Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    S & J Bakery

    3.5 (10 reviews)

    S & J Bakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - S & J Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Pumpkin Custard Pie - VN
    Vince N.

    I've tried only one thing from S&J Bakery. My workplace orders it annually come Thanksgiving time and most recently a co-worker picked one up for us to devour as an afternoon dessert. DESSERT: Pumpkin Custard Pie First off, I'm a huge custard pie fan. Pumpkin, I'll eat but don't enjoy it as much as my eggy love. Mix the two together and you've got a damn tasty concoction. S&J's crust is the closest to my mom's homemade version, yet hers is still better ;). Flakey and moist with a surprising crunch to the exterior. The texture of the filling is my only quibble. The closest paradigm I can come up with is that it's similar to ricotta cheese; gritty and gelatinous. I'm guessing that's what happens when you combine the two fillings together. It's not repulsive but just a bit odd on the palate. That tidbit aside, the pies always have a fresh, quality ingredient-taste. Top it with some whipped cream and you'll moan with pleasure, lol. Highly recommended. OVERALL: Mmmmm... yessss... ooooh... ahhhh... yessss.... I'll have what she's having!

    a slice of chocolate pie

    See all

    Photo of Lisa D.
    5
    123
    123

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sarah B.
    77
    27
    39

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 8
    Thanks 0
    Love this 9
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    8 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Cute mom and pop business that has consecutively had great pies over the years. Definitely a staple in our house during the holiday season.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - S & J Bakery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 3,229 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Stillwell's Bakery & Cafe - Banana cream pie

    Stillwell's Bakery & Cafe

    4.2(582 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    •$$

    It has been a long time since Ive physically gone to Stillwells to get something. Not to mention…read moregetting something other then pastries. I think the last time was before they changed ownership. Walked in & the vibe was overall different. The store is brighter with music playing . Ive also noticed that they're now on social media, which I'm sire has helped bring in business for them. I went for the special which was the hot pastrami sandwich & I chose Caesar salad for my side. It came on a nice thick bread filled with a generous portion of meat. Really tasty & even though I didnt eat it right away the bread wasnt soggy. I'm really not a salad girlie, but decided that it was a good pairing for that sandwich. If you havent been into stillwells in years, definitely make it back there if you can.

    Stillwells has been around for years and has a steady stream of customers, mostly takeout for…read morelocals, police from the station down the road, but there is a small area of outdoor seating with umbrellas if you want to eat there. Obviously the big draw at this popular bakery is their sticky treats, cream horns are in 2 sizes and decadent, Hubby loved their fruit tart and the apple slice. Larger cakes are available too. We stopped by for breakfast after dropping off a friend at OGG for an early flight as they were one of the few places open at that time. Hubbs chose the special Island Boy and enjoyed the spam, bacon, soft scrambled egg and French toast combo. Very filling. I opted for the fried egg sandwich with 2 eggs, mayo, cheese and tomato on Rye. I was a little disappointed as it didn't have too much taste of rye with soft bread. It definitely needed hot sauce to pep it up. However it was filling and cooked to order. They also do salads and sandwiches and sell coffee and Hawaiian salt too. We will definitely be back for sticky treats again.

    Photos
    Stillwell's Bakery & Cafe - Inside

    Inside

    Stillwell's Bakery & Cafe - Blueberry Cheesecake Crumble $5.95

    Blueberry Cheesecake Crumble $5.95

    Stillwell's Bakery & Cafe - Valentines Strawberries

    See all

    Valentines Strawberries

    Sugar Beach Bake Shop - Maui Lani - Banana Bread and Mango Bread

    Sugar Beach Bake Shop - Maui Lani

    4.8(13 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    •$

    SUGAR YOU'RE SWEET!! En route to the Waihee Ridge Trail, we stopped for rations at Sugar Beach Bake…read moreShop. It was pretty quiet when we arrived at 9am. We were lured by the cooling fresh petite mango bread so we split one. Of course, I needed coffee so I ordered a Bee Nutz, which was perfectly sweet and creamy. We picked up some spam musubis to go with house made teriyaki sauce and a spicy option with jalapeño. Everything was delicious and fresh - and although we didn't get our hands on the sold out hot malasadas, I'm glad we were able to snag something tasty. Will arrive earlier next time for those malasadas!

