Get here early so you can get the slice of cake you really want like Caramel. I choose the cake cake not the cheesecake. Parking is a nightmare so people just try to park close to the door which is an absolute fire hazard. Place stays pretty business so you should prolly call ahead but who plans to eat cake? Just go and be mesmerized. This is a must drop in if you are in the area. read more

Lovvvvvvvessss this place. The cheesecake is the BOMB.COM I love everything he makes but the cheesecake is the best l. I don't even like cheesecake normally because of the richness, but this is something all together different. I must say it's the best I've ever had. I've shared it with a few of my friends as well that don't like cheesecake but we all make a surprise exception for Sammy's. I must also have the strawberry glaze that goes with it read more

You won't find a better place!!! 2 thumbs up!!! That's all I want to say however Yelp say it's to short to post as a review!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Overpriced and overrated. I tried the Oreo cheesecake and it was average at best. The customer service is also lacking. It was my first time so I asked what was recommended, I got a very dry response "German Chocolate or New York". For $8+ per slice at least put some excitement in ya voice. read more

Sammy has the best cakes and cheesecake in town. The red velvet, strawberry, and pound cakes are to die for. The Oreo, snickers, and Reese's cheesecake are amazing. The slices are huge and they have remained affordable to always try something new. He has not compromised quality or quantity for success. You will not be disappointed! read more

Went here to pick up desert after dinner down the road at Hattie's Bbq. There's plenty of parking as it's in a shopping complex. There's no space to eat it inside, so pickup only. We got the cheesecake and the strawberry cake. The strawberry cake was $8 I believe which I thought was a lot but the slice was HUGE as it was basically 2 slices. Also, the cheesecake and strawberry cake were DELICIOUS!! Like this is some of the best cheesecake and strawberry cake I've ever had! The cheesecake has like a caramel crunch crust which is spectacularly done and the cheesecake is so light and flavorful. It's PERFECTLY done! The cake was very moist and the flavors were also PERFECT! It is worth the price no doubt! I would hands down recommend this place, especially for catering or just desert options!!! I'll definitely be back! read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

See all

I normally do my Good, Great, Bad, & Ugly take on a business but I don't have anything too negative about Sammy Cheezecake. The only downside to this bakery is the location & it's not a bang bang shoot em up type of locale, but not up to par with the taste of their cakes. My mom brought a slice home a few times, but I'm not much of a cake eater so I left it for her & my husband to enjoy. Fast forward a year, and I just happened to be on that side of town on my birthday (Friday 7/27) and picked up to slices of red velvet ($6 each). Well that night I had a rare hankering for something sweet & I'm absolutely hooked! I have made red velvet cakes from scratch & they were good, but after eating Sammy's cake I will be retiring from making red velvet cake! Yes it's that good! The service was on point too, and I hate I didn't get the young mans name at the register... Thank you sir for the free birthday beverage. I will definitely be back sooner than later! read more

This has got to be the best cheesecake in Atlanta hands down. Fast friendly service. They have all kinds of baked delicious items. The parking lot can be a little sketchy but don't let that stop you from the worlds best cheesecake. Each slice is about $5 or you can get a whole cheesecake for about $40. read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

I don't know Sammy, but he's my new BFF. I had red velvet, and carrot cake...I can die now. My life is complete!

WOOOOOOOW!!!! This red velvet cake is nothing short of amazing! I'm not from here but I wish he had another bakery back home where I live! I'm very picky but this cake has met every expectation I've had visiting Atlanta! This beats the foods I've tried, I'm so serious! Everything in there looked great and I wish I could've got one of each but that would've been to much sweets bc the cake slices are really 2 cake slices!!! GO GET YALL SOME DARN CAKE !!!! It's the best hands down read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Red velvet w/pecans - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

OMG. I just ordered 2 slices of cake from Sammy Cheezecake and it is the most moist cake I've ever tasted. I'm blown away how delicious these desserts are. Another thing the slices are actually a quarter of a cake. I will definitely be ordering again. read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Lemon cake & Red Velvet cake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

