Very good pizza- I like the thin crust Rusty's Special which is a bit expensive but worth it. One time they accidentally forgot the sausage. Within 15 min they delivered another fresh pizza. Great service. read more

Pretty darn good at a great price! We stopped in on our trip driving home from LA to the Bay Area and found his little spot. It's right off 101 and has a bunch of parking in back. Everyone was super friendly and we have leftovers for the rest of our drive. A couple video games inside gave our 5 year old a little break from the car and he loved his cheese pizza. read more

Delivered burned pizza, then refused to give me a refund. Pretty ridiculous for a place that already makes barely-edible pizza. We used to buy a lot of pizza from Rusty's for my company (we do a weekly pizza night), but have since switched to Giovanni's, which is much better (and has much better customer service). I'd try somewhere else if I were you. I tried to speak with a manager named "Gary", and then "Sergio" said no. When I said I would deny the charges, they put me on hold for 10 minutes, then said they would give me a refund only if they came back to my house and picked up the pizza (at 11:45PM). They kept saying "I hope you didn't eat any of the pizza" - we did not. Will never order from here again. Absolutely horrible. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Burned pizza...mmm... - Pizza Near Me - Santa Barbara, California

See all

I'm not happy with the manager Erick because i order a Pizza i it delivered in 1 hour and he told me that if I didn't wait the driver in the street It won't send me the Pizza read more

Hands down , the very best pizza out there No pizza is better then Rustys pizza Also try the Subs n salad Wow one of the best places to eat Great pizza n food Service And all around a awesome place I drive down an hour plus just to get our fix Of RP Thx guys read more

Great place to order and pick up pizza during covid, very nice and relatively quick, pizza is better than most cheaper delivery options. Cheese bread is really good and inexpensive. read more

We've been ordering pizza from Rusty's for years and they always deliver quick within 30 min. Their thin crust is just right, cheese is solid, ranch is top notch and their salads are good too. Every time. 5 stars for consistent and timely quality! read more

Don't order the wings I had them on Saturday I am still sick from them. They look like Tyson frozen wing that they just microwave since they are extremely soggy. Just the thought of them turns my stomach. The pizza was okay nothing special. Save your money we are from Los Angeles and were hoping for a Santa Barbara only pizza place should have stuck with dominos. read more

Although I had a bit of a hiccup with my online order not being transmitted correctly to the employees, I was able to get the correct pizza made for me within minutes! Miriam and the other ladies working were able to address my issue in a timely manner and I greatly appreciate it! read more

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat with my family passing through. Delicious pan crust pizza, it was fast and the atmosphere is medieval, which is pretty cool. Recommend this place, also family friendly. Employees were nice too. Thumbs up read more

We are from out of town and stopped at the location on Carrillo because it was open, and other pizza places were already closed. However, like many other reviews for this location, the employee taking our order and some of her coworkers was extremely rude. From the moment we walked in, the employees gave us hostile looks as if we were inconveniencing them, even though we arrived almost 2 hours before closing. Then, the employee at the cash register was rude to my boyfriend's teenage daughter as she was trying to order. When she ordered and asked the employee a few sinple questions, the employee rolled her eyes, looked at her friend who was working with her, and they both started snickering, which made us extremely uncomfortable and upset. Judging by other yelp amd Google reviews, rude customer service has been an ongoing problem at this establishment. This establishment needs to take care of their customer service problem. I would understand if this was an off night, but other reviews suggest this is a pattern. Pizza was okay, and not worth the rudeness. We will not return, and urge others to find a different establishment with better food and customer service. read more

I have lived in Santa Barbara 4 year and had been to Rusty's once before when they charged my card twice for then same order. It was a real hassle to get my money back. Tonight about 4 years later I decide to go back and order dry wings and cheese bread. The cheese bread was really good but I feel like that is hard to mess up. The wings on the other hand were soggy and just flat out gross. If you're looking for good wings in Santa Barbara go to Taffy's. read more

Love their pizza for sure, when I want something a bit more I go here otherwise dominos because price is cheaper but pizza here is really really good!! read more

Rustys is straight nasty! This is the second time we found a LONG hair going through our pizza! If any of you workers are reading this you need to start wearing hair nets and think of your customers who keep you working. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - hair going through my cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Barbara, California

Cant deny that Diablo fuego pizza is the best topic combination one can taste. diablito pizza is my favorite. place its also cool to small parties. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Diablo Fuego at finest - Pizza Near Me - Santa Barbara, California

The employees have horrible common decency much less customer service skills! I was actually yelled at by the cashier for pointing out that I was paying full price not the coupon price. When I asked for my money back instead they did not know how to use the cash register. Go to Martys Pizza instead! They are great all around! read more