    I've stopped by here a handful of times now, especially when I'm in the mood for coffee. I would…read moremuch rather support a small local business and I have finally found my go-to drink here in the form of the Char-Latte after a few trial and errors. The Char-Latte comes with in-house made dark salted caramel topped with a hit of local lava salt and is available hot or iced. Their iced version isn't your typical ice cube kind, but rather it's made with finely shaved ice from, you guessed it, Ululani's. Now, while I love Ululani's shave ice, I am not a big fan of using shave ice ice in my coffee. The ice melts way too fast and doesn't keep my drink cool for very long. Hence, the four stars. Regular ice cubes or even coffee ice cubes would be better, but it does the job and it's cheaper than other places at just under $6. They've improved quite a bit compared to when they first opened this location after having to close their Kihei shop for a while. I've watched as they quite literally were figuring things out as they went with the makings of the coffee, but they seem to have a better handle on everything now. If you want a bite to eat, they offer a handful of their greatest hits of baked goods like their banana and mango breads, scones, filled malasadas, cookies, and musubis. I recommend their filled malasadas (ube + lilikoi) and their mango/banana bread. Those are winners for sure.

    Photos
    Sugar Beach Bake Shop - Maui Lani
    Sugar Beach Bake Shop - Maui Lani - Ube and Lilikoi Malasada

    Ube and Lilikoi Malasada

    Sugar Beach Bake Shop - Maui Lani - Cinnamon Roll

    See all

    Cinnamon Roll

    Shikeda Bento Patisserie - Lilikoi Toffee Cream Cake

    Shikeda Bento Patisserie

    4.8(91 reviews)
    1.6 mi
    •$$

    The roll cakes at Shikeda are the perfect treat when you're craving something sweet but don't want…read moreanything heavy or rich. The sponge cake is so light, and the cream fillings are just as light, paired with fresh fruit. Nothing about it weighs you down. The strawberry and cream is my favorite, with the matcha strawberry coming in at a close second. But honestly, my suggestion is to go with the sampler box and get a slice of everything: strawberry, ube, mango, banana, matcha, and cookies and cream. You won't regret it. Just make sure to go early, because they sell out fast. Aside from the roll cakes, they also have bentos, musubi, and sandwiches, so there's plenty to love here. Shikeda does beautiful Japanese-inspired bento and patisserie, and if you have a sweet tooth but want something on the lighter side, this is the spot. Highly recommend!

    Saw this little spot while walking out to the car and the word musubi caught my eye as il always a…read moresucker to have one! While it's a bit of a turn off for me when there are no prices displayed for any of the items, I'll still support you at least one time. There was the spam only musubi and one with egg which is what left with me. Initial visual is that it's juicy because of all the space and rolled in furukaki which are both things that I love! Nice hot when it left in my hand and out the door we went. The taste is good as the sauce wasn't too salty and the rice was just right; not to hard or soft. The rice was still able to hold together and the additional furukaki was generous. Nice shop to try! Street parking was easy for us this time

    Photos
    Shikeda Bento Patisserie - Small store front - go early! Everything sells out.

    Small store front - go early! Everything sells out.

    Shikeda Bento Patisserie - Cake roll "birthday cake"

    Cake roll "birthday cake"

    Shikeda Bento Patisserie - Lilikoi Toffee Cream Cake

    See all

    Lilikoi Toffee Cream Cake

    Sam Sato's - Large Dry Mein

    Sam Sato's

    4.3(1k reviews)
    1.2 mi
    •$$

    Made last minute plans for a trip to Maui and this trip decided I wanted to explore more mom and…read morepop places vs my usual suspects in Kaanapali... so upon landed headed to Sam Sato's. Located in old town Wailuku.. the area looks more commercial than residential, but tucked in the street is this cute restaurant. It's nothing fancy, but they sure do serve up a good meal! I feel like I've been missing out all these years.. the dry noodles and beef stick were perfection! The cha shu topping on the eggy noodles, such a good combo. The beef stick was tender and flavorful. The complimentary soup balanced all the flavors... and I wrapped up my meal with a Lima bean manju. Nice and buttery exterior paired perfectly with the Lima bean filling. I really liked that the bean paste wasn't too sweets All in all loved this place and will be back! Staff super friendly, food comes out fast and it's sooo ono - what's not to love? I will add I order a small dry noodles and had extra so took left overs to go and made a sunny side egg and put it on top of my reheated noodles. Winner of a meal!

    Another 3.5 overall rating. Ordered their dry noodles and manju for a lunch…read more.. Pros- the Manju is very tasty! I ordered a box of 16, 8 of both options (pineapple and red bean). I would order these again in a heartbeat! 5/5! Cons- I preordered a medium pan of dry noodles with veg. I was expecting some kind of vegetable in the noodles. I'm allergic to bean sprouts, so asked they not be used in the dish, but I thought carrots, yellow onions, something... nope, it was just noodles and green onions! No meat either, which surprised me. I ordered what I thought was their deluxe dry, but it was super plain. That was disappointing for sure. I would not order this again. Parking is also crazy tight and limited. Luckily I dropped my son off and drove around the block. If I actually had to park, not sure what I would have done.

