I know this place already has a huge ego from all of their excellent reviews but I have to give…read morecredit where credit is due. The chicken vodka burrata pizza is to die for. Vibe is dark and loud. Unless there's a hidden upstairs or back room, seating is limited which is a problem when the pizza is this good. Meatballs as an appetizer is pretty much the only non-pizza thing to get here and those are solid as well. Service was good and pricing is fair for the quality of the food!

Recommended by a server at a new local restaurant. hhe was well versed in food. His comment was -…read more"I'm not from the area but I stopped in at Beekman Ale House...the best thin crust pizza I've ever had" Next day here we are, walked in, there were three seats available at the bar, grabbed all three so that we can have some breathing room. The place is not big but packed, we must have lucked out. The noise level was through the roof - LOUD is an understatement. Every table had at least one pizza 'stand' The menu is limited - 4 starters, 4 salads, 11 pizzas and 1 Pie of the week - (add ons available, pies 12"), oh and 1 desert. On Tuesdays Detroit style pizza - THE END. We ordered the Bianca - Sausages, Garlic, Broccoli, Baby Kale, Cremini Mushrooms and Mozzarella. It took a while but well worth the wait. The pizza was delicious - thin crispy crust, it was like bitting into a loaded crispy, chewy 'potato chip' Very reasonably priced Will be back One star off for room temperature red wine

The food was excellent, particularly the specials. The service was attentive, though there were…read moreoccasional slight delays. While the ambiance is cozy, some of the dining areas may be less accommodating for taller guests.

The vibe here was great, we sat in the beer garden in the back. The tint of the covering adds a fun…read moreambiance, and the service was quick and friendly. I ordered the Cobb salad, which was very sizable and I appreciated the amount of chicken. The elk burger was also delicious, though the cheese was a bit of an odd texture that seemed to not fully melt.

Only take out Had…read morebeen going there for years and then stopped when they moved. Good pizza. Toppings are adequate and good flavors. White pizza was a hit as was vegetarian I recommend this place.

If you're looking for a pizza spot I'd recommend coming here…read more They have pizza, calzones, and more! There is indoor seating and booths available. This is a quiet spot with free parking. If you're looking for pizza, I'd recommend stopping here.

We stopped in here Saturday night during the street fair for Halloween. They were one of the few…read morebusinesses nice enough to let people use the bathroom even if they didn't buy anything. The staff were friendly and efficient. Pizza was good. I just got a plain slice. Sadly they brought out the white pizza as I was leaving. I would definitely come back the next time I'm in Sleepy Hollow.

Casaletto Pizzeria is legit. Good crust, quality ingredients, and the pizza tastes like it should…read more Not greasy, not dry--just done right. Feels like a real neighborhood spot: quick service, fair prices, and consistent every time. Easy place to recommend and come back to.

The pizza is excellent. I have ordered on many occasions and have never had a bad pizza. I have…read moretried both the regular cheese pizza and the white pizza. Have occasionally ordered chicken or veal Parmesan. I live nearby so I pick up when I order so I can't comment on delivery. I definitely recommend this pizzeria. One thing, it is primarily for takeout as there are only a few small tables.

Quick Friendly Delivery within the time frame ... Slices were amazing definitely a new family…read morefavorite since we have moved to the area.. Than You

I'm so sorry for this late review but I dined here on 6/13 for my babygirls 16th Birthday! And I…read morehave been so crazed working and getting ready for our big trip, I haven't been able to sit still anyway, I wish I could give this restaurant more star so I will add to this review at the end. I got a great exclusive prefix menu for my Princesses day! I was able to make some changes and I tell you what I spent per person with my family was a fair price. The food was absolutely amazing. I'm sorry I don't have many food photos because I was trying to be in the moment! But I will be back and will try the patio which I had really hoped for for my party but there was another private party or large and we were upstairs but my girl said it gave her the bday vibe she wanted. We had reservations for 7p, I got there early and everyone welcomed us anyway and sat us immediately no waiting until your whole party arrives. We had amazing drinks, bread, family style apps the Burrata and the meatballs to die for! We all mixed between spicy rigatoni, seafood linguine frute de mar, filet Mignon, branzino, it was all amazing and I'm drooling as I type! Please give this place a try if you haven't because the service is 10 and food 10

Wow! What a delicious meal, with great, attentive service in a place that felt warm, but also…read morefestive and lively! AND there were vegan options, so my vegan sis had a great meal too! Loved this spot!

Large parking lot…read more Arrived around 3pm on a nice Sunday and it was fairly empty. Lots of picnic bench-style indoor and outdoor seating. Neat and very well-maintained space. A great selection of beer on tap. There is also a nice selection of food as well. Good mix of diverse people...different age groups including some kids. Friendly and helpful staff throughout. Shop with some merch and to-go beer. Clean bathroom. Would love to return to try some other beers and maybe some food options.

Fantastic beer selection, even the session IPAs were very good. I thought that my Philly…read morecheesesteak was surprisingly good, especially on the sesame Semolina roll. The vibes were great for the Argentina v Cabo Verde game although they could've cranked up the a/c a bit.

We cannot say enough about how much we love this place. Sylvia is the most warm person and embodies…read morethe spirit of customer service. Anna always remembers our order and is so helpful with recommending options. We love this local gem. And the food is beyond our expectations. My husband always orders the same dish. Thank you for being our favorite spot.

The worse of the worst OMG Save your time I wouldn't feed…read moremy family here. The service is pathetic.