Exceeded expectations!
Service: great; attentive and went beyond what was required
Atmosphere: Dark. Somewhat loud, modern electronic/dance-y music. Not quite my scene, but it felt professional and local. Most rum bars are kitschy tropical and not very polished. Hale Pele already has polished tiki down, so Rum Club blazes their own distinctly non-tiki aesthetic trail, while not falling into kitsch of any variety. It just felt very Portland.
Drinks: Tasty and unique! Heavy focus on originals, using fresh ingredients in novel combinations. My party wasn't always satisfied with what they received,* but I liked my drinks just fine, especially the Space Warrior, which had a pleasant black pepper kick (though why they listed blue curaçao in the menu as simply "blue" I'm at a loss). Air Horn and Divine Hammer were fine. We did not test out their adeptness at standards like Daiquiris, Mai Tais, Zombies, etc, but I assume they'd be solid.
*Fino Countdown was accepted as pretty good but overly rounded and lacking something. I flat out would not recommend the N/A Toddy, which has numerous sour and bitter elements (accentuated by the heat) but zero sweet ones--not even a little honey--so it's just a hot, unpleasant experience through and through. I think whoever is in charge of the cocktail program here should take a fresh look at that one; it's a huge faux pas imo, and DD's especially deserve better.
Overall these folks have a strong cocktail program they should be proud of (reminded me a little of Zombie Village in SF), but an even stronger rum program that they appear to be ashamed of. I've been to several bars with larger rum selections, but the rum flights here are the best I've seen anywhere--taking into account not only the rums they chose but the categories they created for them. I'd recommend any of them! (Bonus points for recognizing Plantation/Plateray as a French producer.) But I saw no mention of this on the website, and you have to ask for the rum list, just by assuming they have one. The prices are generally pretty reasonable, and I LOVE that they offer all pours in 1 and 2 oz sizes (like Pagan Idol), further democratizing the wild and wonderful world of rum.
I'm torn between 4 and 5 stars; it would be a pretty easy 5 (for me) if not for the Toddy (others in my party seemed to give off more 3/4 vibes). I'll leave it as 5 for now because I'd like to go back and try something else (another original, a standard, a rum or two...); we'll see how that goes if I do :) read more