What sets Sal's pizza apart is the cheese. It's amazing, and they don't skimp on it. We are so…read morehappy that Sal's has come to Sussex. As for the service, our pizza was ready exactly when they told us it would be, and they have two card readers which cuts the wait time to pay in half. Great experience for our first of what will become many trips to Sal's.

My parents love this place. The pizza is good overall. I'm a big fan of sausage on my pizza but the…read moretaste of theirs is a bit off. Lots of cheese. Sauce isn't too bad. For some reason my son and I always get stomach aches after eating their pizza. Not sure if it's the cheese, sauce or what. Pizza is always ready on time and staff are polite. I can't speak to seating service as we always get carryout. Not much of a restaurant ambiance inside. I think if we get carryout again I'll try something else off the menu as pizza is one of those foods that vary from person to person as far as what they deem good.

A little place worth finding in Pewaukee. First time diners, we tried a bit of many dishes, and…read morecan absolutely say this is traditional German food. The owner, Mat is doing his Oma and mom (Bo) proud, and I bet this place is especially in the summer when the food is not the same old options up and down the Pewaukee shoreline. With outdoor service and seating in warmer weather, and now a cute little indoor dining room, I am glad I took the time to stop for dinner. We tried the chicken and pork schnitzel, both bunless; the Curry Wurst; Pretzel bites; Spätzle; Oma's Potato Salad; and Sprecher's Root Beer, of course. However, beer is also on the menu, along with other options. The menu is not huge, but if you like or want to try true German dishes, stop in. The pricing is fair, and the owner is very nice. They use the all-natural Wisconsin Gold Tallow for cooking, and I just learned about it and how it makes dishes so tasty. And it is even great for facials!

This was possibly the worst dining experience yet. We came for Sunday lunch, and there were only 3…read moreother tables present. Yet it took a server a good 10 minutes to even bring menus. We finally get to place our order and while we waited noticed the table behind us getting plate after plate of the wrong food. We order and waited another 15 minutes for drinks. Our food finally starts coming out one dish at a time and it's not even correct. We were waiting for the last dish to arrive and our server took it to the wrong table, collected it from the wrong table and tried serving it to us after it was touched by someone else! So, terrible service. To top it off the food just sucks. Tiny portions that are overpriced. Not authentic German, not even close. The schnitzel were absolutely tiny and paper thin, you could barely even notice it was meat. For $15 you get two puny schnitzels and a tiny bowl of potato salad. During our time there at least 5 tables came in, sat and left not even getting drinks.

Very quiet, but friendly and fast service. Can't say that there is a warm atmosphere, but the…read moreSammie's were great.

I don't review on Yelp much, but made a point to do so for this place. This is the type of place…read morethat every community or neighborhood should have available, but only a very lucky few do. No frills, glitz or pomp, just extremely tasty sub sandwiches. It's virtually impossible to go there a few times without ending up on a first name basis with the owner/operator Mark, or getting pulled into conversation with other customers while ordering and waiting. If you're not going for snooty accoutrements and veneer, but instead for high quality food with a friendly feel, you'll love it, and if you're in it for those other things, you'll have your mind changed real fast. Yum. And to make it easy on people that tend to shy away from not knowing the protocol at a new place: the menu can be found online somewhere on social media I believe, and stays mostly the same, but you need to actually go there to see what it is exactly for that day. Cash only, you walk up and order and wait. Each sub comes with choice of chips or drink, and it's something of the honor system with grabbing your chips/drink and checking out (which will make more sense when you see things for yourself). Don't expect to deal with exact change in coins or anything. Kind of treat it like lemonade stand rules - good people just round up to nice even increments and say thank you.

Great service, delicious sandwiches and salad (great alternative for gluten-free or you can ask for…read morethe GF sliced bread) - the bread was warm - so good! We enjoyed our meal outside overlooking the lake. We shared an ice cream sundae after redeeming our free sundae from our punch card - yum!

