don't understand how this over-baked pizza was allowed to be delivered. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

Calzone was good but too much dough. Good taste nut needed more stuffing. Pizza are good

Three stars for recent visit and Four stars for past visits. I have been here a few times now for both dine in and carry out. Everything I have from here has been good. They have recently changed their menu by adding new things and changing the name of a couple of pizzas. On this occasion our choice was The Krewe (pizza formerly known as Sweep the Floor). The pizza was very good and fresh and it was waiting for me when I arrived. Overall their food is very good and it has a uniqueness about it. However, something I noticed when getting my pizza is it was a little smaller than I remember it being in the past. Also another thing that changed with the menu is the price. The pizza was $16.00 and that was only a 12 inch medium. Luck for me, during the month of April, customers can return their old Rotolos cups and get a free pizza. If it wasn't for that I probably wouldn't have came here. I suggest visit when it is Calzone Wednesday. They are $5.99. read more

See all

I typically would not write a negative review over this, but this is the 2nd time! Nearly a year ago, I was there with family. I ordered Chardonnay wine. The very nice waitress didn't know if they had it. She came back and reported they were out. I was a little shocked because they have a bar! When I questioned it, she came back with a hot glass of Chardonnay. The children weren't given silverware and every item had to be requested: refills, silverware, cheese, check. Fast forward: I didn't frequent this place for months because I was irritated over the poor service and lack of management, but I figured it was time to give them another try. I placed an order for Chardonnay and guess what??? The sweet waitress said, "I don't think we have any". I asked why and she said they hadn't ordered any. Then I told her the scenario and she came back with a cold glass of Chardonnay. She didn't bring children's menus to the table until we requested one. When she finally made a round to see if we had enjoyed our meal (which we had) I placed an order for a child's dessert of Chocolate Chip Brownie. I was then told it may take a while. Ok. How long? She said about 25 min!!! Really??? She said it was because they were short handed and busy. We had to ask for cheese and the check. Food was tasty. Waitresses have always been polite, but don't seem well trained. The management obviously is lacking in many areas. Won't be back anytime soon! read more

Recommend stepping up your quality to higher than your average fast-food pizza joint if you're going to charge 2 bucks per topping on top of a mediocre piece of bread that's somehow worth 18 bucks before any toppings (ANYTHING, even cheese) is added. The pizza is worth eating, but it isn't worth what they charge for it. Save some money and go to Dominoes. They've got better crust anyway. read more

Trash. Trash service, trash food, trash all around. Philly cheesesteak with 3 strips of steak. They made wrong pizza as well. Food came after 25 minute wait, yet only 3 other customers. Chips stale and disgusting. Save your money and skip this location. read more

I give this place 2 stars d/t the dry pizza I ordered which was the angry pig and the popeye pizza. The food was okay as if it was possibly fast food pizza which I've had better pizza at little Caesar's. The spinach artichoke dip was okay as well. It was not impressive and all I can say is it was okay. And they didn't have wings which I would think there would be some form of replacement for it or credit or something. This will probably the last time I will eat here, which I have only tried this place twice. Just not a fan favorite. read more

Rotolo's is a good place to gather for lunch with co-workers or friends. The dining area has a lot of seating and there's also a patio on the side of the building. The servers here are nice but sometimes service from the kitchen can be a bit slow. If we are dining in we usually call ahead to place our orders ahead of time prior to arriving. We really like coming here for lunch as the calzones are $5.99 on Wednesdays. There is a lot of variety as they offer calzones done 14 different ways. Although for most, the calzone alone will not be enough to fill you up. I recommend pairing it up with cheese sticks or a side salad. Here they also have sandwiches, wings, soups and even pasta. Rotolos can easily become your Wednesday weekly lunch spot or any other day of the week as they have daily specials all throughout the week. read more

The service is astronomically SLOW. Decided to come in because the kids were begging to have pizza and decided to try something new. The first red flag was when we had to wait to be seated only because nobody wanted to bus the multiple empty tables with plates stacked high. The second red flag is that it took 10 minutes to even get our drinks ordered. The third red flag is that it took over an hour (with roughly 40% of tables with customers) to receive our appetizer. Now this should've been when our family got up to leave, but the kids really wanted to stay. Finally, after an hour and 45 minutes we got our food, except for my muffuletta. It took another 20 minutes to get a slice of a sandwich that should be made before heavy service times. We also never received any drink refills despite spending over 2 hours in the restaurant. If you're really considering this location, I highly suggest just getting Papa Johns. TL;DR this place sucks read more