I'm very disappointed Sammy has been great over the years but this particular time i was very disappointed that the employee gave me this OLD MUSHY CHEESECAKE! It wasn't until i got home until i realized it was looking Like this read more

It's not worth the hype... had gotten a Vanilla slice cake. It has a strange thick texture, not light and fluffy but oily with a weird after taste. The cream cheese frosting was tart but didn't seem fresh. The overall quality was good but definitely not great. I was skeptical on appearance and unfortunately the taste and texture only lived up to what I saw.. not sure if the establishment had a bad day but wouldn't go back. read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

The red velvet cake was the best I HAVE EVER had and that is not an exaggeration. It was so moist and the frosting was so creamy! The kids had the vanilla & strawberries and it was equally as good! The neighborhood/strip mall is a bit sketchy, but well worth the trip! read more

Best desserts around! I had a coworker turn me on to them and trust me their desserts are delicious!!! You won't be disappointed!!

This was first time visiting Sammy Cheezecake. I heard a lot of my coworkers and friends talking bout place. I went in today Friday 2/17/2023. I ask for pound cake and key lime cheesecake. The guy behind the counter said, the pound cake is a 35 minute. So, I decided to go up the street and comeback. I get back less than 35 minutes ordered my pound cake and the guy said we don't have key lime. Wait a minute you just had key lime when I was here a few minutes ago now you don't!!!!! Never going back!!!!!! I just saw the key lime less than 35 minutes ago SMH!!!!!!!! read more

Visited this bakery to purchase a slice of red velvet cake and a slice of cheese cake, but not surprised, they were completely out, so I settled for a slice of vanilla cake, due to the fact I drove 40 minutes. Cake was not cooked throughly and tasted old. My throat was also itchy and burning after eating this cake, not sure if anyone else ever experienced this...... This place was very dirty looking in the inside. I Personally would not eat from someone's home that wasn't clean. I think it's highly overrated and over priced. Would not recommend! This place has high reviews, which is so confusing to me..... But everyone expectations is different! Good luck! read more

With my Wife being a baker is tough for me to really enjoy other folks baking. But this spot was A1! My wife decided on the way home to stop by and see what this spot was hitting on and (Man I'm glad I did). Two got two different slices of cake and then we mixed and matched. We got Carrot and Red Velvet. Both of them were great, but the Carrot was king. This will definitely be a spot I put in rotation when I'm looking for something sweet. Next time it will be German Chocolate and Pound Cake. read more

Had a craving for a great piece of cake. A friend of mine told me about this place so I stopped by. I wanted red velvet but it was later in the day and they'd sold out. So I got the strawberry cake. It was so moist and rich. I really enjoyed it. It definitely hit the spot. Ill be back and look forward to trying the red velvet. read more

You NEED their cheesecake in your life, it's what's missing! Long story short, GETCHU SOME! :-)

The red velvet (w/ nuts) and lemon cakes are moist and delicious. Slices are $7, ea. If your ever in the area or have some time to spare before heading to the airport stop by and grab a slice you won't be disappointed. read more

Best cheesecake and red velvet cake around, period. No frills no thrills just good desserts. Takeout only. I've been patronizing for years and it never disappoints. read more

All of the cake taste the same! I'm guessing they use one big batch of batter that is then separated and made into the cake they choose.

I'm talking about the best damn cake in the city. Get that Reese's peanut butter cheesecake and thank me later

I've heard so many good reviews about this place . Saturday I visited this place I ordered a strawberry cheesecake and a red velvet cake . The cheesecake was okay . I've had better however the atmosphere was amazing . Very friendly upon walking in . The red velvet hunty !! I hate red velvet lol . Sammy red velvet is freaking amazing . It's moist and delicious . It melts in your mouth . It was a good cheat treat i would definitely go back for the cake but not the cheesecake . read more

The strawberry cake is soooo delicious! I tasted the cake two weeks ago at a birthday dinner. I had to get some for myself. The cake is moist and well worth the price. I will support this business and I will be back soon! read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

