I just had buffalo wings. The wings were a bit disappointing. They were a bit bland, had a lot of oil, didn't have a lot of meat on them, and didn't have the typical buffalo sauce. But hey, the service is always great here, and the food is usually quick to get. But wings aren't really their specialty. read more

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta - Buffalo bone in wings - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

I used to live in Schuylerville and loved it. I still try and go there when I am back to visit. We were there in February and it's still great! Love their pizza! read more

What I love about this place is that it's simple, consistent, and affordable. I regularly order their Wednesday pasta special with meatballs, and it's always great. My daughter loves it too, and you really can't beat the price. It's the perfect option for those busy nights when I'm running between dance classes, work, and school. read more

Ordered from here again as it is the only place open. We ordered boneless garlic parmesan rings they were okay. If you have stomach issues like acid reflux I would avoid them. They are extremely garlicky and buttery. Both friend and I had uncomfortable stomach the next day. The pizza. I wanted to like it. The dough doesn't really have a flavor. The crust was too thick for me but not crispy enough and kind of fluffy and I like thinner bottom crust.. The sauce isn't too thick it's not too thin it's got an acidic flavor and a sweet flavor again just nothing special. There's a lot of cheese on it yet like the last time it seemed like it was almost burnt. Somehow all together it doesn't make it anything I want to try again. My roommate called it school lunch cafeteria pizza. Then he said it reminded him of Pizza Hut so if you like Pizza Hut I suppose it could be a good thing. I'm not a Pizza Hut person. I would like to try their gyro or their breakfast. I will not get their pizza again. read more

See all

I've tried to give this place the benefit of the doubt, but last night we ordered take out and everything I ordered was wrong. I was given the wrong salad and the wrong sauce on my wings. There have also been times where I've had to call several times before someone picked up to take my order. read more

From NJ and the pizza there is good....Personal Pan was terrific and the place is really cute inside

In town working on a contract and ordered a large meat lover's through the Toast App. Super easy and quick pickup time. Friendly staff and nice establishment. Pizza was awesome and had a great flavor. Pizza sauce was nice and not sweet like others have said. Glad the sausage wasn't crumbles and instead slices and it was cooked to perfection. Will definitely be ordering from here again when in the area! read more

Finally made it to Schuylerville pizza and pasta for a quick take-out experience. When I first called, the girl that answered the phone just said, "hello?!". So, I had to ask if I had the right number... she said, "yeah". Not the best first impression. But, I ordered the pizza and she said it would be ready in 20 minutes...and abruptly hung up. OK...whatever. Pick-up was a different experience. The girl behind the counter was friendly, courteous and efficient. All staff is masked and the seating area is far away from the takeout counter. There were a few tables with people dining in. I didn't expect it to be as large, clean and spacious as it is. The pizza box was hot and when I got home I put it in a 200° oven for a few minutes. The pizza is somewhere between a thick crust and regular-style pizza. I would maybe classify it as more doughy with a smaller, lighter crust. It's different than most of the pizza places that I've been to in this area, so that's a good thing. It's not NYC-pizza, but it's definitely a decent choice. read more

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta - Large pizza with half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

We have ordered pizza and salad here and it never disappoints! The staff is very nice and efficient. We've never had a problem.

Excellent food and service. Will be back. The pizza is very tasty good crust. The Greek salad was excellent. My favorite was the Buffalo chicken tender sub. The bread was fresh and as were the ingredients. Great stuff all around and very affordable. read more

While traveling and viewing the beautiful leaves of the fall we decided to stop and get something to eat near Schuylerville. We tried a few restaurants from Yelp, they were closed, but we found Schuylerville pizza and pasta open. We were seated immediately, and the waitress took our drink order and brought it out right away. The place was not crowded, and this girl took care of both the counter and the tables. We ordered fried mozzarella sticks with Melba sauce and a medium size pizza with sausage. Both were excellent! The waitress kept our glasses full and stopped by a few times to make sure everything was in order. We were too full to take advantage of the desserts, but they had some cannolis and some cakes and a few other things which really looked delicious. If you're in the area I suggest you stop there, the food is good the service is good and the atmosphere is good. read more

I try this place when I come up to visit family every so often, hoping that they'll get better, because they used to be some of the best pizza and salad I'd ever had. So, I will say compared to my last review, it has in fact gotten better in terms of how the place is run. Granted, I got a pickup order on a Sunday night, but they were still handling delivery orders and the staff was friendly when I went in for my food. I'm mostly let down this time because the chicken parm that I ordered looked delicious out of the container. Smothered in cheese, over some angel hair spaghetti, as any good parm should be... and while I would have loved a little more chicken to pasta ratio, the issue was the chicken itself. It was all burnt, and made to be hidden under the cheese. So, I'm not sure if it typically comes with that much cheese or if this was to cover up the burnt chicken, but that was a let down, especially given the price of the food. The baklava was a delicious classic Greek style. read more