Came to Rusty's to enjoy some pizza and wings but was given very bad customer service. We ordered a Large pizza and the large order of wings with 5 drinks which totaled out to around $55.00. With the wings, it included 2 containers of ranch. We asked for more ranch containers (Since there was 5 of us, we wanted our own) and they charged us around $2 for 3 extra containers. I saw a different person at the register so we kindly approached him and asked for more ranch cups and he gave them to us without an extra charge. Why did the lady charge us and the guy didn't? This was very odd because every other Rusty's I go to, they never charge for the ranch containers. I would understand if we would of ordered a small pizza but it was a LARGE pizza and LARGE wings. Apart from that, when we received our food, they didn't provide us with plates and when we asked for them, the lady gave us attitude about it and walked away. Not to mention our pizza wasn't even cut into 12 slices which is what a Large pizza contains. They where also barely even cut so we had to basically separate them ourselves. Wings tasted like they where microwaved and very sour (I ordered the hot flavor). I've been living in Santa Barbara my whole life and I've always had great experience at all the rusty's in town except for last night. I am very disappointed with her customer service, as for the guy, he was very kind and generous. Wish we would of taken pictures so I could attach them. This incident happened 01/27/19 around 8:00 pm. Next time I will make sure to drive to another location instead. read more

Waited an hour for a delivery less than a mile away from location. I called about 15 minutes after the order was placed and asked to add two ranches to our large pizza (the ranch is supposed to be complimentary with a large pizza order) and they charged me an extra $1.20 for them. I then waited patiently for the pizza to arrive to find that they forgot to bring the ranch and still charged me. Shortly after I checked my bank app and noticed they had charged me twice. The pizza arrived cold and I would definitely recommend that you order from a different location if you're going for Rusty's. Very unsatisfied. read more

Not bad, not great but delivered late night and friendly and FAST service ;-) I would order from Rusty's again!

Great service, delicious pizza, fast delivery, and so much more. Yes, I'll admit they delivered myself the wrong pizza once, but mistakes happen, and they sent me the pizza I wanted pizza within ten minutes. I highly recommend giving Rusty's a shot. read more

Not sure why no one has rated this location yet, because I think it must be one of the best. Certainly has the best ambiance of all the locales that I'm familiar with, since it has the woody rustic decor inside and out. I thought the Pizza here was very good, thin crust was just the right thickness (not ultra thin, but not doughy), and ingredients were in right proportions. We asked for it cooked crisp but not burned (as we always do), and it was done absolutely perfect. Kudos. FYI -- being originally from Chicago, we certainly know our Pizza; and, while I've definately had better in my old hometown, this was darn good. I'd recommend it and intend to return. read more

Friday night customer service at the register bad actitud not friendly seems she doesn't want to work was a bad service, I wouldn't came back read more

The person who answered the phone for to go order was rude. The pizza was not even warm. To spend almost $30.00 on a pizza I expect good service, and hot pizza read more

Poor service, the old lady at the register looked very impatient. No one was cleaning the booths so my partner and I had to sit in the larger party tables. Overall I would not recommend this Rustys, the pizza was still good but the environment wasn't. read more

Ordered Pizza while at Hotel Santa Barbara hotel. It was fantastic. Great crust & arrived very quickly.

Apparently, you can only order online if you have a local number. Lived here for three years but don't want to give up the number I've had for 15, so it looks like I have to take my business elsewhere. read more

Can I give negative stars? I ordered wings from here last night and they were boiled with some sauce thrown on them. I get it, you come here for pizza but they were DISGUSTING. We threw them out immediately. I would advise not ordering here late either. I had to call back 3 times to just put an order in. I'm hoping I'll be able to eat wings again after last night. *shivers* read more

Great pizza! I ordered the Thin Crust 10" El Diablo Fuego - The Fiery Devil! Ortega® green chiles, chorizo, Canadian Style Bacon, pepperoni, fresh onion, fresh tomato, black olives, with pineapple and jalapenos! Excellent and delicious. read more

Cool it mama bear!!! So this place really does have great food. However, the attitude and looks from the main mama bear at the register make you really think twice about having a meal here. I know some people hate their jobs but at least make it a warm experience to be able to enjoy a meal at this establishment. Good food but expect evil eyes from the bear that just woke from hibernation. read more

Love their flat crust pizza every time. Really cool motif to therestraint itself and amazing prices of beer pitchers. Staff was just OK.