Black owned! Large portions provided and several varieties offered. I like that you can see the cakes being decorated in the background. My friend took me here and he remembers the owner before he had a store establishment so it was really pleasant to hear the exchange between the 2 as they flashed back down memory lane. They offer catering and delivery as well. I tried the red velvet and OMG was it good! My friend's ordered the vanilla cake and ended up coming back the next day to get the cheesecake and something else. Everyone loved it! Because I'm watching my girlish figure, I can't eat here too often but I will definitely keep it in mind when I need some dessert :) No seating available read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Vanilla cake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

See all

Thank you father for all things made with cream cheese, sugar and vanilla..Amen!! OMG why did I wait so long to try this place. I was in the camp creek area and decided to give them a try. I purchased the red velvet cake for myself and the strawberry cake for my hubby. That icing, that icing that icing. I couldve just eaten that alone. It was absolutely delish!!! I didnt get to taste my husbands strawberry cake, he refused to share after he took the first bite. ( The selfishness of it all) We will keep this place bookmarked and locked in our memory as whenever we are in the area, we will have to stop for a few slices. read more

Best cake ! Moist & fresh every time cheese cake is good too lol but I'm more of a cake person

Just tasted the red velvet cake and ..........daammmnnnn It's awesome and I will return read more

Y'all did it! I drove 28 miles Saturday to take care of my sweet carving. Lol when I got there 30 minutes before about 20 plus others had the same ideal. We'll needless they only had red velvet cake. Now i bought three and I shared them. One velvet was original and other had happy writing obit. But anyway it was very moist and fresh tasting once the chill was gone. I might take that ride again ijs read more

Cakes are delicious and you get two slices in one . I would walk in the rain for one of these cakes . A lot of different flavors too. Call and ask before coming if looking for a certain flavor. read more

I had the pleasure of visiting this place yesterday. As i was dropping a friend off nearby. The street sign caught my attention. There's even an arrow pointing you to the direction of the store. It's a small backery that features Classic New York Style Cheese Cake. They had a variety of freshly baked cakes as well. I did get a little upset because now i was faced with the dilemma of choosing what flavor cake. They all looked so good. I ended up with the Cheesecake AND and Red Velvet. Both were delicious. I also appreciated the free Figi water for being a first time customer. For the sweet lovers, the is a place you definitely want to visit. read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

Some of the best desserts hands down! I've shared this place with a lot of my friends and they rave about it also. I usually get the red velvet without nuts. The staff is also pleasant and the place is CLEAN!! It helps that you can see the entire kitchen and often times the owner baking and mixing magic upon entering. The slices are also sizeable. Definitely a must try ! read more

Location is easy to find. The slices are great. I ordered a whole red velvet for Thanksgiving and unfortunately it didn't hold up to standard for us. I will stick to the slices for now on. Don't get me wrong, the whole cake was good just not the best read more

Love the cheesecakes. Red velvet & strawberry cakes are delicious and favorite. New York cheesecake with strawberries.

I love love love the red velvet cake. From my understanding most or all of the cakes contain cream cheese. They are sweet, moist and full of flavor. The price and size match because you can munch on this cake for a couple of days. A small shop in East Point that deserves big recognition! read more

I love this place. They have amazing cakes and cheesecakes. The more I go the more I am blown away by the taste. Thanks Sammie, read more

Sammy Cheezecake - Bakeries Near Me - East Point, Georgia

The cakes are so moist and delicious EVERYTIME. The consistency is on point always I don't see why he doesn't have stores nationwide these are literally the the most delicious cheesecakes and and cakes ever omg. 1 million stars read more

As a New Yorker that is Tiiiiiiireddd ! Of people claiming that they have New York cheese cake when they can't even compare. I APPROVE ! I recommend asking them to pour some of the strawberry gelatin on top of the cheesecake it is so delicious. I also had tried the strawberry white cake as well ( I suggest gelatin on that one as well) it taste like heaven and the size of the strawberry cake are like 2-3 slices in one they have a loyal customer out of me after my first visit. read more