Brought both cars in a 2 spans due to my personal scheduling conflicts. Quick response to my…read moreinquiry. They are friendly and courteous team. Definitely recommend the shop and will use them in the future.

you ask would i use again? NO it doesn't take 8 hours for a Plug a play install. i had them install…read moreauto start witch came out good. but a 1500 stereo. and then install side blind spot cameras and they were installed facing to the front. all trans action payed in cash. never haggled about price just asked for honest work. there's others that rave about them and there's others. i hate writing reviews cause i don't hold back.

great joy guys honestly just the best shop they got the job done fast and thorough I will…read moredefinitely be back

They dropped my gas tank to fix a leak and put the gas tank on too tight. Which prevented the evap…read morevalve from opening and I wasn't able to fill up my gas tank. I took it back and they lowered the tank slightly so the valve could open. Not long after my check engine light came on and codes P0442 and P0446 popped up. The mechanic admitted they put the gas tank on too tight, which led to the solenoid malfunction. They offered to fix it for $500! I don't recommend anyone take their vehicle here. They have a pattern of creating more problems for their customers than solving them.

Beyond AMAZING! My husband and I have been taking our cars here for quite a few years now! Steve…read more(the owner) is the most honest, reliable, decent human being you will ever encounter! It doesn't matter if your car is foreign or domestic, old or new, he will always be there for you (and take good care of you).... Appointments are definitely a must, because it's always a very busy shop.He does not do things to your vehicle if they are not needed/required. He's just so very honest and decent! His entire crew are the most skilled and reliable mechanics you'll ever know....Kathy who runs the front office is just the best! She keeps the business moving along never missing a beat...I have recommended Penney's North Country Car Care to many family and friends, and everyone just raves about the service provided here.... If you're ever in the St. James area on the North Shore of Long Island, this is where you need to bring your car for anything! Steve is the absolute nicest guy: truly the best! After meeting him one time you will feel like you've known him forever.... P.S.~I'll never take my car to the dealership again!

He's fixed a number of things onmy old commuter Honda since I bought it quickly and affordably.read more

John Munch is a good mechanic and very fair. He checks the car carefully and recommends what is…read moreneeded. We've been customers for several years.

John has been taking care of my 2005 Honda Pilot for the last 10 years. As this SUV is aging and…read moreI'm putting a beating on it dragging it onto various beaches causing all kinds of salt corrosions, Munch repair does an amazing job to keep it running at a reasonable cost. John is an upstanding person to always lay out all his findings and potential risk with cost considerations in mind. Every problem I have had with the car was always diagnosed properly and repair done quickly often within a day or two.

Always accommodating. Friendly, trustworthy people…read more Pricing is always fair. Family run type of place which makes them easy to work with.

Quick service on my transmission. Very familiar with my vehicle. Nice waiting area.read more

Bob is a very knowledgeable mechanic. He's "old school" and really understands how cars work. He…read moreis conscientious and makes sure your car is absolutely fixed before it leaves the shop. Pricing is very reasonable and as a bonus - Bob is a great guy! If your looking for a person you can trust with your car, you will find it in Bob Testa. It's also nice to bring your business to a local merchant.

From the owner: Full service auto repair center in the heart of historic Stony Brook at Village Green BP gas…read morestation. NY State Inspections performed and free air during business hours.

I wish I could have picked no stars because they don't even deserve one!!! They came to inspect my…read more2001 Buick LeSabre in May 2024. After spending $1,000 I was assured that DMV would pass my car because of the amount of money I spent and it failed for mechanical issues, not safety issues. After months of texts and calls to them, then an irate text because then I got a ticket for the inspection in OCTOBER, they told me they spent too many hours on the phone with DMV, 80+ hours, blah blah blah, and they were done. So I call DMV myself and within 1/2 hour on the phone, my job (which was really their job) was done. DMV had to contact them because the receipt they gave me was not written up properly according to DMV. Needless to say, Rich was accurate with what he said about DMV passing it, but it had to be reinspected within a month, from May to October didn't qualify!!! DMV had them redo the inspection and lo and behold, it's taken care of. They cannot honestly tell me they spend that many hours with DMV yet I accomplished all, the call, emailing DMV, everything, in 30 minutes!! As far as I'm concerned, they got their $1,000 and left me out to dry, having to do their job for them!!! I'd rather walk then to have my car repaired by them again. I hate nothing more than an untrustworthy liar and that's what they are. So if you're looking for a reliable mechanic... KEEP LOOKING!!!! If you're looking to get screwed, Rich and Shawn are your men and best of luck to you, you'll need it! *Please note... I waited to write this review to make sure I didn't do it out of anger, but out of truth and concern for others who may fall for their trap. Rich was super nice (as was I), but nice didn't fix my issues. See photos and pay mind to the dates!

A fantastic experience a few days ago on rear brake pad replacement. Super responsive and…read moreaccommodating! The work done was exactly how I needed as well. The price was awesome for break pads and to be able to get this work done in your own driveway is the best part.

Smitty's Garage for the win!…read more My Corvette place was jammed up with work, they couldn't squeeze me in before my trip to Carlisle. A few car guys on social media said to try Smitty's garage. I went to garage and spoke with Will. I told him this Corvette is my baby, treat it with love. I was traveling and he said leave it with us, I have a good Chevy mechanic. I came back, the valve cover gaskets were installed and I was road worthy. Mind you, his shop is busy with summer auto problems, I'm thankful he was able to get me zoomin'. The big question is, why do they get 5 stars? When they changed the valve cover gaskets, they took the time to clean off the residue oil that splattered out. It's that attention to detail that gets noticed. I need a steering part, he said he'd order it but haven't heard back. I'm typing this review from the Port Jeff ferry, we're all busy! I'll hit him up when I return, I would use this garage again because they did a great job on my Chevy

I was driving out an hour from My house to an appointment in…read moreEast Setauket. when my engine shield started to fall off and drag . Luckily I pulled into Smitty's garage and he got his guys to quickly hoist it up,remove it and place in my car trunk to explain To my service shop back home. All done under 15 Min, at no cost. Just a great owner and great experience. "Salt of the earth" . I would switch to this garage if I lived closer.

It's difficult to find an auto shop that you can trust and that won't try to rip you off. East…read moreSetauket Auto is different than the rest. Been taking my old beater work Honda here for years and they have been reliable, friendly and most importantly- honest. They've done all my basic maintenance, usually just brake pad, battery, inspection related. Always done in a relatively timely fashion for a fair price. Never once tried to upsell me on extra work in order to pass inspection. My most recent encounter with them, which is what really motivated me to leave this review, was especially appreciated. I don't know much about cars, but there was something a little stiff with my steering, and I thought maybe the power steering or some belt was going. Took it into East Setauket Auto and asked them to take a look at it and let me know what needed to be done. They could've told me numerous things and hit me with some multi hundred dollar charges, but instead they looked at it and honestly told me nothing was wrong with it and no work needed to be done so I picked my car up no charge. That type of honesty is priceless and will recommend this auto shop to everyone who needs one. Great people here. On top of all that the place just looks cool- convenient location in a nice area- retro, old school style office and shop, feels like going back in time in a good way.

They recently moved to 616 Main Street in Port Jefferson, I am happy to say that the same great…read moreservice is being provided at the new location behind the USA gas station. No matter the model or type of car, they have always done a great job for me at a reasonable price! Wish this family owned business the best at their new location!