This pizza was delicious!!!!! We had read a negative review, but decided to try it anyway. We were so happy that we did. Tons of pepperoni!!!! Also, the Cesar salad was great too The prices are very reasonable. You can actually afford to take your family to this pizza restaurant unlike the one down the street. read more

Pizza was spot on. Service was as it should be. Wait was not long as previous reviewers stated. We will definitely go back again and again. Thanks rounders crew!!! read more

Pizza is top notch but getting it out is slow as heck. Courteous but slow. One pizza came out, then 20 min later the next and not all the pepperoni rolls. Total wait was over an hour for all our food. read more

We ordered 3 pizzas a salad and a soup. We were given a total for the 5 items. Told the order would be ready in 25 minutes. I send my son to go pick up the food and they tell him we never ordered anything. The staff is incompetent and the manager was worthless. Rounder's will not be visited again. A real waste. read more

Being from Athens I may be a tad bias because I will drive miles for Rounders their sauce is amazing! I'm not sure how they do it but every slice is made to perfection and the only thing I wish they had was a salad buffet and would be perfect family spot when I don't feel like cooking but Rounder's is the best pizza ever period! read more

Very good pizza, pizza rolls, and homemade ranch! Clean restaurant overall. Quick takeout.

Best pizza EVER!!! Best crust, cheese, everything!! So flavorful, and I'm not really a pizza person but WOW!! Need one closer to Arlington Texas. read more

The pizza is great, but the employees did not care about this place. Tables need to be bussed, there was a spilled drink that took over an hour to clean (no, they weren't too busy), the toilets won't flush, the bathroom sinks leak, they had 0 clean forks, and they refused to fix the Coke dispenser (they only change syrup at night). I'd be surprised if this place was still open in 6 months. read more

First time here. Disappointing at best. Ordered the Hawaiian -Pizza was dry without much cheese or sauce. Won't go back.

I had an awful experience here just a few minutes ago. I got my. hair done next door at headmasters and was waiting on my husband to pick me up like I have done many times in the past and went to rounders to order a pizza and a beer until my husband got there. I went to the register and ordered the pizza and a beer. The young lady jumped back and said" I'm not old enough " A young man came out and demanded my Id I explained my husband and i had just been on a trip and he had my id because of airport stuff. The young man said very loudly "I'll sell you a beer when your husband gets here" I am 47 years old and this was humilating! We will never be back and will pass the word on! read more

terrible customer service by Jazz and whoever answered the phone. "Forgot" to make a pizza that was paid for already but refused to remake . Absolutely ridiculous way to run a business read more

Great pizza! Great price! Their slice of the day is good and they can cook to order quick for someone on lunch.

We have consistently been disappointed with Rounders which is sad because it used to be our favorite pizza in town. We've gotten raw pizza, we've been when they told us we're out of ice, items off the menu due to no staff, and today we waited in line for 20 minutes to be told they were cash only, read more

Pretty good pepperoni rolls. My only complaint is the wait times can be pretty unpredictable. Sometimes it only takes 5-10 minutes to get the food, but other times have well been around 20 for just a slice and a box of pepperoni rolls. read more

I like the atmosphere and the food at this place BUT they need to work on getting the orders out at the same time. If your family orders different items instead of getting one big pizza, everyone will eat at different times because they don't see the necessity in placing one table's order in the oven at the same time. Also, a little more friendliness from the staff would be appropriate. read more

(NB: I haven't actually ate here BECAUSE...) I Can't order anything to go as there is NO website, NO online menu. This just seems nuts to me for a pizza place. I realize I could order a regular old pepperoni pizza but come on, it's helpful to know what the menu actually is and how much a pie will cost. read more

It was our first time trying Rounder's pizza. We walked in, ordered a pepperoni deluxe, and sat down. This was at 1:51 PM, after the main lunch rush, and it was Sunday, so it was not too busy. We waited, and waited... People who came in after us and ordered more already got their food. Around 2:15, an employee came and apologized to us for the wait, told us it would be 5 minutes, and asked if we wanted soup or salad. She didn't say it would be on the house for the wait, so we kindly refused. It was not until 2:28 PM we received our pizza. We admit - it was delicious. I recommend it. But we felt like it wasn't worth waiting for 40 minutes. It was just an unfortunate mistake, and hopefully this won't happen to anyone else in the future. read more

Rounder's Pizza - Pepperoni Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

Pepperoni Pizza for my nephew and a large thin crust Italian sausage for my mother and myself. Best pizza in town. The thin crust reminded me of being a child in Chicago and ordering delivery to he house! It was so perfectly cooked. Not over or under cooked! Cheese with the Italian sausage stood up on its own! Price was great too! We will definitely be back! I have been to the other pizza place down the street and it was almost dbl. the price and tasted terrible! read more

One of my favorite pizza places in town. My kids don't even like pizza usually but they love rounders cheese pizza.