    Photos
    Sam Sato's - All the Aunties working hard

    All the Aunties working hard

    Sam Sato's - Teri beef sandwich deluxe

    Teri beef sandwich deluxe

    Sam Sato's - Fresh papaya (8/29/25)

    See all

    Fresh papaya (8/29/25)

    Manuela Malasada - Hawaiian Cream Soda

    Manuela Malasada

    4.2(467 reviews)
    12.2 mi

    We first tried Manuela's malasadas when they had a spot at the 76 gas station in Lahaina. We made…read moretwo visits at their new location at 22 Alahele Pl, Kihei, HI 96753 during this recent Sept 2026 trip. We probably would've gone more if we weren't so full from all the other good eats on the island. On our 1st visit, we ordered Ube cheesecake, cookie butter & Bavarian cream. All were delicious but Ube was our fave. So on our 2nd visit, we ordered Ube (again), crème brûlée & peanut butter cup. Again, it was all so good. Sabrina & John were super friendly. They interacted with their customers with so much aloha. It was also Sabrina's birthday one of the days we came by so she shared extra malasadas & even gave me a rose from her birthday bouquet. How sweet was that?! When you have delicious items plus great service, that would make you want to keep supporting the business.

    Forgot to post this review. It's been a two months since we were there with scrolling through my…read morepictures and saw the malasadas. So I had to write a review These were great -- hot, fresh, and packed with filling. We got lilikoi cheesecake, ube cheesecake, cookie butter, Bavarian, Reese's peanut butter cup, and Nutella. The woman working the truck was the kindest person and patiently helped us pick flavors and fillings. There's plenty places to sit in front of the food truck , an amazing service. Plenty of patience to sit .Highly recommend.

    Photos
    Manuela Malasada - Maui's Ultimate Donut   520 Keolani place   Best Malasadas ever

    Maui's Ultimate Donut 520 Keolani place Best Malasadas ever

    Manuela Malasada - From of the cart with menu

    From of the cart with menu

    Manuela Malasada

    See all

    Wailuku Coffee Company - Bacon, Tomato, Avocado Bagel

    Wailuku Coffee Company

    4.3(503 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    •$$

    absolutely favorite coffee shop. both locations, Wailuku & Haiku are unique but share the same…read moredelicious menu. and the breakfast is so good! I love the siracha bacon biscui sando & a soy latte - every time it's on point. Delish

    It's been a long while since I came to Wailuku Coffee Company. Market Street is always busy and…read moreparking is not really available on the street unless you use the Parking Structure (which is a close walk) but I get lazy at times and want to park close by. Since it was Sunday, I decided today was the day. I'm not a big coffee connoisseur because of a health condition I have and caffeine can affect me but I do love coffee (even if it doesn't love me) but I'll usually go with a Tea option or Smoothie. I decided on a simple smoothie so I got the Keiki Smoothie with Banana, Strawberry and Apple Juice. I asked the waitress what sandwich is the most popular and she said the Turkey Pesto Melt and boy did that hit! It really was the BEST sandwich. It was on a crispy, flaky...and might I add...buttery croissant with thick slices of turkey, tomato, creamy pesto aioli and melted provolone! It came with some chips and dill pickle on the side. The only downside was the price-it was about $17 so I'm sure I'll treat myself once in a good while to this. My small smoothie was $8 but refreshing nonetheless. I love the vibes inside with hanging plants and art work throughout. There was someone doing remote work or school in the corner with her sleepy golden retriever next to her, a few locals outside and some visitors inside. The workers are friendly and I saw one clean the outside tables right away after a few parties left. A nice spot to hit up for some nice breakfast, lunch and a coffee with a friend.

    Photos
    Wailuku Coffee Company - Merch, bought another Tshirt. Now my fave from 2015 & a new one a decade later (8/29/25)

    Merch, bought another Tshirt. Now my fave from 2015 & a new one a decade later (8/29/25)

    Wailuku Coffee Company - Veggie Bagel (rating: 5/5), Thai Iced Coffee - Small (rating: 4/5)

    Veggie Bagel (rating: 5/5), Thai Iced Coffee - Small (rating: 4/5)

    Wailuku Coffee Company - Merch & roasts (8/29/25)

    See all

    Merch & roasts (8/29/25)

    S & J Bakery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...