Try the banana pudding ice cream it's delicious and have nilla wafers in it. Been a Tybee classes…read morefor years.

Cute little ice cream shop located right across from the salt island fish and beer restaurant we…read morehad dinner at so we were tempted and walked across the street to see how this place was. The ice cream I got was the blue monster and it was my first time trying it. The ice cream itself was mediocre and nothing to right home about. The entire shop was really cool and well decorated though.

Nice, family owned business with friendly service and awesome ice cream. I had a custom cookie ice…read morecream sandwich with sugar cookies and butter pecan ice cream. It was tasty.

Got the brookie brownie, one of the best desserts I've ever had. Would return to Tybee for this…read moreplace alone. The owner is extremely friendly. The rating should be 5 stars.

Absolutely stellar beach drinks!! Highly recommend! Relatively cheap as well! Small and quaint…read morethough too

Not the best ice cream- small scoops and expensive. The girl in front of me ordered the same size…read moreand got twice as much ice cream. Won't be back

Got some delicious salted caramel ice cream, I loved it so much!!! Very yummy will return. It was a…read morecute little place on the pier.Wouldn't say service was anything special but they were nice and gave me some big scoops

Good flavor selection & gives a good serving size $4 for a small. It's just Hershey's ice cream not…read morehomemade or anything but if you want some mid-day at the beach this is right on the boardwalk.

We wanted something sweet and went to the Tybee Bakery where we picked out blueberry muffins, a…read morebanana cake and a pineapple upside down cake. All were excellent! And the staff was very helpful. We will definitely go again on our next visit to Tybee Island.

What lovely owners…read more.. We spent a little over a week on Tybee Island, and I wanted to do something nice for our final day, since we were largely eating a lot of leftovers out of the fridge that accumulated all week... The owners did a fresh fruit pie for us that was just great - with fresh whipped cream on the side. If you are on the island, call them ahead (the need a few days) and put in an order for food or bakery items...they are great!

Many flavors at this quaint ice cream shop. I personally loved the cappuccino dark chocolate…read moreflavor. Service was fast and friendly.

The store was a pretty run down, but a nice location near the beach and pier. The ice cream was…read morepretty good, but nothing special. They offer a few tables to sit at while you enjoy your frozen treats.

Don't let the outside fool you. It did me last year, but this year we went ahead and tried it…read more Sundae Cafe is wedged between a liquor store and a convenience store, this is apparently a thing on Tybee island. What you find inside is a nicely appointed restaurant with a beautiful long bar which we highly recommend you eat at. Our bartender Christy was amazing. But more about her later, right now I will talk about the food. We started with the margarita scallops, which was chunks of seared scallops soaked in margarita on toasted wonton chips with a black bean corn, salsa and drizzle with a local aioli, YUM! We also had their fried green tomatoes, which came with apricot horseradish sauce and aoli. Kiki had the catch of the day, which was a grilled piece of grouper atop mediterranean couscous and a medley of mediterranean vegetables. I had the prime rib, which came with lobster Chili Churri butter and a brandy peppercorn sauce. Both entrees were amazing. Now back to our bartender Christie. To say that she wears many hats is an understatement. She greeted us when we sat at the bar, by the way, did I mention that you can reserve seats at the bar? She described the menu items in a way that you only expect to find from a waiter in the finest restaurants in the world. She addressed any and all allergy issues relating to these dishes all the while she is making drinks for patrons at the bar as well as handling the service bar for all the patrons in the restaurant. Without missing a beat, she takes our order.Buses plates from other customers and continues to make drinks for everybody in the restaurant. At this point I think I told her her new nickname should be the Flash. At one point during our dinner, we saw her serve a bottle of wine to another couple at the end of the bar. Her presentation was that of a full wine sommelier with pouring a taste for approval while showing the label of the bottle as she waited for the customers approval then pouring the glasses after approval was given. List of hats: Bartender Bar Back Waiter Sommelier Entertainer Influencer to a new generation of food service, people on Tybee island. ( She babysat the owner of Bubba Gumbo's.) Lest I forget she is also the General Manager of the restaurant. She is someone that I would like to call friend after meeting her once and eating at her restaurant only once.

Our first time here, heard a lot about this restaurant so checking it out. It's also my wife's…read moresister 75th birthday. Started with some bread, a scallop appetizer and salad which was pretty good. Our main dishes are spectacular, the flavors are amazing, best prime rib I have ever had, complements to the chef's. For dessert we had Banana pudding cheese cake. Melissa our waitress was excellent, knew her specials, friendly and professional kept up with us and made sure we had what we needed. The atmosphere is great, not a large dining room but it is a beautiful restaurant. The only thing when at capacity it is loud, so it is at times hard to hear your own conversation. I (we) highly recommend this restaurant when on Tybee Island, The restaurant is open till 9:00pm so make a reservation.

If you want EXPENSIVE frozen yogurt, then this is your place. You pay by weight after filling a cup…read morewith yogurt and topping it with candy. You don't know what you are paying until you weigh in at the register. I was shocked when my daughter's cup rung up at $19. Granted it was a full cup (it was her birthday), but it was still a single serving. The total bill for her and her two friends with smaller portions was over $44, not including tip. To be fair, the girls loved their yogurt. The quality isn't sub-par. Additionally they are located right near south beach and the pier, an easy walk on a hot summer day when you need a cool down. Product isn't bad but I had to downgrade the stars due to the price which I personally thought was a bit too high. I won't be returning.

Absolute worst frozen yogurt I've ever tasted. They don't do samples so your tasting at own risk! I…read moregot the butter pecan and mango sorbet. Both were watered down and partially thawed coming out. There was zero creamy-ness to this. Selection was limited with about 8 options. It was $11.50 for a little of both. I can't believe this place stays in business!! Don't waste your money. I took two bites and threw it away.