Boom!!! Now that was some good pizza and a great salad! Will be coming here as often as I can in the future. Believe that! read more

Love this place. Great place for pizza and beer. Dining outdoors is always nice on cool days. Service is excellent.

I would love to see this location on a game night. Right now it's super slow and it's a goof atmosphere. Our food was fantastic. Minor hiccups such as not having plates to divide the pizza (and the staff not understanding why we wanted plates?) and one of my buffalo wings was actually half a wing and full of bone chips (ouch). Wing sauce was a little thin, but great. The blue cheese was top notch chunky and creamy. Sandwich was good. The bread was super dry, but still good. Pizza was fantastic. The soups and salad were great. Best croutons I've ever had. read more

Absolutley amazing pizza. The bacon Alfredo pizza was simply some of the best I've ever had. The pepperoni was extremely flavorful, clearly not cheap meat. Service was friendly and we were greeted with a smile. Beautiful warm summer Friday night, got to eat outside, and was totally enjoyable. Highly recommend. read more

Rounder's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

See all

If you're like me, you get sick of eating the main 3 pizza places. (Pizza Hut, papa johns, dominos) they really aren't that good. Bruno's is good but gets expensive and their locations are inconvenient. Double Dave's sucks. Little Caesars is not great but cheap. But this place is awesome. Fair prices, great pizza, chill environment, good location, and pizza by the slice from 11-2. The Hornet is my favorite to eat here. The first bite of the hornet which the employees call "the stinger" can set your mouth on fire but gets less spicy after every bite. So good. The ranch sticks are just cheese bread sticks, just FYI. I think you get a free Rounders koozie when you get a beer. read more

See all

The pepperoni rolls are great. Wings are okay. The service is terrible. (Or has been for us). Every time we have ordered they (usually the same girl who works the front counter) have been rude over the phone and rude when we came into the store. Does not really pay attention to what she is doing, had to drive back for part of my order on one occasion and only avoided it by checking myself a second time. Phone rang endlessly when we tried to call in an order. Then got put on hold for 10 minutes, then on a third attempt they picked up the phone and hung up. Like I said, them pepperoni rolls is gud, service not so much. read more

I've been working for 5 weeks now and I would totally go their soo many times and their pizza is delicious and if you ever want fresh and handmade pizza come to Rounders pizza for our wings , cinnamon sticks and Ranch sticks this place is phenomenal and we strive for our place to be happy and hard working employees and management is 10/10 read more

hands down the best pizza in town. also hands down worst management in town. their online cook time is 17-27 mins... been waiting an hour and 20 mime and my pizzas have just now came out... pick your poison read more

Started off great but they've gotten lazy. It doesn't herlp that they're either playing trash country or worship music. read more

Rounder's Pizza - I remember when they put cheese on the entire pizza... - Pizza Near Me - Tyler, Texas

Horrible experience today. Waited almost ONE HOUR for one pizza and pepperoni rolls. We were told they had messed up our order so it would be 7 more minutes. (No one came and told us our wait would be longer- bad customer service) We waited.. and NOTHING. we went to ask again and were told it would be 7 more minutes! We decided to get a refund at the end. We witnessed 3 more people get refunds and a lobby with frustrated customers not being helped. The manager was not helpful, didn't apologize, nothing. read more

I went to check out this new pizza restaurant this week. I was disappointing in both the taste and the price value for their food. Compared to Kens buffet you can get all you can eat salad and pizza for $21 dollars for two people. At Rounders you pay $21 dollars for just the pizza and drink. Kens gives me Pizza,salad, and dessert. The Rounders hand tossed pizza crust does not taste as good as Kens hand tossed. It is a matter of taste and value to me!!! read more

Took my grandson this time and he said we should leave a good review. Crust great sauce very good.

This is our "go to" pizza joint. The pizza is great - the staff is friendly and attentive. We really like this place!