Wow!!! I usually go to Rotolos on Millerville but I found myself in Prairieville after a softball game. Loved the service from Angel and Amanda!!! I was greeted with smiles and my drink never ran dry!!! 10/10 would recommend!!! read more

We are not the type of people that normally leave a review, but todays experience has compelled us to write this review. We were blow away by the phenomenal pizza as well as customer service. Our waitress Heather provided excellent and personal service giving us beer recommendations as well as food recommendations. It was nice to see the manager (Ariel) coming around asking us about our meal and experience. Will definitely be eating here again!! read more

We really like Rotolo's it used to be our almost weekly stop after my daughter got out of dance. We put up with a rotating door of staff members some good, some not good, and some downright​ horrible. We put up with slow service and sometimes rude service. We love the calzones, wings, and the cauliflower pizza is the best I have had. If they could get a good staff in there this location could really do great. We also REALLY love the trivia​ nights. read more

So disappointed. We recently tried Rotolo's for the first time. We ordered a couple of calzones. They came with maybe a teaspoon of cheese. Decided to give it a second try tonight. We ordered "to go" at the bar and made sure to tell the person taking our order about the calzones we ordered the previous time. We were assured that they would make sure my calzone would come with meat AND CHEESE. After waiting about an hour, our food came. Guess what....couldn't find the cheese so brought it up to the server. Was told it's at the bottom. Pulled the calzone open...if there's cheese we can't find it. They offered to remake my calzone but that would put us waiting who knows how much longer and then the rest of my family would be eating cold food. We got home and cut into it only to be more disappointed. I called and was told they would give me $5 off my next visit. Ummmm....no! I asked for it to be taken off my ticket to which I was told they couldn't do because the ticket was closed. I'll call again tomorrow when hopefully a manager is available or I'll dispute the ticket with my credit card company. read more

Rotolo's Pizzeria - Where's the cheese???? - Pizza Near Me - Prairieville, Louisiana

The sweep the floor AKA the crew is one of the best pizzas around. This pizza is definitely the business.

Whoever worked on March 19, 2021 should all be fired. I don't typically write these kind of reviews. But the staff at this location were just awful. I had a to go order to pick up. I got there at 7:10pm, I didn't walk out with my order until 8:00pm. Completely absurd. As I waited, I watched the kitchen staff joking around having a good ole time and the other servers and even managers just standing around like they have no care in the world. My family will never go to this location ever again. What a complete waste of time. My wife even tipped them on our to go order. Never again. read more

Love this place I always go to eat at their patio very spacious and laid back atmosphere to eat pizza and have some draft beer the customer service is genuine and food is always fresh and yummy one with obsessed with spinach and artichoke dip read more

"Local pizza chain done good!" That's what the headline should read for this place! Good anytime but Wednesdays are when it kicks into high gear cause that's when they do their $5.99 for ANY calzone special ... Yes... ANY CALZONE! And by 6:00 PM almost every seat is full. Deluxe Combo Calzone ( hold onions and add olives) has my name all over it! They also have pitcher beer specials the same night for adult beer savor-ers. The staff is great... That's why they almost always get homemade chocolate chip cookies from one local customer too! Go for it one Wednesday ... You'll really like it! read more

Always like coming here with family. Very laidback setting is perfect for kids. Service is always good. I love their spaghetti and meatballs. They are delicious. Any of the calzones, you can't go wrong. read more

My kids loved $1.99 kids night on Monday where kids get to make their own pizza. I ordered the combination/supreme pizza. The sausage topping was delicious, the veggies fresh, and the pizza dough was just how I like it. We will definitely be coming back and bringing friends and family when they visit. Much better than Roma's down the road. read more

Such a great family spot and an easy access location. I love trivia night on Tuesdays and their cheese sticks are to die for! The service is great and they also have the best carder dressing in town! It's also a great place to get take out from! I highly recommend. read more

I'm going to have to actually go and sit down to give it 5 stars, but yesterday, Hubs and I had woken up late from late-night-party-hosting-duties the night before, and I mentioned briefly, "I could really go for a pizza!". He jumped on that with enthusiasm and suggested Rotolo's since it's close to our house AND they carried gluten free crusts AND I'd never had Rotolo's before (I know, I know, Louisiana staple and all that...) We ordered a bacon cheeseburger pizza on gf crust and it was ready within 20 minutes for pickup. Their sauce is good, different from other pizza places, but in a good way! Toppings were good, not too much cheese, and delicious crust. They had a good array of menu options (not all heavy Italian dishes) and for some locations you can order online, which I can see being very helpful! We will definitely go there in the future to see how the in-house service stacks up to the food! read more