I would not recommend this place. We came here to eat because there was no one in the building it seemed like they practiced social distance rules, but as we were eating a party of about 20 ppl walked and sat in the section we were in, filling up the tables and even the booths they had roped off. There were no middle tables blocked or anything after that party arrived so all these ppl were in a crammed space. no 6ft. apart and I was shocked to see that the business allowed all these ppl to walked in there all fill it up without saying anything. We have our son that has asthma and therfore makes him high risk so we had to get up in the middle of our lunch and leave. My son has not been out in months and its unfortunate he had to experience a HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE because the business allowed them to just fill up the place and not say anything at all!!! I would give this place zero stars but I had to at least do one to post this review. read more

Horrible ! Over an hour wait and no pizza! I called back and they said they needed to confirm my address. Hello, horrible service! Huge prices! They said one hour 30 minutes unless they rushed the order for 40 minutes. No thank you! Went with Taffy's. read more

It was the first visit of Rusty's Pizza! My friend recommended Rusty's Special, which was so good. Meat, pepper, onion (maybe), and cheese were put on it, I remember. (This time, I forgot taking pictures) Usually, every pizza can be chosen from three or four sizes. We shared the biggest one and shared it, but we could eat all! lol If you order only one, you should have the biggest one! It's tasty, so you'll be satisfied with it ;) read more

Very bad customer service not the actual restraint but the call order Gary the manager really rude and couldn't take care of my issue he just blurred out the corporate number no customer service skills at all will never ever order from rustys ever again I orders after I paid by credit card then they tell me it's going to take an hour to receive my pizzaw read more

This was my first time being at Rusty's pizza my girl friend had said let's stop here before going back to slo well the customer service was real real bad I felt unwelcome and when they asked for my name I said Matt 3 time then she said oh well I put Pam that's ok right I said sure and sat down it was very embarrassing to stand up and be called Pam :( not funny I'm realy upset with how they talked to us and treated us food was ok. But I will not be back to this one I will try another later but this spot by far the worst experience never made a yelp review till now read more

Rusty's, Rusty's is good pizza. It's a little bit pricey so if I'm comparing food quality and taste to price is where I got my rating. I also wanted to point out that I don't. I think that is what you would call bull shit. Pretty sure that the point of tipping is how good was your server on serving you the items I requested. When the bill comes in is $200 what does that have to do with how well the server did their job? Now if my tip was based on the cook's performance in the cook was getting the tips I understand this. It's just another way that Society Baker's their actions on repetitive motion and what is normal. But something I heard recently. .... I want to be uncommon amongst the uncommon. I don't care if the bill is $10 or $100 I am tipping the server based on their performance of their job. Yes I have tipped $10 on a $10 bill and yes I have $5 on $100 ticket and I feel no shame or guilt. I was a server in restaurant and a bartender for many years and I was damn good so I deserved every tip I received. Not that I'm going off on a tandem or anything but I also hate that civilians that don't understand how to tip tip a server because their meat was too pink (speaking about a steak). Who are they tipping, the Cook or the server? Get my point? 10 yeah and Rusty's have a really good salad bar. We can't get the pizza without the salad load it out oh I almost forgot that Rusty's have a great salad bar. No pizza without the salad. Load it up baby! read more

Went out to watch the Fiesta events on Friday night with my husband, sister in law and brother in law. We decided that we really wanted pizza before we drove home an hour away. We rushed over the the location with 5 minutes before closing time thinking if they turn us away its ok, we would go somewhere else, but we get in and nothing is said to us, so we order and go to sit down. Our order was about $60.00 keep in mind...so after a few minutes the man in charge (didn't catch his name) told my brother in law that they were closed and that we needed to take it to go. There were still two families in the restaurant eating, but we decided not to make it a big deal, and asked for a refund. At that time, I told the worker that he should have told us when we walked in instead of waiting until we ordered and sat down, his response...he started yelling and pointing his finger saying "I toll you, I toll you, I toll him over there," and started pointing at my husband who only tried to order a beer and was told that they were no longer serving beer, nothing else. I told him that he didn't need to yell, and that he was being very unprofessional. If he would have told us when we go there then we would have gone somewhere else! No problem. He was not listening, just yelling. It was embarrassing, since the other families were watching this. Anyway we left, went to IN and OUT and got GREAT service from them. For much less at that! I do love Rusty's pizza, but will not go back to this one again. read more

Best pizza I've ever had. When I lived in sb I was a frequent customer. Make sure to get their ranch too even though it costs an extra 55 cents! It's worth it. Love you rustys always read more

This place has the ambiance of a dungeon castle which is damn cool but the pizza sucks balls. Get 2 stars for sending me back in time. read more

Best pizza in town! I love the salad bar too, price is reasonable! Clean, good service and fast when you are in rush.