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta - a fork in a pie pan - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

Grilled chicken sand homemade onion rings where great. Honey had a Rubin. Also tender ,sliced a bit thick but no fat and tender.

got the same order wrong twice and owner was extremely rude and charged me for the wrong order

There has been a change in staffing or something. The pizza is now inedible with raw crust. I have given them many chances but the last 3 pizzas at least have been terrible. I've been going there for at least 15 years. I will not be back. I should have taken a picture of the pizza they sent me home with that looked like it dropped on the floor. read more

Great pizza - we love the house. Always reliable delivery no matter the weather. Not a bad spot to stop and eat as well.

Great location right off the main Route 29/Spring St. area. Very nice setting. Nicely remodeled in recent years. LOVE, LOVE, LOVE the pizza as the crust is very unique. Seems like it might be made with corn meal. But what ever it is made with, I love it and so do several others that I know whom live in the area! The same waitress seems to be there whenever I've visited and she's very quick and efficient when the place gets busy. While not highly amiable, the service is friendly enough to make you want to return over and over. The last time I was there, I had the house-made lasagna and it was DELICiOUS! read more

I can recommend without reservation. The best pizza around. Great prices and good service.

We have eaten here many many times. It's usually very good, we always get the Calzones, there delicious. Tonight they were very busy, we sat at table for like 10 min and no one came over. We finally ordered. My Calzone was cold in the middle, my moms pizza was undercooked. Very disappointing meal. read more

Went here a few weeks ago and was disappointed in the pizza. I have been getting pizza there for almost 20 years and when I went the crust was totally different. Tasted like a pre made Boboli crust. Very disappointing to a faithful customer. I heard that it might be new owners. Maybe this is the reason but they need to get the old recipe to keep this customer and many others that have stopped going there. read more

I kept trying to give them the benefit of the doubt- I love supporting small businesses but again tonight placed order for delivery ordered at 6:08- Called at 7:22 to check on status of order- she tells me he is out for delivery. Shows up at 7:45! We live 5 min up off Rt 29. Only ordered 2 wraps and a sub! Fries ice cold. Had many issues over the years and nothing has changed with giving the feedback to the owners just gets worse. This was the last time! Too many other places to give my business to. read more

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

Really great veggie pizza. Lots of veggies on a tasty crust ... not too tick and not too thin. read more

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

I discovered Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta several years ago - before the fire/renovation - via a coupon in an Entertainment book. That did the job, because it convinced me to come back here when I could, even though they no longer participate with that coupon. They don't need to; their food speaks for itself, especially the pizza. They do a Greek-style pizza with a Greek-style crust, which I actually prefer. The crust is lighter and crisper. The toppings are very fresh. You definitely get your money's worth in terms of portions as well, and service is fast. But don't expect to show up on a "slow" night, because I don't think they have those. Tuesdays are half-prize for small and medium cheese pizzas, and there is a pasta special on Wednesday nights. Good luck - and use some patience - getting a parking spot on those nights, as they do a lot of take-out business. read more

Parking and access was easy, the facility is clean and open feeling. pretty comfortable. My wife had ravioli and marinara and raved about it. And she brought half of it home. I have a rueben and fries and I would have to say both were amongst the best I have ever had. The rueben was excellent, lots of very flavorful and tender meat, excellent kraut, good bread and a tasty russian dressing. The fries, were well seasoned, super crispy and yet still soft inside. We will be back. read more

We happened upon this place after we went apple picking. One of the employees there recommended this place. The staff was very nice and helpful. My meat lovers pizza was amazing! Best pizza I've ever had!! The dough was so light. The cheese was so good , it's was on the pizza and on my toppings. I wish it was closer to home. I would totally come back next time I'm in town. read more

I really am not sure what has happened to this business. The food used to be good and the place was normally packed with patrons. It seems as of lately the customer service and quality of food has been lacking. More and more complaints around the area of food quality and service. Whatever has changed needs to be reversed as this was once a great place for pizza and calzones. Something has changed. read more

This is the best pizza shop in Schuylerville. My 12 year old son had a small pepperoni pizza. My boyfriend ordered a roast beef sub and I ordered a chicken parm sub. The service was excellent and fast. The bathroom was very clean and i would have to say the best bathroom I've been in in a pizza shop. There is nothing I can say bad about this place. #perfection read more

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta - Half of the chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Schuylerville, New York