Food is extremely good as usual and the price is reasonable. Staff is also very friendly. Favorite…read moresub is the garlic turkey which is their special. Otherwise I would normally go for their blackberry Turkey sub. I liked their oatmeal cookie dough ice cream too. Restaurant is well kept and clean. It's right by the lake so it is nice to sit and eat outside

Food was amazing! We had the shrimp scampi, chicken Marsala, and scallops. Yum! Chef thoughtfully…read moreaccommodated a dietary restriction. Service was paced perfectly. Beautiful night.... doors were open to the spacious patio. Plenty of room between the tables. Soloist on the patio provided lovely background music. We already picked our entrees for our next visit. Looking forward to going back soon!

Food: we all had several different things and it seems that everyone was happy with their meal…read more Service: the lady was flighty but nice Ambiance: bar atmosphere and had one dude walking around trying to strong arm people to give money for the live entertainment. So that was complete bs

Nice staff, great cocktails! Menu offerings are intriguing…read moreand tasty. Dinner service quick and very attentive. Only negative is the noise level - I'll be back but will bring ear plugs

The food was okay. Small portions. Standard flavor.Nothing stood out. The staff was very nice…read more Place was she dirty. Good selection of bourbon. But they had the air blasting in the dining room. Someone walked back in with their sweatshirt and put the hoodie up. Keep in mind it was only 73 outside. We asked if they could adjust the temp, waitress said she'd look into it but nothing changed and she didn't circle back with us.

First time here. We stopped in after a long bike ride with some friends and were hungry for ice…read morecream. Food: When we first walked in, it didn't look like they had much in the way of ice cream. However, they actually offered a wide variety of choices, including cones, sundaes, and shakes. We ended up ordering a couple of Turtle Sundaes, a PB Lovers Sundae, and a Pumpkin Shake. It took a few minutes for our order to be prepared, and everything was delivered to our table. All of the items were excellent. They looked great, were generously filled, topped with plenty of whipped cream, and finished with a cherry on top. Everything looked like it had been made with care. Service: I'm not exactly sure, but I think the person helping us may have been the owner. They were super friendly and helpful and did a great job explaining the different sundae options. Our order was delivered to the table promptly, with an appropriate sense of urgency. After all, nobody wants the whipped cream to melt! Atmosphere: The shop is located at the end of a larger strip-mall-style building and has an outdoor seating area with several tables. Since it was a little cool outside, we chose to sit indoors. There were large tables that worked well for groups, along with big windows that let in plenty of natural light. Several other tables were occupied, and people were enjoying friendly conversations. The noise level was comfortable and made for a pleasant experience. Glad we stopped in. We've heard they make great burgers, so we'll have to come back and try those next time.

Food 5/5 the burger I was excellent. Cooked perfectly with great toppings. The french fries had…read moreexcellent taste when salt was just right. The raspberry shake was also very good. They use frozen raspberries in the mix. This feels like a hidden gym that more people should know about. I'm at the owner. Seems like a great guy has a couple other locations around the area. Runs an excellent business I will return.

Food was very good ,one thing for sure you wouldn't be hungry when you leave…read more I had a black and blue it was huge,my husband had the classic burger, the haystack,so very good and the Ruben rolls excellent . Service experience was excellent. There is alot to look at on the walls.

Second time here and enjoyed it as much as the first time. Our server was great and had an…read moreexcellent personality. The food was very good, severed hot, and had nice size portions. The Pub burger was outstanding. Mac and cheese patty plus sharp cheddar cheese and warm beer cheese sauce is perfect for a true Wisconsinite! The Prime Rib Dip was also excellent. The ambiance is warm and inviting to complement your experience.

My wife and I drove up from Chicago to have lunch with our Grandson and his family…read more We both agree that this restaurant is deserving of a 5 Star Review for the following reasons: 1. Friendly proprietor 2. Cozy environment 3. Good appetizers 4. Great Pizza We will definitely be back when in Sussex.

Excellent service! Excellent pizza and garlic bread!…read moreBeer was cold! We arrived around 6 PM. We will be back! Great place for the family too.

I said it like 4 times and I'm gonna say it again. THIS IS THE BEST JERSEY MIKES EVER!!!! Andrew…read moreMartin and Noah are the best employees ever, need a raise, no glaze at all. AND, and, they got the most peak childhood memory inducing music, Life is a Highway! This is why Jersey Mikes is the best, truly, A Sub Above.

Stopped in on March 21 at 11:45 am. Was told they only…read moreaccepting online orders. How stupid is that on a busy Saturday morning. Went next-door to chic fil a.