This place is a GREAT - * Pizza tastes absolutely AMAZING * Owners are SUPER kind & welcoming Only tiny complaint: The cheese melts into the box and rips off paper bits... Now I have to inspect every bite for cardboard - still totally worth it, though! read more

Love their pizza, my Monday night pickup for dinner. If you want to order online then you may be upset, IDC so I call in and it works for me. Pizza is delicious, I get sausage and giardiniera for me and giardiniera for my wife. I've also tried their beef roll and it was delicious. Next time I think I will add the giardiniera to the beef roll. read more

They are fantastic and always accommodating and the taste is on the money! Due to medical issues we need our pizza cut in squares and they make sure all the family can enjoy ! This is the place to get the Chicago Tavern Pizza! read more

I gave them a two star for the benefit or the doubt. I hear that the pizza here is good, but when you call at 5:30 and they give you an hour and a half pickup time, something is wrong. Any other place you call is 30 minutes max. Maybe training could help or new ovens. I'll try again in the not near future or when I have an hour or two to kill. Sorry not sorry. read more

Excellent pizza. Sometimes there is a delay but the food is always worth the delay. The staff are nice, friendly and professional. The place is well lit and comfortable. Plenty of seating too. read more

Didn't taste as good as it used to and it was 27.00 for one large pizza. I won't be ordering from here anymore.

Everyone in Sycamore is calling Sam's pizza tonight! I can see how some people many get a little upset about the lead time for their order. They told me 1 hour for pickup. I waited an extra 30 minutes for my order. While I was there waiting for my food at Sam's the phone rang off the hook! Order after Order! They could double the size of their place and still not reduce the lead time! The pizza was the best I have had in Sycamore. I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza! The sauce was really good along with the rest of the pizza! Absolutely enjoyable meal! I recommend Sam's and please be patient with them they really care and work really hard to provide YOU with great pizza! I did see someone order there pizza a head of time and eat it in at Sam's maybe that might be a good option for you. read more

We've gotten pizza from here twice. Both times carry out orders. Ordered both thin crust and stuffed. First time they said it would be ready in an hour. About 1 1/4 hours later we got there only to find that they hadn't even started part of our order. Waited more than a half hour more before our order was ready. The second time we ordered, they said it would be an hour and a half. My wife and brother-in-law went to get the order: three thin crust pizza and wings. They waited for more than the specified time them went and again our order wasn't ready. Took another 20 minutes before the order was ready. It would be worth the wait if the pizza was special but really it is not. Sausage and pepperoni aren't particularly flavorful. They chop their onions rather than thin slices. Mushrooms weren't necessarily the freshest. Taste overall was average at best. Won't be ordering from here ever again. read more

The food is always hot and fresh, they are friendly and efficient. I love getting pizza from here rather than some fast food pizza.

Excellent pizza and Sam and his family are amazing . They make the best pizza in town

We always order ahead to dine in and just enjoy the business being busy. We've never have had a bad experience the pizza is always delicious we drive from DeKalb. The establishment is cozy bustling as people are coming to pick up and the phone is constantly ringing off the hook. This place is my go to for the BESTEST PIZZA IN DEKALB COUNTY. My children grew up eating Sam's pizza, Love Sam & wife. Friendly, hardworking, devoted to their mom & pop pizzeria!! . read more

The best Sycamore pizza and one of the best in all of DeKalb County. Love the Ma&Pa atmosphere to dine in.

Every time I'm in the Chicago area I order delivery to my truck. First time having their pizza and wasn't disappointed! Loads of toppings, plenty of sauce and delivered hot! Delivery guy was very polite. Will definitely eat here again when I roll back through. read more

Sam's Pizza Sycamore - Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Sycamore, Illinois

What can I say, as far as pizza goes in DeKalb County, Sam's sets the standard. Place has been there for decades and, unlike other places an have happen, it is extremely clean, including the kitchen you can see from the counter. You can order just about any pizza you can imagine from the extremely friendly staff/owner. This includes a Keto friendly cauliflower crust. This is definatley our goto in the area and, even though the dining area is small, lookforward to eating in when it opens back up. Highly recommend. read more