See all

Only pizza game in town. And yes, I know you are there Monument Pizza, but as I just said... Large pie is 8 big 'ol slices of cheesy goodness. Place is always hoppin' on the weekends. You know what they say, when you visit a town, eat where the locals eat. They will point you to the best in their town for the best price. read more

This place is horrible! I came in here during lunchtime today and I was the only one there with my wife and daughter.. I had the roast beef sub. The roast itself is good but only got 3 small thin layers of it with a lot of lettuce on top, my wife had turkey and broccoli sub and she only had 1 layer of turkey. My daughter had French fries with cheese and bacon, that was good but not enough nacho cheese. The prices are very high for this small amount of food! My check totaled $35, $30 +5 for tip. Just for lunch.. I'm never coming back here again! The management either needs to up on their meat on subs.. I had to order fries separate because the sub does not come with a side. $10 for a roast beef sub with small meats and tons of lettuce.. I can go to a sub shop and get the best sub with tons of meat for same price. Good luck to anyone who comes here to visit at this place! read more

See all

I love this place. Prices are good. Food is 99% of the time on point and they don't close and reopen every two months like another place in town. The only thing I wish they would change is when contacted about an issue, they should respond. We notified them via FB, it's quick and easy for us to message them, plus it doesn't tie them up during busy times, but we had a problem with a delivery and they read it but never even acknowledged the small issue but it's a free pass. It wasn't anything extreme like we have had elsewhere. Delivery times are always fair for sure. Please don't ever close! read more

It was good but damn that's some weird German food. The lady at the counter was excellent and reminds me of star trek

Pizza: ok Pasta: absolutely not Friendly service, both in house and delivery. Nice/clean dining area. read more

Whether you want just put pizza or a complete dinner, this place has good food and great service at reasonable prices. My wife had the pesto chicken dinner and said it was much better than another well known fancy Italian restaurant. read more

I give this restaurant two stars because the pizza was pretty tasty. I would like to give them one star because of their aggravating business practices. I ordered a pizza on half price Tuesdays just to arrive and have them inform me that a large pizza doesn't qualify. The pizza I paid for cost way more than I was otherwise willing to spend. They should have confirmed this rule when I asked them if pizzas were half price on the phone, then immediately followed with ordering a large pizza. This is completely unfair and was done on purpose. Beware of the specials here. They will not inform you of the stipulations beforehand. read more

Stop taking dinner orders 50 minutes before closing. Then they should say they close at 8 not 9! Especially on a busy end of summer weekend.

We love this place. Authentic Italian. Nice friendly staff. I called to order a lasagne dinner to go and they didn't have any. I was about to hang up when the woman on the phone suggested I try the Penne w/meat sauce. It was fantastic. I thought it was great that she took the initiative to suggest another option. We have not had a bad meal here. Love it. read more

Good location, clean and bright dining area, friendly employees...but terrible pizza. Tastes like a thick piece of cardboard, topped with Ragu and cheap mozzarella cheese, then cooked in a food dehydrator. read more

They just reopened after a fire and we were hoping the pizza would have improved like the look of the new and improved dining room. No such luck. We ordered a 24 cut 1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni and what we got was a lot of bread. VERY little cheese. The bread is super thick and has no taste. The sauce almost non existent. The pepperoni side had one or two pieces of pepperoni per slice. Really? Just awful and too expensive for what we got. I can get a much better pizza at Price Chopper for half the cost. Such a disappointment. It makes me wonder if the owner tries his own pizza. I don't think he/she does. I understand they have to make a profit to pay for all their improvements, but if the food is terrible you lose customers. It's that simple. read more

So much nicer to go to and have a meal since the remodel. Service is good and the food is excellent. Wait staff I pretty good and attentive. Entrees range from lasagna, stuffed shells, spaghetti and meatballs balls to fish and chips and burgers and more. I had the lasagna, my wife ravioli, my oldest boy had a bacon burger and the two younger kids had chicken tenders and pizza. And yes... They certainly do have pizza. Go on one of the pizza or pasta special nights for discount pricing. They have subs too, but we haven't tried any yet. read more

Schuylerville Pizza and Pasta has reopened after a fire, and it's even nicer than it was before. The dining room has been expanded and updated, and it seems busier than ever. It's still my mom's and my favorite place for pizza in the greater Saratoga region, worth a drive east to Schuylerville. My elderly mom likes to eat pizza in a restaurant setting rather than take-out, and she's pretty fussy about what she likes. We both prefer a somewhat crispy, lightly seasoned, bread-like crust, not too thick (a la deep dish) or underdone-doughy, with tasty sauce and rich, gooey cheese. The pizza here is exactly the way we like it (definitely not a NY or Long Island style). We recently went on a Friday night, and every table or booth was full. There were quite a few waitresses on hand, so service was fast and friendly. They also do a brisk take-out business. read more