When this place first opened- it was an instant fan favorite. Great service and the food was great. Today, not so much. I ordered a pizza to go. When I got the restaurant to pick it up, I waited at the counter for several minutes for employees that were standing at the front, too involved in their personal conversation to help a customer. Then, the guy that did help me just swiped my card and handed me my pizza as he continued on with his conversation with the other female employee. I felt as if I were intruding on their social time and felt very unwelcome. Finally, I got home to discover my pizza was completely raw on the inside. I will not be visiting this location a read more

I'd love to actually rate this location but their inept staff has made it impossible. Although I have been to the Athens spot and received quality food & service.. The Tyler branch is useless. We (my wife and 3 kids) arrived hungry and ready to eat good pizza, ordered the Hornet for us adults and a simple pepperoni pizza for the children. They hand us our cups, I pay the money, and we take our seats. And then we wait patiently. The time begins a little after 7pm. After awhile, the waitress brings the Hornet out and sets it down but no word on the kids pepperoni. We continue to wait, it would be wrong for the parents to eat in front of their hungry kids. To abate their restlessness and looking back for food, they pick off Pepperoni's. Who delivers a half order?? Still waiting. Waitress walks by and I ask about the kids pizza. She tells me it'll be out of the oven soon. At that point I'm visibly frustrated, and I ask for a to go box for the uneaten Hornet, and for the pepperoni to be placed in a box too. Now I'm standing at the counter because there is still no medium pepperoni pizza being handed to me. The staff ask if they can help me, a different one each time, STILL NO PIZZA! Eventually, their "shift leader" walks out and after a little back and forth, he investigates & discovers the pepperoni JUST went into the oven.. And after a quick apology, let's me know it'll be another 15 minutes. I ask for a refund and he does so, including taking the Hornet from me and placing on the shelf. So not only did I not get the 2nd pizza I ordered, they completely wasted my time, returning us back to zero with even hungrier kids. We left and went to Sonic because of the hurry to get the kiddos to bed at that point. So yea.. 1 star (because it requires something for the review) for your completely horrible customer service and inept ability to process an order. I'll never come back and if any asks about where to eat pizza in Tyler.. I'll be sure to let them know where not to go. read more

I wanted to love this place, as Tyler is really lacking in the pizza department. I called in a pizza for take out. The place was clean and the service was prompt and friendly. My order was ready and waiting. My pizza was no better, no worse than a Dominos or Papa John's, and I doubt I will return. There was simply nothing sexy or special here. My quest for an exceptional pizza joint in Tyler goes on......... read more

Great pizza at a bit too high of cost. I've tried Rounders twice and the pizza is the best i've had in tyler. That beings said, I think the prices do need to come down just a bit. Paying $30 for 2 small pizzas, 1 small order of cheesesticks, and 2 medium drinks is tad on the expensive side. The good: Excellent house made crust. Decent sauce Crispy pepperoni well seasoned sausage and chicken The Hornet! ( Finally a spicy pizza that is well thought out!) The Cheese is actual cheese and pretty awesome combinations The bad: The price: ( should be $6 for small, $12 for medium, $15 for large, $18 for extra large). Drinks should be $1.50 to encourage people to dine in and possibly purchase more. Sauce is a bit too sweet, ( works well on the hornet though) Overall, excellent food, but more than I'm willing to pay for pizza thats not fire or coal grilled. ( at least on a regular basis) I understand they can't compete with the chains due to the freshness of ingredients but its hard to make an impulse purchase for a large with a side, or several smalls to try out different flavors. Things tried: Hornet ( Medium and small) Chicken, Bacon, Ranch(small) Ranch sticks ( small) Both are excellent and well seasoned. Ranch sticks have a better cheese to crust ratio and better cheese and crustrin general than chain. read more

Used to love this place but will never eat here again. You know service is bad when you get there right after your food comes out of the oven but have to wait 15 minutes and watch it cool on the bottom oven while some goon mists degreaser over it that he is using to clean the top oven all because none of the staff could be bothered to stop folding boxes or whatever the hell their doing to finish preparing your food. Screw this place way over priced anyway. read more

I love the one in Athens but I won't be going back to the Tyler location. I order a hand tossed pizza and when I got home I noticed it was thin crust. I called back to see what happened and they admitted to mixing up two different orders. They said I could drive back up there, but that's all they would do. A discount on the next order would've been fine. Poor customer service, not worth driving passed 4 of their competitors and not getting what I ordered. read more

By far one of the worst places in town when it comes to customer service and etiquette. The employees are teenage hoodlums who have neither manners or the etiquette required for a open kitchen dining experience. It seemed I was dining within the confines of a zoo, with all the noise. No manager seemed apparent as they where running amuck, like gremlins... Your food is only as good as the people behind it. This place belongs in North Tyler... read more

rounders is the only pizza i will eat in tyler!! love love love - great ingredients and always a good ratio of toppings to cheese and crust! i normally get it doordashed or i call ahead and pick up at a specific time. today i called at 4:30, orders a pizza, cinnamon sticks & a salad... i asked for it to be done at 7pm. i got to rounders around 7:15, traffic + 2 wrecks on my route. my food still wasn't ready & then i had to wait for 20 more minutes. some of the ladies at the front were super kind and smiling, while the others were... not kind or smiling. i will continue coming here for how great the food is - but service & timeliness could use a little help :) read more