Great pizza! A little better than Rosati's and reminiscent of it. Sweeter sauce and better ingredients

These clowns need to get out of 1975. Been ordering from there for years. Tonight was told an hour for delivery. Two and a half hours later I call to find out where our pizza is. Guy tells me I must have called the wrong number! Never again. read more

Great pizza. Order ahead, expect to wait and wait. No matter how we order the pizza is always atleast an hour late. Call in the order two hours ahead. Show up on time, wait in the lobby for a hour. Was there a rush, nope. Walk in order the pizza without calling in. Wait an hour and a half. Was there a rush, nope. Sam's Pizza. Great pizza, terrible service. read more

Arrived for pickup an hour after ordering, as instructed. Told pizza would be ready in another 15 minutes. Three teenage kids "working" inside, but really flirting and not paying attention. Now I remember why I stopped ordering from here years ago. read more

Pizza is just not great. Crust was so dense and clearly they put no effort into it. Will never order from here again. Really disappointing because I heard this place was good. Was definitely not good. read more

Called my delivery order in at 5:30 on Fri and was told an hour or so, (Small pepperoni pizza and a dozen wings) when it still hadn't arrived by 8 i called for a status, the teeniebopr girl that took my order didn't give the ticket to the kitchen (too busy playing on her social media) so my dinner got here about 9pm ( $42 for a small pepperoni pizza and nine wings.. This is what being a loyal customer gets you.. read more

Best pizza in town. Literal mom and pop joint for 45 years. Family owned authentic pizza. Get some!

Pizza was huge and it was pretty good! Delivery woman was so kind and the food was piping hot when it arrived. My favorite part was the hot wings, these things are 10/10 amazing. read more

Best pizza in Sycamore or Dekalb. I grew up with my fathers pizza joint (Pagilias) and workd in one for 10 years...known as a pizza snob

My boyfriend and I were in the area so we decided to stop here and eat. We are from Chicago so we didn't expect the pizza to be great from the suburbs. We ordered to dine in, a 14 inch half sausage half pepperoni. He said it would be about 20 minutes, it took about an hour, no apologies or anything. I understand it's a Saturday evening but a simple "sorry it took so long" goes a long way. The pizza was decent not bad but not great. I would of given this place 3 stars but now my boyfriend and I are both sick from the pizza. It was the only thing we ate all day, so their is no doubt it was from the food here. Do not recommend at all. read more

We ordered a 20inch pizza pepperoni/sausage. It was hot and tasty. We ordered to go and it was ready on time.

It seems like every town has a Sam's pizza, I don't know what it is but it's most definitely a thing. Anyways, I decided to try it out one night and it was definitely worth the wait. Pan pizza is always the way to go. And don't forget the breadsticks, garlic or cheese, you can't go wrong with either. Inside has an old school vibe with the smells of pizza coming from the back obviously. Check it out. read more

A staple in Sycamore! Great pizza and great cheesy beef roll! Though wait times can be over average the food is well worth the wait!

Awesome deep dish!Sauce is sweet and the cheese is melting away in your mouth. Good amount of quality ingredients. Price for the pizza was outstanding! read more

Sam's Pizza Sycamore - a deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sycamore, Illinois

Best pizza in town (including DeKalb)! They are open and deliver until midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. 10pm during the week.

Pizza here is the best in Sycamore. Delivery can take a little bit at times, but it is worth the wait. Order early!

The pizza and wings are just WOW! Super delicious and worth it. I've been coming here for 10 years never disappoints.

Happened to be in Sycamore for the first time, and thought this little unassuming pizza place had serious potential. Boy was I right!! The place is small. Filled with neon orange booths that look like they were transported from a 1981 McDonalds. Awesome. The pizza maker behind the counter is Sam's son, direct from Italy. I struck up a conversation with him and learned that he has been making pizza there for 37 years. THIRTY SEVEN YEARS. That alone is reason to visit!! The menu is small, but the pizza is great. Sausage was big homemade chunks, and the cheese was plentiful. Check online for the special and you get a free 10 inch cheese pizza for free with your order. Bonus! So...Sam's rocks. Run, don't walk, to Sam's Pizza!! read more

This was the first time I ordered from Sam's Pizza and thought the pizza was great. It is the best pizza I have had in the Dekalb/Sycamore area since I moved here 5 years ago. The thin crust was perfect and the amount of cheese was just how I like it. The only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because of two things. I was told that delivery would be around 40 mins and it took almost 90 mins for my pizza to arrive. I do not have a problem waiting as long as they give me an accurate time. The nice thing is that the food was hot when it arrived. I also ordered bread-sticks and they did bring them. Normally with the forgot bread-sticks and long delivery time I would put this on my no go list, but the pizza was great and will order again. read more

I've began wondering about this pizzeria as I often pass it to and from one of my New Glarus beer hauls. Ordered a stuffed pizza to go, which had a 55 minute wait, which didn't bother me as I figured that it must be pretty good. Walked in and encountered a friendly grey-haired man making dough, who had a pleasant aura and demeanor about him. Pizza was pretty good, even though the flavor was rather light as I really never had a stuffed pizza wasn't either too cheesy or had too much sauce, this had an equal balance of both. Overall not bad, interior had a 80's nostalgic feel to it. read more

Let me start by saying they have good pizza, but I don't think they have any idea of customer service. We ordered a pizza( on the busiest night of the year) and it took 1 1/2hrs to get it in my car, they stated pick up would be an hour and delivery would be about 2-3, pick up it was. 1hr later we pulled up and sent my kid in with $. 25 minutes later they had not comeback, so I went in and saw him paying, then heard them talking and saw them making the pizza watched it bake and was waiting for a simple we missed it or a sorry(nothing free or money off) but it never came. much can be fixed with that one simple word, lawsuits have been stopped by "sorry". Heartbroken I will have to find a new pizza place, maybe Hinks or world famous. read more

If you are looking for a well made large Pizza for under $15, Then Sam's is the place for you. Even though it isn't a deep dish pie, it is a real, homemade Chicago style Pizza. Sam's does use quality ingredients with an exceptionally good sauce and cheese. During my visit, there was only one guy running the entire restaurant, and despite that, he provided excellent service. The Atmosphere of the restaurant was casual and seemed like a great place to hangout with friends, not a Restaurant suitable for a first date. I will definitely be back for another pizza soon read more

This place is great! I recommend their pizza to everyone. Ordered this evening and everything was delicious. Have to try their cheese breadsticks aka bosco sticks for your side with your pizza. read more

A good friend of mine at the school we teach at brags about Sam's Pizza place every day I'm with him. How awesome the pizza is, a local family owns it with the BEST D**M chicken wings. Well I live 55 minutes away from Sam's. So to shut him up I called his bluff, last night my wife and I ordered chicken wings from Sam's with a large thin pizza. I saw some of the other reviews mentioned that they tend to run late but not on our order. They quoted me 1.25 hours for the food order to be ready. When I pulled in a little over an hour later our order was ready. I brought a warming bag and it worked well on the long drive home-it kept everything hot. The tomato sauce tasted home made with a hint of sweetness, the vegetables were cooked perfectly with a slight crunch and the Canadian bacon was delicious. The pizza crust had a slight crunch but not too soft, excessively baked, or too doughy it was just right. The chicken wings were fall off the bone-out of this world. Fully cooked and the sauce had just the right amount of heat to wake up your taste buds. My apologies, my wife and I never tried their ranch sauce since we fell in love with the bar be que sauce. Usually my wife and I order a large pizza for leftovers on the following day but we finished both the pizza and the wings that night. We couldn't stop eating- it was soooo good! It is our favorite Pizza restaurant now. Place Sam's on your bucket list of restaurants to try. Yup, my friend was right. read more

The pizza is the best. It is cooked the old fashion way and use quality ingredients. You won't be disappointed. Keep in mind that it does take a little longer for them to cook the pizza. They are not cooking it on a conveyor belt. read more

I have loved Sam's pizza every since my childhood growing up in Sycamore. Whenever I come back to visit my parents ordering Sam's is always on my "to do" list. I have always enjoyed their thin crust, tasty sauce, and the generous amount of cheese. A family run business that really cares and knows its customers. read more